The chief executive of Mozilla, Brendan Eich, resigned yesterday amid protests over his $1,000 donation in support of California’s Proposition 8, which defined marriage as the union of a man and a woman.
Brendan Eich’s 2008 donation was first revealed two years ago while he was serving in a senior role at Mozilla. But it was after his appointment as CEO last month that half of Mozilla’s board quit and company employees publicly voiced their disapproval. Others launched a public campaign seeking his ouster. In the wake of yesterday’s news, Andrew Sullivan, a leading advocate for redefining marriage, said the episode “should disgust anyone interested in a tolerant and diverse society.” Heritage Foundation scholars weighed in with their reaction.
Ryan T. Anderson, the William E. Simon Fellow in Religion and a
Free Society, warned that “bullies” were poisoning democratic discourse by
attacking anyone who doesn’t share their view:
The
outrageous treatment of Eich is the result of one private, personal campaign
contribution to support marriage as a male-female union, a view affirmed at the
time by President Barack Obama, then-Sen. Hillary Clinton, and countless other
prominent officials. After all, Prop 8 passed with the support of 7 million
California voters.
So was President Obama a bigot back when he supported marriage
as the union of a man and woman? And is characterizing political disagreement
on this issue—no matter how thoughtfully expressed—as hate speech really the
way to find common ground and peaceful co-existence?
Sure, the
employees of Mozilla—which makes Firefox, the popular Internet browser—have the
right to protest a CEO they dislike, for whatever reason. But are they treating
their fellow citizens with whom they disagree civilly? Must every political disagreement
be a capital case regarding the right to stand in civil society?
When Obama “evolved” on the issue just over a year ago, he
insisted that the debate about marriage was legitimate. He said there are
people of goodwill on both sides.
Hans von Spakovsky, manager of the Election Law Reform
Initiative and senior legal fellow, said the episode was an example of how the
disclosure of political contributions served as a means to intimidate and
harass an individual for his personal views:
Before Eich resigned, he pointed out that he had kept his
personal beliefs out of Mozilla and that they were not relevant to his job as
CEO. He was exactly right, although that did not prevent him from resigning.
In a startling display of irony that was obviously lost on her,
Mozilla Executive Chairwoman Mitchell Baker, who approved of Eich’s
resignation, said it was necessary because “preserving Mozilla’s integrity was
paramount.” She seems not to recognize that forcing a founder of the company to
resign because of his personal beliefs that have nothing to do with his
qualifications as a corporate officer is the exact opposite of “integrity.”
Eich is certainly not alone in his
predicament. As the Heritage Foundation previously pointed out, other
supporters of Proposition 8 in California have been subjected to harassment,
intimidation, vandalism, racial scapegoating, blacklisting, loss of employment,
economic hardships, angry protests, violence, death threats, and anti-religious
bigotry. All committed by individuals claiming they are simply trying to gain
“acceptance” and who complain about the
supposed intolerance of society over their lifestyle.
Submitted by a Former
Union yes, Marriage no




4 comments:
I'm conflicted on this. I fully support LGBT rights, but this feels really petty. But, it's no worse than people canceling their child sponsorships at World Vision when they briefly changed their policy on hiring married gay couples. In fact, at least with Mozilla, no one got hurt.
Frankly, both sides are intolerant, and always happy to escalate the latest skirmish in the culture wars, but I guess it's just the 'market speaking': Eich wasn't fired for his views. He resigned.
As I mentioned, I fully support LGBT rights, but I don't consider those opposed as 'bigots'.... yet.
Society is clearly moving in that direction, and history shows there won't be any turning back, but I don't expect everyone to change. It will take generations, and I think the more aggressive LGBT supporters are just delaying the process.
But, give it thirty or forty years, and people opposed will sound as strange as the KKK. The LGBT side of things need to encourage that process, not force it, and actions like this don't help.
Dear Anonymous,
I agree with you wholeheartedly! I was enmeshed in all of the intolerance and out and out lies about gays and gay rights told by the religious right in America (and lies toward anyone else who disagreed with the religious right's views)for over twenty years, to the point that I wound up creating a rather large archive about it all, that now sits in the archival library of the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley, California.
But I'm also aware of the other side of it too, where today certain gay rabble rousers on the internet, seem to be out to destroy TSA for instance, because they don't understand that what's going on in TSA as a church, is exactly the same process that is taking place among the members of most other churches, when it comes to the evolution of understanding what homosexuality is all about.
It is an internal struggle that will probably be completely cleared up within a generation or two with a new understanding of the subject. In the mean time Salvationists, whether officers or soldiers, etc. are at various places in their understanding and hold a myriad of personal views on the subject, spanning the whole spectrum from ultra-conservative to ultra-liberal.
Yet this has no bearing on the Army's social services which is available to ALL without discrimination (including needy gays)and I dare say, should not be "punished" by anyone, or any segment of the population because of differing political views.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand With Jesus in the Morning!"
The question is not whether SS marriage should be supported or not, it's, was it right to hound Brendan Eich from his job at Mozilla? So let’s consider just that for a moment….
Brendan is a multi-millionaire Jew and therefore it's a given is it not, that he'd be a card carrying liberal. But whoa there, he's not, not your average California millionaire, instead he's a champion of traditional American values and marriage. What's up with that?
And, he used personal funds and exercised his constitutional freedom in voicing his opinion. And aside from his financial contribution, he kept his actions private; again his choice.
But what might happen next is frightening on so many levels. William Saleton at Slate facetiously suggested “activists would now have to force the remaining 34,999 Proposition 8 donors out of their jobs”.
Facetious, yes, but could this not be a further hounding of those who the LGBT lobby target?
Some believe Eich’s ouster is a victory, the ouster of a founder and CEO by his own people, at a foundation based on the text book model of open and equal expression, an example of the system” working exactly as it should”. Just what percentage of the Mozilla folk asked their founder to instead of leaving Dodge, ask him to host a goodwill meeting to keep his projects running smoothly while both sides demonstrate a bit of grace? ? Do they not realize that an important duty of any CEO is to maintain inclusivity, one that was well in place; - all are welcome, so long as they don't bring their opinions into the workplace – a code that Eich respected and upheld.
A reporter wrote, “Eich is free to believe what he wants, and same-sex marriage remains a divisive issue in America. But to gay people and their allies, supporting an outright ban on equal marriage is concerning: to many, it appears to say same-sex love is lesser than heterosexual love. Given most gay people feel they had no choice over their orientation, that message becomes in effect a statement that gay people aren't the equals of their heterosexual counterparts.”
I don’t think Brendan Eich believes any of those things, nor do the large majority of educated adult Americans. And Eich's fatal flaw, and possibly ours, is to assume that the LGBT lobby will lessen their battle even if recognizing that the fight has waned.
Many liken their battle to that of the civil rights uprising of the 50’s and 60’s. The only real comparison is that many in both camps haven’t got the message, the battle’s over, let’s smoke the peace pipe and move on. Join the 21st century!
This was never a question of tolerance or freedom of expression. But it has caused me to exercise mine- I’m looking for Eich’s recommendation of what to replace my Firefox (my former university emplyer's selection), and my own, Mozilla.
It's been a week now since the first same sex couples legally wed in the UK… and Brighton was never as colourful and bright! Thyngs they are a'changing.
I have long been a champion for gay and lesbian rights, but come on guys and gals, let up a bit will you? Spend some time instead planning your Fire Island and Frisco bay weekends shopping, outfits and eateries..
First of all - I AM NOT HOMOPHOBIC! I do, however, object to same-sex 'marriage' - because it is, actually, very different from heterosexual marriage. SS sex CANNOT of itself procreate - so where's the 'equality'? There is none - and that's a fact. Civil partnerships were acclaimed as 'doing the right thing' by LGBTs, but now they have hijacked the union between men and women. Why? Their aggressive actions win them no favours with conservatives, and all we can see is the stifling of free thought, when people cannot say what they think, even though it's logical, for fear of offending those who don't agree with them and for fear of reprisals. Folks, we have to agree to differ - God made us all different - we are not all in the same mould, we do not think identically, but stifling free speech is not the way forward. Mr Eich should be able to do what he wants with his own money, as long as it doesn't affect his ability to do the job.
The donation was made in 2008. Why has it taken the board 6 years to complain? I smell a LGBT rat here.
Post a Comment