Wednesday, October 16, 2013

There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak



When not saying enough could be dangerous?

The Bible tells us that we will account for every idle word we speak - Matthew 12:36
‘But I say unto you, That every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account of them in the day of judgment’.  

One part of the meaning of idle is "careless."  

Besides careless words, a careless silence can also be dangerous. It can be a form of condoning an action we witness that is wrong. Silence, when a warning is needed, is something that we hold people responsible for. God, too, holds people accountable for being silent when they ought to cry out. 


WAITING AT THE HH - An uncertain future-

Ezekiel was set as a spiritual watchman over the nation of Israel to warn the people with a message from God to repent and return to the paths of righteousness. Notice what God said in Ezekiel 3: 17 - 21: ‘Ezekiel, son of man, I have appointed you to stand watch for the people of Israel. So listen to what I say, then warn them for me. When I tell wicked people they will die because of their sins, you must warn them to turn from their sinful ways so they won’t be punished. If you refuse, you are responsible for their death. However, if you do warn them, and they keep on sinning, they will die because of their sins, and you will be innocent. Now suppose faithful people start sinning, and I decide to put stumbling blocks in their paths to make them fall. They deserve to die because of their sins. So if you refuse to warn them, I will forget about the times they were faithful, and I will hold you responsible for their death. But if you do warn them, and they listen to you and stop sinning, I will let them live. And you will be innocent’.


A watchman was a key figure in the towns of the ancient world. He would be stationed to guard the maturing crops in the field to see that they were not stolen by bandits or ravaged by wild animals. From his position on the walls, he would observe the traffic of society moving each day in and out of the city, sometimes announcing the approach of strangers on the roads leading in. In time of war, the watchman would warn of enemy troops coming against the town to lay siege. His vigilance meant life or death to the city's inhabitants. How people responded to his warning message was critical.

There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak (Ecclesiastes 3:7). 
Wisdom is knowing the difference, and character is applying that knowledge.

ST. PAUL HOSPITAL CLOSES AFTER 123 YEARS

God provides watchmen for His people in today's world, too, and I see the role of FSAOF and the supporters who have contributed to the Howard Hospital issue as that of spiritual watchmen - or 'watchpeople' if you wish to be PC. No individual or organisation is perfect, and we all stray from the 'pure' path. We all need reminding of God's standards. They are our moral and spiritual guides for faithful Christian service.

It is disheartening and frustrating for such a concerted effort as this (to try to bring TSA leadership to acknowledge the wrongdoing at HH) to have yielded nothing but silence until the publication of the Tariro story. This article, although laudable in concept, contained so much that can only be labelled ‘spin’, and left out the ‘heart’ of the hospital – the contribution of Dr Thistle. Truly – a wasted opportunity.

There is a basic spiritual discipline at stake here which, as Major (Dr) Watt says, threatens the very future of our beloved Army – it is repentance - - and it beggars belief that senior leaders have not yet acted upon it in this case. However unpalatable the truth is, God says wrongdoing must be confessed and laid at the foot of the cross. Not until then will this story cease. Unconfessed sin is a barrier to spiritual progression, and the leaders should know this and act accordingly.

Former Officer
Canada





27 comments:

Anonymous said...

This article ought to be in the General's 'ACTION NEEDED' box! Pull Pallant and send an independent auditor to investigate - search through every doc dating back to '95!

Excellent Biblical instructions: thank you Canada.
Active DHQ

Unknown said...

When I read the article about Howard Hospital in 'All the World" I saw that it left much to be desired and was at best 'spin.' I read in this blog a balance by Jolinda Cooper which refered to the article. I wondered why in 'All the World' an SA publication why there was no mention of either Dr Watt or Dr Thistle. So on 11 October 2013 I asked why. On 15 October I received this reply: "Dear Mr Pogson, Many thanks for your message. The article is about the current situation at Howard Hospital and plans for the future. While Drs Watt and Thistle undoubtedly played significant roles in the hospital's past, so did many other medical and administrative staff. It would be impossible to single out every individual that has played a part in the hospital's 85 years of service to the community. Regards, Kevin Sims (Editor, All the World)"

A poor article in All the World and a reply to my question which again 'spins' the story. IHQ needs to order a fully Independent Inquiry into what happened at Howard Hospital and what really are the plans for the future.

Anonymous said...

Andy, your observation is dead on! But, smack i the middle of any enquiry would be the name Cox. Born there and served at HH during the 90s. Don't think he'll want to go there!
UK

Anonymous said...

this is just too sad. Surely we have just ONE who will stand up and be counted amongst our many leaders and commissioners. Please DO SOMETHING. What has become of our conscience! Come on General, BE BRAVE!

Anonymous said...

Was DP run out of Chikankata?

Anonymous said...

'Surely we have just ONE who will stand up and be counted amongst our many leaders and commissioners'........seems not. Tragic.

Anonymous said...

Just an aside - what's happened to the live feed? It was interesting seeing where people were posting from.

Anonymous said...

'Pull Pallant' - excellent suggestion - he is too close to the action to be objective. That isn't a criticism - it's a fact. With his wife being involved in the same field of service - it isn't fair on either of them to expect them to be objective, and in the light of all that he has said since the doctor was dismissed, it would be better to have a new person on the job. Anything he says will be met with criticism, so yes - arrange for someone else from now on.

Anonymous said...

Then stop criticising these poor guys with an impossible job to do, let alone please anyone. It is not their job to please anyone anyway.

Anyone appointed will fall short of expectations if it does not fit already fixed mind sets.

Keep going DP! Praying for you.

Anonymous said...

Thank you Former Canada for this exegesis of the watchman text. Truly some of us have been acting in this role for over a year now and your timely blog article gives us the encouragement and inspiration to continue despite fatigue.

One could say we have been relentless and stones have been hurled at us as stones were hurled at God's messengers the prophets. It is never an enviable task to be the spiritual watchman, but alas some people God calls to it and so thank you for reminding us that what we are doing is an act of obedience.

Canada

Anonymous said...

They will all fall short until they drop the SA internal political interest, ineptitude in conducting a professional enquiry, dismissing previously acknowledged misappropriations, admitted and documented theft while Cox was the FS ZIM, constant spin, refusal to credit Watt/Thistle and respond to the very simple questions posed by the hundreds of visitors to the SA's most visited and honest blog. IHQ- perhaps if you opened all HH related posts with the words, 'let's begin with this transparent paragraph', truth night follow?

4th generation but now out of SA uniform i n protest

Anonymous said...

With all due respect, what is you being out of uniform hoping to achieve at local level at the corps you attend? Would it be correct to assume that you have withdrawn from being actively involved as well in protest?

Just curious.

Anonymous said...

From another 4th generation who is out of uniform in protest -

Being out of uniform is largely symbolic - it is my way of saying I am extremely upset and disappointed in what happened (and continues to happen) at HH, and the ongoing silence from SA leadership. It is also a statement that my continuing membership in the SA is currently being re-evaluated. In the meantime I am continuing in the same activities in my corps and my commitment to the Lord remains strong.

It also creates a talking point with members of my corps. I have had a number of conversations with corps folk who had no idea about this situation. My actions are never explained in anger - I merely state that this is what I feel I have to do, and suggest they find out for themselves what has happened.

Anonymous said...

I would never take off my uniform because of the sins of others.
Would the Lord withhold his blessing on an Army over a million strong because of the sins of a few? No never!!

Anonymous said...

But do you really know what has happened in context except by what has been presented as fact on this one-sided, hyped up blog by some well meaning ( or not)individuals?

It is very probable that there are elements of truth in whatever anybody is saying but it has been groping in the dark all along as none of the principal parties involved have opened up with first hand information. Nor did they have reason to.

Where did you get this information confirmed that the whole truth and nothing but the whole truth is being told and not some selective postings by people with their own agenda's, biases and prejudices?

Internet blogs are notoriously untrustworthy in this respect, this one certainly not being exempted.

Be careful in that you are not being used as fodder to satisfy the cravings of a few moral and ethical crusaders/ watchmen/ gatekeepers who set out to be somewhat manipulative in controlling the minds and actions of the more good hearted and generous.

Blessings


Anonymous said...

Anonymous wrote about 2 comments above this one
"Would the Lord withhold his blessing on an Army over a million strong because of the sins of a few? No never!!"

You are biblicly wrong. The Lord witheld the blessing of victory for ancient Israel's Army when one man - Achan - had sinned. Read the story for yourself.

Canada

Anonymous said...

'Then stop criticising these poor guys with an impossible job to do, let alone please anyone. It is not their job to please anyone anyway.

Anyone appointed will fall short of expectations if it does not fit already fixed mind sets'.

What is so impossible about telling the truth? it's something we teach children, isn't it? It's a crying shame we haven't seen it much in this casel.

And the people on this blog are not children waiting to be 'pleased' - all we want is justice and compassion for the Chiweshe community and an apology for Paul Thistle, who was treated pretty shabbily by TSA leaders. Don't forget - these people are the among the highest ranking salvationists we have - do you not think they should have handled it better?

Anonymous said...

.....'a few moral and ethical crusaders/ watchmen/ gatekeepers who set out to be somewhat manipulative in controlling the minds and actions of the more good hearted and generous. '
I fear for your values if you really think that the crusaders/watchmen/gatekeepers are the manipulative ones - in my book it's TSA that fits this description. What has been good hearted and generous about the actions and conduct of IHQ so far?

Unknown said...

It is obvious that General Cox is determined not to order an Independent Inquiry into Howard Hospital so what now? Surely there must be someone at IHQ who will stand up!

Anonymous said...

Apparently not anyone at IHQ - the corruption runs deep and high up I suppose.

Meanwhile the watchmen will continue.

Unknown said...

Indeed yes!

Anonymous said...

It would be rather interesting if the freedom of Information Act applied to the IHQ!

Anonymous said...

I suppose not every country has a freedom of information Act as we do in Canada.

Yes it would be truly interesting to apply such a law to IHQ.

Anonymous said...

Don't know much about it but I'm pretty sure we do have a freedom of information act in the UK too.

Anonymous said...

It is good to remember that the UK FOIA only affects public authorities or persons providing services for them...and then there are numerous exemptions.

"An Act to make provision for the disclosure of information held by public authorities or by persons providing services for them and to amend the Data Protection Act 1998 and the Public Records Act 1958; and for connected purposes"

So I believe it is not your lucky day if you want to apply it to the SA at whatever level.

Anonymous said...

I'm sure everyone would like to know what really happened, but that can never be, for various reasons.There are circumstances where it would be disastrous if information was 'free' to all. People realise that. What IS needed is proper restorative action. TSA should be helping the Chiweshe people get to Karanda for treatment where necessary.
And an apology by TSA for all the harm it has done and the hurt it has caused to many people would be welcome. And an INDEPENDENT inquiry. If they have acted with integrity they have nothing to fear form such an inquiry.

Anonymous said...

In this situation I believe it is more disastrous for TSA to be involved in cover-up than what it would be to reveal the truth.

Agree with all else that you among others are calling for:
1. independent inquiry
2. public apology to Chiweshe
3. amends to the Chiweshe community by providing transportation to Karanda
4. apology to the Thistle's - is it inconceivable that even now their dismissal and termination could be reversed? The Thistle's would probably not consider working as officers again especially if #5 doesn't happen
5. changes to TSA's archaic funding system - a systemic problem
6. only after changing the funding system, if not Dr. Thistle, get a qualified surgeon into the Howard to replace Dr. Thistle, If the funding system remains status quo the result for any CMO will be a repeat performance.