![]() |
| I BELIEVE IN THE WORD OF GOD, EVERY WORD, EVERY VERSE, EVERY CHAPTER IS TRUE! I BELIEVE IT - SO WHY DON'T YOU?! |
What about Mary’s Immaculate Conception? If Joseph believed it (as scripture tells us), why didn’t everyone else? If it was such a miraculous event, why didn’t everyone else believe it? Scripture tells us that Mary and Joseph, and Mary’s relative Elizabeth and her husband John, were the only ones who believed it at the time. Why? This is where we need to look at the context of the narrative, and examine other documentation.
Far from being a unique event, we find that for at least 3,000 years before the birth of Christ, nearly every religion, and nearly every cult within every religion, from around the world, has at least one narrative of a virgin birth by the deity of that religion/cult. The following is the narrative of the most famous of these (aside from Joseph, Mary, and Jesus). It dates from around 2,500 – 3,000 BCE.
A young woman was visited by the King of the gods – Zeus. She is made pregnant by him. Her son grows up full of power, and does miraculous deeds. He tells people that the gods do not need all these sacrifices and offerings. They can all have a more personal relationship with the gods. This pleases many of the people, and so he gains quite a following. However, the religious leaders despise him because it spells the end of their lifestyle. Eventually, the young man performs his greatest deed in order to back up what he says. Because of his love for humanity (some legends say it was mainly the woman he loves), he dives into Hades (hell) and does battle with Hades himself. Eventually, he conquers Hades, and tears open the divide between Hades and the Elysian Fields (heaven) so that those who wish, no longer have to be trapped in death, but can live in the Elysian Fields. He then rises from death (Hades), shakes off his mortal persona, and takes his rightful place, seated at the right hand of his father.
Does this narrative sound familiar? It’s actually the story of Hercules. The point here is that the virgin birth described in scripture was not a unique event. Mary was just the latest in a very long list of unwed women who were pregnant, claiming to be a virgin, and that her child was sired by her god. People would have been fed up with such stories. I can imagine a Monty Python skit showing the Priests’ reaction to being told that Mary was a pregnant virgin “What? Another virgin birth? Doesn’t anyone ever have sex anymore? Put her with all the other virgin mothers, and we’ll decide what to do with her bastard son later”.
Part FOUR of SIX
Part FOUR of SIX

9 comments:
Graeme- sorry that my own first posting on this blog has to be a corrective, but your opening statement in this article refers to the RC dogma of Mary's 'immaculate conception' - this is not the same concept as the virgin birth of Jesus.
The dogma of the immaculate conception posits that Mary herself was preserved from the stain of original sin
while this view has been held throughout church history, it was not formally proclaimed by the Roman Catholic church until 1854
while one can understand certain benefits deriving from this doctrine, it is not implied in Scripture, and perhaps counterbalances the argument that God can still bring good things forth from sinful lives
Immaculate Conception, should be confused with neither the notion of Mary's own perpetual virginity, nor the virgin birth of Christ
In light of other comments in your article, I wonder how you would respond to the notion that other accounts of 'virgin birth' noted in antiquity may derive from satanic counterfeits of true religion, in the same way that worship of the eschatological 'unholy trinity' of the Beast, Anti-Christ and False Prophet' mirrors a counterfeit of worship of the true trinity...
I look forward to reading the rest of your articles
With religion in decline in the UK, those identifying themselves as having no religion has increased by 10 percentage points from 15%, 7.7 million people, in 2001, to 25%, 14.1 million, last year, according to the latest census.
The decade's shift away from religion is very troubling, and I believe that people like you Graeme, through your teaching, can help stem and in time turn the tide.
Thank you. I'm looking forward to the remainder of your articles.
Active SA officer
Canada & Bermuda
Graeme,
The actual technical term is neither "immaculate conception" nor "virgin birth", but "virginal conception". This doesn't take away from what you have written.
Former
Canada and Bermuda
Hi Graeme,
I’ve been reading your series with interest, and as we have now turned the half-way point, I thought I’d make some responses:-
1. I agree it is important to consider all additional information available to help us in our understanding of the Scriptures. However, there are often various schools of thought relating to issues of reliability, and/or interpretation of such additional data. Therefore I would suggest we need to bear this in mind when assessing the value of such information and exercise caution as and when required.
2. I agree that the NT was not written in a special form of Biblical Greek. However, I would suggest that we do need to recognise that some words used within the NT may indeed carry certain nuances which are not necessarily present in usages outside the NT. The meaning of words is dependent on the context and it is possible that the particular context that the NT writers were writing in and to may have resulted in some of the above mentioned nuances. We might even see this occurring within the NT, perhaps in how Paul uses the word ‘faith’ at times, as compared with its use in James. I think you have also illustrated this when you said in the final paragraph of Part 1 that the phrase, ‘Death of the Author’ had a certain nuance to its meaning within the Social Sciences. Obviously it would not carry that particular nuance when the phrase is used in other contexts.
3. I was going to raise your use of the phrase,’ Mary’s Immaculate Conception’ but as Denis has already done so I will wait your response to him.
4. You suggest that the account of Jesus’ virgin birth, which is what I assume you are referring to by the phrase ‘Mary’s Immaculate Conception’, may have been no different to other narratives about’ virgin’ births, and you have given the example of Hercules. Though there may be similarities with this and other accounts, there are also major differences. The claim that Jesus was born of a virgin it seems was not duplicated in any other account. You can find this point being made in a Q and A series between Ben Witherington (BW) and Bart Ehrman (BE), both well respected NT scholars, but coming from very different positions. BW is a conservative evangelical NT scholar, and BE is a NT scholar who used to be evangelical but would now position himself I believe as at least agnostic. (You may find the whole series of Q and A of interest.) The particular post (see the 5th paragraph, but also see the rest of the post re narratives about divine men and supernatural births) I refer to can be found at:- http://www.patheos.com/blogs/bibleandculture/2012/06/11/bart-ehrman-on-did-jesus-exist-part-seven/ I would recommend reading BenWitherington’s blog in particular for giving additional information for the NT period.
5. You have highlighted a number of important issues related to increasing our understanding of the Scriptures, such as the importance of context and additional data. This has led you to question much of what you call traditional theology, and resulted in you moving towards a new theology. I’m obviously assuming what you mean by traditional theology, but if you mean what I think you mean (and I may of course be misunderstanding you) I would suggest that recognising the issues you have raised does not necessarily result in a move away from traditional theology. I would agree that we need to truly understand what the Scriptures say, and we need to let the evidence lead us, and not us lead it, but I and many others have not found that it has led us away from traditional theology.
Regards.
Bernard (Martin)
Former UKT
Graeme,
What I really wanted to do was respond to your answer about the old established Xian myths not really working any longer--at least for the last few decades as you put it, but I won't have the time to do so until later in the week.
In response to what you write in part 4 though I tend to lean towards C.S. Lewis' explanation. He saw no problem with there being "similar" virgin birth stories in the polytheistic relgions that had gone before. He saw them as pointing to a truth and need that was deeply ingrained in the human psyche and condition: The belief that God was somehow involved in our human lives and came down to earth and gave himself for us. He believed that it was there in the human heart because God put it there and that the polytheistic stories were just reflections of that ingrained truth. What is important is that the Xian story is the one that was universal (the others were largely local) and took!
I might also add that from what I've read many (even most) scholars now believe that from the beginning of human history there was an underlying belief in monotheism---long before polytheism ever came on the scene--which I might also add the Genesis account certainly agrees with. Polytheism was a deterioration from the beginning monotheistic beliefs--not a necessary step in a religious evolutionary process toward monotheism. Comparing the polytheistic "gods" and their myths (stories) to the Judeo-Xian Sovereign God myths are like comparing apples to oranges.
The gods were synonymous with nature, were not sovereign, could be manipulated by humans through the process of rituals and the rituals were just that--an end in themselves. They were void of any ethical content whereas (as you yourself pointed out) in the worship of Yahweh for a religious experience to be valid there had to be ethical content to it that led to holiness of life (the doing of justice).
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home by the Way of the Cross, to Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
If the Creator of the universe can create something out of nothing(by speaking it into existence) then a female can conceive that has no human father but was (overshadowed) (a miraculous event) by the Holy Spirit. Satan can mock in many ways before an event and after (the virgin birth). If we cannot trust scripture then you may as well throw out the whole Bible, and the Triune God.
Robert Dreidick Former USA
I think the key contribution this series is making is to encourage a move away from a "sunday school" understanding and actually grappling with the complexities of a text written in an unfamiliar language, in an unfamiliar time to an unfamiliar people. The value is in saying "does this really mean " Graeme, you have done a good job of grappling with these issues and starting the conversation. Well done.
Thank you all for commenting.
Yes, virginal conception is a better way of putting what I have said in this part.
Throughout the article (broken up in many parts) I have used certain words/phrases that keen Theologians and historians would greatly disagree with (there is an absolute doosey of an example in what I think will be the final part - Sven is dividing the article up into parts - I think it will be in the final part most of you will jump up and down). However, I was trying to be inclusive in the way I write - for people with deep Theological and historical understanding, and for those who just have a 'Sunday School' understanding. Clearly, those of you with a deeper Theological understanding understood what was meant. I used the term I did because the vast majority of people with only a Sunday School type teaching on Theology would have been more familiar with it, and might have made them feel a little more comfortable. Writing can be very difficult at times.
So before you all bombard me with a million responses to the final part, let me explain here...
In the final part, I refer to a certain group of people as being possibly understood as 'Muslims'. Now yes, I know that Muslims weren't around in 4 BCE. Mohamed came well after Christ. The people I refer to are possibly most likely Zoroastrians, and if not, another similar religion from the area. Whichever one they were, they were more likely taken over by Islam when Islam rose to prominence in that part of the world - with little alteration to the way they practiced their faith etc. Hence, if we were to describe their practices and faith, many people would say 'they're Muslims, aren't they?'
However, I remember from my own ultra conservative days that very few people know who the Zoroastrians were. I have heard some REALLY wild explanations of them that have had me in stitches with laughter and in shock with the misunderstanding of them all at the same time. The wildest was that they worshiped a giant bird called Zoar, who is really a beautiful sorceress in animal form, who lived on a distant planet (possibly the one that is supposedly now circling the earth and about to crash into the earth now that the end of the world has already come and we just don't know it), which is the inspiration for the children's cartoon 'He-man' (I actually heard quite a lot of people express that understanding - including most of the Corps Census, and some of the Officers, in my home Corps). As a result, I wanted to use a word that most people would understand, which can have a logical link if you trace the history back, and at the same time, the deeper Theologians would understand what I mean (I hope).
The person who posted previous to this post has hit the nail on the head beautifully with my intent regarding this article - it's to make people start discussing things, and ask questions. I think it has achieved this. Whether or not it changes Theology is irrelevant. People are discussing it, and asking questions. It might change some views within Theology, and some of the periphery, while leaving the fundamentals unchanged. The fundamentals remain the same - no matter whether you are an extreme ultra conservative, or raging loopy liberal.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme
Hi Graeme,
I am really enjoying your series and particularly because it is encouraging people to question. It is always interesting to see how some people go straight to closing down rather than open questions and looking at possibilities.
I remember well hearing a conversation between an open-minded FSAO and a SAO high up the tree where the question was asked "I wonder would it make any difference to salvation, if it wasn't a virgin birth", the intention simply being to ponder, and assess, and refine thoughts and beliefs. However the response was immediate shut down. Sadly many do not tolerate the questions which may, if explored, lead to richer depths of faith.
A quote I enjoy sums this up. "Why would you want to spoil such a wonderful question, by giving it an answer".
FSAO Aust East
Post a Comment