After Bell’s book questioned the existence of Hell, one prominent theologian posted on Twitter, “Farewell Rob Bell.”
On a Sunday evening last year, Rob Bell pulled up outside a stone building in Philadelphia, peered at the stained-glass window above the entrance, and frowned—the place looked like a church. Bell is the founder of Mars Hill Bible Church, a megachurch in West Michigan, and one of the most influential Christian leaders in the country. But when he goes on tour, to talk about his evolving faith, he tries to avoid churches, because he doesn’t want to cause trouble for any staffers brave enough to book him. “I don’t know where I’m anathema and where I’m considered to be on the good team,” he says. “The landscape is so confusing, in churchyworld, that I just gave up trying to navigate it.” The previous night, he had appeared at Lupo’s, a venerable rock club in Providence, where there was a stern warning posted backstage: “No spitting or throwing drinks on the stage or equipment.”
Bell is a provocateur, but a mild-mannered one, with a pinched, nasal voice that somehow projects calm. He is forty-two, tall and lean, and, in both his fastidiousness and his fondness for black clothes, he evokes Steve Jobs; indeed, Bell sees no reason that a sermon shouldn’t have the same cool, frictionless appeal as an Apple product launch, or a ted Talk. For much of his career, Bell was affiliated with the evangelical movement, which has been the most robust Christian tradition in America for half a century. To many casual observers, the aughts seemed like a triumphant era for evangelicals. In the elections of 2000 and 2004, evangelical voters provided crucial support to President Bush, and Rick Warren became the symbol of a sophisticated new kind of megachurch. In fact, the popularity of evangelical Christianity probably peaked sometime in the early nineteen-nineties, and may now be in decline. Some Christian leaders have predicted an evangelical collapse, as aging congregations fail to attract young adults. Bell is now loosely aligned with a cohort of pastors worldwide who are searching for ways to move beyond old-fashioned worship. (This movement is sometimes called the emerging or emergent church, but many pastors, including Bell, disavow the term.) Bell talks often about the demand for a different kind of church, one that can keep pace with the rising “waterline of culture.”
For his Philadelphia engagement, Bell had been booked into the Baptist Temple—which, he discovered, with some relief, had been deconsecrated and turned into a performing-arts center. He went inside for sound check and a quick nap; soon, a technician cued up his pre-show mix (Blur, Midnight Oil, Starsailor), and the hall started to fill up. Bell attracts an earnest crowd of young people, full of questions about the church they once loved unquestioningly. For many of them, Bell is a reassuring figure: proof that it’s possible to challenge certain articles of faith without leaving behind faith itself. (In Philadelphia, one college-age fan greeted him by saying, “If it wasn’t for you, I wouldn’t still be a Christian.”) Onstage, Bell told self-deprecating stories about botched sermons and humbling discoveries, and he cited the Dalai Lama as a paragon of Christian grace. In Bell’s monologues, Jesus comes across as a rebellious mystic, opposed to any form of small-mindedness. “He seemed to have no problem confronting the hypocritical religious establishment,” Bell said. “And he told these extremely mysterious, enigmatic stories that ended in such a way that sometimes they wanted to kill him and sometimes they wanted to crown him.”
Out front, on the sidewalk, a preacher had come to speak out against what he called “the lies of Rob Bell.” Without an amplifier, or any evident need of one, he issued precisely the sort of fierce warning that Bell takes pains to avoid: “It is a broad way that leads to eternal damnation, and many will enter into it.” This line, a standard weapon in every street preacher’s arsenal, arises from Matthew 7:13, part of the Sermon on the Mount, in which Jesus sets down a series of precepts and aphorisms. But “eternal damnation” might be a misleading translation: the original contains no reference to eternity, and, instead of “damnation,” the more common rendering is “destruction.” The Greek word is apoleia, which can also mean “waste,” or “loss.” (It recurs later in the Book of Matthew, to describe the Disciples’ indignant reaction when Jesus is anointed with precious oils: they ask, “Why this waste?”)
To anyone looking for loopholes in the doctrine of damnation, the Bible offers plenty, and last year Bell compiled many of them, in a book called “Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived.” Bell says that the book, his fifth, was inspired by a congregant who insisted that Mahatma Gandhi, because he wasn’t a Christian, must be suffering in Hell. In the opening pages, Bell recalls his incredulous response:
Really?
Gandhi’s in hell?
He is?
We have confirmation of this?
A different kind of pastor might have replied, modestly, that Christian eschatology—the study of the afterlife—offers few certainties. Instead, Bell set out to answer the question. He considered the possibility that Hell might not exist, or that it might be empty, or that it might exist on earth, or that it might be temporary. Maybe, he thought, Hell is an unpleasant place where posthumous repentance is possible and, in the fullness of time, inevitable. He never answers his own question about Gandhi, but he strongly suggests that the answer couldn’t possibly be yes. He quotes I Timothy 2: “God wants all people to be saved and to come to a knowledge of truth.” And then he poses the impertinent question around which the rest of the book revolves: “Does God get what God wants?”
Even before it was published, “Love Wins” caused a sensation. The word went out that a prominent megachurch leader had rejected Hell, thereby embracing heresy. The outcry helped make the book a best-seller, even though a number of Christian bookstores refused to stock it. The central message of “Love Wins” is that the church needs to stop scaring people away, and, in publishing the book, Bell hoped to spark a movement toward a more congenial, less punitive form of Christianity. He knew that some Christian leaders would object, but he didn’t foresee how much. His detractors stated their case on blogs, from pulpits, and, eventually, in books. “Love Wins” appeared in March, 2011, and by summer there were half a dozen rebuttals in print, including “God Wins,” by an editor at Christianity Today, and “Erasing Hell,” by Francis Chan, a fellow-pastor. John Piper, a prominent theologian and minister who expounds the value of “objective Biblical truth,” posted a terse message on Twitter: “Farewell Rob Bell.”


7 comments:
What is amazing is that so many Christians think that Bell has raised a new question, whereas it is as old as the church fathers, more recent as Luther, and as contemporary as Stott and Pinnock.
The real question is whether or not God is gracious, loving and compassionate, or punitive and threatening. If we believe that the decisive revelation of God's character is to be seen in the man Jesus, which one of the character traits above comes closest to the picture of what Jesus was lie?
It seems that the most popular view, at least in America, is a combination of the two, which invariably leads to conditional grace:
God loves us and saves us if we believe in the eleven cardinal doctrines. God loves us and saves us if we earnestly repent and cry buckets of tears at the mercy seat.
God loves us and saves us if we behave in accordance with God's will. God loves us and saves us if we are reasonably decent people.
It seems to me if one has to believe in a punitive God, the best one could do is to believe in annihilation, as many of the church fathers did and Luther, Stott and Pinnock; or as separation from God as our Roman Catholic sisters and brethren.
Former
Canada and Bermuda
I still don't understand what all the fuss is about!! Jesus made it very clear that there's a Hell and once again I'd rather be wrong with him (if someone judges him wrong) than right with anyone else. The eleventh doctrine of TSA sits quite well with me thank you.
Where the problem seems to lie is with mere mortals thinking they can go around deciding who's there and who's not depending on their own likes and dislikes and prejudices---such as the man who told Rob Bell that Gandhi was in Hell because he apparently never signed his name on someone's inquirer card and declared himself a Xian.
Once someone is dead why can't these decisions just be left in God's hands where they clearly belong? The issue once someone is dead is whether or not God can be trusted. The comfort (for me anyway) is that the person is in God's hands and that the Creator, Redeemer and Sustainer God of the universe seen and unseen, knows everything about that person that my finite brain will never know.
As far as the suppossed "problem" of a God of love casting people into Hell, I really don't see much of a "problem" there either. C.S. Lewis said it the best of anyone. Hell the same as Heaven is an outgrowth of God's love. It's for people who want it. The doors of Hell are all locked from the inside.
What a person really is on the inside no matter how ugly, may be hidden quite nicely for 70 years of time and space but if it's not nipped in the bud at some point and is allowed to grow unfettered in eternity that very ugly, awful thing becomes Hell itself.
I find it interesting that in almost all of the accounts of people who've died and experienced Hell with demons and devils gnawing at and tearing them apart, the victims report that as soon as they call upon the name of God or Jesus the creatures back off as if they can't bear to be exposed to the light. They instead prefer their separation from God and the Hell that they've made for themselves.
As I've written twice before on this blog in the 4 years I've been reading and commenting on it (and will do so again and again whenever the subject comes up) the question isn't "Why would a God of love condemn anyone to Hell?" but rather, "Why would a God of love condemn the unwilling to Heaven?"
Daryl Lach
USA Central
P.S. Maybe the "real" problem has to do with Greek dualism vs. Eastern paradox. In the west because we always see everything in terms of "either ors" and "opposites" and not in paradox (as life oftentimes really works!) we just have a harder time reconciling a God of Love with an eternal Hell. It's time to think paradox and get over it already.
"You Must go home By the way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
If you say so Daryl, but you neglected to mention that C.S.Lewis also believed in purgatory. I wonder why?
Former
Canada and Bermuda
Dear former C&B,
I really have no problem with Lewis' purgatory either. Lewis' views were Anglo-Catholic. He died in 1963 and so Purgatory was a part of his tradition. It's not a part of our SA tradition.
Actually, the idea was floating around in Xian theological circles from the earliest centuries and probably got much of its steam from what Paul wrote about our works of faith going through a refining fire and the wood being consumed.
To me as a Protestant, the "problem" with Purgatory as an actual place that most Xian people went to after they died before going on to Heaven, lies in the fact that the church dogmatised and institutionalised the concept because the hierarchy saw a cash cow in it! Fortunately the RC Church has in the last 50 years corrected and even repented of that error.
I also don't see how someone's personal belief in the possibility of a purging in anyway negates Lewis' ideas about Heaven and Hell. Once again, Lewis' views of eternal twilight and the doors of Hell all being locked from the inside along with the eleventh doctrine of TSA work just fine for me.
Lastly, as Graeme and others have already expressed, the doctrines of TSA are an amazing document that are stated in such a way as to leave the peripheral stuff open to a myriad of personal views and interpretations. (From what I can see this is even true to at least some extent with the most controversial of the doctrines--the tenth one!)
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
Daryl,
I certainly agree with you that the doctrines of TSA leave a lot of room for intepretation, and that is to be commended. It also makes for a lot of lazy theological salvationists!
I mistakenly thought that the discussion was about Rob Bell's view. There is no need for anyone to be defensive.
No one knows what lies beyond death. Even Jesus, when he appeared to his disciples as the Risen Lord, had nothing to say about it.
Perhaps we might apply humility to any discussion about both Heaven and Hell, and concentrate instead on the quality of life (eternal) that Jesus offers us here and now.
Former
Canada and Bermuda
Dear former C&B,
I certainly do agree with you too. Eternity transcends time and space and so eternal life is just as important and present here and now as it is in the eternal dimension we're all going to experience after we croak.
However, we can't stop there because if there is a Hell people need to be warned and confronted with it.
How about another Lewis quote? When sophisticated people complained to him that they didn't like the idea of "pie in the sky" he replied, "There either is pie in the sky or there isn't!" Amen.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
.......oh, and P.S.
when Jesus appeared before the disciples as the Risen Lord---that WAS the statement!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Post a Comment