My May 28th article, “Five Simple Truths about the Mideast Conflict,” elicited some passionate responses from those on both sides of the debate, with the first point in particular proving to be the most controversial: “There is no such thing as a historic ‘Palestinian people” living in the Middle East.’”
Let’s unpack two of the most common responses to that assertion, separating myth from fact. Of course, we know that there are several million people living in the West Bank and Gaza who identify as Palestinians today, and regardless of their historic pedigree, they are human beings with real needs. But when a misleading “history” is presented so as to delegitimize Jewish claims to the Land, the falsehoods must be exposed.
Myth #1. The modern Palestinians can trace their lineage back to the ancient Philistines, who were living in the land of Canaan (= Palestine) long before the Israelites had arrived on the scene.
This is completely false as to any lineal or ethnic connection between modern Palestinians and ancient Philistines.
First, the Philistines were Aegean (or Cypriot) sea peoples who migrated to the southern coast of Israel/Canaan in the 12th century BC. It is unclear what relationship they bear with the Philistines who are mentioned in Genesis, hundreds of years earlier. In short, they were not a Semitic people, as the Israelites and Arabs were.
Second, from the 8th-5th centuries BC, they were crushed or ruled by the Assyrians, Babylonians, and Persians, ultimately being absorbed by these populations and entirely disappearing from history. In other words, there was a distinct, end of the line for the Philistines roughly 2,500 years ago.
Second, from the 8th-5th centuries BC, they were crushed or ruled by the Assyrians, Babylonians, and Persians, ultimately being absorbed by these populations and entirely disappearing from history. In other words, there was a distinct, end of the line for the Philistines roughly 2,500 years ago.
Third, six hundred years after the extinction of the Philistines, and after putting down a Jewish revolt, the Romans changed the name of Judea to Palaestina (in Latin) in order to discourage Jewish patriotism. So, there is absolutely no lineal or ethnic connection between the (earlier) Philistine people and the (later) land called Palestine. In fact, the Philistines had previously lived in the western part of the country, on the Mediterranean coast, whereas Palestine originally referred to the eastern part of the country, on the West Bank of the Jordan river.
Fourth, some Muslim leaders have claimed that there was a continuous Arab presence in Palestine dating back to Muslim conquests in the 7th century AD. But this dubious claim, even if true , would still mean that the continuous Jewish presence in the land predated the first major Arab presence by at least 2,000 years, and it would also underscore the fact that there is no connection between the later Arabs and the earlier (extinct) Philistines.
Myth # 2. The whole argument about there being no historic, “Palestinian people” is meaningless, since there’s is no such thing as a historic Iraqi people either. Borders were artificially created after World War I.”
This is false, as to the overall argument and only partially true about the artificial borders.
Anyone who knows the history of the modern Middle East will recognize the names of nation-states that did not exist as such before (such as United Arab Emirates). But not all national identities in the Middle East are of recent origin.
There has certainly been an ancient, historic Egyptian people in the region, to the south of Israel, and an ancient, historic Syrian-Lebanese people, to the north of Israel, while the Iraqi people often traced their heritage back to the ancient kings of Babylon as well as to the golden age of Islam that flourished in their region 700 years ago. In contrast, the Arabs living in Palestine had no such national identity because they had no such ancient, historic roots, not to mention the fact that there were dozens of other (non-Arab) peoples living in Palestine, some of whom had ruled the region for centuries.
In the oft-quoted words of the celebrated Arab-American historian and Princeton University professor, Philip Hitti, testifying before the Anglo-American Committee in 1946, “There is no such thing as ‘Palestine’ in history, absolutely not.” And so, if there was no “Palestine” in the pre-1948 Arab consciousness, there was no Palestinian people. The only people living in Palestine who traced their pedigree back to ancient, biblical times and who awaited the restoration of their ancient homeland were the Jewish people.
But why bother with facts? The old myths and lies are so much more effective.
Michael Brown


4 comments:
I find this whole argument quite disturbing. The history of the whole world is one of conquest and occupation. Every people you care to name, at one time or another has either conquered another - claiming their land, Occupied another's land - claiming their land, or been conquered or occupied - having their land claimed. Tracing genealogies etc through a people in a particular land is pointless and futile - and irrelevant. If your'e going to trace genealogies like this, then why not displace every single people in every single land. Remember - originally, there were no settled peoples - all peoples were basically nomadic, and had a 'range' as opposed to a designated area. Even the Jews were not originally in that area of land - they were a nomadic people who had no land. Then they conquered a people, then they were conquered. The land historically belongs to no-one - therefore, all peoples need to learn to co-exist - like we do in other parts of the world.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
Promises were made to the Jews in the OT. Some were about possessing the land of Israel.If the Jewish tribes and eventually a nation was formed through Abraham by these promises there are still some to take place. God told the Jews to move into the land (that was already occupied by other tribes.)At first the Jews were afraid but moved into the land and conquered the people. Some were killed and some were displaced.That is what scripture states. To this day there is fighting in the area and claims are put upon the whole region by descendents from Arabs (which are descendents of Jewish relatives.)The Palestinians are displaced Arabs rejected and moved out of Syria, Jordan and who knows where else.This fighting will continue until Christ returns.
If Israel has to return land to the Palestinians(pre1967)as called upon by the US President and other Arabs , then The US should return land in Texas, Southern California and Arizona,back to Mexico. It does get complicated.I am still waiting upon Jordan and Syria to take in and support some of the Arab refugees. Israel has released more land to the Palestinians but it is never enough. There are some people that would have all of the Jews in Israel pushed into the Mediterranean Sea.
In the end it will take the Lord to sort it out
while men struggle to resolve these issues.
USA former
Eh Graeme,
Once again I can't get over how much we think a like on so many different subjects! Thanks to your ususally beating me to the punch line when it comes to reading submissions and commenting on them, I almost never have to type as much as I originally planned to do!
I do want to add a few extra comments though. I suspect that the article's author Michael Brown has probably been influenced by the teachings of the Pat Robertsons, Al Mohlers, John Hagees and late great Jerry Falwells, etc. of the world. I'd insert the F__________t word here but it might upset our USA East Former friend so I won't. (lol!)
In my archive I have several video examples over the years of Pat Robertson in particular, on his 700 Club, claiming that such and such recent weather calamity in the states had something to do with the U.S. government at the time caving into some demand of the Palestinians and not siding with the state of Israel politically 100%. (a very rare occurance indeed considering the strong Zionist lobby in D.C.---but it does happen in the name of fair play sometimes--though sadly not in the latest UPI press release from a few days ago!)
My own personal view is that just like in any conflict between two people, two nations or whatever both sides have their good and bad points. Political compromise that keeps the human diginity of both entities intact is always the best course of action.
Where the problem lies is in two areas: The first is in the tendency of humans to always get bogged down in Biblical technicalities while (as Jesus himself pointed out) forgetting the more important things that scripture teaches such as love and mercy.
Years ago I had a relative who had one son and two daughters. The son and one daughter were doing fine financially while one of the daughters was deserted by her husband with two small children. This relative (who probably never actually read the Bible in her life) had heard somewhere that the Bible taught that the parents are supopose to help the oldest son and that once a daughter got married it was her husband's parents who were responsible for helping her.(!!!???) If the son-in-law's parents were deceased (as was so in her daughter's case) it was just too bad! So she helped her son and his family out with financial gifts even though he didn't need it and totally ignored the daughter who was in a desperate situation.(uh duh,) According to her she was doing God's will because that's how she understood the Bible!!
One can also see this perverted thinking at work in how people interpret James 1:27 and his admonition to always remember widows and orphans. The spirit if his statement was to help those in dire straits. But sure enough a whole slew of people are out there today giving widows who may have pensions and paid up mortgages, etc. free cups of coffee with understanding, etc. while treating some other woman whose been deserted by her husband and is living in dire straits like she's a piece of garbage.
The second problem is that people always seem to get the word "chosen" in the Biblical sense mixed up with what the world thinks "chosen" means! I contend that when we're "chosen" by God in any context whether as Jews, or Salvationists or Xians, or Salvation Army officers or on and on----we are chosen to "lay down our lives daily for the sake of others." It does not mean what the world thinks it means! And since Jesus taught it thus, I think my belief of what the Biblical view of chosen means puts me in good Xian company.
God Bless TSA!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home by the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
Being a chosen people calls for many responsibilities. That goes for Christians and Jews.Both have often failed in what God has required and expected. I think that is one reason why Israel is in a mess today. It will take the return of the Lord to fix it all.
USA former
Post a Comment