Friday, November 4, 2011

Should the Salvation Army be distinctive? Part Three of Four



What about Salvation Army service?  Are the services provided by the Salvation Army so different from that of other organisations?  In terms of social services, other churches do similar things to us and have often been doing so for as long as the Army has exited, e.g. Anglicare[7] helped over 400,000 in NSW alone last year and has been going since 1859.  Uniting Care is of a similar size to the Salvation Army.  (The Salvation Army[8] helped 1.2 million Australia Wide.)  Sometimes the Army even takes over the welfare services of other organisations, and vice versa.  We work in co-operation with the welfare organisations of other churches, and are often co-located.  This does not equate to distinctiveness either.
Perhaps our worship services make us distinctive?  Today it would just depend where you went both in the Salvation Army and in other churches.  Different Corps and different churches all have different flavours, but in reality we’re just not that different.  Have you ever been to another service in another church and really enjoyed it?  Have others been to our services and really enjoyed them?  The answer to both those questions must surely be yes.  How does this make us so distinctive we are incapable of being blended with any other people?
To be fair to Higgins there are things that make us different, such as the lack of Baptism and Communion etc.  But in perspective we are still not that much different from other churches for there is wide variation within the Church as to how Baptism and Communion are conducted and in the case of Communion the frequency of the sacrament.  The Salvation Army’s position as indicated by Salvation Army leaders in India is just another variation: “We hear our Lord’s command to remember his broken body and his outpoured blood as in our families and in our faith communities we eat and drink together. We affirm that our meals and love feasts are an anticipation of the feasts of eternity, and a participation in that fellowship which is the Body of Christ on earth.”[9]  


A similar position with regard to Baptism exists.  We have replaced one ceremony or sacrament[10] for another.  We don’t baptise, but we swear in Soldiers, and have a ceremony to become an Adherent.
Perhaps Higgins was referring to the fact that when he wrote his statement Salvation Army Worship was characterised by Brass Band music.  Many would still identify with this today.  But the original reasons for using brass band music no longer exist today, namely that it was the most popular form of music around in the 1850’s until the early 1900’s.  For example Sousa composed “Stars and Stripes Forever” in 1896 and some claim that his band was the most popular musical act in the world for over 30 years[11].  The new entertainment craze, the brass band, gave the Salvation Army the chance to proclaim the gospel. The Army with its brass band would play on street corners, especially pub corners. People would flock out of the pub and from all over the neighbourhood, and listen for hours. This is how an audience was gathered to whom the gospel could be preached. Salvation Army bands attracted large crowds that gave Salvationists an opportunity to present the gospel.
There was no doubt that this method of winning people for the Lord was distinctive, but it is not the brass band in itself or that it was part of our worship that was distinctive, but the fact that we were prepared to use the most modern popular music of the day to win people for the Lord.  More than forty years ago the likelihood of someone coming to know the Lord through the playing of a brass band on a street corner had diminished to virtually zero.  If Booth were alive today, he might ask: “Why are you guys walking around in funny looking outfits and playing brass bands? You should be doing the most current and relevant thing, not immortalizing some practice! The value was in preaching Christ, not the perpetuation of the band and the bonnet.”[12]




Graeme Glenn
Former
Melbourne, Australia

The article was originally written whilst working for the Salvos at a men's hostel (for homeless etc) and attending Frankston Corps




[7]            http://www.anglicare.org.au/aboutang.html
[8]            http://www.salvationarmy.org.au/students/helping.asp
[9]            http://www1.salvationarmy.org/www_ind.nsf/0/9b47bc12fd0e3d0980256c5800499add?OpenDocument
[10]            sacrament means a formal religious act conferring a specific grace on those who receive it
[11]            http://www.greentequila.com/apexperts/music/#bands
[12]            http://www.wcg.org/wn/98july/window_on_the_world.htm

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Very true and interesting.

USA Former