Al Mohler clarifies his views on attending same-sex weddings, but more questions arise.
by Url Scaramanga
Last week I wrote a brief report about Al Mohler's dissatisfaction with Joel Osteen's answers during his CNN interview with Piers Morgan. Osteen said that while he would not officiate a same-sex marriage ceremony, he was open to attending one if it involved close friends. Dr. Mohler said Osteen's position was "beyond mere incoherence. It is moral and theological nonsense. More than that, it is a massive statement of ministerial malpractice."
On this blog I asked whether Mohler's objection to attending a same-sex marriage ceremony was held by other Urbanites. And what about other marriage ceremonies that didn't mesh with sound Christian doctrine, like Muslim, Hindu, or Buddhist weddings? Could a Christian attend those events?
It seems that Dr. Mohler caught wind of our conversation here on Out of Ur and has written another column to clarify his thinking. But it raises even more questions about what a Christian leader who does not theologically agree with same-sex marriage is allowed or obligated to do about it.
(First of all, in Dr. Mohler's column he mistakenly calls me Uri (U-R-I) Scaramanga rather than Url (U-R-L). A common and innocent mistake, but Uri is my younger brother who stayed in the family circus business while I left the trapeze for seminary. But I digress.)
Mohler clarifies that he does not believe attending a same-sex marriage ceremony is the same as officiating one. However, he does believe it is inconsistent. Why? He appeals to the history and tradition of the Christian marriage ceremony. Essentially, according to Mohler, attending the ceremony is the same as affirming and blessing the marriage. He writes:
The traditional Christian ceremony, as reflected in The Book of Common Prayer, asks if anyone present knows of any reason why the couple should not be joined in holy matrimony. That is not intended as a hypothetical question. It is intended to ensure that no one present knows of any reason that the union should not be solemnized, recognized, and celebrated.... To remain silent at that point is to abdicate theological and biblical responsibility. Even if the question is not formally asked in the ceremony, the issue remains. We cannot celebrate what we know to be wrong.
This argument raises a number of questions for me. First, what if the same-sex marriage ceremony isn't a Christian service? What if it's a civil ceremony not rooted in any Biblical tradition or liturgy?
Second, does this logic mean that every time we are invited to attend a wedding we must investigate the moral and spiritual histories of the couple being married to ensure that we can indeed celebrate their union? Personally, I've been to a few weddings of couples who I felt shouldn't be getting married, or at least who didn't have a good chance of making the marriage last. Was I wrong to attend? Certainly being the same gender isn't the only thing to disqualify a couple from Christian marriage, is it?
Third, does Mohler's reasoning apply to Christians interacting with same-sex couples in other settings? For example, should a Christian tax attorney refuse to help a same-sex couple file a joint return? And should we refuse to work for corporations that offer benefits to same-sex couples because it passively affirms the union?
Finally, what about same-sex divorce? With more states legalizing these marriages, it's only a
matter of time before some of them are dissolved. Is that something Christians should celebrate--the correcting of a theological error? Or is it a case of two wrongs not making things right?
Al Mohler ends his column with a statement I'm guessing we can all affirm: "Given time, no church, no family, and no individual Christian will escape this question. This will lead, unquestionably, to hard decisions and awkward situations. The time to think about this question is now."
Indeed, we do need to think about how to appropriately respond to shifting cultural mores and values. And if a consistent, uncompromising non-affirmation of same-sex marriage is what Mohler advocates, are we ready to fight that everyday on every front: church, business, government, schools, entertainment, and family? Apart from attending a ceremony, what else could be interpreted as affirming or celebrating a same-sex union? Talk about a slippery slope!
Logic may mandate consistency as Dr. Mohler argues. But wisdom may lead us to choose the battles worth fighting.
October 19, 2011
Dr. R. Albert Mohler, Jr., serves as president of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary — the flagship school of the Southern Baptist Convention and one of the largest seminaries in the world.


38 comments:
I would absolutely attend...d
I would and have attended a same sex ceremony but, when asked to officiate, declined to do so. Even if the day comes when TSA endorses same sex unions (can't imagine that happening in my life time) my personal principles would not allow me to officiate in any form.
I attended because one partner was the son of officers and the other a good friend.
Active, Australia
Dear Active in Melbourne- I was able to identify your location from your IPO (not who you are though) and would invite you to share your views through a blog article. Were there other SA persons present and in uniform?
We in TSA appear to have become steadily more tolerant and thankfully, inclusive.
Blessings-
I would, and have, and am delighted to see my friends are still happily 'married' four years later. There were numerous Salvationists who shared this occasion with the happy couple, Officers active, formers and retired. Personal greetings sent from a retired General and his Commissioner wife. None of us were in uniform but I don't think we would have been had a hetrosexual couple of friends been getting married at a registry office.
I was pleased to have been invited and share in their moments of commitment and celebration. What would my response have been had they asked me to perform their ceremony ...I really don't know.
Active UKT
To answer the question , no. I would not attend either. I also do not think that The Salvation Army will ever sanction same sex marriages. Ever.
Yes people have and are entitled to their opinions. We all live with our decisions bad and good. I strongly disagree with even promoting this.
I have noticed this topic draws attention. Usually not many conservatives respond.
USA Former Major
NO!
YES!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
P.S. I'm in a hurry to get to work but will try to comment in more length/depth if I get a chance to on Monday. Btw, Al Mohler should start worrying about more important things. I've been monitoring him and his far right cronies for several years now (since 1994 to be exact)and considering some of the things they say and do it's becoming harder and harder over time to believe that any of them have ever been playing with a full deck.
Before we can even begin to answer this question, we need to as a church, and a body of believers, come to agreement on the subject of homosexuality. We have a VERY long way to go in this discussion. Then, we need to tease out the distinction between church marriage, and civil marriage - and what legal rights are attributed to both - and how they are enacted. This will be different for each country as different countries have different legal definitions of marriage enshrined in their respective constitutions.
You all would know my view - yes I would. And if given the opportunity, I would even bless a same sex union.
P.S. - is there a comment that has been deleted? Sven's comment suggests he is responding to another comment - but it doesn't seem to be there. Would be interesting to read it.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
No! Subject closed!
Active Officer
yes, yes, yes, subject wide open!
ACTIVE UK
Not on my turf!!!
ACTIVE C&B
thats ok,other turfs are ok too....!!!
ACTIVE UK
Yes there ARE other turfs too as Active UK notes and once you've been exposed to a few of them you just might be led (hopefully by the Holy Spirit) to change your mind Active C&B!(and others).
Twenty years ago I had made up my mind that gays (the same as many women) had been throughout the millennia victimised by (an often times hypocritical) patriarchy and that the Holy Spirit may very well had been speaking to the church and leading it to a new understanding---in much the same way the Spirit did on various hot button social issues in the early church and throughout Xian history.
I have to admit though that I still had my reservations about gay marriage. It was just something I had never been exposed to and saw as a strange anomaly.
Then ten years ago I was living in southern California and attending an "inclusive" Episcopalian (Anglican) Church and was forced within myself to do a complete turn-a-around! We had both straight and gay couples (and many singles)in our congregation who were every bit as committed to living out their faith in the world as I had seen in any evangelical or holiness church including the Army. We had a church directory that included colored photos of the various families that attended. It was an eye-opener.
The few lesbian couples we had as members tended to be older and from another generation altogether but many of the men were young and/or middle aged and were creating families made up of unwanted, oftentimes physically challenged and sometimes very abused children whom they had adopted as couples. It made a very deep impression on me and quite frankly blew my mind! If I were to listen to the Al Mohlers of the world I would have to believe that all any of these men ever cared about was where their next orgasm was coming from and that any marriage between two gays were somehow "intrinsically evil." It just wasn't/isn't true. The gay men couples I met all made wonderful fathers to children who would otherwise have no one.
Of course there are selfish, evil gays in the world the same as there are selfish, evil straights---but why discriminate on whose wedding to attend based on just sexual orientation? It makes no sense.
As Scott Peck once pointed out in "People of the Lie" evil often times comes in "couples." He believed that there are marriages where the whole attraction and reason for the marriage is to do great evil in the world. In fact I just recently saw two television documentaries on one such famous couple in Toronto and then another one in California! (The UK has has a few well-known ones too!)
According to Al Mohler it would apparently be O.K. to attend the wedding of of an evil heterosexual couple (as long as you didn't know just what it was that they were up to) but not O.K. to attend the wedding of a gay couple no matter how much Xian love they may exhibit through their marriage in the future. Balderdash!
One last point: If the fundamentalist views of Al Mohler are all "scriptually based" then the lives of E.C. Booth, Eva Burrows and Linda Bond have been and are "unscriptural and sinful" as were and are the lives of thousands of women who have been and are Salvation Army officers. The man probably wouldn't be caught dead at a Commissioning Service.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home by the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!
Since the practice of homosexual acts is specifically forbidden in Scripture then I would not attend such. I also fervently hope that TSA never gives in to political correctness on ths matter.
To be trite asbout this , God created Adam and Eve, Man and Woman he created them He did not create Adam and Brucie (or the female version) and pronounce it okay.
And by the way I know and have "gay" friends who accept that I have such a view but we still remain friends and get along. I also know many whose temptation has been in this area who have resisted such because of what they see as Biblical standards and what they see as sin.
John Stephenson
Canada and Bermuda
But John you keep missing the point. Homosexual acts are specifically forbidden by scripture only if you have a fundamentalist view of scripture. If you(or anyone else) does have a fundamentalist view of scripture then what the heck are you doing in The Salvation Army? A fundamentalist view of scripture does and always has specifically forbidden women preachers---not to mention a myriad of other acts throughout TSAs history that fundamentalists would without question condemn. For instance, non-participation in the sacraments also comes to mind. (uh duh,)
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Not everyone has a total of all fundamentalist beliefs. I rarely see true Calvinists or Arminians any more either. I see a lot of mixed bags during this day and age. Although I may agree with a few "fundamentalist" doctrines that does not make me a true "fundamentalist" as you (Daryl) have proclaimed upon certain individuals. I think you are in error in that reasoning. I also think much of Salvation Army doctrine and much of it's practice is leaning toward fundamentalism , but not completely. I cannot speak for the rest of the Army world but many American and Canadian Salvationists would agree that gay and lesbian marriages are not acceptable according to Scripture. Nothing was ever mentioned in the Bible about same sex marriages but homosexuality was condemned. It did not need to be considered.
As several times before on this site, I would have to say that the biggest difference between opinions about the subject is the interpretation of Scripture. Some Bible scholars that have spent years studying the Greek and Hebrew texts will differ on some interpretation of the meanings and practices of older societies.
USA former
Hi,
I'm neither an Officer or a "Former", but if I were to be invited to a Same-Sex Marriage Ceremony then I would attend. Absolutely!
The Salvation Army is a movement that started life – influenced by Jesus – radically reaching out to the marginalised and in large part that remains the case. Sometimes, though, we do need to remind ourselves of that heritage and to show more willingness to find ourselves in a place that reaches out to our LGBT brothers and sisters with love and grace.
It seems particularly in the US we’ve become public enemy #1 for many in the gay community, and for me this is a great source of sadness.
Like many/most Christian tribes we’re on a journey when it comes to our interpretation of and response to human sexuality, and there is no longer absolute consensus at grass roots within our global ranks about quite where we stand on this issue. I would hope and pray that informed dialog is happening at a senior International leadership level.
The place where we are today may well not be where we are in the future.
I’m less convinced than some of the other commentators that the Army’s position will stay the same, in fact rather feeling that we are getting marginally closer to some kind of tipping point where we really do “stand for and serve the marginalised”. Many individuals in the Army are certainly showing signs of a shift in their view of human sexuality.
If change happens – and I think it may - I don’t see it as bowing to Political Correctness, and would suggest we consider not too closely associate our Movement with any particular political worldview. Salvationists come from all sides of the tracks politically and within the local context they find themselves in.
It may even be – given our history and reputation with the LGBT community – that we have a special ministry of reconciliation to engage in here.
Most of all, we need as Salvationists to see ourselves and be seen as people who follow the way of Jesus.
Grace & peace
J
And Johnny our view needs to within the bounds of what Scripture allows. Isn't it interesting that in Genesis in the Creation story that it says He created them man and woman and told them to Go forth and multiply. Seeing that God indicated that how then does a same sex couple multiply. God's direction is clear. Marriage and sexual activity is for opposite sex partners.
John Stephenson
Canada andf Bermuda
John S
I would agree with you 100% but you must know a big disagreement is the interpretation of Scripture. Also you will hear that today is a different culture and God is revealing some things now that He did not reveal in Scripture. Also "theology" is evolving. These are some arguements for the pro-gay and lesbian reasoning. I do not buy it or agree with it but people are entitled to their opinion.
USA former
John S.
If one were to take your reasoning to its logical conclusion then no one should be allowed to marry except young fertile couples. And then what if after the marriage it's discovered that they're infertile (at least with each other) and that they can't produce children together? Would they in your worldview then be allowed to divorce and find someone else with whom they could have children?
Also, if the reason for marriage is only reproduction wouldn't it be more logical for everyone to have sex before marriage and see if the woman in question can first can get pregnant--- and thus in the process disregard the Biblical injunction from Paul that the Xian sexual standard is celibacy before marriage and fidelity after?
I doubt that the world has ever worked as neatly and idealistically as the fundamentalist mindset seems to insist that it does. Where exactly does Xian GRACE fit into such absolute one size fits all pronouncements?
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Darryl
Prevenient Grace reaches out to all mankind showing us that we are totally depraved, have the tendency to sin (original sin or whatever you want to call it) It shows us that and with the help of Holy Spirit convicts us that we are not only tainted with the sin principle but that we actually do sin. It also shows us that we can reconnect with God and become part of His Forever Family by repenting, confessing and accepting Jesus as Lord and Master. We also do not get to choose some sins as being no longer sin and ignore them. The fact that society today is rejecting certain behaviours as sin does not mean that God no longer considers them sin.....Christs Grace has no limits in its forgiveness except the limits we as individuals put on it be rejecting His word and His commands.
Does that belief structure make me old fashioned to the extent that I am wrong...no it does not. I do not bleief for a moment that God who is immutable has changed--it is us ,mankind, who hopes He has changed.
As a Salvationist I pray that we never get to thestage where we as an organization accept same sex relationships as being okay. If that happens I would predict that many will go elsewhere rather than remain in an apostate organization.
John Stephenson
Canada and Bermuda
Dear John,
Thank you very much for the refresher course on prevenient grace but methinks you're making way too much out of six unrelated (out of what--a million?)Bible verses that when an in-depth exegesis is done on them all turn out to mean something very different from what they seem to "read" in modern English and imply in 21st century culture. This is especially true in light of all the scientific and psychological knowledge we now have on the subject that was not available to the Biblical writers.
I mean, why not just go backwards and re-adopt the idea that the "circle of the Earth" as mentioned in Isaiah 40:21 was speaking about a cosmos where the Earth was held up by two poles and everything taking place between them represented a circle-like canvas?
As the creature instead of the Creator whenever there's even the slightest question mark about anything in my head I much prefer to stick with all of the verses that have to do with and/or lead to mercy and GRACE---common, prevenient, saving, sanctifying---you name it---GRACE! That's why if invited, I'd gladly attend a same sex wedding ceremony.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home by the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!
What did I tell you John ? Todays culture is different, the verses do not mean what you think they do because the original Hebrew or Greek translations vary or mean something different than what some scholars say they do. You name it , a host of opinions and excuses can be made about a person's belief or their own "theology" to fit their own lifestyle or practice.
USA Former
Dear USA Former,
Uh huh. So have you closed out all of your bank accounts and given everything to the poor YET?? It's right there in black and white, very easy to memorize and Jesus (the WORD in the Flesh, not just the Word in words) actually said it. Or doesn't it fit in with your lifestyle?
Daryl Lach
USA Central
You used that one before , Daryl. It does not cut it since I am not a fundamentalist anyway and you took the Scripture out of context. Who was Jesus speaking to? How would you know if I gave everything anyway? Jesus has not commanded me to give up ALL of my earnings since I would neglect the support of my family and then I would be in worse shape. You have abused what you state that others do. That is why I stated what I did to John.
A major factor seems to be once again interpretation of Scripture and opinion. We may agree on many things but on this subject, NO.
USA former
USA Former and John Stevenson,
Daryl makes a very good point. You both hold up scripture as the final arbiter in this debate, say that we can't pick and chose which sins are applicable or not - we must obey all of scripture. Then you say certain things don't apply to you because your not a fundamentalist. With that level of hypocrisy, how can anyone take anything you say in this debate seriously? Either you are a fundamentalist and you obey every part of the Bible to the letter, or your not, and you bow to interpretation and agree to disagree, allowing others to have their individual relationship with God as you are, and we all worship together in one family. There is no middle ground here.
By saying that certain things don't apply to you because you're not a fundamentalist means you are doing exactly what you claim the 'pro-gay' Christian scholars are doing - cutting and pasting. If you're going to accuse someone of doing something, you have to make sure you're not doing it yourself.
Yours in Christ
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
Graeme,
I would totally disagree with you on your reasoning.You are mixing up all type of hype and opinion to qualify your life. That is up to you.You have the right to live the way you desire. You can twist the Bible to your way of thinking and talk in circles.You are accusing me of something that is not correct.
We have been down this road many times and you know it.I have shared about how I relate to people of different back grounds and opinions in my line of work in social services.I have lost all of my gay friends . They are dead. They died of HIV disease.
I have shared that no one follows the Bible in a 100% set pattern. You are not 100% liberal. Tagging titles and calling me a hypocrite is not very conducive to your phrase (worship together in one family). You seem to be overbearing and rude to people. I do not insinuate a title to you like "Hypocrite".
I do not tell you how to live. You live your life according to your conscience and your interpretation of Scripture. I DO NOT tell you how to live. You have your mind made up.You are wrong in your assumption and idea of my thinking. You are in short attempting to tell people that they can not have their opinion because it is your way or the highway.
I am not a fundamentalist anymore than you are.
My statement on Bible scholars disagreeing on interpretation was to display that we all may disagree on certain texts or interpretation of Hebrew and Greek words. You have shared in the past that certain words do not have the meaning that certain Bible commentators have declared. Hence we have different opinions and interpretation. THAT is what I was referring to.
So when it comes to that, there must be agreement to disagree. I disagree with your opinion concerning the topic currently discussed. On other issues I would agree and I have found that quite often.
USA Former , soon to be active
By the way, for further thought... does anyone believe in the true "TITHE"of the Old Testament? It is much more than 10% and was used for the Theocracy and government of Israel. This demand is in Scripture , but is it for today for Christians ? The principal is understood for supporting a fellowship of believers and for paying taxes for services that we use in our respective governments. The fact is that teaching was to Old Testament Jews. That does not apply to us today , however we do need to support the Lord's work in some proportionate manner. Paul states in the New Testament that we should set aside a portion of our income so that the ministry would be supported.
I share that as well as circumcision (OT practice) to reveal to Daryl and Graeme that YES, I do not follow the Bible verbatim. Much of the OT has nothing to do with me but I would add that there is some history and principles that we would all agree that blend with the NT. Those areas would be concerning God's love , judgement , forgiveness and so forth. So, I am guilty as charged. I am not a literalist. The OT mentions (the finger of God). God is a Spirit and has no body , so how can He have a finger ? Here we have figurative communication. I am just a disciple that does not claim to know it all but will answer to God for my actions and how I shared Jesus with a lost world.
USA former
I would absolutley attend, and I would officiate if it were a couple I believed were sincere and well prepared for marriage. Of course, as an active officer I am confident I would be ousted immediatley. Gratefully I work for God and not man. Acitve Officer - Canada
Dear USA Former five comments back and Soon to Be Re-activated,
Taken out of context and blown up way out of proportion to what the main themes of scripture (and the words of Jesus in particular) teach? My point (via satire) exactly!
Six unrelated verses out of one million have been taken out of their cultural, historical and linguistic context to unfortunately promote and maintain a centuries old prejudice against a minority group of people whom we now know were/are born/wired differently from the majority.
For God's Sake (and I mean that literally) isn't it about time that this travesty STOPS??!!
Do your part USA Former Soon to be Re-activated and attend the next same sex wedding you're invited to. Small meaningful gestures of solidarity can go a long way in the scripture inspired struggle for universal justice.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
P.S. Btw, why do you keep insisting that people who disagree with you on this subject are perverting the scriptures to "justify their lifestyles?" I thought that I already made it very clear that my "lifestyle" consists of working 10 hour shifts, taking care of a mother with Alzheimers for the past nine years, sleeping when and wherever I can, reading, writng and overeating greasy potato chips and cheezelets? Also, I met Graeme in London during the ISB 120 Celebrations in June and I hardly doubt that the man in any way lives a licentious life. Put a lid on it already.
P.S.S. Oh and one other thing: Congratulations on your soon to be re-instatement! I always suspected upon reading your comments that at heart you could not "Leave the Dear Old Flag" and would probably be back. After two plus decades you probably just needed a respite to re-group and re-energize. It's interesting that other denominations have seen the need for and have already adopted respite procedures for their clergy without any recriminations and as a result everyone's the better off for it. I don't know exactly how that would look within the Army system but if something similar was done within TSA maybe there wouldn't be so many resignations in first world countries.
I'm reminded that Catherine Bramwell Booth had "health concerns" in her early 40s and was sent to the south of France with a private duty officer nurse for a couple of years to "recuperate." We all know the story: She came roaring back, preaching well into her 90s and didn't croak until the ripe old age of 104! May the same fate be yours USA Former! And may God Bless You and your family as you seek to do His will.
P.S.S.S. Just curious---are you going to be reinstated in the USA East or are you staying in the USA West?
Daryl,
Yes ,you shared that all before. We have gone round and round as you know.You have your mind made up on certain things and I do on others.I am glad that we are not robots but have freedom of choice.Again , I do not know you as God does and cannot judge you and I haven't .I just disagree on a few issues.You make some good points about time off from active ministry. I always thought that there should be other provisions concerning that issue.Whatever happens in this Army usually takes much time for change.
I doubt if I ever will attend a same sex marriage. I think that it is wrong. My understanding and interpretation of Scripture and the way God has "wired" me says NO.We will ALL face the Lord on that and several other issues.We must ALL account for our lives and practice one day.
I have over 25 years as an officer and time in another ministry as a pastor. I do not have many years left and hope to serve in the West. My wife had a few health issues and we desired to live near family. I love it in the desert.
Time will tell. The Lord is good.
USA former (for now)
USA Former (for now)
I don't think you realise that when you call into question my salvation because of what you call 'your lifestyle' (more correctly - my theology), that you are being just as hurtful, just as judgemental, just as labelling etc (if not more so) than you are accusing me of being towards you. Yes. We do have different opinions and views on different things. And yes, we will all be called to account for them before God on the day of judgement. But this side of eternity, we cannot know the full mind of God, or what He says on certain issues, or what is the answer to these questions/topics that keep coming up.
It is not my intention to change your view and make you pro-gay. I accept that different people have different understandings, and different relationships with God as God is an individual God who has an individual relationship with each and every one of His children. What I'm trying to get you to do is accept me as a fellow Christian, allow me to minister as a fellow Christian. You don't have to accept as right everything I say, we can agree to disagree. But allow me to live as a Christian the way God has called me. I will never stop you from being accepted as a Christian, or demand that you be kicked out of the church because of what you believe. I will put the mirror up to you when you make certain statements about me - but I will always accept you as part of the church. When you say the things you do, you belittle God who called me. You assume you can know the full mind of God. You assume you know my lifestyle etc. I don't insist that you affirm homosexuality, but I do ask that you allow homosexuals who may or may not be in a relationship, to be considered Christians and be part of the church, and have full ministry and membership rights in the church, and let them answer to GOD on judgement day as we all will.
All the arguments about the 'dangers of homosexuality' and how accepting it will pervert society, and how homosexuals 'do this' or 'do that' etc. are not helpful or accurate. Again, it simply indicates that people do not know what a homosexual is, and are willing to make up spurious data that has no basis in reality in order to support a particular view/theology.
Much of our discussions has not been about biblical interpretation, but about what a homosexual is. You believe homosexuality is a choice or a sickness. That means that although you have had gay friends die of AIDS, you still don't know what a homosexual is. We cannot even begin to have a discussion on interpretation of scripture until we agree on what a homosexual is.
BTW - I join with Daryl in congratulating you on your future re-instatement. I would probably be seeking re-instatement tomorrow if I were allowed to.
Yours in Christ
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East.
Graeme,
When I state a "lifestyle", I am not pronouncing judgement only God can do that. I still think you are misunderstanding a few things that I share. I always am better at voice to voice. You can always stress with the voice or have a friendly tone.I do understand what a homosexual is but YES probably not quite as much as you, but I believe from what the Bible shares (and doesn't share)that homosexuality is sin. Bluntly , two people of the same gender having sexual intercourse is sin.Having tendencies and abstaining is not sin. I agree with the Army policy on homosexuality.I am totally against marriage of the same sex. I do not believe it is of God. I believe it is human choice only. I do not believe God creates homosexuals. Yes, I think it is choice with what one does with their lives.
I do think much does have to do with interpretation of Scripture and some peoples persuasion and what they read and what they are exposed to. This has come up several times.
I am one that believes in freedom of choice.We often watch people go down the tubes in sin or in a downward spiral after we have shared or warned of consequences. When we make bad or wrong choices we often pay the price this side of eternity. Having stated that I condemn no one.I will leave that up to Jesus.
My thoughts as far as you being called as gay to minister, I think that you are wrong.What you do is your business. I have no right to tell you how to live. You want to know my opinion, I have shared it. I just would not make anyone a soldier or officer if they were openly having a sexual relationship.Same as a man and woman. I was asked by a couple that were living together and having sexual relations , to become soldiers. I stated , NO. But if they took the proper steps to correct the situation I shared that there would be consideration.
With what I have shared all along does not diminish the love that God has for us all.
Evidently you worship and serve somewhere else besides the Salvation Army. Although I agree with the Army policy about this subject, you seem to put an over-all general blame on me. I think you are more upset with Army leadership and policy , not me. I am not your enemy. You have chosen a place where you worship and fellowship. I personally think that is a good thing, although some would disagree with me on that one.
For the fifteenth time I also remind you of my temperment and concern for all people. Black, Indian-American Native, white, gay , Hispanic, Chinese, lesbian, Christian , atheist , Hebrews,followers of Islam , you name it. I serve and assist all types of people without discrimination.I am friendly to them all. That is what Jesus would do. Full ministry and officership for what you request, I would say no.There is our disagreement.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and reasoning. I have a better understanding from you but as you see I stand firm on my belief. If I didn't I would be one big hypocrite.
Just remember there are several things that we do agree upon.I would agree that there are many
pieces of info that people are off base concerning gays and lesbians. Some folk I know will not discuss these issues at all. Some issues are very deep.
USA former
USA former (and others who might want to respond)
I want to try and understand what you are saying as you say that I am misunderstanding you, and that you are better at speaking than writing. There are a number of things in the above post which as I read them contradict each other - just doesn't make sense to me - so I would like you to explain it better to me so I understand where you are coming from.
1) Why do you believe that homosexuality is a choice? On what basis/research etc are you making that statement/belief? Especially considering that the former leaders of Exodus International have said that no-one in the entire history of the organisation has ever successfully changed from being gay to straight, and those who have attempted to do so have either lived double lives, or have ended up living lives in chronic depression as a result. Also, how do you respond to the mountain of psychological evidence that contradicts the 'choice' idea of sexuality? Do you really believe that homosexuals 'choose' to be gay? Given what happens to gays around the world (including the west, and in the church), why would anyone 'choose' to be gay if they could choose something else? What benefit do they get from that 'choice'? Did you 'choose' to be heterosexual? What's the difference? A thief will 'choose' not to steal if they think that things are going to go bad for him, and when they are good, they can enjoy the spoils of their theft. What benefit does a homosexual get for their 'choice'?
2) What research are you using to understand those 6 biblical verses as referring to homosexuality? Why do you believe that what they are referring to is the same as how we understand homosexuality today? Because I agree that what those verses refer to is sin, and I would not enrol anyone partaking in those practices as a soldier, and I would challenge their salvation if they identified as a Christian. But why do you believe they refer to homosexuality? I don't understand that.
I do think debate on this subject is possible. I hope you will seriously answer my questions to you and not just say something trite like 'the Holy Spirit will convict you' etc. as most people do. These are serious questions, and need to be seriously answered.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
Oops! Big mistake on my part! The more I thought about it there couldn't possibly be one million verses in the Bible---so I did an official check. There are over 31,000 verses and approximately 775,000 words in the KJV. My apologies and as Ann Landers use to write 40 lashes with a wet noodle for me! I take my licks. Someone gave me that one million number along time ago (a Sunday School teacher)and I just never thought about it again!
Yet I believe my original premise is still valid. That 6 unrelated verses out of plus 31,000 representing however many paltry number of words out of 775,000 could cause such a ruckus---verses and words that when the research is done on them probably have nothing to do with the subject as we understand it today, is as stupid as me hearing something at the age of 11 and never thinking any further about it or questioning it!
This is especially poignant when one considers that according to Jim Wallis of Sojourners out of those 31,000 verses nearly 3000 have to do with our moral obligations to the poor and outcasts of society and 500 have to do directly with a government's moral obligations to its poorer citizenry.
Something is obviously amiss with the thinking of many conservative Xians---at least in the United States. I can't speak for other western countries (where they provide their citizens with better social safety nets) but in the U.S. I'm afraid that many Xians unfortunately get their Xianity mixed up with Capitalist-Puritanism.
Few people seem to understand the difference or even care to understand that there is a BIG difference! I suppose that this is at least in part one of the main reasons for all the hysterical ruckus regarding the "horrors" of same sex marriage.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
Graeme,
As I said we have gone this route before, several times.I would be repeating scripture and detail and opinion.You have your mind made up on homosexuality. I have my mind made up. You are emphasizing that if I do not answer to your liking that I am incorrect on one hand but then we need to wait on the other side of eternity for the results. It ends up being a continual argument. Not productive.We have used verses of Scripture showing view points and we disagree. Why keep hashing the same stuff ?
As I shared I agree with the policy statement about homosexuality from the Salvation Army. My understanding is that you do not. I do believe we have a choice on how to live. If homosexuality was condemned in scripture why would God purposely make someone in a state to purposely sin? Choice. As all of us can choose to not sin today. Choice. God does not "make" homosexuals. I think that thought came from lucifer.
I really do not think we want to keep this back and forth. You can live your life and believe what you want. Choice.
USA former
Hi,
Same-sex marriage ceremonies provide officiants and full wedding planning for all couples wishing to marry. When planning a same-sex marriage ceremony, couples need to research their state's laws regarding the legal aspects surrounding the marriage. Thanks...
It's sad when reading Christians are being judgmental towards sexuality. Have you guys ever thought of some of your comment could be hurtful especially people who were born "intersex"? How could you possibly take away the rights of same sex relationship while one in every five hundred people were born being "intersex"? God is gracious and will always be understanding.
Post a Comment