October. 2011
In the LCMS, (The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (LCMS) is a mission-oriented, Bible-based, confessional Christian denomination headquartered in St. Louis, Mo., founded on the teachings of Martin Luther) we've always had a strong doctrine of what it means to be called. It was a term reserved for our clergy, our male clergy (we only have male clergy).
Ministers have certain protections under the tax system. They balance out the additional penalties that Ministers get because they are regarded as self-employed by the Social Security System, and therefore must pay the full 15%, and are regarded as employees by the IRS, and therefore get no tax breaks as self-employed.
Way back, the Synod decided to invoke the title "commissioned minister" upon our male teachers. Since they don't get paid well, and they have families to support, lets extend those benefits to them. Then, of course as female teachers became more prominent and didn't necessarily stop teaching just because they got married, and because it was sexist and the title was meaningless anyway -- it was extended to female teachers as well.
All of this goes against the good sense of reserving the title of Minister for the clergy. It confuses our doctrine. Since this has happened, the Office of the Ministry has lost some of the respect that it once had.
Now, because of the nebulousness of the "commissioned minister" title, an LCMS school teacher has opened the flood gates and given the Obama Administration exactly what they always wanted, the possibility of applying discrimination and employment laws to the Church. She signed a contract when she received a call as a "commissioned minister" but now argues that she really wasn't so that she can win a discrimination suit. I don't envy her health issues, and am not sure why the church school contracted another teacher instead of bringing in a long term substitute -- maybe one wasn't available, but they shouldn't have contracted a teacher to fill her position for the entire year. But the Obama Administration is using this as an opportunity to argue that the nondiscrimination laws are so unbiased that they need to be applied to church situations as well. Here's another story as well.
And...the school is closed down. They've partnered with another church, but these children are not hearing God's Word, and the battle is before the public eye. I'm sure Satan is happy.
The Rebellious Pastor's Wife

3 comments:
With some situations in the USA,maybe it is time there was government intervention. There are cases of discrimination and abuse. I am speaking of various denominations including the Salvation Army.If there was concern and proper care and not the "lording" over people, this thought would not have to be considered.Maybe leaders should think of this before the government moves in as more complaints are brought out in the public.
USA former
The Apostle Paul said 'There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.'
Galatians 3:28. Even Paul, in his day, recognised that in Christ, there is no distinction between people on any grounds. All are equal. All have the same rights.
The church should be leading the way in areas of discrimination. We should be champions and exemplars of non-discriminatory practice. Instead, the secular world is showing us up. We deserve every bit of bad press we get as a result. Satan isn't gloating because our fight is being played out in public, but because we were being deceived by him all along - practising discrimination and following what we THOUGHT was the word of God, instead of actually challenging our beliefs, our theology, our practice, and actually following God.
Something to think about.
Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East
That was GREAT Graeme! Ditto for me. Thanks to you and the way you so eloquently expressed yourself I today only need to comment with three sentences!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
P.S. Btw, USA Former: I also agree with you. Sometimes church groups have gotten away with incredible abuses toward people that never would've been tolerated in a secular setting without immediate police and/or civil authority intervention. Years and years of clergy sexual abuse cases---in EVERY denomination---come to mind, though other types of discrimination and unfair practices can also be cited.
The abuses were generally hushed up, the victims were made to feel guilty and the perpetrators were at best transferred out of the area---if that! I'm happy to see that sad state of affairs now changing thanks to people speaking up and the civil authorities stepping in where need be.
Post a Comment