Friday, November 5, 2010

WHO DO THEY SAY WE ARE?

In 1878, our founder, William Booth, said this: “It was not my intention to create another sect ... we are not a church. We are an Army - an Army of Salvation.”

However, at the 1904 International Congress in London, England, General Booth did declare that “The Army is part of the living Church of God - a great instrument of war in the world, engaged in deadly conflict with sin and fiends.” 11He still did not go as far as saying that the Army is a church, but admitted that we are “part” of the Church.

Catherine Booth
does not specifically say that The Salvation Army is a church either, but she does group us with other churches, called to a distinct witness to them. “The main difference” between us and them, she said, “is in our aggressiveness ... The Bishop of Durham, the learned Dr. Lightfoot, says: ‘The Salvation Army has at least recalled us to the lost ideal of the work of the Church – the universal compulsion of the souls of men.’”

General Bramwell Booth
Echoes and Memories:
There is one Church.. The Salvation Army are an integral part and element -we humbly but firmly claim that we are in no way inferior, either to the saints who have gone before,

General Albert Orsborn
said repeatedly during his office from 1946 - 1954, “We are not a church - we are a permanent mission to the unconverted.” 14 It was during Albert Orsborn’s tenure as General that The Salvation Army became a founding mem- ber of the World Council of Churches, but it was in an article on our relationship with that ecumenical body that he expanded on why he was not comfortable with the Army being regarded as an established church or sect.

To this day, we are still accepted by some churches only as social welfare workers; they do not admit our claim that we have within ourselves a corporate spiritual life, with its own authority, able to provide for our people all the services and rights exercised by a church toward its members. But we are almost universally recognized as a religious denomination by governments, and for purposes of a national emergency – such as war services – or for convenience in designating our offi-cers, they group us with the churches. That is as far as we wish to go in being known as a church. We are, and wish to remain, a Movement for the revival of religion, a permanent mission to the unconverted, one of the world’s greatest missionary soci- eties; but not an establishment, not a sect, not a church, except that we are a part of the body of Christ called ‘‘The Church Militant” and we shall be there, by his grace, with “The Church Triumphant.”

General Frederick Coutts
 “The place of The Salvation Army within the Christian community ... has long been an area of sensitive concern both to those without as well as within the Movement itself.” He suggests, however, that William Booth never left the Methodist Church but simply had an eagerness to fulfill the mission of the Church more effectively when he gave up his place among the Methodists.

It should be remembered that when, on July 18, 1861, William Booth left his assured place as a Superintendent Minister in the Methodist New Connexion, he did not think of himself as leaving the Church. “I offer myself,” he wrote even in his letter of resignation, “for the evangelistic work, in the first instance to our own connexional churches, and, when they decline to engage me, to other portions of the religious community.” This was not the language of a man who was washing his hands of the Church, but of one who could only be faulted for his greater eagerness that the mission of the Church might be fulfilled more effectively.

Members of the Church are those who are “incorporate in Christ Jesus” (Ephesians 1:1, N.E.B.). This is the one thing needful. The Church is the whole of the worshipping, witnessing Christian community through- out the centuries into whatever groupings, large or small, accepted or persecuted, wealthy or poor, her members may have been structured in the past or are governed in the present.

In a sermon preached at a united church service during the week of prayer for Christian unity, he linked the

General Clarence Wiseman
In an article in The Officer magazine of October 1976, General Clarence Wiseman clearly pointed to the need for a Salvationist ecclesiology, a Salvationist doctrine and theology of the Church. As the international leader of our movement at the time, he ventured towards suggesting what the basics of that theology might be. The article was entitled “Are we a church?” and General Wiseman concludes with a positive response to the question of the title. He indicated that he was comfortable with our using a number of terms to describe ourselves, and suggested that all of those descriptions relate to the New Testament concept of “Church.”

It appears ... that we are a permanent mission to the unconverted and a caring social service movement; in some places we assume the features of a religious order. These various aspects exist within the God-given shape of the Army, the worldwide Army of Salvation! Can all these elements be sub-sumed under the generic designation “Church?”

The 1969 Handbook of Doctrine

 “The Holy Spirit called into being that fellowship of believers known in the New Testament as ‘the Church,’” an item not included in the former 1923 Handbook of Doctrine.

(from a paper by Earl Robinson)

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Often overlooked is Booth's intent that, if TSA was not effective as intended in his view, he'd resign, become a 'former' and fulfill the Call by moving his ministry in a new direction.

Keep up the fine blogging- a favourite daily read !

Active UKT HQ

Jeffery T Bassett said...

Thanks Earl. There should be a distinction between being a "church" and being a part of the "Church"
I believe this was Booth's intent as I read his writing and have tried to reconcile same over the years?

Former USA East

Anonymous said...

Thanks Sven for adding the Coutts' quote to the blog head, and your interpretation of it. Speaks soundly for who I am, for one!

I sense the army world is beginning to take notice, finally.

Former; served for 14 years in TSA, and now 11 years in another ministry.
USA East

JTB said...

I just finished looking at the "Exposing The Salvation Army" website referenced in the comments of the Challenging Times article posted earlier on this website. The question of "Who do they say we are?" is being asked by the public, not at all in a flattering way. While many of those making comments have an obvious agenda, there may be some relevance to this particular article.
Don’t be afraid to listen to your critics…don’t listen to them only, but do not ignore what they have to say.

Former USA East

Anonymous said...

People during this recession do not want to hear of hundreds of thousands of dollars spent on a parsonage or quarters. Any where near $1,000,000 is asking for a shellacking , like the democrats received in the recent USA elections. Understanding that most funds for quarters come from wills and estates, the breakdown also covers many other expenses including officers pensions and development. That is all well and good but this could have been handles much better and not as defiant to the American donor. I also think that something else could have been done to not spend such a high dollar on quarters. This will take a while to quiet down and probably caused a loss of many donors. Yes , we do need to listen to the public sometimes and we need to "Do the Most Good".

Former USA East

Anonymous said...

Except for the Prosperity Gospel ding-a-lings who see it as some sort of sign of God's favor and proof of "walking in the light" people don't want to hear about near million dollar quarters and parsonages even in good times----not just during recessions! SA leadership in the USA better wake up and smell the coffee--and soon!

Daryl Lach
USA Central

"You Must go Home by the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"

Anonymous said...

Is the problem that UK Corps, and others I guess, are facing that the
Salvation Army is becoming too much of a so called Church? Or as John Stott was quoted to have said in a recent sermon; “too settled down!” I doubt that The salvation Army are on the streets anywhere in the world as much as they were in the early
years of The Salvation Army’s explosive growth.

Has The SA become nearly too stale now? Where is the drive? Where is the
fighting?! ...Did we lose the fight by letting people push us off the streets
and into our buildings/Corps? Or did we get tired and simply retreated ?

I guess out of sight, out of the mind huh. I guess it makes life a little brighter knowing that if they don't have a grand Salvation Army marching down one’s street, that “our town/area be clear of evil. I wonder if they could possibly be more wrong?

I fear it’s a case of, if you bring in a bunch homeless people, those that are smelling of
drink/smoke, that a lot of soldiers, folk that tend the corps would turn
their noses at them and no doubt complain after they have left about the smell
and mess. Are Corps losing the image that they are for all types of people, that
you don't need to be in a suit or uniform, be clean shaven AND SAVED?

It will be a very very sad day when Salvationists start to loose pride in
standing up to fight for what they believe in. I'm not a Salvationist nor do I
believe in god ( yet.. As I know that Sven will probably more so change this in
time)... But I'm proud of the Salvationist out there and what they fight for.
Stand up and be counted as a soldier of God :)

If we come across a town/ centre / Mall that wouldn't let us come in and spread
the word of God / play band music / songsters at, then shouldn't we fight for
the right to do so? Sadly we are going to offend some people but that can't be
helped... ( the whole skeleton army proved that but William Booth and his army
didn't give up eh) People out there can't be saved if we don't fight to win their souls.
I fear that HQ is a bit overly concerned about PT. But should they not be more involved with dealing with places that don't want us to be there at, to be more helpful, and support us in the fight.

Last question would be : Are we becoming too 'Soft' to be called an Army?...

I'm probably too young and naive to understand but from standing outside of the
box and looking in , these questions and thoughts come to mind. No better place
to seek answers than from the officers of the past (who have fought and lived as
salvationists) and maybe the future officers, those God is calling to battle for him.

Jay Robb
23yr old
Hamilton Corps’ videographer and corps supporter
Scotland

Anonymous said...

Is the problem that UK Corps, and others I guess, are facing that the
Salvation Army is becoming too much of a so called Church? Or as John Stott was quoted to have said in a recent sermon; “too settled down!” I doubt that The salvation Army are on the streets anywhere in the world as much as they were in the early
years of The Salvation Army’s explosive growth.

Has The SA become nearly too stale now? Where is the drive? Where is the
fighting?! ...Did we lose the fight by letting people push us off the streets
and into our buildings/Corps? Or did we get tired and simply retreated ?

I guess out of sight, out of the mind huh. I guess it makes life a little brighter knowing that if they don't have a grand Salvation Army marching down one’s street, that “our town/area be clear of evil. I wonder if they could possibly be more wrong?

I fear it’s a case of, if you bring in a bunch homeless people, those that are smelling of
drink/smoke, that a lot of soldiers, folk that tend the corps would turn
their noses at them and no doubt complain after they have left about the smell
and mess. Are Corps losing the image that they are for all types of people, that
you don't need to be in a suit or uniform, be clean shaven AND SAVED?

Jay Robb
hamilton, scotland

Anonymous said...

It will be a very very sad day when Salvationists start to loose pride in
standing up to fight for what they believe in. I'm not a Salvationist nor do I
believe in god ( yet.. As I know that Sven will probably more so change this in
time)... But I'm proud of the Salvationist out there and what they fight for.
Stand up and be counted as a soldier of God :)

If we come across a town/ centre / Mall that wouldn't let us come in and spread
the word of God / play band music / songsters at, then shouldn't we fight for
the right to do so? Sadly we are going to offend some people but that can't be
helped... ( the whole skeleton army proved that but William Booth and his army
didn't give up eh) People out there can't be saved if we don't fight to win their souls.
I fear that HQ is a bit overly concerned about PT. But should they not be more involved with dealing with places that don't want us to be there at, to be more helpful, and support us in the fight.

Last question would be : Are we becoming too 'Soft' to be called an Army?...

I'm probably too young and naive to understand but from standing outside of the
box and looking in , these questions and thoughts come to mind. No better place
to seek answers than from the officers of the past (who have fought and lived as
salvationists) and maybe the future officers, those God is calling to battle for him.

Jay Robb
23yr old
Hamilton Corps’ videographer and corps supporter
Scotland