"Let me take this opportunity to say that I hope and pray we will continue to make progress in the way we treat and think about officer colleagues who relinquish officership. Trials come. Some are unavoidable. It is not for us to stigmatise any colleague."
Shaw Clifton General
The Officer; Spring, 2009
An update on ‘Sensitive Statistics’ was shared in The Officer, November-December, 2010. In addition to the actual loss in the number of officers, the statistics were listed in a dozen or so categories. The categorization, while providing a general overview, falls far short of the FSAOF survey results shared some months ago in our blog site. Many in SA leadership at TC, CS, DC levels are familiar with our fellowship. It seems logical that our stats, gathered directly and privately from former officers would have been included in “the latest information” discussed in the International Management Council.
No reference was made in the article relative to stemming the tide of attrition, except to say that other churches suffer ‘far steeper losses’,
As in his first article 18 months ago, the General encourages Cadets, Officers, retired and active, to ‘bring the information I have shared with you to the Lord in prayer as you read. Each statistic is in fact a valued person whom the Lord loves beyond measure. Let us remember the children of our colleagues’.
He also writes; ‘Every loss causes us sorrow. Each one is a sadness to us all.’
I don’t believe any in our fellowship doubts the General’s genuine concern. However, one would be hard pressed to see evidence of his earlier challenge and encouragement that we; “continue to make progress in the way we treat and think about officer colleagues who relinquish officership.”
Some months ago an approach was made to IHQ seeking dialogue in order to effect a more uniform, compassionate and consistent program of pre and post resignation care. We were informed that such concern ought to be addressed to individual territories or commands. Many perceived this IHQ dismissal as nothing more than their ignoring what they must have deemed inconsequential and a nuisance. We believe that to ensure an across borders effective program of care we need more than just warm words from HQ’s side. Merely seeking a prayerful approach is not enough to bring about change. It’s a matter of shared aims and values replicated in every country ‘round the world. What is needed is an irresistible momentum for change articulated and issued as instructions about exactly what the expectations ought to be.
Our intention is not embarrass or critique the army. A brief perusal of our poll results highlights time and again that we hold TSA in the very highest esteem. Nonetheless we believe some simple facts will reveal the scale of the problem. Almost 400 former officers are of the opinion that a paradigm of care (agreement) needs to be brought within the frame of the global SA governance, not just the patchwork of local parochial rules and regulations.
Such an agreement would place duties and regulations guaranteeing rights and privileges for officers during and subsequent to the resignation process, and the expectation that TSA establish high ethical standards of social, labor and human rights behavior.
Many former and active officers deem TSA’s activities relating to ‘formers’ as nothing more than PR exercises designed to give the impression of an ethically conscious organization, without any real intent of change to corporate change in activities. The necessary action cannot be delivered through voluntary initiatives, even if recommended by the General. To date the voluntary approach has clearly failed. And perhaps a reminder is needed: what's deemed ethical in one Command can differ dramatically from a Command on the other side of the ocean. Ethics are culturally driven. What's needed is moral instructions on Christian care!
We challenge IHQ to demand a published annual performance report of accountability, a call for a convention on corporate accountability worldwide.
The online slide presentation that follows highlights our concerns and provides an insight to our activities and fellowship profile.
God bless The Salvation Army !


11 comments:
Not being a former officer I have no real idea how it feels but have read and listened to many stories. I believe that Sven Ljungholm is a man who has both 'The Salvation Army' and 'formers' at heart I would like to suggest TSA appoint him to minister to 'formers' and possibly those who could have a foot in the doorway on the way out. Sven is already doing this in an 'unofficial' capacity but how much weight and appreciation it would hold if this ministry was given the backing of TSA he could continue to minister to those in other territories through this means and pastor those in the UK in a more hands on way. I would love to know the response of IHQ and UKT to such a suggestion. Surely he and Glad could work together as a strong team within such an appointment.
Active UKT
Very good response, Sven. We all need to be accountable. Even Jesus was accountable to the Heavenly Father when He walked this earth. So, why does IHQ , THQ and DHQ leadership think that they are any different. Let's be honest here. It is one word that describes most of the problem. PRIDE.
Blessings from the USA Eastern Territory , former
I am a former from the USA-East (23 yrs active officership/24 yrs conventional pastoral ministry in the Wesleyan tradition), and have experienced a continuing sense of purpose in the fulfilling of my calling in active ministry service. It has always been my position that I would not 'leave from,' but rather 'go toward' the direction of God's leading; never running from an appointment/assignment/experience, but always advancing in Christian service.
God has wonderfully blessed, and my life and ministry is completely satisfying, as I have been faithful to God's leading; there is not one regret as I am confident it has always been God's will for me.
My supervisory/senior officers never, in any way reached out to me or my family, and I consider it regretable that they did not try to undertsand what God was doing in my life. I don't believe the SA really knows how to respond/react to resignations, rather than not interested; they don't seem to understand God's moving in some areas of individual situations.
I love the SA and appreciate the place of it's ministry within the body of Christ, now, more than when I was a part of the movement. It has been my privilege to help interpret the Army's work, serve on advisory boards, help with finacial campaigns, and render other practical volunteer service, and I only desire God's richest blessings upon the work of 'Doing the Most Good.'
Sincerely in Christ,
A brother
"Let me take this opportunity to say that I hope and pray we will continue to make progress in the way we treat and think about officer colleagues who relinquish officership. Trials come. Some are unavoidable. It is not for us to stigmatise any colleague."
Shaw Clifton General
The Officer; Spring, 2009
I can hardly believe what I read!...Without doubt Clifton played the major part of the resignation of my wife and myself. After 30 & 35 years service as TC he simply refused to speak to us or allow us the courtesy of an interview. The UKT had provision for Officers to retire after 25 years... he would not allow it and all his Territorial Executive were scared to go against him, or were they just looking after themselves?
Add to that the UKT had made provision for 'former' who has completed at least ten years to receive, albeit reduced, a pension. He stopped that after our resignation and neither my wife nor I have any pension. She retires next month on just a state pension. We appealed to CoS but were not allowed to submit anything other than a letter of appeal. Clifton sent his papers to IHQ
and having obtained them through Data Protection here in UK there were several downright lies contained in his papers, the decision was based on his word over which we had no idea and could not even answer.
Clifton should hang his head in shame at the way he treated officers under his command! I know I am not to only one!
Will the UKT now have the courage to acknowledge they were wrong? Perhaps not legally but most certainly morally. A Caring Army? You must be joking!!!
Time will tell if Sven's efforts have any effect on the leadership... but whatever..To Sven.. thanks for caring!
Anthony,
My heart goes out to you and your wife. I believe what you are saying. I can associate with what you have gone through somewhat. Many have worked for years and have been faithful in ministry and for some reason see the need to leave officership. A pension fund may have been paid into for 20 , 30 , 35 years and then the former officer finds no security near the end of their lives. It is a sin ! I pray to almighty God that this tragedy will be corrected in the near future.God has His ways of dealing with people but also organizations and corporations.
May God bless you and use you in the days ahead.
USA former
Sven,
I want to thank you for your courage and concern for former officers and the work that you do.No one else gives such an opportunity for feelings of hurt to be shared. There are many that feel so cheated and wounded. Some of us do wonder at times if The Salvation Army leadership at territorial levels and above really care about the loss of officers. It sounds like the General and others are rationalizing the loss and that it is acceptable. Too bad. Some of the repercussions to that line of thought are evident. Until some changes take place the Army will diminish in effectiveness and the powers to be are to blame.
God is watching and in his way will intervene.
Former officer USA Eastern Territory
Anthony,
I feel just terrible for you and your wife and don't question for a second that what you say happened to you did in fact happen to you. I also think it's fantastic that Sven has produced such an in-depth survey and has given ex-officers a place to vent their feelings.
Several decades ago I remember hearing from an officer friend of mine who had a friendship with another officer couple who were dismissed in probably one of the cruelest ways I ever heard of. The husband who was a bit on the heavy set side was asked that year by the DC and DS to play Santa Claus at the annual divisional officers kid's Xmas party. After he finished playing Santa for their kids the DC and DS took him aside and handed him his resignation papers. They used him right up to the end and then humiliated him to boot without a moment's thought as to how they might take it if someone did such a thing to them!
When I hear of such stories (and know from past experiences that there are some officers in the Army who are quite capable of being sadistic when it suits their purposes)I'm some times very happy that in 1973 when I was honorably discharged from the US Navy and had to decide whether to go north on Halsted Street in Chicago to the training college or south to Olivet Nazarene College that I chose the latter--in spite of my then and still continued love for the Army.
With that said I'm also wondering why anyone is in the least bit shocked that all of these types of unjust things go on in the Army. They always have (even in the days of William Booth---and some times done by WB himself!)) and unfortunately probably always will even if Sven's survey does hopefully have an impact and brings about some important changes.
1. TSA the same as any other church body or institution is a corporation. Corporations all pretty much act the same way. I remember working for a nursing agency a few years ago where my visiting nurse partner and I were called into our supervisor's office together and were told what a great bang up job we were doing and what she had planned for us in the way of promotions and fringe benefits in the future only to later find out that while she was talking to us she had already posted our jobs in the want ads section of the local paper! After we found out about it and handed in our resignations she asked me if I'd come back to the office at a reduced hourly rate with no benefits and help her organize and re-write all of the agencies' nursing care plans because she never knew anyone who could do them as well as I did! duh,)
2. People who make it to the top of corporations are there because they have proven themselves to be die-hard administrators. In the case of Xian organizations they might also actually be good Xians too---but don't count on it. It really isn't necessary. That's not the reason why they're there. They're there because they'r die-hard adminstrators.
3. All things (in this life) yield to economics---no ifs, ands or buts about it. Period.
That's the way the world works from the perspective of a man who turns 60 next month.
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home by the Way of the Cross to Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"
Daryl,
Many years ago I probably would have disagreed with a few statements that you have made, but now after being a former for some time and several years of service behind me I reluctantly have to agree. Just because a corporation is Christian, does not make it look at bottom line "assets" or finances much differently from secular corporations. Many of us trusted the holiness component of the movement and we find that words and action do not always coincide. I find that a shame. A movement stops moving and becomes stagnant with this mind set. Honesty and openness is needed so much in the Army today. May God make it so.
Blessings
USA Eastern , former
My heart goes out to you have faithfully served and were thanked with a big slap in the face. As you know the Army's new buzz word "Social Justice", which I think is ironic. I think we need to take a hard look in the mirror and stop ignoring the Injustice that exist within. Someone needs to stand up to the bullies and hold them accountable for the lives they are destroying. Someone needs to be an advocate for those who have been abused and ensure that healing, restoration and even compensation take place. I also find it ironic that the General is using "Sensitive Statistics" for self-promotion. His conduct as General,TC and probably other appointments leave a trail of such abuse. He should be the one to resign and for-go his pension and distribute it amongst those he denied it from. Who is going to hold the tyrants accountable? Who is going to protect the faithful? and Who will reach to the hurting?
Appreciate your Ministry Sven
Wow!!! Thank you to you all for wearing your heart on your sleeve and sharing.
I am appauled at how Christian leaders can treat their colleagues, their brothers and sisters in Christ in this way, our motto is 'Heart to God, hand to man'(I would like in my heart to believe this but I can't)
In James 3 v 1, we read these words:-
"My friends, we should not all try to become teachers. In fact, teachers will be judged more strictly than others".
Heed the warning christian leaders for you will be judged more strictly than others for the way in which you treat others and conduct yourself!!
I recently tried to make contact with the pastoral care team for some counselling support which I now feel in a position to take up but I am still waiting for them to contact me back with the details. Immediate care is important but equally 2, 3, 4 years down the line is just as important as people are not always able to deal with their problems straight away they need time, space to get themselves adjusted and deal with all that has happened. When they are at a point, in a place,and ready to deal with their situation then support needs to be at hand.
I would like to see a helpline set up where formers can have access to support for upto 5 years (and beyond if necessary) after a resignation has taken place. This support could range from simply listening, to sign posting to specialised services, benefit and housing advice and information. I believe many need an independent who can be an advocate. I was on my own, I couldn't have anyone with me when I was in my interview with the DC and I felt very alone, afraid and abandoned.
If anyone at THQ reads this site, please, please hear our cries, we need help, support and loving through resignation, please, please don't abandon us in our time of need and distress.
Blessings
Former
UK
Sven,
Viewing the survey as I did last night brought me to tears. The use of 'In His Presence' is powerful right from the start! I pray that the Holy Spirit will speak to the hearts and minds of those army leaders who are charged with the sacred care of officers under their pastoral ministry.
Thank you for your ministry to the FSAOF.
Former
USA East active in my corps
Post a Comment