Monday, June 10, 2019

CYSTAL PALACE II

The orchestra, like an immense amphitheatre split in the middle, formed the half of a great circle. Around the Conductor, Herbert Booth, on the lower seats, were massed the string bands. Next in order, and about the half-circle, were the brass instruments carried by members of the SA Household Troops and Home Office Bands. Back of the bands was ranged the first company of singers. Nearly every company in the London Division was represented. Recruited from all ranks of London soldiers….            Up and beyond these was the main body of singers, to the left twelve hundred male voices, each man clad in a red jersey and holding in his hand a fluttering pennant. On the right there was a corresponding company of female voices, each lassie robed in the sombre uniform of the bonnet and darkblue, and each holding one of the many coloured pennants.                                                          
Above this great choir, fringing the semi-circle at the top, was the junior choir, a thothusand girls ranged above the women and a thousand boys above the men. Each of these juniors held a flag, making another brilliant scene
         Fry presided at the Grand Organ, Band­master Appleby was in charge of the brass bands, and Bandmaster Slater directed the string bands. The total strength of the choir, including the orchestra, was five thousand….. On the cue by Herbert, Bandmaster Fry struck the keys of the organ, the women singers removed their sashes, then their bonnets, and suddenly the sashes were seen to stretch out into broad folds of pure white, the more splendid to look upon because of the contrast with the flaming red jerseys worn by the men.                                                                                                                               The reader can easily imagine the soul-stirring effect produced upon the audience of more than fifteen thousand people when, in response to the baton held by Herbert, that mighty chorus thundered forth the battle song of the Army, the words by Colonel Pearson, the Pioneer Poet of the Army. and the music of Herbert's composition :
God is keeping His soldiers fighting ;
Evermore we shall conquerors be : 
All the hosts of hell are uniting,
But we are sure to have victory.
Three hundred Salvation Army bands from outside of London had arrived. These, with the fifteen hundred bandsmen of London, constituted a company of five thousand instru­mentalists.In addition to these there were gathered together sixty thousand Salvationistsrepresenting every section of the globe.

The War Office of the British Government commissioned an agent of the Secret Service to watch the proceedings and report on the Army's organization. That at the time was not known, but was afterward stated by W. T. Stead, an ally and firm friend of the Army. More than fifty members of Parliament, nearly all of them from the Labour representatives of the Tom Burt type, were seen on the Crystal Palace grounds. Men of wealth like John Cory, John T. Denny, one of the Rothschilds, Samuel Morley and others were present ; as were Robertson Nicoll, W. T. Stead, Morgan, of Morgan & Scott, publishers, Lady Frances Balfour, sister-in-law of the Earl of Balfour, and many more of that intellectual order.
No small attraction of the day was the Musical Festival, defined on the programme as "The Battle of Song". Nothing even approaching this in spectacular display and volume of song was ever before seen or heard in the Crystal Palace. (or since? Sven)

         

Sunday, June 9, 2019

2019 Pentecost, Week 7: O Come Let Us Adore Him

Exploring the Names of God Continues: 

What’s In A Name?  Holy Spirit: Power From On High

We began this 2019 Pentecost series with Holy Spirit, and considered some of His roles and characteristics. It seems fitting, therefore, to look some more at the One Whom baptizes us with Holy Fire and fills us with “Power From On High”.

Power From On High: When we think about the names of God, many come to mind for God, the Father, and for Jesus Christ, the Son. But we have a Triune God, and we may not be as familiar with the names of Holy Spirit. I found one site that listed 33 names and titles for Holy Spirit, including : Breath of the Almighty; Comforter; Eternal Spirit; Free Spirit; God; Good Spirit; Holy Spirit; Lord; Power of the Highest; Spirit, The; Spirit of the Lord God Isaiah; Spirit of the Lord; Spirit of God; Spirit of the Father; Spirit of Christ; Spirit of the Son; Spirit of life; Spirit of grace; Spirit of prophecy; Spirit of adoption; Spirit of wisdom; Spirit of counsel; Spirit of might; Spirit of understanding; Spirit of knowledge; Spirit of the fear of the Lord; Spirit of truth; Spirit of holiness Romans; Spirit of revelation; Spirit of judgment; Spirit of burning; Spirit of glory; and, Seven Spirits of God. [To see the list and the Scripture references, see bottom of page – 

Wow!  When Jesus promised His disciples that when He went away, He was going to send them “Power From On High,” (Luke 24: 49), He was serious! How many times have we struggled in our own strength to accomplish what we need Power From On High to be effective for the Kingdom? Holy Spirit is our Power From On High: may we grow in our understanding and adoration of Him.  Hallelujah!

Scripture Reading:  Acts 1: 1- 2: 41
Falling Fire: Arrival of Holy Spirit—Pentecost Sunday


Today is Pentecost Sunday. The word “Pentecost” comes from the Greek word “pentekostos”, which means “50”. Pentecost signified the conclusion of the Feast of Weeks, which commenced on the third day after the Passover and concluded on the 50th day (Exodus 34: 22; Leviticus 23: 15-20; Deuteronomy 16: 9-10). This Feast of Weeks became one of the festivals that drew Jewish pilgrims to Jerusalem to worship, even from remote areas of the Roman Empire.

In Christianity, Pentecost commemorates Holy Spirit’s coming. Before Jesus ascended to heaven, He commanded His disciples to remain in Jerusalem until they received the promised “Power from on High,” (Luke 24:49; Acts 1:5, 8). A group of 120 people, including the disciples, gathered and prayed together. And on the day of Pentecost, “a sound like the blowing of a violent wind came from heaven and filled the whole house where they were sitting.They saw what seemed to be tongues of fire that separated and came to rest on each of them,” (Acts 2: 2-3).


Was this baptism and infilling of Holy Spirit necessary? After all, the disciples had been with Jesus for approximately 3.5 years, had seen Him minister, and had been used to minister to others. Wouldn’t that have been sufficient? Yet, during Jesus final hours, Judas betrayed Him, Peter denied Him, and the others fled in fear, hiding together in a house. So why was their time with Jesus not enough for them to overcome their anxieties and concerns for their own safety? And, of course, in their extremely fearful state, there was no way they were going to be able to fulfill Christ’s Great Commission! Was the Church doomed before it had a chance to get started?

In fact, being baptized and filled with Holy Spirit was precisely the life-changing experience the fearful disciples needed. How do we know? Because Peter—who had denied Christ only a few weeks earlier—boldly spoke to the gathered crowd, delivering a sermon that was replete with fulfilled prophecies, identified Jesus as Lord and Christ (Messiah), testified to His Resurrection, admonished the crowd to heed the message, and emphasized that, “everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved,’ (Acts 2: 21).


Being saved and filled with Holy Spirit is still the life-changing, empowering experience that Christians need—the Power From On High—to be passionate, and bold in our mission to “Go, teach, and make disciples—for His glory and the extension of His Kingdom!



O Come Let Us Adore, Holy Spirit, our Power From On High! 



Hallelujah!

Blessings & Peace

Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk
Former Salvation Army Officer
Canada








To see the list and the Scripture references: https://www.biblestudytools.com/concordances/torreys-topical-textbook/titles-and-names-of-the-holy-spirit.html

Saturday, June 8, 2019

Home, not so sweet, Home!


More from the book - 

We unloaded what gear we’d carried with us to Russia and inspected the 3rdfloor flat. We learned to use the stairs as the lift was not always functioning, and was un-hygienic as it served regularly as a public WC. In the stairway on each landing, was a collection of refuse too large for the common use garbage chute, already loaded to over flowing. The flat consisted of three rooms and one smaller one. We learned later that by Russian standards it was considered a large flat. The small room was used as an office with the other three rooms forming the living room and two bedrooms. The kitchen, bathroom and toilet were a nightmare. The kitchen had holes in the walls and was infested with cockroaches, and a family of mice.













Friday, June 7, 2019

THE ENIGMA OF TRANSFORMATION THROUGH FEAR

In researching the astonishing transformations of Russia's economy when Stalin instituted communist political, ideological and practical theories into practice. Perhaps the greatest challenge was changing the mind-set of the majority of the population, those who worked in agriculture. Stalin wanted to create more industry, and achieving this ambition required that peasants had to be turned into industrial workers.                                                      The race to industrialise was spurred on by the fear that capitalist countries would try to destroy communism in the USSR.Offering actionable strategies to cultivate a growth mindset, critical for long-term success, was key in insuring that Russia’s economy would thrive while others flounder.

THE MOTIVATING ENIGMA
Premise:
The mindset paradigm is a cognitive perspective. It places learning in the context of our thoughts and beliefs.
But there’s another perspective worth mentioning: the emotional dimension.       A fixed mindset is governed by fear…. Within each of us are two opposing forces: one pulls us to safety and the other propels us toward growth.
As Maslow articulated, when the delight of growth is greater than the anxiety of safety, we choose growth. But when the anxiety of safety is greater than the joy we experience from growing, we freeze.         
Psychologists call this freezing neurotic fear. When our brains experience appropriate fear, the flight or fight response signals a danger for us to avoid or eliminate. That is, appropriate fear triggers an action.

Thursday, June 6, 2019

More from Return to Battle V2




                                                                                                                                     FROM:

The Enigmas I

Following the death of Lenin in 1924, a power struggle ensued  from which Stalin gradually emerged as winner. Stalin was aware that he had to assert his leadership status. One way he could do this was to make a success of his policiesby making the USSR strong through industrialisation. Stalin exercised his leadership four years layer, in 1928. Stalin began one of the most dramatic transformations of a country's economy that the world had ever seen. There were political and ideological reasons for putting communist theories into practice. There were also practical reasons to change the economy of the USSR.                                                                 The USSR had a large population, but the majority of people worked in agriculture. A small amount of industry existed in the west of the country. Stalin wanted to create more industry and industry in the east. To do this, transport links between the regions had to be improved and peasants had to be turned into industrial workers.                                                             The race to industrialise was spurred on by the fear that capitalist countries would try to destroy communism in the USSR. At the First Conference of Workers in 1931, Stalin delivered a passionate speech, commanding workers to play a crucial role in industrialisation. He said: "We are fifty or a hundred years behind the advanced countries. We must make up this gap in ten years. Either we do it or they will crush us."[1] 

 Eight years later, in October 1939, at the outset of World War II,
 Spencer-Churchill insisted that there was a basis on which to deal with the Soviets. Winston Churchill was on BBC radio, and famously proclaimed that Russia: "It is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma."
Of course, World War II had just begun, and the question regarding the intentions of the Soviet Union — and particularly its relations with Nazi Germany — was of paramount importance to the United Kingdom, Europe and the world at large.                        


The many Characteristics of the Enigma
The immensity
            To early 20th century Salvationists the enigma was represented by Russia’s immensity, and a country of un-rivalled potential. Karl Larsson, and the band of ten Swedish Comrade Salvation Army officers (including my paternal grandparents)

visualized two and one half decades earlier, planting their colours initially in Petrograd and Moscow. The intent was to evangelize across the Russian Empire.                                                   For more than a century it operated the longest train route in the world, from Moscow in the east to Vladivostok on the Pacific Ocean, crossing through two continents. Offering only 2nd and 3d class carriages, train #100 operates every other day making 120 stops on the route, crossing the distance of 9300 km. (5778 miles) in 6 days, 23 hours. Its schedule was well known to the Army as many SA missionaries, bound for China, travelled on it from Moscow.                                    And, many countries throughout history sought to conquer Russia. The landmass that it holds is a tenth of the entire earth’s land surface. But it’s not just land that makes it special; it has Europe’s biggest river and the world’s deepest river, with the latter containing 20% of the world’s fresh water supply.                         
Religion
Its religion too was an enigma to most ‘westerners’; Being multi-ethnic it follows that it is also a multi-faith nation. Orthodox Christianity is Russia's largest religion with 71% of the population belonging to the Orthodox Christian denomination. Islam is professed by 5% of the population, with Catholicism, Judaism and Buddhism professed by 1% of the population each. Protestantism is professed by 2% of Russians. Other religious denominations represent 1% of the population. And, adding to the religious th, Russia’s population of 114 million live in European Russia, bordering on Christian countries, whose Christian traditions differ.                                                                              The populations of these groups vary enormously, from millions to under 10,000, speaking 35 different languages, all considered official languages in various regions of Russia, along with the key official language, Russian. In addition, there are over 100 minority languages spoken in Russia, with one culture where only 2 people spoke the language.

Kathie and Sven co-authors
ENIGMA I of IV


[1]http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/education/heroesvillains/g4/cs1/

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

Members of our church value learning as much as the pastors.

Moving from a happy clappy church to a Full-Orbed teaching church, where members value learning as much as the pastors. 


As my wife and I raise our two-year-old daughter, we’re learning a lot about learning. For one thing, I’m realizing how unhelpful all of those “people learn best by …” books and articles are. Even as a toddler, our daughter learns in many different, seemingly conflicting ways. In some cases, she soaks up information like a sponge. It’s like living with a parrot—she repeats everything we say. Even my sneezes are followed by tiny, fake “ah-choo”s. She learns through imitation, so my wife and I trying to be intentional about the things we do and say around her.

But in other cases, she’s less like a sponge and more like a stump—unyielding and uncompliant. “Time to brush your teeth,” I say at the same time every night. She looks me in the eye, frowns, and goes right back to playing. I wish she picked up this habit as quickly as she did mocking my sneezes! Situations like this require clear, consistent, firm instruction.

Similarly, teaching in the church needs to come in a variety of ways. You may read that young people no longer learn well through lectures or that people are less likely to trust and imitate authority figures than they used to be. Those things may be true broadly, but I still believe in the transformative power of weekly, Spirit-filled preaching over a person’s lifetime. And I believe examples of faithful, godly living are just as important as lessons from the pulpit.

Since people learn in many different ways, our churches must employ a variety of teaching methods. This week, Angie Ward shares how her church is moving toward a more robust vision of what it means to be a teaching church. It requires more than a weekly Sunday-morning message, though that’s very important. A teaching church is one whose members value learning as much as the pastors. It’s one whose culture is saturated with clear training in every venue, from thoughtfully prepared sermons to thoroughly explained programs to teachable moments in one-on-one interactions.
As my wife and I raise our two-year-old daughter, we’re learning a lot about learning. For one thing, I’m realizing how unhelpful all of those “people learn best by …” books and articles are. Even as a toddler, our daughter learns in many different, seemingly conflicting ways. In some cases, she soaks up information like a sponge. It’s like living with a parrot—she repeats everything we say. Even my sneezes are followed by tiny, fake “ah-choo”s. She learns through imitation, so my wife and I trying to be intentional about the things we do and say around her.
But in other cases, she’s less like a sponge and more like a stump—unyielding and uncompliant. “Time to brush your teeth,” I say at the same time every night. She looks me in the eye, frowns, and goes right back to playing. I wish she picked up this habit as quickly as she did mocking my sneezes! Situations like this require clear, consistent, firm instruction.
Similarly, teaching in the church needs to come in a variety of ways. You may read that young people no longer learn well through lectures or that people are less likely to trust and imitate authority figures than they used to be. Those things may be true broadly, but I still believe in the transformative power of weekly, Spirit-filled preaching over a person’s lifetime. And I believe examples of faithful, godly living are just as important as lessons from the pulpit.
Since people learn in many different ways, our churches must employ a variety of teaching methods. This week, Angie Ward shares how her church is moving toward a more robust vision of what it means to be a teaching church. It requires more than a weekly Sunday-morning message, though that’s very important. A teaching church is one whose members value learning as much as the pastors. It’s one whose culture is saturated with clear training in every venue, from thoughtfully prepared sermons to thoroughly explained programs to teachable moments in one-on-one interactions.

Kyle Rohane

Kyle   Rohane
Editor, CT Pastor

Saturday, June 1, 2019

Only Half of Kids Raised Southern Baptist Stay Southern Baptist


Christianity Today
Only Half of Kids Raised Southern Baptist Stay Southern Baptist
JUNE 2019


Analysis: The bigger factor behind the SBC’s decline isn’t the struggle to gain new converts; it’s keeping their own.
RYAN P. BURGE

By now, Southern Baptists recognize that their movement is in a decline that shows no signs of changing course.                                                                                    By their own measures, they’re not adding as many new believers to their flocks each year—the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) went from baptizing 321,000 in 2007 to 246,000 last year.                                                           Plus, despite adding more than 10,000 more cooperating churches over the past couple of decades, church attendance across the denomination is also dropping.                                                                                                                    In 2006, the SBC had 16.3 million members, now that’s down to less than 15 million, according to the denomination’s most recent Annual Church Profile (ACP).                                                                                                            Outside surveys have also tracked the decline. New findings released this year show the Southern Baptist trajectory more closely resembles the downward trend among the United Methodist Church (UMC), the nation’s largest mainline Protestant body, than fellow evangelicals in non-denominational traditions.

Image: Ryan P. Burge
According to the General Social Survey (GSS), nearly the same percentage of Americans identified with the SBC as the UMC in the 1980s, then the two denominations’ trends began to separate, and both experienced a slow, steady decline from the mid-’90s on.                                                                                While close to 1 in 10 Americans identified as Southern Baptist in 1987, that number has been cut in half to 1 in 20 (4.8%) in 2018. Data from the Cooperative Congressional Election Study (CCES) reinforces this point as well, with 5.4 percent of the sample identifying as SBC.
There are four major ways for a religious denomination to change in size over a longer period of time: They add members through conversions, they keep those born into the faith as they grow up, they shed members through people defecting to other religious traditions, or members die and are not replaced by young adults.
            Every religious group experiences these losses to some extent—like a bucket that has sprung a few leaks. While some of the water will inevitably trickle out, it’s possible to put more water back in the bucket from other sources. If the amount of water that leaks out is greater than the amount of water that is replaced, then a decline will occur in overall members. The Southern Baptist Convention has a bucket that is aging and springing more leaks every year.

Conversion and Defection                                                                                          As evangelicals, Southern Baptists put particular emphasis on conversion as a potential source of membership growth and celebrated around a quarter of a million baptisms last year, according to ACP figures. However, nearly all Southern Baptists have been part of the denomination for a while.                                                                                                                       CCES, which tracked the same group of 9,500 respondents in 2010, 2012, and 2014, found few newcomers to the SBC during that time. Of the 476 Southern Baptists in the sample in 2014, close to all of them (97.9%) had also identified as Baptists in 2010. Of those who converted to the SBC, two had been Catholics, two were from other faiths, and six had been religious “nones.” These numbers are too small to make claims about converts from any specific group, but the overall impression is clear: Southern Baptists are not seeing significant growth through conversion.
The necessary follow-up question, then is: Are a lot of Southern Baptists leaving the faith? CCES data also showed that 91.8 percent of people who started out as SBC in 2010 were still SBC four years later. Of the 37 people in the sample who left the SBC between 2010 and 2014—not a significant enough portion to extrapolate—31 of them either became a non-denominational Protestant or some other type of Protestant Christian. Just two became “nones.” Obviously, any defection is disappointing for those who want to see the SBC grow, but based on this sample, of the members who do leave, they often don’t stray too far.

Births and Deaths                                                                                                                   The last two factors around shifts in the denomination have to do with whether enough children born into Southern Baptist families remain in the church—or return as adults—to offset the eldest generation, which is dying off.                                                                                                                              Recent research by University of Oklahoma sociologist Samuel Perry concluded that evangelical Protestants have seen a decline in fertility in recent years. It’s a well-known phenomenon that young people drift away from church attendance in their 20s and 30s but return when they get married and have children.                                                                                                The GSS, which asks respondents about their current religious affiliation as well as what religion were they were raised as, shows that fewer Southern Baptists are sticking with their parents’ denomination.
For much of the ’80s and ’90s, Southern Baptist kids were pretty likely to grow up to become Southern Baptist adults: Seven in ten maintained their SBC identity into adulthood in surveys conducted between 1984 and 1994.
That has declined precipitously. In the most recent surveys conducted between 2015 and 2018, just over half of those raised Southern Baptist were still with the SBC. In other words, nearly half of Southern Baptists kids leave and never come back.                            However, where the real worry comes is related to a generational shift in the American population. In the 1980s and 1990s, Southern Baptists could count on a huge majority of the children born and raised in the church to become committed and active members of the congregation as adults. That has eroded over time. Now, it’s likely that half of the children being raised Southern Baptist today will not maintain that identity into adulthood.                                                                                                           Compounding that fact, the average Southern Baptist is now nearly ten years older than they were in the mid-1980s. The water is leaking out of the bucket at an ever-quickening rate and the amount of water that is being added is slowing to a trickle. There is little reason to believe that the SBC won’t sustain serious declines in the next 10–20 years.                                                                                                                                           If there is any silver lining to be found in these results it is this: Half of youngest Southern Baptists (those between the ages of 18 and 35), attend services at least once a week. That is the highest rate of attendance of any group aside from those 65 and older. This is a strong foundation to build upon.Just as researchers such as Ed Stetzer have suggested that much of the decline in overall Christian affiliation in the US can be attributed to “nominal” believers leaving the faith, it appears that the young Southern Baptists who stick around are particularly committed to their church and their beliefs.   For those who stay affiliated with the SBC from a young age, their attachment to the tradition is strong. Now, the question becomes how to convince more young people to stay, or become, Southern Baptists.                                                                                 Leaders such as SBC president J. D. Greear are already praying and working for gospel revival through the denomination’s young leaders. He stated, “For the upcoming generation, our prayer should be to see an increase in evangelism, church planting and revitalization, and ultimately an end to decades of decline.”

Foursquare’s Female Leaders Have it Harder Today

Christianity Today

Current Issue

Why Foursquare’s Female Leaders Have It Harder Today



The Pentecostal denomination was founded by a woman nearly a century ago, but it has failed to elect another female president since.o
On Tuesday, the Foursquare Church elected Oregon pastor Randy Remington its next president over general superintendent Tammy Dunahoo, who would have been the first female president since the denomination’s founder, Aimee Semple McPherson.
 After the race brought in double the votesof any other Foursquare election, Dunahoo’s defeat underscores the ongoing struggle for women to reach to the highest positions in evangelical institutions, even in traditions that ordain women and affirm their roles as preachers, teachers, and leaders.
Over the years, many have wondered, “Why hasn’t a denomination founded by a woman elected another?” Foursquare may have begun with a woman at the helm, but after decades of male leadership and moves toward the evangelical mainstream, it’s actually harder for a woman to make it to the top now.
Several mainline denominations such as the Episcopal Church, the United Methodist Church, and Evangelical Lutheran Church in America have had women in top positions, as have evangelical movements such as the Salvation Army and the Northwest Yearly Meeting of Friends (evangelical Quakers). Despite more women are enrolling in seminary and training for ministry now than any other time in history, their presence in local churches remains disproportionately small; only about 5 percent of American churchgoershave a woman as a pastor.
Women pursuing ministry today still lookto Aimee Semple McPherson’s example. She founded the International Church of the Foursquare Gospel in 1923 and led the burgeoning movement—which now numbers 68,500 churches around the world—until her untimely death in 1944, when she left some big, flamboyant shoes to fill.

Celebrity culturewas just beginning in the early 20th century when she moved to Los Angeles, becoming a self-styled ingénue with the self-promotion skills of Taylor Swift and the good humor of Kelly Clarkson. Plus, preaching that could compete with T. D. Jakes or Steven Furtick; a mass media empire; a megachurch; a Bible college; an “interdenominational” movement; and a global healing ministry that was the prototype for Kathryn Kuhlman, Benny Hinn, and many others.
Semple McPherson’s ministry was so exceptional that critics thought she must have hypnotized gullible audiences and devotees saw her has a divine vessel for the Holy Spirit. She was a hard act to follow, but during her lifetime, many women sought to do just that. Just under half of early Foursquare pastors were women, and her magnetic daughter Roberta Semple was her assumed successor.
Perhaps the trajectory would have been different if the mother-daughter leadership team hadn’t suffered a falling out and Semple McPherson’s son Rolf McPherson had not filled the role instead. He held the top position at the Foursquare Church for more than 40 years after his mother died, and the movement has been led by men ever since.
Since 1944, female ministers had very few examples other than their founder to encourage them to lead beyond the congregational level. For the past decade, Dunahoo—this year’s presidential candidate—was the only woman in Foursquare’s executive leadership. As of 2017, there were only seven women in national leadership positions.
To thrive as leaders at all levels, women in Foursquare must have more than denominational policygranting them access to the office of the ministry. And, they need more than the distant memory of biblical women to inspire them. If stories of Deborah and Junia and women-friendly ordination policies were enough, women would probably enter the ministry at rates similar to the rise of women in other professions like the law or medicine. Foursquare churches as well as Nazarenes, Quakers, Methodists, and many other congregations would have a lot more women in ministry leadership roles.
The fact Foursquare has yet to elect another female president shows how much women’s potential depends on the models she sees in ministry and the support around her. Women need congregations who are able to imagine, accept, and support a woman as their pastor. The imaginative component is key here: The idea of a woman as pastor needs to be present in the collective consciousness of a congregation in order for a female pastor to become a reality.
Seeing mostly men in leadership roles narrows that imagination, and the low percentage of Foursquare women in pastoral roles after the death of Aimee Semple McPherson attests to this principle. In the 1930s, 40 percent of Foursquare senior pastors were women; as of 2012, the number had dwindled to 7 percent.
Another reason for this lengthy hiatus of women in national-level Foursquare leadership is because Foursquare is not the same organization that it was in its early days. It has grown from 29,000 members in 410 congregations to over 8 million members in 68,500 churches across 146 nations. For revivalist movements like Foursquare, such rapid growth equals undeniable success. But growth comes with side effects that have had lasting influence on women in ministry leadership in Foursquare.
An unintended consequence of Foursquare’s growth and development is it has gone from being seen as a vaudeville-inspired sideshow of American Christianity to being an accepted part of the American evangelical establishment.
Semple McPherson’s ministry was as controversial as it was groundbreaking; her career included lawsuits and public trials, a high-profile disappearance and reappearance, and rumors of an affair with a married man. Early Foursquare folks often relished their lack of respectability; they saw the Holy Spirit in Semple McPherson and loved and defended their “Sister” Aimee. They didn’t care a lot about what critics thought of their pastor or her followers.
Now, few would question the notion that Foursquare is a part of the evangelical mainstream. But with that “respectable” reputation comes an expectation of typical churches led by white, middle-class men. These changes have arguably made having a female president today even more unlikely than the presidency of Foursquare’s founder Aimee Semple McPherson.
It’s one thing to have a woman as a founder. The history of Christianity is full of “exceptional” cases of talented women who attract male followers; Joan of Arc, Teresa of Avila, Anne Hutchinson, Ida B. Robinson, and more.
Historically speaking, Christian women often step out on their ownto establish authority through alternative structures (that, or they are forcibly removed or killed). Whether it is by founding their own religious order, creating their own denomination, establishing their own congregation, or building multi-media ministries in the form of radio, televangelism, blogging, vlogging, or other forms of social media influencing, women often leave established structures to fully express their gifts.
In many ways, that blaze-your-own-trail approach is more feasible than rising through the ranks of a “respectable” evangelical organization with very few women around you. Candidates like Dunahoo, who made her way up—as a pastor, cabinet member, district supervisor, and now general supervisor and vice president of Foursquare’s US operations—have been and will always be rare.
The movement that Foursquare was in the days of Aimee Semple McPherson is no more. In its place is a much larger, more influential organization with a global reach. In this respect, should Foursquare elect a female president sometime in the future, she will not simply be the “second woman” to lead the movement after Sister Aimee.
In many ways, she will be the first of her kind.

Leah Payne is assistant professor of Theological Studies at Portland Seminary of George Fox University and author of the award-winning book, Gender and Pentecostal Revivalism: Making a Female Ministry in the Twentieth Century.