Monday, October 8, 2012

Belshat the Fig Picker, one of Gideon’s 300


Play: Belshat the Fig Picker, one of Gideon’s 300
By Lloyd Carpenter © Thadeus Productions 1999

Scene: TV reporter with microphone, interviewing Belshat about his history.
Can be sitting down as in studio model. Belshat is a bit of a moronic coward.

TV reporter is ‘over-the-top’ with false TV host-style enthusiasm.
----------------------

L: So, Mr Belshat, you were there!

B: Yup.

L: Um, could you elaborate for our viewers?

B: Yup, I was there alright.

L: Ah yeah. You were… one of Gideon’s 300 men

B: When we sorted out the Midianites. Yup.

L: Right! So you stayed when Gideon offered the scared and the
knee-knockers the chance to go home.

B: I was actually running to the front of the army to head home,
when my sandal broke. By the time I could walk again, the
chance had passed…

L: And then you survived the selection procedure at the river!
Tell me how that worked.

B: If I tell you the truth, will you edit it out before you put it on TV?

L: Sure! Trust me. (false smile)

B: I was so scared, I had both severe indigestion - I ate some
dodgy takeaways the night before - and I had the hiccups.
I was scared I might…

L: (interrupts quickly) Yeah, yeah I get the picture.

B: Yeah, well I didn’t dare bend over to lick the water. So by
using my hand to try and get some water to stop the hiccups….

L: You got selected.

B: Ah, yeah. So we went to fight ten billion million thousand Midianites
with (getting more and more frenzied) armour, swords, fighting camels,
bad breath and a negative attitude toward fig pickers!

L: Yes, yes. OK

B: And what does Gideon give us? A trumpet, a pottery jar, and a torch. No
hand grenades, bazookas or even a big club with a spike in it!

L: You were brave!

B: I had no choice! Gideon reckoned it was all God’s plan. He even
did some tests with a fleece to confirm it! Who am I to doubt
almighty God?

L: Who indeed?

B: Plus there was the fact that if I didn’t go, I’d be the only one left
in a camp in the middle of Midianite territory helped me make
up my mind!

L: So you attacked the Midianites at night?

B: Me? Na. Well, yes, I suppose we did. It was all God’s work actually.
We surrounded the Midianite camp, then at the signal, blew our
trumpets, threw down the jars, waved our torches and yelled “A sword
for the Lord and for Gideon!”

L: Wow!

B: I actually was asking for a sword at the time, but it still had the
desired effect.

L: Now what’s this I hear about the Midianites killing each other?

B: Well, for a start, I did some strategic cowering behind a gorse
bush, so I could… ah… you know… ah… write a book about
what I saw later. Yeah, that’s it! As an observer.

L: So what did you see?

B: Well, from my skilfully chosen vantage point, first I saw the camels
got a heck of a fright. They broke loose and began to charge through
the camp, knocking men over, and making a lot of noise.

L: So when did the fighting start?

B: For me? Oh, I see what you mean. Well, the Midianites came out of
their tents and thought they were under attack by war camels, so they
started fighting them. And then the owners of those camels thought
that their neighbours, who were killing their camels, were the enemy,
and they started fighting.

L: And that’s how the battle was won?

B: No, ah… we ah, we did a lot of fighting too. Yeah.

L: You fought?

B: It was hard work too! Some of those Midianites were faster than
Usain Bolt. They were running away so fast, we had to really chase
to catch them.

L: And?

B: And ah, get their money off them.

L: Money?

B: Oh, sure, we made boodles. They offered us money not to kill them.
I didn’t tell them all I had was a trumpet and a torch, so I couldn’t
kill them!

L: You took the money.

B: Sure, what should I do? I don’t want to be Belshat the fig picker all
my life! I want to be famous, you know, play the banjo or something.
Funny thing though…

L: What?

B: After that, and in all the time in the future, Gideon stopped telling us
what God wanted, and only told us what he wanted. You know he
even made us cough up some of our gold, then he made a ephod out of it.

L: And what did he do with the ephod?

B: I’d rather not say. But let’s just say I don’t expect to see Gideon’s
name in lights as a great follower of the one true God. Na, it’s the
safe life for me now. I’ll just learn the banjo, or something equally
prudent. But I won’t stop following God. That’s a mistake I won’t make.
(looks furtively around) Not like our esteemed hero Gideon, anyway.

L: Well, there you have it folks. A hero of the Midianite Campaign.
One of Gideon’s 300 brave… ah, men. Thank you!

Both sit down again

Lloyd Carpenter, New Zealand
© Thadeus Productions 1999
A gentle reminder… This play is provided for your personal or church use, or for workshop purposes.
It is provided without charge, provided (1) the copyright and authorship notice are retained and (2) it is not re-published or in any way sold

Friday, October 5, 2012

4 Benjaminites


This is a play in two parts. It is designed to be read as two separate dramas,
with some time between them.

It helps if the story of Gideon is read as part of the service before the dramas.
It is intended that a sermon based on the life, exploits or later decisions of Gideon will follow the two dramas.

4 Benjaminites
By Lloyd Carpenter © Thadeus Productions 1999




Scene: Each actor gets out of his seat and comes to the front & picks up a
microphone before beginning talking. Stand in a semi-circle to talk to each other.

A: I’ve had enough of it all. Everytime I start to prune my roses, some big hairy Midianite rides up on his war camel, beats me up, pulls out my plants and spits in my coffee.

B: I know what you mean! Just the other day, I decided to dry some figs in the sun. And along comes the Midianite boss, rides all over my figs, and I won’t even tell you what his camel did.

C: And me. I started threshing grain – I mean it was a good day for it, with the right amount of sun and wind. Then clump, clump, clump, a Midianite patrol rides up, pinches all my seed, just leaving the husks. And then they tell me that the husks are a good source of fibre, so it aids digestion!

B: I didn’t finish my story. And then the Midianite guy goes “Here, what’s that great big lump on your head?” I says “Wot lump?” and he pointed it out, with a dirty great club. (motions swinging a baseball bat) Bang! Owww.

D: At least we’re not like that big pink blouse Gideon.

A: That wimpy gopher? Old worm-man Gideon? Lives in a hole in the ground Gideon?

B: That’s the loser. At least we’re brave enough to get a thrashing in plain view! Why get beaten up in private, I say.

C: Those bandages are badges of pride Belshat. And my bloodstains make me look manly. And it takes your mind off the hunger, the burnt crops, and the cold coffee.

D: No bandages on the worm man though. There’s old Gideon threshing wheat in a hole in the ground. What a wimp. Not a man at all.

A: Nothing will ever come of him, you mark my words.

B: 10 years from now no-one will even remember his name or family. But they’ll say mine, Belshat the Fig-picker, with pride.

C: (turns to look at the back left corner of the hall) Hey, Gideon. Who’s that you’re talking to? Got an imaginary friend?

D: What’s that glow? Hey, Gideon, ya want to turn that torch off? The Midianites are on patrol, ya wally.

A: That’s no torch. Whoa! That whole guy Gideon’s talking to is glowing. Hey pal! Fly over Chernobyl or something? Hey…( notices that it is an angel)…um, ah, nothing (start heading to seat) it’s OK, no worries… (sits down)

B: Ah, (looking very worried, looking toward the back left corner of the hall) I think that this is my signal to mosey on off (nervous laugh) ha ha… (walks off & resumes seat)

C: Glowing men talking to the most insignificant member of the most insignificant family (shakes his head as he sits down)

D: Next thing you’ll be saying is that God is going to rescue us from the Midianite oppressors. Yeah, right. (sits down).

A gentle reminder… This play is provided for your personal or church use, or for workshop purposes.
It is provided without charge, provided (1) the copyright and authorship notice are retained and (2) it is not re-published or in any way sold for profit. Failure to observe these rules will cause problems for us both.


Lloyd William Carpenter

Former Officer
New Zealand

SDA - We can agree to Agree


For those of you who discuss the Sabbath with Adventists. I think there is something you might want to make clear. Adventists pull together two different subjects and make them feed off each other unnaturally.

First always be confident.... Christians have always worshipped on Sunday. In fact, Christians worshipped every day of the week. (Acts 2:46) Jesus worshipped at the Temple on some Sundays (high annual Sabbaths.) There is nothing anywhere in scripture that would suggest that worshipping on Sunday would be wrong. There is no biblical nor historical records that anyone has ever found that suggested that worship on Sunday was wrong nor will ever be wrong.

Secondly, when they speak of Sabbath, that is a whole different story all together. Make sure they clearly understand that now the topic has shifted OFF of Sunday and onto the Sabbath. Let them know that from the beginning Christians have differed on if they should REST on the Sabbath. Som
e areas did keep resting on Sabbath. Some didn't. Hence Paul saying that it should be up to one's conscience and don't judge.

But the controversy was never about worshipping, but on resting. Keeping Sabbath as a rest or not. Sunday was always a day to worship on as was Sabbath too! The importance of those two days in early Christianity was what gives us our weekend today. Sabbath was a day of rest for some--AND worship and Sunday was a celebration of Christ's resurrection and they also worshipped. This is supported by ALL Christian historians who are not SDA.

Make sure you differentiate those two subjects. Sunday has since the beginning been a day of worship for Christians. That is historically irrefutable. The controversy was about resting on the Sabbath.

Why is keeping these two topics separate important. Because Adventists do not know Christian history. They ASSUME (because they find documents of the controversy over Sabbath) that somehow it was the ONLY worship day for Christians. That it was the "chosen" day, the correct day. Not so at ALL. All days were chosen and sanctified to worship on. The Sabbath rest was a separate issue and no Christian would ever have pitted worshipping on Sunday with worshipping on Saturday. They did both! In fact every day.

Tell an Adventists that you are simply thrilled they have chosen to rest on Sabbath. Tell them they resemble the eastern church who did indeed keep that tradition going in the New Covenant, even when they understood it was no longer a mandatory part of the New Covenant.

But stress to them that worship on Sunday is also never wrong. There is overwhelming evidence both in the Bible and in history of that.

Teaching that worshipping on Sunday is a last-day test is not biblical. They are confusing two separate issues by combining Sabbath and Sunday.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

What If “No Creed but the Bible” Is Unbiblical?



JUSTIN TAYLOR|3:05 PM CT


In his new book The Creedal Imperative Carl Trueman writes:
Christians are not divided between those who have creeds and confessions and those who do not; rather, they are divided between those who have public creeds and confessions which are written down and exist as public documents, subject to public scrutiny, evaluation, and critique; and those who have private creeds and confessions which are often improvised, unwritten, and thus not open to public scrutiny, not susceptible to evaluation and, crucially and ironically, not subject to testing by scripture to see whether they are true or not.
He concludes his first chapter—which you can read online—with a gentle challenge and encouragement to anti-confessional evangelicals:
I conclude this chapter by posing a challenge to those who, in  their earnest desire to be faithful to Scripture as the supreme authority of faith and life, claim that they have no creed but the Bible. Reflect critically on the cultural forces that are certainly consonant with holding such a position and ask yourself whether they have perhaps reinforced your antipathy to creeds and confessions in a way that is not directly related to the Bible’s own teaching at all. Then, setting aside for just a moment your sincere convictions on this matter, read the rest of this book and see whether creeds and confessions might not actually provide you with a better way of preserving precisely those aspects of biblical, Christian faith which are most valuable to you and which you passionately wish to communicate to your church.
Here are a couple of commendations of the book:
“If the title of this book sounds boring to you, then it probably means you need it! Doctrinal aversion, radical individualism, unexamined subjectivism—these are only a few of the problems afflicting the evangelical church. In The Creedal Imperative, Carl Trueman wisely applies his vast historical knowledge to offer a remedy for such deficiencies. This book is especially important for so many believers whose Christian life, like mine, grew out of the soil of vibrant experience with insufficient doctrinal moorings. And beyond merely correcting errors, the lessons here have great potential for protecting the church, reinvigorating our cherished beliefs, and fostering greater unity in our worship. I’m grateful for Carl, and I’m grateful he wrote this book.”
—C. J. Mahaney, Sovereign Grace Ministries
“It is commonplace among many church leaders to dispute the need for confessions of faith on the grounds of the supreme authority of the Bible. In this timely book, Trueman demonstrates effectively how such claims are untenable. We all have creeds—the Bible itself requires them—but some are unwritten, not open to public accountability, and the consequences can be damaging. Trueman’s case deserves the widest possible hearing.”—Robert Letham, Director of Research and Senior Lecturer in Systematic and Historical Theology, Wales Evangelical School of Theology; author, The Holy Trinity and Union with Christ

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

FSAOF membership qualifications; Update 2012-1/1/2015


This secluded meeting place has been especially created for all former SA officers. A “former officer” refers to any person who entered TSA training college as a cadet, envoys and commissioned officers whom resign their status for any reason. If a ‘former’ returns to substantive rank and office they will be given the option to remain in our fellowship. However, to qualify for membership all persons are required to seek acceptance while absent from SA officership. No active officers will be accepted regardless of their officership history.

Separated for various reasons some former officers come to this group wounded by the actions or words of leaders or colleagues, others moved out of TSA to follow God’s leading to share the gospel of Jesus elsewhere, still others have been so devastated by the hurt they experience as officers that they have become disillusioned with the church and with God. Many former officers are angry due to the lack of pastoral care exhibited by TSA leaders, especially upon departure, by the organization to which they had committed their lives. And for many we are simply a place to fellowship with folks sharing a common experience with other former SA officers. Irrespective of how or why you left the Salvation Army’s unique place of service, you will receive a warm welcome here.

We encourage discussion and want to remind everyone that sensitive and private comments are commonly shared; therefore, we ask that nothing revealed in our FSAOF be shared with non-members. In the five years that we have been active our integrity has never been jeopardized, which speaks highly of our fellowship. Please help us ensure that this record of integrity and mutual respect remains unbroken.

At this FSAOF face book page, the moderator, along with designated associate administrators, have full authority to post, moderate and maintain this FB fellowship page.

Sven Ljungholm  and associate Administrators

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

INTERNATIONAL APPOINTMENTS AND PROMOTIONS

The Salvation Army
International Headquarters
The Chief of the Staff




1 October 2012


To:        Active and retired commissioners, 
        Active and retired territorial commanders 
        And officers commanding         


Dear Comrades, 


INTERNATIONAL APPOINTMENTS AND PROMOTIONS


It is my privilege to share with you information regarding international appointments and promotions decided by the General.

EFFECTIVE 1 JANUARY 2013 

COMMISSIONERS JOASH AND FLORENCE MALABI, officers of the Kenya West Territory, currently serving as territorial leaders in that territory, are appointed to International Headquarters.  Commissioner Joash Malabi is appointed as International Secretary for Africa, and Commissioner Florence Malabi as Zonal Secretary for Women’s Ministries - Africa. They will take up their new appointment responsibilities on 1 January 2013 in succession to Commissioners Amos and Rosemary Makina who will be retiring from active service. 

COMMISSIONERS KENNETH G. AND JOLENE K. HODDER, officers of the USA Western Territory, currently serving respectively as International Secretary for Personnel and Associate International Secretary for Personnel, at International Headquarters, are appointed as territorial leaders of the Kenya West Territory. Commissioner Kenneth G. Hodder is appointed as Territorial Commander, Kenya West Territory, and Commissioner Jolene K. Hodder as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. 
Further word will reach you in due course with regard to the ongoing work of the International Personnel Department at IHQ. 

COMMISSIONERS JOHN AND DORITA WAINWRIGHT, officers of the United Kingdom Territory with the Republic of Ireland, currently serving as territorial leaders of the Kenya East Territory, are appointed to International Headquarters.  Commissioner John Wainwright is appointed as International Auditor in the Business Administration Department (effective 1 January 2013). Commissioner Dorita Wainwright is appointed as Zonal Secretary for Women’s Ministries – Europe (effective 1 March 2013).   

COMMISSIONER VINECE CHIGARIRO, an officer of the Zimbabwe Territory, currently serving as Territorial Commander and Territorial President of Women’s Ministries of that territory, is appointed as Territorial Commander and Territorial President of Women’s Ministries, Kenya East Territory, in succession to Commissioners John and Dorita Wainwright who will be taking up new appointment responsibilities (see below). 
COLONELS HENRY AND CATHERINE NYAGAH, officers of the Kenya East Territory currently serving as territorial leaders in the Malawi Territory, are appointed as territorial leaders of the Zimbabwe Territory. Colonel Henry Nyagah is appointed as Territorial Commander, Zimbabwe Territory, and Colonel Catherine Nyagah as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries.  They will take up their new appointment responsibilities with the rank of commissioner – Colonel Catherine Nyagah on 1 January 2013 and Colonel Henry Nyagah on 2 January 2013. 

COLONELS MOSES AND SARAH WANDULU, officers of the Uganda Territory currently serving as territorial leaders in that territory, are appointed as the territorial leaders of the Malawi Territory.  Colonel Moses Wandulu is appointed as Territorial Commander, Malawi Territory, and Colonel Sarah Wandulu as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. 

COLONELS BENJAMIN AND GRACE MNYAMPI, officers of the Tanzania Territory currently serving respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women's Ministries in the Kenya West Territory, are appointed as territorial leaders of the Uganda Territory. Colonel Benjamin Mnyampi is appointed as Territorial Commander, Uganda Territory, and Colonel Grace Mnyampi as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. 

MAJORS JOHNSTONE AND LINNET WOLAYO, officers of the Kenya West Territory, currently serving respectively as Secretary for Personnel and Territorial Director, Community Caring Ministry in that territory, are appointed respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Kenya West Territory. They will take up their new appointment responsibilities with the rank of lieutenant-colonel. 

LIEUT-COLONELS NAHASHON AND ZIPPORAH NJIRU, officers of the Kenya East Territory and currently serving respectively as Divisional Commander and Divisional Director of Women’s Ministries, Kangundo Division, in that territory are appointed respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Kenya East Territory.  They succeed Colonels Gabriel and Monica Kathuri who will receive new appointments. 

COLONELS MICHAEL AND JOAN PARKER, officers of the United Kingdom Territory with the Republic of Ireland, currently serving respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries, Indonesia Territory are appointed as territorial leaders, Indonesia Territory. Colonel Michael Parker is appointed as Territorial Commander, Indonesia Territory, and Colonel Joan Parker as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. They will take up their new appointment responsibilities with the rank of commissioner – Colonel Joan Parker on 3 January 2013 and Colonel Michael Parker on 4 January 2013. They succeed Commissioners Basuki and Marie Kartodarsono who will be retiring from active service. 

LIEUT-COLONELS JONES AND MARIYAM KASAEDJA, officers of the Indonesia Territory, currently serving respectively as Secretary for Personnel and Territorial Home League Director in that territory, are appointed respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries, Indonesia Territory. 

EFFECTIVE 1 FEBRUARY 2013 

COMMISSIONERS CLIVE AND MARIANNE ADAMS, officers of the Norway, Iceland and the Færoes Territory, currently serving as territorial leaders in that territory, are appointed territorial leaders of the United Kingdom Territory with the Republic of Ireland. Commissioner Clive Adams is appointed as Territorial Commander, United Kingdom Territory with the Republic of Ireland, and Commissioner Marianne Adams as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. 

COMMISSIONERS DICK AND VIBEKE KROMMENHOEK, officers of the Netherlands & Czech Republic Territory currently serving as territorial leaders of the Finland and Estonia Territory, are appointed as territorial leaders of the Norway, Iceland and the Færoes Territory. Commissioner Dick Krommenhoek is appointed as Territorial CommanderNorway, Iceland and the Færoes Territory, and Commissioner Vibeke Krommenhoek as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. 

COLONELS JOHNNY AND EVA KLEMAN, officers of the Sweden and Latvia Territory, currently serving respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in that territory, are appointed as territorial leaders of the Finland and Estonia Territory. Colonel Johnny Kleman is appointed as Territorial Commander, Finland and Estonia Territory, and Colonel Eva Kleman as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. 

LIEUT-COLONELS DANIEL AND REBECCA SJOGREN, officers of the USA Central Territory,  currently serving respectively as Divisional Commander and Divisional Director of Women’s Ministries, Northern Division, in that territory are appointed respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries, in the Sweden and Latvia Territory. 

LIEUT-COLONELS KONG CHEW (BOB) AND TEOH GIM LENG (WENDY) LEE, officers of the Singapore, Malaysia and Myanmar Territory, currently serving as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in that territory, are appointed respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Philippines Territory.  They succeed Lieut-Colonels Ronald and Robyn Clinch who will be proceeding to appointments in their home territory (Australia Southern). 

LIEUT-COLONELS LYNDON AND BRONWYN BUCKINGHAM, officers of the New Zealand, Fiji and Tonga Territory currently serving respectively as Secretary for Programme and Assistant Secretary for Programme in that territory, are appointed respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Singapore, Malaysia and Myanmar Territory. 

LIEUT-COLONELS NEIL AND CHRISTINE WEBB, officers of the United Kingdom Territory with the Republic of Ireland, currently serving respectively as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Papua New Guinea Territory, are appointed as territorial leaders of that territory. Lieut-Colonel Neil Webb is appointed as Territorial Commander, Papua New Guinea Territory, and Lieut-Colonel Christine Webb as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. Lieut-Colonels Webb take up their new appointment responsibilities with the rank of colonel. They succeed Commissioner Andrew Kalai who will be retiring from active service. 

LIEUT-COLONEL MIRIAM GLUYAS, an officer of the Australia Eastern Territory, currently serving as Secretary for Programme in that territory, is appointed as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Papua New Guinea Territory. 

MAJOR HANNELISE TVEDT, an officer of the Norway, Iceland and The Færoes Territory, currently serving as Assistant Secretary for Programme in the United Kingdom Territory with the Republic of Ireland, is appointed as Chief Secretary and Territorial Secretary for Women’s Ministries in the Netherlands and Czech Republic Territory, in succession to Colonels Pieter and Alida Dijkstra who will be retiring from active service. She will take up her new appointment responsibilities with the rank of colonel. 

LIEUT-COLONELS GORDON AND SUSAN DALY. Subsequent to the General’s decision that the Spain and Portugal commands shall be combined to form the Spain and Portugal Command as of 1 February 2012, Lieut-Colonels Gordon and Susan Daly, officers of the New Zealand, Fiji and Tonga Territory are appointed as command leaders. Lieut-Colonel Gordon Daly is appointed as Officer Commanding, Spain and Portugal Command, and Lieut-Colonel Susan Daly as Command President of Women's Ministries. 
The bringing together of the Spain and Portugal commands and the appointments of Lieut-Colonels Daly as command leaders coincide with the retirement from active service of Lieut-Colonels Luis and Aida Castillo who have given leadership to the Spain Command in recent years. 

EFFECTIVE 1 MARCH 2013 

COLONEL BIRGITTE BREKKE, an officer of the Norway, Iceland and the Færoes Territory, currently serving as Territorial Commander, Denmark Territory, is appointed to International Headquarters as International Secretary for Europe. She will take up her new appointment responsibilities with the rank of commissioner in succession to Commissioner Robert Street who, with Commissioner Janet Street, will be retiring from active service. (Commissioner Janet Street being succeeded by Commissioner Dorita Wainwright as indicated above).

LIEUT-COLONELS KNUD DAVID AND LISBETH WELANDER, officers of the Norway, Iceland and the Færoes Territory currently serving respectively as Secretary for Business Administration and Sponsorship and Scholarship Secretary in the Philippines Territory, are appointed as territorial leaders of the Denmark Territory. Lieut-Colonel David Welander is appointed Territorial Commander, Denmark Territory and Lieut-Colonel Lisbeth Welander as Territorial President of Women’s Ministries. They will take up their new appointment responsibilities with the rank of colonel. 


I know you will join me in praying God's richest blessing upon our comrades as they prepare to assume their new appointment responsibilities. 


Sincerely yours 


Barry C. Swanson
CHIEF OF THE STAFF

"Can Christians really trust an Arab movement?"


While there are no easy answers, one thing is clear: The Arab Spring has put American Christians in a dilemma. Many are wondering, “Can we really support a movement fronted by Arabs—and more specifically, by Muslims?”

The fact that Arabs would desire many of the same freedoms Americans enjoy, and they would choose to express these desires non-violently, goes against every stereotype many American Christians have been taught to believe.

Many have been raised under a certain end-times theology, groomed to harbor deep suspicion of all things Arab. For Christians who follow this way of thinking, the formation of Israel in 1948—and the subsequent 750,000 Arabs who either left their homes or were expelled—was a result of divine prophecy, a rebooting of the prophetic time clock, triggering a series of events that will culminate in the return of Christ.

In this particular theology, Arabs are often cast in the role of the violent “sons of Ishmael” who always have, and always will, persecute Jews (and their stepchildren, Christians) until Jesus comes back. So is it any wonder millions of American Christians schooled in this theology are suspicious of masses of Arabs demonstrating on the streets?

“What exactly are they aspiring to?” asks this Christian. “Is it the destruction of Israel, or the annihilation of Christians?”

Further complicating matters is that many American Christians’ primary source of information about Arabs, the Middle East and Muslims in general is what they read in newsletters highlighting the suffering of persecuted Christians. They see radical fundamentalists burning down churches, and Christians being ostracized, beaten, imprisoned or killed for their faith—and often these atrocities are taking place in predominantly Muslim countries. This leads one to conclude Muslims have an innate hatred toward Jesus and His followers.

The reality is a bit more complex.

What do Muslims really believe about Christians?

Contrary to popular belief, the Quran does not call for the indiscriminate killing of Christians, so fears that a group like the Muslim Brotherhood would automatically start killing Christians upon seizing power is overstated. Jews and Christians are called “People of the Book” in the Quran, not infidels.

Jesus is also highly revered in the Quran, though not given the same divine status as in the New Testament. The Quran specifically commands Muslims to protect Jewish and Christian houses of worship (churches, synagogues, holy sites). It’s true that in some cases. Christians have to pay a tax under Islamic law, and that open proselytizing is forbidden, but Muslims see these laws as protecting, not subjugating, Christians.
I’ve befriended and interacted with thousands of Muslims over the years, and one of the questions I often get is, “Why do so many American Christians accuse us of persecuting Christians?” They think it’s strange because, from their perspective, Christians in their countries have freedom to worship as they please. A lot of my Muslim friends, especially the ones in the Middle East, are even proud of the fact that the Christian minorities in their countries date back to the first century, and have held on to their traditions. They would argue that—right or wrong—Christians in their countries have been treated far better than minorities in Christian lands (think: the Crusades and the Inquisition).

While most Muslim countries today do not allow for open proselytizing as is common in the West, and it is true that Muslims who convert to Christianity are often persecuted, it’s not true that Christians have always treated Muslims better than Muslims have treated Christians. When you look at the long view of history, even up to recent history, the reality is a bit more nuanced.

This is an explosive issue on both sides, so here are a few points to offer perspective:
1. Christianity is viewed by most Muslims as the religion of the colonialists, the people who come (or came) with a Bible in one hand and a gun in the other. They view missionaries, and their spiritual offspring, as a ploy by the colonialist powers to occupy their land, exploit their resources and subjugate their people.
2. Muslims who convert to Christianity aren’t just persecuted by other Muslims; they’re often viewed with suspicion, and sometimes outright derision, by the Christian population who trace their faith through the centuries. I’ve also seen “Insider Muslims” (Muslims who follow Jesus but don’t call themselves “Christians”) persecuted by those who have openly converted to Christianity.
3. In some cases, radical Christians are just as violent as radical Muslims. Americans often feel violence between Christians and Muslims is a one-way street, with Muslims as the persecutors and Christians as the victims. Muslims feel the exact opposite. They think of “us” as the persecutors and “them” as the victims.

So what does this have to do with the current situation in the Middle East?

For one thing, America has supported ruthless dictators in Muslim lands for years. Take Egypt, for example. Mubarak was a tyrant. He tortured, manipulated elections, controlled the media, stole billions of dollars from the Egyptian people to finance his lavish lifestyle and enrich his cronies, all with support from the United States. The same story can be repeated throughout the Muslim world.

It stands to reason that when a people see skyrocketing food prices and high unemployment, while their leaders are living lavishly, they’re going to want change. Just like Americans, they want free elections and a chance to determine their future. Because we’ve been the ones financing their dictators, they see the U.S. as an obstacle to their freedom, not a partner for peace and equality.

This is why the question of whether or not American Christians should support Arab aspirations for democracy is easily answered with a resounding “yes.” It’s silly to think their primary motivation is religious domination, or some plot to establish a global Muslim theocracy.

Sadly, many Arabs have negative perceptions of American Christians. If we choose to not support them now, they will continue to stereotype Americans as warmongering hypocrites. That has huge implications for indigenous Christians living in Arab lands. If some theorize American Christians’ approval of the revolutions could lead to the greater persecution of Christians in Arab lands, then how might our disapproval also lead to the greater persecution of Christians in Arab lands?

Carl Medearis


Carl is an international expert in the field of Arab-American and Muslim-Christian relations.

He acts as a catalyst for a number of current movements in the Middle East to promote peace-making, as well as cultural, political and religious dialog leading toward reconciliation. He is the author of the acclaimed book on these issues, Muslims, Christians and Jesus.

Carl, his wife Chris, and three kids lived in Beirut, Lebanon for 12 years. Through their unique and strategic approach around the Arab world, they encouraged university students, business professionals and political leaders to live their lives by the principles and teachings of Jesus in order to change their societies and nations.

Today Carl spends much of his time working with leaders both in the West and in the Arab world with the hope of seeing the Arab Middle East and the West experience full and fruitful relationships through the life and teachings of Jesus of Nazareth.