Saturday, February 4, 2012

The Stranger in Our Midst Part One


Part One

 
Minneapolis, Minnesota -- April 17, 1999

Matthew 25:31-46



Last Sunday and Monday evenings, one of the major television networks played Kevin Costner's movie version of Wyatt Earp. To help the viewer understand this man's adult behavior of intense loyalty to family and hostile distrust of everyone else, we were shown scenes from his childhood. His father passionately taught the children: “Nothing counts so much as blood. All the rest are strangers.”  Most of us seem to know that without being intentionally taught it. There are few things we naturally fear more than the unfamiliar. It is a fear so universal we have a name for it: Xenophobia -- the fear of the foreign. It comes from the same Greek word from which we get the word strange. It refers to everything outside the boundaries of the circles within which we are familiar.

The Strangers
Think of the way we view strangers in our midst. Are we not defensive about them and do we not work to protect ourselves from them? The warnings we give one another range all the way from Stella Bensen’s advise, Call no man foe, but never love a stranger; through our parent’s persistent counsel, never speak to strangers; to the policy of our police forces which urge us to report the presence of strangers. It may be a linguistic coincidence that stranger rhymes with danger, but our natural fear of the foreign and our social conditioning against those we don’t know, both tie them tightly together.

With such warnings in our ears, our primary line of defense is exclusion. By keeping ourselves separate we feel more secure. So we remove ourselves as far as possible from those who are different from us in ways either great or small. The poor are separated from those with enough; the sick from the healthy; the old from the young; ethnic minorities from the ethnic majority; prisoners from the free; and the weak from the strong. On and on the descriptions of our separations could go. But the point is the same: if others are different from me they are bad or wrong or unworthy, so they must be excluded from participation in my life and society.

But surely, some would say, that description is no longer true in our society. We live in a generation that affirms diversity, that values human differences, that celebrates multicultural experiences. Inclusion rather than exclusion is the buzzword today, at least among those who are politically and religiously enlightened. While it is true that in places like Yugoslavia there still may be remnants of the exclusive spirit that marked the way past generations dealt with strangers, we are for the most part beyond it. Things are getting better all the time. Just this past week the State of Alabama began the process of repealing its Constitutional prohibition against interracial marriage. Since South Carolina removed its similar ban last February, there will soon be no State in these United States that legally forbids people of different races to love one another. There really are no strangers among us anymore. We are becoming just one big happy family.

Are we? Or, does there still remain one class of people who continue to experience exclusion right there in the middle of our newborn inclusiveness?

Robert Dawidoff, Professor of History at Claremont Graduate University, thinks there is. He calls this group of people the Last Outcasts. The Washington Post thinks so, too. A recent Post article headline identifies One Area where Americans Still Draw a Line on Acceptability.  Based on a national survey conducted jointly by the Post, the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation and Harvard University, the article asserts that Americans have radically adjusted their moral sensibility in the last 30 years, reserving judgment on people and lifestyles they once readily condemned. A majority now finds divorce, sex before marriage, interracial relationship and single motherhood acceptable. But one group whose behavior remains firmly outside the bounds of acceptability for a majority of Americans is homosexuals.

In a recent opinion sampling, Alan Wolfe of Boston University found that middle class Americans no longer believe that Jews, Muslims or atheists are inherently less worthy than Christians. But he notes one exception to what he calls America’s persistent and ubiquitous nonjudgmentalism. He says, most Americans I spoke to were not prepared to accept homosexuality.

Do we need studies and surveys to tell us that? Any homosexual person you meet, who has not been totally successful in hiding the reality of his or her sexual orientation, can tell you experiences of exclusion that heterosexual people frankly find hard to believe. Here is the way that experience is described by an anonymous high school student in Massachusetts, as reported in the Winter 1999 issue of Open Hands.

“Nobody tells Latino kids in the high school that nobody cares if they’re Hispanic so long as they keep it to themselves. Jewish kids aren’t told that they’re sinners and they could change into Christians if they wanted to. People don’t tell black kids they should put up with racism because they’ve come so far from when they were slaves. They don’t have to defend why there is a black history month, or why people want black studies included in the curriculum. People don’t say, That’s so Korean! when they mean something is stupid or weird. People don’t tell disabled kids that the community isn’t ready to defend their equal rights and inclusion yet. You never hear anyone argue that breast cancer is God’s way of killing off women, or that it’s a good thing. If a teacher hears anyone use a slang insult for a Chinese kid, they jump on it. When foreign exchange students ask teachers about dating in school, they aren’t sent to see a guidance counselor.
“But every day in the high school, I hear its okay if I’m gay so long as I stay in the closet, and that I‘m an abomination against God, that I can change if I want to, and that people like me shouldn’t be taught about in school. I’m told that I should be satisfied because our school is far better than it used to be, and that I shouldn’t push for my equal rights and inclusion because the community isn’t ready yet. I hear, That’s so Gay!, all the time, and I hear that AIDS is my punishment for being who I am, and I hear the world faggot all the time. It’s hard not walk around angry all the time.”

If Americans are serious about building an inclusive society (and the last time I looked that was the American Dream), we are going to need a lot of people to lead the rest across this last frontier of fear in response to people who are different. If Christians are serious about building an inclusive Church (and putting those two words side by side is redundant in the Bible I read), we have a special challenge to face. For the fact to be confessed is that Christians have been largely responsible for the inability of people in this country to accept these last outcasts. As the Post/Kaiser/Harvard survey showed, Most Americans who find homosexuality unacceptable say they object on religious grounds.

Do we need surveys to tell us that? Last week, Nancy Hanson sent me a copy of her recent book, From Pain to Joy -- Inspiring Words for Hope and Healing. She’s a Midwestern Norwegian who was transplanted to Hawaii and is now planning to enter Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary in Berkeley to prepare for a second career in the ordained ministry. As a new comer to the Bay Area, she spent last Easter Sunday in the Castro District of San Francisco, the heart of the gay/lesbian community there, giving away free copies of her book to anyone willing to receive it. While there, she saw a tee shirt displaying the slogan: Jesus hates me, this I know, for the Christians tell me so.

Paul W. Egertson, Ph.D


An advocate whose eldest son is gay, he chose to participate in the ordination of a lesbian pastor in Minnesota in 2001, eight years before his denomination officially opened its doors to gay and lesbian clergy in committed relationships. In the storm of controversy that followed the ordination, Egertson resigned at the request of denominational leaders a month before his term would have expired. After the resignation, the synod assembly named his as Bishop Emeritus. People speak highly of his courage, advocacy and leadership as a pastor and teacher.

Part 10 GLBT Conclusion



Sitting here pondering and reflecting on some of the discussions that have come out of GLBT posts here on the blog. The first thing that strikes me is that there are so few persons leaving comments in relation to the high number of visitors.

I think that fear may be a large factor, both for those who disagree (who fear being labeled as bigoted fundamentalists) and those who agree (who are afraid of getting into trouble in their own congregations).
For a Christian, it can be difficult enough to "come out" and be GLBT-affirming. I recall that not so long ago I was with a number of my colleague officers present, seated there and I with a pounding heart and sweaty palms. Filled with anxiety I wondered what would happen when I began sharing with them my views on the GLBT issue. There were several persons present who tried to mediate; "what Patrik really means is that one must love the sinner and hate the sin ..." Oh how easy it would be to just remain quiet and slide back down in that abyss, but no, that's not what I mean.
What also strikes me is that it's so difficult to have a discussion without getting bogged down in judgmental, polarized arguments. Even if on the positive affirmative side, how does one maintain an open-minded, unbiased posture toward people with pronounced biases.

But I realize once again how important this conversation is and that it is in the public light, "Only in the open, you have an opportunity. Locks you if you suffocate and wither you. In the open air, you should walk with the Lord. My power is made perfect in your weakness then. "

I believe that we must love all people regardless of their actions (whether we categorize the action as a sin or not) and that we must be allowed to affirm, and even rejoice that GLBT persons are in fellowship, and realize that they are God’s gift to us. Some were curious, others stunned, and a few glared judgmentally and commented harshly. I can and I do understand fear. It is not easy to "come out."

But I realize once again how important this discussion is and that it take place in a public forum:

"In the arena of candidness you have opportunity.
Lock yourself away and you will suffocate and wither.
Step out into freedom and walk with the Lord.
(for) My power is made perfect in your weakness."

If we dare not (or aren’t allowed) to "come out" and discuss these difficult to handle issues in transparency and honesty, how are we ever going to find, understand, (and) love one another! So I continue blogging, Continue asking questions and highlight issues from as many perspectives as possible; maybe it attracts one more out of the closet where we can have the conversation, in the open.

.
Psalm 90 – Surely in the light


"Surely in the arena of candidness you have opportunity.
Lock yourself away and you will suffocate and wither.
Step out into freedom and walk with the Lord.
(for) My power is made perfect in your weakness."

Live in a world converted to reality,
Turned toward God's future, urged onward by His faithfulness.
You’ll never face darkness alone.
Only in the light will your possibilities be kindled.

Text: Britt G Hallqvist 1972 - J Kirkegaard 1971
Music: O Widestrand 1974, 19












Lt. Patrik Olterman
Commanding officer
TSA Malmo, Sweden
















TRANSLATION: Dr. Sven Ljungholm

Friday, February 3, 2012

PART NINE GLBT - The discussion continues, a way forward. 2012 ASSEMBLY,

Following many words and much wrestling with the scriptures, doctrines, and my own faith, I have come to find, that no matter how I read the biblical text, I can never escape from my commission to love the Lord with all my soul, with all my heart and with all my strength. And to love my neighbor as myself.  Unless Jesus came into the world to condemn it but rather to save it, then it's not my role to judge the world, or any other person.


When I then delve down into the depths of the Bible, I understand that I do not have much ground under my feet to speak soundly either for or against GLBT (issues). The only thing that I can deduce with all possible clarity is that I am called to love all people regardless of gender, sexuality, nationality, social status and political opinion. Yes, I am even to love my enemies and pray that God will bless them.

How then shall I be able to move forward to, in a sensible and dignified manner, continue to discuss these issues? Can I do other than to tolerate (simply allow) GLBT persons to be who they are and to actually love them? How can I learn more (in order) to live near to and in Christian fellowship with these my fellow human beings and siblings -  joined by faith?

RFSL & EKHO
For my part, I am now a card-carrying member of RFSL and have been part of the startup team of EKHO, the Province of  Scania. EKHO is a special interest organization that works to create a safe place where LGBT people can have freedom and encouragement in their Christian faith.

Here in Malmö EKHO will host an open cafe for conversation and fellowship once a month with the first meeting taking place on January 26 Please contact us if you want to join with us.

Ekho works therefore to:

·      Provide a living and liberating community for GLBT persons
·      an environment that provides care and social security
·      liberation and justice for GLBT persons in Christian churches and denominations
·      to actively carry out and in collaboration with others, further awareness of gay, lesbian, bisexual and trans support available through members' active work in their own church
·      ensure that every individual be able to feel the strength of being a whole person, created in God's image
·      that every individual must be able to accept, respect and rejoice in their ability to fall in love with someone of the same sex and feel that it is a gift from God, reflecting God's love
·      to respond to ignorance and fear of GLBT issues with the insight of GLBT persons.

Addendums
 (RFSL—The Swedish Federation for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Rights) is a non-profit organization that works with and for the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people (LGBT). It is non-partisan and not affiliated with any religious organization. 

RFSL was founded in 1950 and is one of the world’s oldest LGBT organizations. It currently has approximately 4,000 members.)

(The Swedish Ecumenical Group for LGBT Christians

‘We believe that LGBT and Christianity are fully compatible; you can be Christian and have a same-sex relationship.
Click here for more information
Worship and Events
We organise discussions and social events once a month)
Here is an excerpt from the Ekho folder:

EKHO has since the early 80's been a driving force to make Sweden an open country where Christian GLBT persons can live and work in their churches and communities.

Ekho seeks to move forward socially by providing enlightening work through various hosted programs, services, information activities, camps, youth work, telephone and personal counseling.

________________
FROM THE UK SITE
Anti-discrimination

Discrimination on the basis on sexual orientation and gender identity is prohibited in the areas of employment, and provision of goods and services.
In Gibraltar discrimination on the basis on sexual orientation is prohibited only in employment. 


Legal gender recognition of trans people

The United Kingdom has administrative procedures to obtain legal gender recognition compulsory genital surgery, however with compulsory divorce.


Partnership recognition

In the United Kingdom (England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland) same-sex couples are able to enter into a registered partnership. It also provides registered cohabiting same-sex couples with a set of limited rights. 
The UK civil partnership law does not apply to Gibraltar and Guernsey.


Parenting rights

Same-sex couples are eligible to jointly apply for a child adoption and each other’s biological children. 
Medically assisted insemination is available to lesbian couples.
The UK legislation on these issues does not apply to Gibratar, Guernsey, Isle of Man and Jersey.


Criminal law on hate speech/ crime

Sexual orientation and gender identity (only in Scotland) are included in the law on hate and violence, and are recognised as aggravating factor. The UK legislation on law on hate and violence does not apply to Gibraltar, Guernsey, Isle of Man and Jersey.

Freedom of assembly/Pride events

Pride events have taken place with authorisation.


Criminal law on age of consent

The age of consent is equal for all sexual acts.

Asylum



Thursday, February 2, 2012

Part 8 - GLBT Salvation Army 2012 DENOMINATION - CORPS FELLOWSHIP




The problem persists in the Salvation Army, of today. In which way can we include GLBT persons in our fellowship without creating groupings; an A team and a B team? How can the Corps offer (church) membership in the Salvation Army in a positive manner that allows GLBT persons to feel valued, appreciated and loved by both the corps fellowship (soldiers/adherents) and also by the God to Whom the fellowship is showing (leading) the way.

Somewhere in this discussion one must remember that the Salvation Army has traditionally been the spokesperson for the marginalized. GLBT persons with Christian beliefs are often ‘doubly marginalized’. They are both excluded from the Christian community because of their sexual orientation, but often also excluded from the GLBT community due their grounding in the Christian faith.

In the Salvation Army soldiership is in itself problematic; we apply vague/weak and double morality standards concerning the various ‘offenses’ that exclude one from soldiership status. It appears that as it concern this there are several different options from which to choose.

Firstly, we can say that soldiership is open to all regardless of lifestyle and it is up to each one who enters into soldiership that they will to their best ability seek to interpret God's will and live a pure and holy life. This solution makes it possible for GLBT persons to become soldiers and makes civilians membership (adherents status) quite unnecessary. This solution (interpretation/ reading) on the other hand, allows for alcoholics, smokers, gamblers, people who abuse pornography, to become soldiers as well. Then it falls on the local pastor (an officer with the gift of pastoring or BOSC - Board of Spiritual Care) to guide each one, in good faith, to a whole life (integrity) before God.

Secondly, we insist that soldiership is a lifestyle choice, (as it’s defined and appears today) one not compatible with GLBT persons who choose to live out their sexuality. If one chooses this path one must also ensure that soldiership is also observed in all other respects. Adherent membership is offered today (as an alternative) to others seeking a corps community membership. (But then one should probably review the wording of the description of Adherency, see below)

Thirdly, one can select to remove the soldiership status and instead simply have a membership status where holiness is not a requirement but rather (a fellowship) wherein faith in Jesus is what unites us and binds us together. In common with the first solution this places responsibility on the local pastor who will engage with each member working out what this means individually in every person's life.

With regard to Adherency membership, (Existing civilian membership) this is already problematic. The (Swedish) leaflet explaing Adherence membership reads; "Civilian membership is full membership in the Salvation Army as a Christian community." It further states; "Being a member means you are offered corps’ ceremonies (are freely available) such as baby blessings/dedications, confirmations, weddings and funerals." This means that a GLBT person as a civilian member is promised the offer of both a marriage ceremony and baby dedication.
Of course one can argue that according to the SA a marriage not a marriage unless it is between a man and a woman but do we not then do exactly what the SA was accused of in the TV show Cold Facts: come with empty words; everyone is treated equally. This especially given the fact that the marriage ceremony is not instituted explicitly in the Bible but is rather, a tradition we have added to the Bible through methodical exegesis and our normal hetero interpretation of the scriptures
In addition, marriage is enshrined as one of our inalienable human rights in the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights. (Http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml # A16)

Without any exaggeration it can be said that the Salvation Army is facing a huge assignment regardless of the route one choose to take in the future relative to GLBT issues. If we as a denomination want to take a more positive inclusive approach it requires repentance and thorough, in-depth, strategic Bible teaching at all levels.

If we choose to go in the other direction it requires ransacking, repentance and a culling of the current soldiers and officers in order to resolve what we in our Orders and Regulations say that we stand for.

What is clear is that we as a denomination have to initiate a debate and bring this discussion to all levels, both in public and within the corps walls, both on the local level and the cabinet (SA leadership council).







If we as the Salvation Army want to be both open to embrace the oppressed and continue to be a holiness movement, we must engage in lengthy and giving discussions about how we should live in and manage the tension between these concepts.



 VISIT OLTERMAN'S BLOG





http://warcry.olterman.se/







Translation: Dr. Sven Ljungholm

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

PART 7 GLBT




There are probably as many ways to approach LGBT issues as there are people with opinions. What follows is a summary of the second half of "One family’s story" written by Bishop Paul Wenner Egertson and found in Walter Wink's book: Homosexuality and the Christian Faith (pages 28-30).

Bishop Paul Wenner Egertson depicts four different approaches to LGBT people who may be able to help congregations to find both clarity and perspective, but perhaps also assist it in its own move forward on these issues. It would, of course,  be better to read the article in its entirety in Walter Wink's book but here is an abbreviated version (a translation to Swedish) and half as a paraphrase interspersed  with the author's own opinions.

SIN?

The first way one can choose to approach the matter is as a moral problem. One chooses to read a handful of scripture verses with a literal interpretation and conclude that GLBT behavior is a sin, that is, a (conscious) choice to rebel against God and God's will, like prostitution, promiscuous sex or violent acts.

In this case, the only way to deal with the issue as a breaking (conscious dismissal) of a law, that ought to be corrected (reprimanded) and the response we want to witness is remorse /repentance and a complete change/turnaround. But the question must be posed, is homosexuality a choice to rebel; can it really be likened to ‘prostitution’?


ILLNESS?

A second method is to liken GLBT behavior to an illness (or condition) or resulting in certain behaviors that stem from abuse  (from an addiction) that can only be treated with complete abstinence, similar to alcoholism. The disease is treated solely in apart from the external behavior: alcohol consumption. If this is the case, a life of celibacy is the solution to the GLBT issue. But can LGBTQ really be likened to alcoholism?

In both cases we are forced to solve the problem through abstinence (which often leads to clandestine promiscuity), However, can we force someone or something to act against their nature? And more importantly, can one force someone to live out a Charisma, a spiritual gift?

And as long as we treat homosexuality as something sinful, we force homosexuals in our community to live “outside/beyond” that which we would normally suggest to anyone else. Only if we let go of the stigma, sinfulness, can we bless and encourage, tenderness, fidelity, and long-term commitments.

DISABILITY?
A third option is to liken GLBT to a tragedy of nature, where nature has been misconstrued; the effect of the “fall” in the world.  Something not planned by God or a part of God’s plan or will, but something that happens regularly in our world nonetheless. An unfortunate phenomenon that we could hardly call good. However, it is a fact that we do everything we can to help disabled people to a valued and decent life. Should we not then, in such cases make special rules for them so they (too) can live as rewarding a life as possible within the limits of their disability?

When someone’s legs are paralyzed we do not draw the conclusion that God does not want them to walk (be mobile), but we solve the problem with prosthetics or wheelchairs. If a couple cannot have children (conceive) do we not conclude that it is God's will that they shall be childless, but we assist/arrange an adoption.

Should we not in the same manner arrange a parallel structure providing marriage for gay people; to live out a full life to the best of their ability? But the question remains, can GLBT issues really be compared to a disability?

NATURAL VARIATION?
The last possibility is to see GLBT persons as a natural variation in creation, one of the wonderful differences that regularly occur in opposition to the norm. In this case, GLBT can be compared to left-handedness. One must remember that left-handed persons have been persecuted, punished and forced to live against their nature throughout history. Man eventually learned that it turns out to resemble issue of GLBT persons; you cannot make left-handed into right- handed persons, it only creates problems. When society relinquished their views on left-handedness one was free to discover the positive rewards assumed by, for example, the sports’ world. But can GLBT be likened to left-handedness?

If it can be, can’t we simply include GLBT persons in our congregations with joy, and also celebrate these persons as God's gift to our churches.

The latter two subversives allows us to include LGBT people in a positive way in our corps (church fellowship) and also provide meaningful information, opportunities, pastoral care and above all, we can encourage a sexual morality which is the same as we teach all the other members of the Corps without distinction. That is, we can encourage abstinence outside of marriage, we can teach gentle, loving and committed relationships. And we can help GLBT couples to manage their relationships; build them strong and sustainable in a world where promiscuity is otherwise elevated to a virtue.









Translation: Dr. Sven Ljungholm