THE CHRISTIAN MIND
A white building stands near my home. Heavy oak doors guard the entrance. Stained glass windows adorn each side. A cross rises from a single bell tower at its front, and the cornerstone still declares the date this particular structure was dedicated, over a hundred years ago, “to the glory of God.”
But it’s not a church. Not anymore. It’s called “The Choir Loft,” and it houses a business that sells fabrics and craft items. The structure looks like a church, but it is no longer Christian because it no longer functions Christianly.
That building symbolizes what has happened among Christians in the past century. Most of us still look, act, and speak like Christians, but inside—in our minds—we function no differently from our non-Christian colleagues and coworkers, acquaintances and antagonists. “There is no longer a Christian mind,” wrote Harry Blamires over thirty years ago in his classic, The Christian Mind. In other words, we may think as Americans or Canadians, Kenyan or Laotian. We may have a Midwestern or southern frame of reference. Our thinking may be colored by our race, ethnicity, or gender. Our perspective may be Republican or Democrat, Liberal or Conservative. But with few exceptions, we do not think Christianly; we approach issues from a thoroughly secular perspective.
“To think secularly,” Blamires wrote, “is to think within a frame of reference bounded by the limits of our life on earth. . . . To think christianly is to accept all things with the mind as related, directly or indirectly, to man’s eternal destiny as the redeemed and chosen child of God.” Yet, for the most part, we form opinions on politics, economics, commerce, history, art, literature, entertainment, sports, family, law, technology, philosophy, and science without a thought for how the mind of Christ (1 Corinthians 2:16) should inform our conclusions. We sometimes choose and (especially) pursue our vocations in much the same way as do our non-Christian colleagues. We treat fortune and misfortune, authority and celebrity in ways that are indistinguishable from those around us.
In doing so, however, we cheat the world and ourselves.
The Rewards of the Christian Mind
“The spiritual man,” Paul the Apostle wrote, “makes judgments about all things, but he himself is not subject to any man’s judgment: ‘For who has known the mind of the Lord that he may instruct him?’ But we have the mind of Christ” (1 Corinthians 2:15, 16, NIV).
The man or woman who learns to think Christianly is empowered, in a way the secular-thinking Christian is not, to “understand what God has freely given us” (1 Corinthians 2:12, NIV). This occurs because thinking Christianly is obedience to God and his Word. God will reward those who love him with heart and soul and mind (Matthew 22:37), who are transformed by the renewing of their minds (Romans 12:2). These rewards will take several forms, among which are:
1. An antidote for confusion. Gary Sweeten, author of Rational Christian Thinking and director of the Lifeway family of ministries, says, “There is enormous confusion in our culture these days, and it looks impossible to make any sense of today’s cultural, ethical, and moral climate. Thinking Christianly can prevent that overwhelming sense of confusion by giving us a set of lenses for the mind.” A man or woman who has never seen a chess game may watch the game being played for hour after hour, and may even form opinions regarding certain pieces, players, and strategies; but imagine if that same person were to sit down next to a true master who explains the invisible rules, strategies, and purpose behind every move. Now imagine the change of expression that would appear on the novice’s face as confusion disappeared, replaced with insight and informed judgment. That is what can happen for a man or woman who begins to perceive the world around him or her with the mind of Christ.
2. A new sense of empowerment. J.P. Moreland, professor of philosophy at Talbot School of Theology and author of Love Your God With All Your Mind, says that many of us as Christians have a sense “that society’s going crazy, and we don’t know what to do about it. We watch the news and see our values trashed . . . and we end up feeling disempowered and frustrated.” But learning to think Christianly can change that, he says. “I’ll never forget a man named Bob who came up to me after a twelve-week class I taught on Christian apologetics. With tears running down his cheeks, he thanked me for treating him like an adult, and said that he had always been embarrassed and afraid to speak up in his workplace, but the previous week had shared his faith with three coworkers because for the first time he felt he had some answers, some insight.”
3. An increased sense of meaning and enjoyment in life. “It’s obvious,” says Dr. Wade Bradshaw, former director of the Francis Schaeffer Institute at Covenant Theological Seminary, “that our culture knows very little about meaning and enjoyment. Our society has very little grasp of true sexual enjoyment, for example. People live only for the weekend, but the weekend leaves them feeling empty and unfulfilled. Thinking Christianly is an antidote to the boredom, depression, and cynicism that pervades the world around us, because enjoyment increases as understanding grows.” The more you understand a movie, for example, and what it is trying to say, the deeper will be your appreciation of it. The more you understand the world, and everything that’s in it, from a Christian perspective, the richer and fuller will be your enjoyment of it.
4. A greater sense of fulfillment in friendships. J.P. Moreland points out that Aristotle described three levels of friendship: friendships based on usefulness, those based on pleasure, and the highest level, when people band together around a conception of the good life, and their friendship involves mutual stimulation and encouragement in the pursuit of wisdom, character, knowledge, and virtue. “That’s New Testament koinonia, as far as I can see,” Moreland says. “Friendship should involve being fully informed and fully Christian. If I want to be a good friend, I need to bring all that I can to my fellowship with others, and the more stimulating I become, the more fulfillment I’ll be able to get—and give—in my relationships.”
5. A deeper sense of meaning in vocation. Dr. Bradshaw, currently on staff at L’Abri Fellowship, a residential Christian study center in England, relates the experience of a Chinese scientist who came to L’Abri believing that the Gospel was true, but that his scientific pursuits were somehow separate from his Christian beliefs. One day, in the middle of a conversation, his eyes opened wide, and he said, “Oh, but you mean it is true,” meaning the Christian message was not just a “religious”message but that the truth of Christianity could actually inform his pursuit of scientific knowledge. He returned to China with a new enthusiasm for his faith and his vocation. While some fields present greater challenges than others to someone working to integrate his or her Christian discipleship into a career, there is no area of life and no vocation in which the truth and reality of the Gospel doesn’t have some application.
6. An enhanced ability to deal with hardship. Thinking Christianly will also give a new perspective to life’s struggles and misfortunes. For example, the woman who has the mind of Christ will be better equipped to endure physical affliction with a sense of worth and dignity, knowing that her significance is not rooted in her appearance or her health, but in an understanding of what it means to be a human being created in the image of God. A man who loses his job will certainly struggle with the difficulties of his situation, but if he is thinking Christianly, he will be aided by a perspective that is rooted not in temporal ease or pleasure but in the priorities of eternity.
BOB HOSTETLER
Former SA officer
USA East & USA Nat’l HQ
Copyright © 2005, Bob Hostetler, use only with permission.
____
a forum for intelligent and respectful commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.
Tuesday, August 2, 2011
Monday, August 1, 2011
Homosexuality and the Bible Conclusion- Part 4
An Appeal for Tolerance
What most saddens me in this whole raucous debate in the churches is how sub-Christian most of it has been. It is characteristic of our time that the issues most difficult to assess, and which have generated the greatest degree of animosity, are issues on which the Bible can be interpreted as supporting either side. I am referring to abortion and homosexuality.
We need to take a few steps back and be honest with ourselves. I am deeply convinced of the rightness of what I have said in this essay. But I must acknowledge that it is not an air-tight case. You can find weaknesses in it, just as I can in others'. The truth is, we are not given unequivocal guidance in either area, abortion or homosexuality.
Rather than tearing at each other’s throats, therefore, we should humbly admit our limitations. How do I know I am correctly interpreting God's word for us today? How do you? Wouldn't it be wiser for Christians to lower the decibels by 95 percent and quietly present our beliefs, knowing full well that we might be wrong?
I know of a couple, both well-known Christian authors in their own right, who have both spoken out on the issue of homosexuality. She supports gays, passionately; he opposes their behavior, strenuously. So far as I can tell, this couple still enjoy each other's company, eat at the same table, and, for all I know, sleep in the same bed.
We in the church need to get our priorities straight. We have not reached a consensus about who is right on the issue of homosexuality. But what is clear, utterly clear, is that we are commanded to love one another. Love not just our gay sisters and brothers who are often sitting beside us, unacknowledged, in church, but all of us who are involved in this debate. These are issues about which we should amiably agree to disagree. We don't have to tear whole denominations to shreds in order to air our differences on this point. If that couple I mentioned can continue to embrace across this divide, surely we can do so as well.
About the Author
Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.
His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.
He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.
Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quaker meeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.
What most saddens me in this whole raucous debate in the churches is how sub-Christian most of it has been. It is characteristic of our time that the issues most difficult to assess, and which have generated the greatest degree of animosity, are issues on which the Bible can be interpreted as supporting either side. I am referring to abortion and homosexuality.
We need to take a few steps back and be honest with ourselves. I am deeply convinced of the rightness of what I have said in this essay. But I must acknowledge that it is not an air-tight case. You can find weaknesses in it, just as I can in others'. The truth is, we are not given unequivocal guidance in either area, abortion or homosexuality.
Rather than tearing at each other’s throats, therefore, we should humbly admit our limitations. How do I know I am correctly interpreting God's word for us today? How do you? Wouldn't it be wiser for Christians to lower the decibels by 95 percent and quietly present our beliefs, knowing full well that we might be wrong?
I know of a couple, both well-known Christian authors in their own right, who have both spoken out on the issue of homosexuality. She supports gays, passionately; he opposes their behavior, strenuously. So far as I can tell, this couple still enjoy each other's company, eat at the same table, and, for all I know, sleep in the same bed.
We in the church need to get our priorities straight. We have not reached a consensus about who is right on the issue of homosexuality. But what is clear, utterly clear, is that we are commanded to love one another. Love not just our gay sisters and brothers who are often sitting beside us, unacknowledged, in church, but all of us who are involved in this debate. These are issues about which we should amiably agree to disagree. We don't have to tear whole denominations to shreds in order to air our differences on this point. If that couple I mentioned can continue to embrace across this divide, surely we can do so as well.
About the Author
Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.
His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.
He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.
Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quaker meeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.
Saturday, July 30, 2011
Homosexuality and the Bible Part -3-
The Problem of Authority
These cases are relevant to our attitude toward the authority of Scripture. They are not cultic prohibitions from the Holiness Code that are clearly superseded in Christianity, such as rules about eating shellfish or wearing clothes made of two different materials. They are rules concerning sexual behavior, and they fall among the moral commandments of Scripture. Clearly we regard certain rules, especially in the Old Testament, as no longer binding. Other things we regard as binding, including legislation in the Old Testament that is not mentioned at all in the New. What is our principle of selection here?
For example, virtually all modern readers would agree with the Bible in rejecting: incest, rape, adultery, and intercourse with animals. But we disagree with the Bible on most other sexual mores. The Bible condemned the following behaviors which we generally allow: intercourse during menstruation, celibacy, exogamy (marriage with non-Jews), naming sexual organs, nudity (under certain conditions), masturbation (some Christians still condemn this), birth control (some Christians still forbid this).
And the Bible regarded semen and menstrual blood as unclean, which most of us do not. Likewise, the Bible permitted behaviors that we today condemn: prostitution, polygamy, levirate marriage, sex with slaves, concubinage, treatment of women as property, and very early marriage (for the girl, age 11-13).
And while the Old Testament accepted divorce, Jesus forbade it. In short, of the sexual mores mentioned here, we only agree with the Bible on four of them, and disagree with it on sixteen!
Surely no one today would recommend reviving the levirate marriage. So why do we appeal to proof texts in Scripture in the case of homosexuality alone, when we feel perfectly free to disagree with Scripture regarding most other sexual practices? Obviously many of our choices in these matters are arbitrary. Mormon polygamy was outlawed in this country, despite the constitutional protection of freedom of religion, because it violated the sensibilities of the dominant Christian culture. Yet no explicit biblical prohibition against polygamy exists.
If we insist on placing ourselves under the old law, as Paul reminds us, we are obligated to keep every commandment of the law (Gal. 5:3). But if Christ is the end of the law (Rom. 10:4), if we have been discharged from the law to serve, not under the old written code but in the new life of the Spirit (Rom. 7:6), then all of these biblical sexual mores come under the authority of the Spirit. We cannot then take even what Paul himself says as a new Law. Christians reserve the right to pick and choose which sexual mores they will observe, though they seldom admit to doing just that. And this is as true of evangelicals and fundamentalists as it is of liberals and mainliners.
Judge for Yourselves
The crux of the matter, it seems to me, is simply that the Bible has no sexual ethic. There is no Biblical sex ethic. Instead, it exhibits a variety of sexual mores, some of which changed over the thousand year span of biblical history. Mores are unreflective customs accepted by a given community. Many of the practices that the Bible prohibits, we allow, and many that it allows, we prohibit. The Bible knows only a love ethic, which is constantly being brought to bear on whatever sexual mores are dominant in any given country, or culture, or period.
The very notion of a "sex ethic" reflects the materialism and splitness of modern life, in which we increasingly define our identity sexually. Sexuality cannot be separated off from the rest of life. No sex act is "ethical" in and of itself, without reference to the rest of a person's life, the patterns of the culture, the special circumstances faced, and the will of God. What we have are simply sexual mores, which change, sometimes with startling rapidity, creating bewildering dilemmas. Just within one lifetime we have witnessed the shift from the ideal of preserving one's virginity until marriage, to couples living together for several years before getting married. The response of many Christians is merely to long for the hypocrisies of an earlier era.
I agree that rules and norms are necessary; that is what sexual mores are. But rules and norms also tend to be impressed into the service of the Domination System, and to serve as a form of crowd control rather than to enhance the fullness of human potential. So we must critique the sexual mores of any given time and clime by the love ethic exemplified by Jesus. Defining such a love ethic is not complicated. It is non-exploitative (hence no sexual exploitation of children, no using of another to their loss), it does not dominate (hence no patriarchal treatment of women as chattel), it is responsible, mutual, caring, and loving. Augustine already dealt with this in his inspired phrase, "Love God, and do as you please."
Our moral task, then, is to apply Jesus' love ethic to whatever sexual mores are prevalent in a given culture. This doesn't mean everything goes. It means that everything is to be critiqued by Jesus' love commandment. We might address younger teens, not with laws and commandments whose violation is a sin, but rather with the sad experiences of so many of our own children who find too much early sexual intimacy overwhelming, and who react by voluntary celibacy and even the refusal to date. We can offer reasons, not empty and unenforceable orders. We can challenge both gays and straights to question their behaviors in the light of love and the requirements of fidelity, honesty, responsibility, and genuine concern for the best interests of the other and of society as a whole.
Christian morality, after all, is not a iron chastity belt for repressing urges, but a way of expressing the integrity of our relationship with God. It is the attempt to discover a manner of living that is consistent with who God created us to be. For those of same-sex orientation, as for heterosexuals, being moral means rejecting sexual mores that violate their own integrity and that of others, and attempting to discover what it would mean to live by the love ethic of Jesus.
Morton Kelsey goes so far as to argue that homosexual orientation has nothing to do with morality, any more than left-handedness. It is simply the way some people's sexuality is configured. Morality enters the picture when that predisposition is enacted. If we saw it as a God-given gift to those for whom it is normal, we could get beyond the acrimony and brutality that have so often characterized the unchristian behavior of Christians toward gays.
Approached from the point of view of love rather than that of law, the issue is at once transformed. Now the question is not "What is permitted?" but rather "What does it mean to love my homosexual neighbor?" Approached from the point of view of faith rather than works, the question ceases to be "What constitutes a breach of divine law in the sexual realm?" and becomes instead "What constitutes integrity before the God revealed in the cosmic lover, Jesus Christ?" Approached from the point of view of the Spirit rather than the letter, the question ceases to be "What does Scripture command?" and becomes "What is the Word that the Spirit speaks to the churches now, in the light of Scripture, tradition, theology, and, yes, psychology, genetics, anthropology, and biology?" We can't continue to build ethics on the basis of bad science.
In a little-remembered statement, Jesus said, "Why do you not judge for yourselves what is right?" (Luke 12:57 NRSV). Such sovereign freedom strikes terror in the hearts of many Christians; they would rather be under law and be told what is right. Yet Paul himself echoes Jesus' sentiment when he says, "Do you not know that we are to judge angels? How much more, matters pertaining to this life!" (1 Cor. 6:3 RSV). The last thing Paul would want is for people to respond to his ethical advice as a new law engraved on tablets of stone. He is himself trying to "judge for himself what is right." If now new evidence is in on the phenomenon of homosexuality, are we not obligated--no, free--to re-evaluate the whole issue in the light of all the available data and decide what is right, under God, for ourselves? Is this not the radical freedom for obedience in which the gospel establishes us?
Where the Bible mentions homosexual behavior at all, it clearly condemns it. I freely grant that. The issue is precisely whether that Biblical judgment is correct. The Bible sanctioned slavery as well, and nowhere attacked it as unjust. Are we prepared to argue today that slavery is biblically justified? One hundred and fifty years ago, when the debate over slavery was raging, the Bible seemed to be clearly on the slaveholders' side. Abolitionists were hard pressed to justify their opposition to slavery on biblical grounds. Yet today, if you were to ask Christians in the South whether the Bible sanctions slavery, virtually everyone would agree that it does not. How do we account for such a monumental shift?
What happened is that the churches were finally driven to penetrate beyond the legal tenor of Scripture to an even deeper tenor, articulated by Israel out of the experience of the Exodus and the prophets and brought to sublime embodiment in Jesus' identification with harlots, tax collectors, the diseased and maimed and outcast and poor. It is that God sides with the powerless. God liberates the oppressed. God suffers with the suffering and groans toward the reconciliation of all things. In the light of that supernal compassion, whatever our position on gays, the gospel's imperative to love, care for, and be identified with their sufferings is unmistakably clear.
In the same way, women are pressing us to acknowledge the sexism and patriarchalism that pervades Scripture and has alienated so many women from the church. The way out, however, is not to deny the sexism in Scripture, but to develop an interpretive theory that judges even Scripture in the light of the revelation in Jesus. What Jesus gives us is a critique of domination in all its forms, a critique that can be turned on the Bible itself. The Bible thus contains the principles of its own correction. We are freed from bibliolatry, the worship of the Bible. It is restored to its proper place as witness to the Word of God. And that word is a Person, not a book.
With the interpretive grid provided by a critique of domination, we are able to filter out the sexism, patriarchalism, violence, and homophobia that are very much a part of the Bible, thus liberating it to reveal to us in fresh ways the inbreaking, in our time, of God's domination-free order.
About the Author
Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.
His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.
He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.
Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quaker meeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.
Thursday, July 28, 2011
World Famous Evangelical Leader, John Stott Dies Aged 90
Evangelical Christian leaders from around the world are mourning the death of evangelical figure John Stott, who died Wednesday at the age of 90.
Stott, known for shaping 20th century evangelicalism through his writing and preaching, died 3:15 p.m. in his retirement home at St. Barnabas College, located 30 miles away from London. He was surrounded by his longtime secretary Frances Whitehead and close friends who read Scriptures and listened to Handel's "Messiah" when he passed.
An Anglican theologian from the U.K., Stott was the chief architect of the 1974 Lausanne Covenant and the author of over 50 Christian books in which he took complex theology and explained it in a way lay people could understand. One of his most popular books was Basic Christianity (1958), which has been translated into more than 60 languages, according to Christian book publisher InterVarsity Press. He has also influenced millions of Christians through other well-known titles including Christ the Controversialist (1970), Issues Facing Christians Today (1984) and the one he always considered his best: The Cross of Christ (1986).
In 2005, Stott was featured in TIME magazine as one of the world's "100 Most Influential People."
Despite his wide influence on the evangelical faith, many fondly knew him as "Uncle John."
When news broke of his death, evangelical leaders immediately posted statements to mourn and honor Stott as a beloved mentor and one of the greatest evangelical thinkers of his time.
Like us on Facebook
"The evangelical world has lost one of its greatest spokesmen," famed U.S. evangelist Billy Graham said in a statement.
"I have lost one of my close personal friends and advisors. I look forward to seeing him again when I go to Heaven."
Graham helped organize the international meeting that unveiled the Lausanne Covenant, a historic document that served as a manifesto for Christian evangelism worldwide. When he heard of Stott's death from his assistant, Graham shed tears and was speechless, his grandson Tullian Tchividjian said via Twitter.
California megachurch pastor Rick Warren called Stott one of his "closest mentors."
"I flew to the UK recently just to pray for him &sit by his bed. What a giant!" the Saddleback Church pastor tweeted.
Dr. Geoff Tunnicliffe, secretary general of the World Evangelical Alliance, the largest global body of evangelicals, said he was personally impacted by Stott's teachings.
“Uncle John, was a great influence in my own theological development. His commitment to biblical orthodoxy, global mission and unity in the body of Christ were foundational in my own spiritual journey,” said Tunnicliffe in a statement.
Stott was the primary author of the Preamble to the 1951 constitution of the WEA, which today represents 600 million evangelicals in 128 countries. In the document, Stott provided a biblical framework and the three primary purposes for the existence of the WEA.
A major legacy that Stott left to the world church is the Langham Partnership International and its U.S. chapter John Stott Ministries. The organization trains preachers, funds doctoral education for evangelical thinkers and provides evangelical books to pastors around the world.
Chris Wright, international director of Langham Partnership International, issued a statement on the John Stott Memorial website celebrating the preacher's Christ-like character.
"Like Moses, he was one of the greatest leaders God has given to his people, and yet at the same time, one of the humblest men on the face of the earth. He was, for all of us who knew him, a walking embodiment of the simple beauty of Jesus, whom he loved above all else," wrote Wright.
Lausanne Movement executive chair S. Douglas Birdsall and international director Lindsay Brown said in a joint statement:
"We are saddened by his departure, but strengthened with the knowledge that his great confidence and his lifelong hope in Christ has now been made real to him, and his life’s work has been vindicated."
They noted that Stott's "greatest contribution was to articulate clearly and to defend robustly the evangelical faith which he always understood to be biblical faith, grounded in the New Testament."
Stott, known for shaping 20th century evangelicalism through his writing and preaching, died 3:15 p.m. in his retirement home at St. Barnabas College, located 30 miles away from London. He was surrounded by his longtime secretary Frances Whitehead and close friends who read Scriptures and listened to Handel's "Messiah" when he passed.
An Anglican theologian from the U.K., Stott was the chief architect of the 1974 Lausanne Covenant and the author of over 50 Christian books in which he took complex theology and explained it in a way lay people could understand. One of his most popular books was Basic Christianity (1958), which has been translated into more than 60 languages, according to Christian book publisher InterVarsity Press. He has also influenced millions of Christians through other well-known titles including Christ the Controversialist (1970), Issues Facing Christians Today (1984) and the one he always considered his best: The Cross of Christ (1986).
In 2005, Stott was featured in TIME magazine as one of the world's "100 Most Influential People."
Despite his wide influence on the evangelical faith, many fondly knew him as "Uncle John."
When news broke of his death, evangelical leaders immediately posted statements to mourn and honor Stott as a beloved mentor and one of the greatest evangelical thinkers of his time.
Like us on Facebook
"The evangelical world has lost one of its greatest spokesmen," famed U.S. evangelist Billy Graham said in a statement.
"I have lost one of my close personal friends and advisors. I look forward to seeing him again when I go to Heaven."
Graham helped organize the international meeting that unveiled the Lausanne Covenant, a historic document that served as a manifesto for Christian evangelism worldwide. When he heard of Stott's death from his assistant, Graham shed tears and was speechless, his grandson Tullian Tchividjian said via Twitter.
California megachurch pastor Rick Warren called Stott one of his "closest mentors."
"I flew to the UK recently just to pray for him &sit by his bed. What a giant!" the Saddleback Church pastor tweeted.
Dr. Geoff Tunnicliffe, secretary general of the World Evangelical Alliance, the largest global body of evangelicals, said he was personally impacted by Stott's teachings.
“Uncle John, was a great influence in my own theological development. His commitment to biblical orthodoxy, global mission and unity in the body of Christ were foundational in my own spiritual journey,” said Tunnicliffe in a statement.
Stott was the primary author of the Preamble to the 1951 constitution of the WEA, which today represents 600 million evangelicals in 128 countries. In the document, Stott provided a biblical framework and the three primary purposes for the existence of the WEA.
A major legacy that Stott left to the world church is the Langham Partnership International and its U.S. chapter John Stott Ministries. The organization trains preachers, funds doctoral education for evangelical thinkers and provides evangelical books to pastors around the world.
Chris Wright, international director of Langham Partnership International, issued a statement on the John Stott Memorial website celebrating the preacher's Christ-like character.
"Like Moses, he was one of the greatest leaders God has given to his people, and yet at the same time, one of the humblest men on the face of the earth. He was, for all of us who knew him, a walking embodiment of the simple beauty of Jesus, whom he loved above all else," wrote Wright.
Lausanne Movement executive chair S. Douglas Birdsall and international director Lindsay Brown said in a joint statement:
"We are saddened by his departure, but strengthened with the knowledge that his great confidence and his lifelong hope in Christ has now been made real to him, and his life’s work has been vindicated."
They noted that Stott's "greatest contribution was to articulate clearly and to defend robustly the evangelical faith which he always understood to be biblical faith, grounded in the New Testament."
Homosexuality and the Bible Part -2-
Hebrew Sexual Mores
Nevertheless, the Bible quite clearly takes a negative view of homosexual activity, in those few instances where it is mentioned at all. But this conclusion does not solve the problem of how we are to interpret Scripture today. For there are other sexual attitudes, practices and restrictions which are normative in Scripture but which we no longer accept as normative:
1. Old Testament law strictly forbids sexual intercourse during the seven days of the menstrual period (Lev. 18:19; 15:19-24), and anyone in violation was to be "extirpated" or "cut off from their people" (kareth, Lev. 18:29, a term referring to execution by stoning, burning, strangling, or to flogging or expulsion; Lev. 15:24 omits this penalty). Today many people on occasion have intercourse during menstruation and think nothing of it. Should they be "extirpated"? The Bible says they should.
2. The punishment for adultery was death by stoning for both the man and the woman (Deut. 22:22), but here adultery is defined by the marital status of the woman. In the Old Testament, a man could not commit adultery against his own wife; he could only commit adultery against another man by sexually using the other's wife. And a bride who is found not to be a virgin is to be stoned to death (Deut. 22:13-21), but male virginity at marriage is never even mentioned. It is one of the curiosities of the current debate on sexuality that adultery, which creates far more social havoc, is considered less "sinful" than homosexual activity. Perhaps this is because there are far more adulterers in our churches. Yet no one, to my knowledge, is calling for their stoning, despite the clear command of Scripture. And we ordain adulterers.
3. Nudity, the characteristic of paradise, was regarded in Judaism as reprehensible (2 Sam. 6:20; 10:4; Isa. 20:2-4; 47:3). When one of Noah's sons beheld his father naked, he was cursed (Gen. 9:20-27). To a great extent this nudity taboo probably even inhibited the sexual intimacy of husbands and wives (this is still true of a surprising number of people reared in the Judeo-Christian tradition). We may not be prepared for nude beaches, but are we prepared to regard nudity in the locker room or at the old swimming hole or in the privacy of one's home as an accursed sin? The Bible does.
4. Polygamy (many wives) and concubinage (a woman living with a man to whom she is not married) were
regularly practiced in the Old Testament. Neither is ever condemned by the New Testament (with the questionable exceptions of 1 Tim. 3:2, 12 and Titus 1:6). Jesus' teaching about marital union in Mark 10:6-8 is no exception, since he quotes Gen. 2:24 as his authority (the man and the woman will become "one flesh"), and this text was never understood in Israel as excluding polygamy. A man could become "one flesh" with more than one woman, through the act of sexual intercourse. We know from Jewish sources that polygamy continued to be practiced within Judaism for centuries following the New Testament period. So if the Bible allowed polygamy and concubinage, why don't we?
5. A form of polygamy was the levirate marriage. When a married man in Israel died childless, his widow was to have intercourse with each of his brothers in turn until she bore him a male heir. Jesus mentions this custom without criticism (Mark 12:18-27 par.). I am not aware of any Christians who still obey this unambiguous commandment of Scripture. Why is this law ignored, and the one against homosexual behavior preserved?
6. The Old Testament nowhere explicitly prohibits sexual relations between unmarried consenting heterosexual adults, as long as the woman's economic value (bride price) is not compromised, that is to say, as long as she is not a virgin. There are poems in the Song of Songs that eulogize a love affair between two unmarried persons, though commentators have often conspired to cover up the fact with heavy layers of allegorical interpretation. In various parts of the Christian world, quite different attitudes have prevailed about sexual intercourse before marriage. In some Christian communities, proof of fertility (that is, pregnancy) was required for marriage. This was especially the case in farming areas where the inability to produce children-workers could mean economic hardship. Today, many single adults, the widowed, and the divorced are reverting to "biblical" practice, while others believe that sexual intercourse belongs only within marriage. Both views are Scriptural. Which is right?
7. The Bible virtually lacks terms for the sexual organs, being content with such euphemisms as "foot" or "thigh" for the genitals, and using other euphemisms to describe coitus, such as "he knew her." Today most of us regard such language as "puritanical" and contrary to a proper regard for the goodness of creation. In short, we don't follow Biblical practice.
8. Semen and menstrual blood rendered all who touched them unclean (Lev. 15:16-24). Intercourse rendered one unclean until sundown; menstruation rendered the woman unclean for seven days. Today most people would regard semen and menstrual fluid as completely natural and only at times "messy," not "unclean."
9. Social regulations regarding adultery, incest, rape and prostitution are, in the Old Testament, determined largely by considerations of the males' property rights over women. Prostitution was considered quite natural and necessary as a safeguard of the virginity of the unmarried and the property rights of husbands (Gen. 38:12-19; Josh. 2:1-7). A man was not guilty of sin for visiting a prostitute, though the prostitute herself was regarded as a sinner. Paul must appeal to reason in attacking prostitution (1 Cor. 6:12-20); he cannot lump it in the category of adultery (vs. 9).
Today we are moving, with great social turbulence and at a high but necessary cost, toward a more equitable, non-patriarchal set of social arrangements in which women are no longer regarded as the chattel of men. We are also trying to move beyond the double standard. Love, fidelity and mutual respect replace property rights. We have, as yet, made very little progress in changing the double standard in regard to prostitution. As we leave behind patriarchal gender relations, what will we do with the patriarchalism in the Bible?
10. Jews were supposed to practice endogamy--that is, marriage within the twelve tribes of Israel. Until recently a similar rule prevailed in the American South, in laws against interracial marriage (miscegenation). We have witnessed, within the lifetime of many of us, the nonviolent struggle to nullify state laws against intermarriage and the gradual change in social attitudes toward interracial relationships. Sexual mores can alter quite radically even in a single lifetime.
11. The law of Moses allowed for divorce (Deut. 24:1-4); Jesus categorically forbids it (Mark 10:1-12; Matt. 19:9 softens his severity). Yet many Christians, in clear violation of a command of Jesus, have been divorced. Why, then, do some of these very people consider themselves eligible for baptism, church membership, communion, and ordination, but not homosexuals? What makes the one so much greater a sin than the other, especially considering the fact that Jesus never even mentioned homosexuality but explicitly condemned divorce? Yet we ordain divorcees. Why not homosexuals?
12. The Old Testament regarded celibacy as abnormal, and 1 Tim. 4:1-3 calls compulsory celibacy a heresy. Yet the Catholic Church has made it mandatory for priests and nuns. Some Christian ethicists demand celibacy of homosexuals, whether they have a vocation for celibacy or not. But this legislates celibacy by category, not by divine calling. Others argue that since God made men and women for each other in order to be fruitful and multiply, homosexuals reject God's intent in creation. But this would mean that childless couples, single persons, priests and nuns would be in violation of God's intention in their creation. Those who argue thus must explain why the apostle Paul never married. And are they prepared to charge Jesus with violating the will of God by remaining single?
Certainly heterosexual marriage is normal, else the race would die out. But it is not normative. God can bless the world through people who are married and through people who are single, and it is false to generalize from the marriage of most people to the marriage of everyone. In 1 Cor. 7:7 Paul goes so far as to call marriage a "charisma," or divine gift, to which not everyone is called. He preferred that people remain as he was--unmarried. In an age of overpopulation, perhaps a gay orientation is especially sound ecologically!
13. In many other ways we have developed different norms from those explicitly laid down by the Bible. For example, "If men get into a fight with one another, and the wife of one intervenes to rescue her husband from the grip of his opponent by reaching out and seizing his genitals, you shall cut off her hand; show no pity" (Deut. 25:11f.). We, on the contrary, might very well applaud her for trying to save her husband's life!
14. The Old and New Testaments both regarded slavery as normal and nowhere categorically condemned it. Part of that heritage was the use of female slaves, concubines and captives as sexual toys, breeding machines, or involuntary wives by their male owners, which 2 Sam. 5:13, Judges 19-21 and Num. 31:18 permitted--and as many American slave owners did some 150 years ago, citing these and numerous other Scripture passages as their justification.
About the Author
Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.
His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.
He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.
Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quakermeeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
Homosexuality and the Bible Part -1-
Sexual issues are tearing our churches apart today as never before. The issue of homosexuality threatens to fracture whole denominations, as the issue of slavery did a hundred and fifty years ago. We naturally turn to the Bible for guidance, and find ourselves mired in interpretative quicksand. Is the Bible able to speak to our confusion on this issue?
The debate over homosexuality is a remarkable opportunity, because it raises in an especially acute way how we interpret the Bible, not in this case only, but in numerous others as well. The real issue here, then, is not simply homosexuality, but how Scripture informs our lives today.
Some passages that have been advanced as pertinent to the issue of homosexuality are, in fact, irrelevant. One is the attempted gang rape in Sodom (Gen. 19:1-29). That was a case of ostensibly heterosexual males intent on humiliating strangers by treating them "like women," thus demasculinizing them. (This is also the case in a similar account in Judges 19-21.) Their brutal behavior has nothing to do with the problem of whether genuine love expressed between consenting adults of the same sex is legitimate or not. Likewise Deut. 23:17-18 must be pruned from the list, since it most likely refers to a heterosexual prostitute involved in Canaanite fertility rites that have infiltrated Jewish worship; the King James Version inaccurately labeled him a "sodomite."
Several other texts are ambiguous. It is not clear whether 1 Cor. 6:9 and 1 Tim. 1:10 refer to the "passive" and "active" partners in homosexual relationships, or to homosexual and heterosexual male prostitutes. In short, it is unclear whether the issue is homosexuality alone, or promiscuity and "sex-for-hire."
Unequivocal Condemnations
Putting these texts to the side, we are left with three references, all of which unequivocally condemn homosexual behavior. Lev. 18:22 states the principle: "You [masculine] shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination" (NRSV). The second (Lev. 20:13) adds the penalty: "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall be put to death; their blood is upon them."
Such an act was regarded as an "abomination" for several reasons. The Hebrew prescientific understanding was that male semen contained the whole of nascent life. With no knowledge of eggs and ovulation, it was assumed that the woman provided only the incubating space. Hence the spilling of semen for any nonprocreative purpose--in coitus interruptus (Gen. 38:1-11), male homosexual acts, or male masturbation--was considered tantamount to abortion or murder. (Female homosexual acts were consequently not so seriously regarded, and are not mentioned at all in the Old Testament (but see Rom. 1:26). One can appreciate how a tribe struggling to populate a country in which its people were outnumbered would value procreation highly, but such values are rendered questionable in a world facing uncontrolled overpopulation.
In addition, when a man acted like a woman sexually, male dignity was compromised. It was a degradation, not only in regard to himself, but for every other male. The patriarchalism of Hebrew culture shows its hand in the very formulation of the commandment, since no similar stricture was formulated to forbid homosexual acts between females. And the repugnance felt toward homosexuality was not just that it was deemed unnatural but also that it was considered unJewish, representing yet one more incursion of pagan civilization into Jewish life. On top of that is the more universal repugnance heterosexuals tend to feel for acts and orientations foreign to them. (Left-handedness has evoked something of the same response in many cultures.)
Whatever the rationale for their formulation, however, the texts leave no room for maneuvering. Persons committing homosexual acts are to be executed. This is the unambiguous command of Scripture. The meaning is clear: anyone who wishes to base his or her beliefs on the witness of the Old Testament must be completely consistent and demand the death penalty for everyone who performs homosexual acts. (That may seem extreme, but there actually are some Christians urging this very thing today.) It is unlikely that any American court will ever again condemn a
homosexual to death, even though Scripture clearly commands it.
Old Testament texts have to be weighed against the New. Consequently, Paul's unambiguous condemnation of homosexual behavior in Rom. 1:26-27 must be the centerpiece of any discussion.
For this reason God gave them up to degrading passions. Their women exchanged natural intercourse for unnatural, and in the same way also the men, giving up natural intercourse with women, were consumed with passion for one another. Men committed shameless acts with men and received in their own persons the due penalty for their error.
No doubt Paul was unaware of the distinction between sexual orientation, over which one has apparently very little choice, and sexual behavior, over which one does. He seemed to assume that those whom he condemned were heterosexuals who were acting contrary to nature, "leaving," "giving up," or "exchanging" their regular sexual orientation for that which was foreign to them. Paul knew nothing of the modern psychosexual understanding of homosexuals as persons whose orientation is fixed early in life, or perhaps even genetically in some cases. For such persons, having heterosexual relations would be acting contrary to nature, "leaving," "giving up" or "exchanging" their natural sexual orientation for one that was unnatural to them.
In other words, Paul really thought that those whose behavior he condemned were "straight," and that they were behaving in ways that were unnatural to them. Paul believed that everyone was straight. He had no concept of homosexual orientation. The idea was not available in his world. There are people that are genuinely homosexual by nature (whether genetically or as a result of upbringing no one really knows, and it is irrelevant). For such a person it would be acting contrary to nature to have sexual relations with a person of the opposite sex.
Likewise, the relationships Paul describes are heavy with lust; they are not relationships between consenting adults who are committed to each other as faithfully and with as much integrity as any heterosexual couple. That was something Paul simply could not envision. Some people assume today that venereal disease and AIDS are divine punishment for homosexual behavior; we know it as a risk involved in promiscuity of every stripe, homosexual and heterosexual. In fact, the vast majority of people with AIDS the world around are heterosexuals. We can scarcely label AIDS a divine punishment, since nonpromiscuous lesbians are at almost no risk.
And Paul believes that homosexual behavior is contrary to nature, whereas we have learned that it is manifested by a wide variety of species, especially (but not solely) under the pressure of overpopulation. It would appear then to be a quite natural mechanism for preserving species. We cannot, of course, decide human ethical conduct solely on the basis of animal behavior or the human sciences, but Paul here is arguing from nature, as he himself says, and new knowledge of what is "natural" is therefore relevant to the case.
About the Author
Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.
His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.
He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.
Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quaker meeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.
The debate over homosexuality is a remarkable opportunity, because it raises in an especially acute way how we interpret the Bible, not in this case only, but in numerous others as well. The real issue here, then, is not simply homosexuality, but how Scripture informs our lives today.
Some passages that have been advanced as pertinent to the issue of homosexuality are, in fact, irrelevant. One is the attempted gang rape in Sodom (Gen. 19:1-29). That was a case of ostensibly heterosexual males intent on humiliating strangers by treating them "like women," thus demasculinizing them. (This is also the case in a similar account in Judges 19-21.) Their brutal behavior has nothing to do with the problem of whether genuine love expressed between consenting adults of the same sex is legitimate or not. Likewise Deut. 23:17-18 must be pruned from the list, since it most likely refers to a heterosexual prostitute involved in Canaanite fertility rites that have infiltrated Jewish worship; the King James Version inaccurately labeled him a "sodomite."
Several other texts are ambiguous. It is not clear whether 1 Cor. 6:9 and 1 Tim. 1:10 refer to the "passive" and "active" partners in homosexual relationships, or to homosexual and heterosexual male prostitutes. In short, it is unclear whether the issue is homosexuality alone, or promiscuity and "sex-for-hire."
Unequivocal Condemnations
Putting these texts to the side, we are left with three references, all of which unequivocally condemn homosexual behavior. Lev. 18:22 states the principle: "You [masculine] shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination" (NRSV). The second (Lev. 20:13) adds the penalty: "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall be put to death; their blood is upon them."
Such an act was regarded as an "abomination" for several reasons. The Hebrew prescientific understanding was that male semen contained the whole of nascent life. With no knowledge of eggs and ovulation, it was assumed that the woman provided only the incubating space. Hence the spilling of semen for any nonprocreative purpose--in coitus interruptus (Gen. 38:1-11), male homosexual acts, or male masturbation--was considered tantamount to abortion or murder. (Female homosexual acts were consequently not so seriously regarded, and are not mentioned at all in the Old Testament (but see Rom. 1:26). One can appreciate how a tribe struggling to populate a country in which its people were outnumbered would value procreation highly, but such values are rendered questionable in a world facing uncontrolled overpopulation.
In addition, when a man acted like a woman sexually, male dignity was compromised. It was a degradation, not only in regard to himself, but for every other male. The patriarchalism of Hebrew culture shows its hand in the very formulation of the commandment, since no similar stricture was formulated to forbid homosexual acts between females. And the repugnance felt toward homosexuality was not just that it was deemed unnatural but also that it was considered unJewish, representing yet one more incursion of pagan civilization into Jewish life. On top of that is the more universal repugnance heterosexuals tend to feel for acts and orientations foreign to them. (Left-handedness has evoked something of the same response in many cultures.)
Whatever the rationale for their formulation, however, the texts leave no room for maneuvering. Persons committing homosexual acts are to be executed. This is the unambiguous command of Scripture. The meaning is clear: anyone who wishes to base his or her beliefs on the witness of the Old Testament must be completely consistent and demand the death penalty for everyone who performs homosexual acts. (That may seem extreme, but there actually are some Christians urging this very thing today.) It is unlikely that any American court will ever again condemn a
homosexual to death, even though Scripture clearly commands it.
Old Testament texts have to be weighed against the New. Consequently, Paul's unambiguous condemnation of homosexual behavior in Rom. 1:26-27 must be the centerpiece of any discussion.
For this reason God gave them up to degrading passions. Their women exchanged natural intercourse for unnatural, and in the same way also the men, giving up natural intercourse with women, were consumed with passion for one another. Men committed shameless acts with men and received in their own persons the due penalty for their error.
No doubt Paul was unaware of the distinction between sexual orientation, over which one has apparently very little choice, and sexual behavior, over which one does. He seemed to assume that those whom he condemned were heterosexuals who were acting contrary to nature, "leaving," "giving up," or "exchanging" their regular sexual orientation for that which was foreign to them. Paul knew nothing of the modern psychosexual understanding of homosexuals as persons whose orientation is fixed early in life, or perhaps even genetically in some cases. For such persons, having heterosexual relations would be acting contrary to nature, "leaving," "giving up" or "exchanging" their natural sexual orientation for one that was unnatural to them.
In other words, Paul really thought that those whose behavior he condemned were "straight," and that they were behaving in ways that were unnatural to them. Paul believed that everyone was straight. He had no concept of homosexual orientation. The idea was not available in his world. There are people that are genuinely homosexual by nature (whether genetically or as a result of upbringing no one really knows, and it is irrelevant). For such a person it would be acting contrary to nature to have sexual relations with a person of the opposite sex.
Likewise, the relationships Paul describes are heavy with lust; they are not relationships between consenting adults who are committed to each other as faithfully and with as much integrity as any heterosexual couple. That was something Paul simply could not envision. Some people assume today that venereal disease and AIDS are divine punishment for homosexual behavior; we know it as a risk involved in promiscuity of every stripe, homosexual and heterosexual. In fact, the vast majority of people with AIDS the world around are heterosexuals. We can scarcely label AIDS a divine punishment, since nonpromiscuous lesbians are at almost no risk.
And Paul believes that homosexual behavior is contrary to nature, whereas we have learned that it is manifested by a wide variety of species, especially (but not solely) under the pressure of overpopulation. It would appear then to be a quite natural mechanism for preserving species. We cannot, of course, decide human ethical conduct solely on the basis of animal behavior or the human sciences, but Paul here is arguing from nature, as he himself says, and new knowledge of what is "natural" is therefore relevant to the case.
About the Author
Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.
His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.
He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.
Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quaker meeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.
Monday, July 25, 2011
Clothes Make the (Wo)Man—Or Do They? Conclusion
The prophet, Samuel, was sent to Bethlehem, to anoint the man who would be King Saul’s successor. This man would be from the family of Jesse. Samuel’s arrival in town made the leaders nervous, because they thought it was a sign of something negative. Of course, Samuel was also nervous; if King Saul found out that he was on a mission to anoint the king’s successor, he could lose his life. So, Samuel reassured the leaders, organized a feast, and invited the whole town. When Jesse and his sons arrived, the prophet spotted Eliab and was convinced that he was the chosen one, “…Samuel took one look at Eliab and thought, “Here he is! God’s anointed!” (1 Sam. 16:6) However, God reprimanded Samuel, saying, “Looks aren’t everything. Don’t be impressed with his looks and his stature. I’ve already eliminated him. God judges persons differently than humans do. Men and women look at the face; God looks into the heart,” (1 Sam. 16:7). Jesse introduced seven sons to Samuel, and each time Samuel noted that the male before him was not the one God had chosen. Finally, Samuel actually had to ask if there were any more sons. Jesse reluctantly replied, “Well, yes, there’s the runt. But he’s tending the sheep,” (1 Sam. 16: 10-11). Samuel refused to budge until David, the youngest, was presented to him. When David arrived, Samuel was even more surprised when God confirmed, “Up on your feet! Anoint him! This is the one!” The “runt”, the unimpressive son, the least likely was the one God had chosen to be the next king of Israel? If Samuel had not been tuned into God, he would have done what so many are prone to do: judge a book by its cover.
Yet Scripture makes it clear that God looks much deeper. Uniform wearing is one of the outward appearances that people in the Army engage in judging. Yet, at a time when former Army Officers are sorting through their hurts and confusions, the last thing they need is to have their identity as individuals and as God’s servants attacked.
Both men and women Salvationists experience identity-ties to their Army uniforms; and these ties are even stronger for those whom have served as Army Officers, because they have chosen to spend their lives in full-time service to others. So, former Army Officers face additional challenges as they rebuild their lives. Part of the process of rebuilding former Officers’ lives includes separating their identity as Army Officers from their identity as children of the King.
Ultimately, the best garment we can be clothed in—for whatever service and ministry He calls us to—is the garment of Christ’s righteousness. This garment is also visible in a society that is geared to “looking out for number one”, and it definitely marks us as set aside for God’s service. Therefore, be encouraged: whether or not you continue to wear the Army’s uniform, take to heart God’s words, “Looks aren’t everything. Don’t be impressed with…looks and… stature.…God judges persons differently than humans do. Men and women look at the face; God looks into the heart,” (1 Sam. 16: 7). Becoming former Army Officers involves laying aside Officers’ uniforms, laying aside a role that no longer fits. However, the call to service expands beyond the confines and constraints of the Army. So, whatever new paths former Army Officers pursue, my prayer is that they (we) remember the words of David in Psalm 139: “You [God] both precede and follow me, and place Your hand of blessing on my head,” (vs. 5, Living Bible).
Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk,
Guardians of the Truth, ‘85,
Former SA Officer
Canada and Bermuda
Yet Scripture makes it clear that God looks much deeper. Uniform wearing is one of the outward appearances that people in the Army engage in judging. Yet, at a time when former Army Officers are sorting through their hurts and confusions, the last thing they need is to have their identity as individuals and as God’s servants attacked.
Both men and women Salvationists experience identity-ties to their Army uniforms; and these ties are even stronger for those whom have served as Army Officers, because they have chosen to spend their lives in full-time service to others. So, former Army Officers face additional challenges as they rebuild their lives. Part of the process of rebuilding former Officers’ lives includes separating their identity as Army Officers from their identity as children of the King.
Ultimately, the best garment we can be clothed in—for whatever service and ministry He calls us to—is the garment of Christ’s righteousness. This garment is also visible in a society that is geared to “looking out for number one”, and it definitely marks us as set aside for God’s service. Therefore, be encouraged: whether or not you continue to wear the Army’s uniform, take to heart God’s words, “Looks aren’t everything. Don’t be impressed with…looks and… stature.…God judges persons differently than humans do. Men and women look at the face; God looks into the heart,” (1 Sam. 16: 7). Becoming former Army Officers involves laying aside Officers’ uniforms, laying aside a role that no longer fits. However, the call to service expands beyond the confines and constraints of the Army. So, whatever new paths former Army Officers pursue, my prayer is that they (we) remember the words of David in Psalm 139: “You [God] both precede and follow me, and place Your hand of blessing on my head,” (vs. 5, Living Bible).
Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk,
Guardians of the Truth, ‘85,
Former SA Officer
Canada and Bermuda
Friday, July 22, 2011
Clothes Make the (Wo)Man—Or Do They? Part 2
Part two
I’ve contemplated these questions and have reflected upon the posts in the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship private FaceBook discussion site, where another related question has been raised, “As formers in The Salvation Army what does that make us in the real world?” As I have been reading in Exodus during the past several weeks, I recalled Mark Twain’s quote, “Clothes make the man”. The meaning of Twain’s quotation was certainly true for Aaron, his sons, and those who later became priests. Exodus 28 details the precision, down to the minutest details, with which the priestly garments were to be constructed and worn. These special clothing requirements for priests were to make them visible before the Israelites (i.e., it made it easy for the people to identify which individuals were priests), and to set the wearers apart as holy for God’s service. God commanded Moses to follow His directions for the construction of the priestly vestments:
Get your brother Aaron and his sons from among the Israelites to serve Me as priests: Aaron and his sons Nadab, Abihu, Eleazar, and Ithamar. Make sacred vestments for your brother to symbolize glory and beauty. Consult with the skilled craftsmen, those whom I have gifted in this work, and arrange for them to make Aaron’s vestments, to set him apart as holy, to act as priest for me.
(Ex. 28: 1ff).
So, the 28th chapter of Exodus notes that there are two factors that are associated with the specialized priestly vestments—the high visibility for easy identification and the indication that these individuals were set apart for God’s service. Isn’t this also true of uniform-wearing? These two components (i.e., easy identification and service) are true of the military; and they are certainly true of the Army, which patterns itself after military constructs. With all this emphasis on Army uniform-wearing and the aspects of the individual’s identity that become linked with it, how do former Officers gain a different perspective, one that allows for some peace of mind?
Examining the Bible’s assertion about outward appearances may provide some insight into the significance of inner identification ties to wearing the Army uniform. Throughout history, there have been standards of clothing set out for many vocations and jobs (e.g., kings, priests, military personnel, medical professionals, and even for those in academia). For instance, recall the Biblical account in 1 Samuel 17 of the giant Goliath taunting the Israelites with defeat and slavery. David requested an audience with King Saul, provided the king a summary of the wild animals he had killed while watching his father’s sheep, and asserted that God would help David kill Goliath. Saul finally agreed to let David confront Goliath, but he insisted that David could not do so until he had been “properly outfitted” with the king’s own armour. However, the weight of the armour was too heavy, and David couldn’t move in it. So, he took it off, because it didn’t fit him. The key here is that David couldn’t comfortably wear somebody else’s uniform. We can also see a metaphor here: David couldn’t comfortably wear the king’s armour, which came with certain expectations of conduct for the one wearing it. David could not adopt somebody else’s expectations for how he should conduct himself and what he should wear when facing the giant. So, David took off Saul’s expectations, and he was free, then, to successfully follow God’s guidance.
David’s case illustrates the custom of taking off clothes that no longer fit. Clothes that are outgrown are not usually held onto for sentimental reasons, but are dispensed with (e.g., via garage sales or donations to local charities). This custom also becomes a metaphor for our lives—we take off things that no longer ‘fit’, we leave them behind and move forward in our lives. I believe this also applies to former Officers’ uniforms: we leave them behind when they no longer fit our lives. Even military personnel take off their uniforms when the uniforms no longer “fit” them, in a metaphorical sense (e.g., because the personnel have completed their tour of duty, they have resigned, they have been given a medical leave, or they have been dishonourably discharged). However, laying aside a military uniform doesn’t diminish the soldier. Boot camp and training gives soldiers confidence, self-discipline, tools and skills that may be used in a variety of life-situations, and these are the strengths that military personnel use to rebuild their lives when they step away from that avenue of service. This also applies to Army Officers whom leave Officership for a myriad of reasons: they take off their Officer uniforms, which no longer “fit”, because their roles have changed. However, their basic training, intensive instruction in Training College, and experience in the field, have provided leadership training, confidence, self-discipline, and tools and skills that may be used in a variety of life circumstances, and they use these strong points to rebuild their lives.
Many former Officers have taken their skills, talents and training back to the local corps settings, where they faithfully serve and provide leadership and support through diverse ministries. We also know that a number of former Officers have transferred their ordination to other denominations, where they serve as ministers. Still others have cut ties with the Army, yet they have taken their gifts and experiences into other denominations and avenues of ministry. So, while former Army Officers’ uniforms may be laid aside, none of their gifts, talents, skills, and usefulness for God’s service is lost. So, it becomes even more important to remember God’s perspective and position on who He deems fit for service. We can gain insight into how God views former Officers by probing the Scriptural account of David’s anointing (to be king of Israel) in 1 Samuel, chapter 16.
Part two of three
__________
Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk,
Guardians of the Truth, ‘85,
Former SA Officer
Canada and Bermuda
I’ve contemplated these questions and have reflected upon the posts in the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship private FaceBook discussion site, where another related question has been raised, “As formers in The Salvation Army what does that make us in the real world?” As I have been reading in Exodus during the past several weeks, I recalled Mark Twain’s quote, “Clothes make the man”. The meaning of Twain’s quotation was certainly true for Aaron, his sons, and those who later became priests. Exodus 28 details the precision, down to the minutest details, with which the priestly garments were to be constructed and worn. These special clothing requirements for priests were to make them visible before the Israelites (i.e., it made it easy for the people to identify which individuals were priests), and to set the wearers apart as holy for God’s service. God commanded Moses to follow His directions for the construction of the priestly vestments:
Get your brother Aaron and his sons from among the Israelites to serve Me as priests: Aaron and his sons Nadab, Abihu, Eleazar, and Ithamar. Make sacred vestments for your brother to symbolize glory and beauty. Consult with the skilled craftsmen, those whom I have gifted in this work, and arrange for them to make Aaron’s vestments, to set him apart as holy, to act as priest for me.
(Ex. 28: 1ff).
So, the 28th chapter of Exodus notes that there are two factors that are associated with the specialized priestly vestments—the high visibility for easy identification and the indication that these individuals were set apart for God’s service. Isn’t this also true of uniform-wearing? These two components (i.e., easy identification and service) are true of the military; and they are certainly true of the Army, which patterns itself after military constructs. With all this emphasis on Army uniform-wearing and the aspects of the individual’s identity that become linked with it, how do former Officers gain a different perspective, one that allows for some peace of mind?
Examining the Bible’s assertion about outward appearances may provide some insight into the significance of inner identification ties to wearing the Army uniform. Throughout history, there have been standards of clothing set out for many vocations and jobs (e.g., kings, priests, military personnel, medical professionals, and even for those in academia). For instance, recall the Biblical account in 1 Samuel 17 of the giant Goliath taunting the Israelites with defeat and slavery. David requested an audience with King Saul, provided the king a summary of the wild animals he had killed while watching his father’s sheep, and asserted that God would help David kill Goliath. Saul finally agreed to let David confront Goliath, but he insisted that David could not do so until he had been “properly outfitted” with the king’s own armour. However, the weight of the armour was too heavy, and David couldn’t move in it. So, he took it off, because it didn’t fit him. The key here is that David couldn’t comfortably wear somebody else’s uniform. We can also see a metaphor here: David couldn’t comfortably wear the king’s armour, which came with certain expectations of conduct for the one wearing it. David could not adopt somebody else’s expectations for how he should conduct himself and what he should wear when facing the giant. So, David took off Saul’s expectations, and he was free, then, to successfully follow God’s guidance.
David’s case illustrates the custom of taking off clothes that no longer fit. Clothes that are outgrown are not usually held onto for sentimental reasons, but are dispensed with (e.g., via garage sales or donations to local charities). This custom also becomes a metaphor for our lives—we take off things that no longer ‘fit’, we leave them behind and move forward in our lives. I believe this also applies to former Officers’ uniforms: we leave them behind when they no longer fit our lives. Even military personnel take off their uniforms when the uniforms no longer “fit” them, in a metaphorical sense (e.g., because the personnel have completed their tour of duty, they have resigned, they have been given a medical leave, or they have been dishonourably discharged). However, laying aside a military uniform doesn’t diminish the soldier. Boot camp and training gives soldiers confidence, self-discipline, tools and skills that may be used in a variety of life-situations, and these are the strengths that military personnel use to rebuild their lives when they step away from that avenue of service. This also applies to Army Officers whom leave Officership for a myriad of reasons: they take off their Officer uniforms, which no longer “fit”, because their roles have changed. However, their basic training, intensive instruction in Training College, and experience in the field, have provided leadership training, confidence, self-discipline, and tools and skills that may be used in a variety of life circumstances, and they use these strong points to rebuild their lives.
Many former Officers have taken their skills, talents and training back to the local corps settings, where they faithfully serve and provide leadership and support through diverse ministries. We also know that a number of former Officers have transferred their ordination to other denominations, where they serve as ministers. Still others have cut ties with the Army, yet they have taken their gifts and experiences into other denominations and avenues of ministry. So, while former Army Officers’ uniforms may be laid aside, none of their gifts, talents, skills, and usefulness for God’s service is lost. So, it becomes even more important to remember God’s perspective and position on who He deems fit for service. We can gain insight into how God views former Officers by probing the Scriptural account of David’s anointing (to be king of Israel) in 1 Samuel, chapter 16.
Part two of three
__________
Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk,
Guardians of the Truth, ‘85,
Former SA Officer
Canada and Bermuda
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Clothes Make the (Wo)Man—Or Do They? Part 1
(All Scripture quotes are from The Message, unless otherwise noted.)
Most of us are familiar with the first part of Mark Twain’s expression, “Clothes Make the Man.” However, the second part is rarely quoted; “Naked people have little or no influence on society.” Fashion-minded people certainly ascribe to the concept in this quotation, which is why there is great emphasis on what Hollywood stars are wearing and which designers’ clothing is being show-cased by these stars, along with the liberal use of references to Red Carpet fashion, the Fashion Police, “power suits”, and the like. Plus, make-over shows are very popular—we wait to see the transformation from the “before” to the “after” photos. The fashion industry definitely places an emphasis on what trends are in, which are out, which are classic, which are retro, etc. So, we live in a society that makes much to-do about the idea that “clothes make the man (or the woman)”.
The prominence given to fashion is not new; the same emphasis has been noted throughout history, as far back as Biblical times. For example, the common people, friars and monks wore the simplest of garments in contrast to the kings and queens, and their courts, which were filled with folks whom were set apart, identifiable by their richer and finer clothing. Even the military was clearly recognized by its distinctive garb. Throughout the ages, this focus on fashion has also been true in the Church, where distinctive clothing as been worn by popes, bishops, priests, and ministers, as well as altar-servers and choirs. Additionally, from its inception, we see that the Salvation Army has also employed the practice of wearing distinguishing clothing in the form of uniforms.
However, the uniform worn by Salvationists is more distinct than the vestments worn in other denominations, because many lay Salvationist people wear it and not just the Army’s leaders. Similar to military uniforms, the Army’s uniform sets it apart from the general population. Moreover, this idea of uniformity begins with prescribed Junior Soldier uniforms; so, from the ages of about seven or eight, children are groomed for the eventual wearing of the Army’s adult uniform. Furthermore, the Army’s uniform is recognized world-wide, especially for its visibility during service to soldiers during the World Wars, its social services in local communities and around the globe, and its service to countries and communities during natural disasters such as floods, tornadoes, and earthquakes.
The highly recognizable Army uniform means that those whom wear it are expected to conduct themselves in a manner that reflects the high standards that are associated with it. With the great emphasis on the Army’s uniform, the question that continues to be raised, including in the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship group on Face Book, is, “What happens when Army Officers leave Officership and are no longer wearing Officers’ uniforms?
The answer to the question of what becomes of former Army Officers’ uniforms may not be as simple as it seems. It is true that some former Army Officers resume fellowship, worship, and service at local corps. If they choose to continue wearing the Army’s uniform, they may do so. However, the Officers’ insignia must be replaced with the trim of Senior Soldiers’ uniforms. And what happens to Officers whom end up parting ways with the Army? In either case, there are challenges, because wearing the Army’s uniform becomes part of Senior Soldiers’ personal identity. These personal identity ties are even greater for Officers, whom have committed their lives to full-time service as pastors.
So, is it any easier for former Army Officers to resume wearing Senior Soldiers’ uniforms than for Officers whom part ways with the Army? Is changing back to Senior Soldiers’ uniforms possibly seen as a “demotion” by the former Officer or by others in Army?
There are many related questions that must be addressed during the post-Officership stage. It is a time of great soul-searching, and many individuals have struggled with questions, such as: “Who am I now that I am no longer an Officer?”; and, “How do I now serve God when I believed that I was called to be an Army Officer, and now—for whatever reason(s), that door is closed?” In the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship forum, we’ve attempted to answer these questions based on our own experiences and struggles to rebuild our lives. Each of us is at a different stage of this process, the process to define our identity apart from Officership, apart from our uniform, and apart from the Army.
Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk,
Guardians of the Truth, ‘85,
Former SA Officer
Canada and Bermuda
Most of us are familiar with the first part of Mark Twain’s expression, “Clothes Make the Man.” However, the second part is rarely quoted; “Naked people have little or no influence on society.” Fashion-minded people certainly ascribe to the concept in this quotation, which is why there is great emphasis on what Hollywood stars are wearing and which designers’ clothing is being show-cased by these stars, along with the liberal use of references to Red Carpet fashion, the Fashion Police, “power suits”, and the like. Plus, make-over shows are very popular—we wait to see the transformation from the “before” to the “after” photos. The fashion industry definitely places an emphasis on what trends are in, which are out, which are classic, which are retro, etc. So, we live in a society that makes much to-do about the idea that “clothes make the man (or the woman)”.
The prominence given to fashion is not new; the same emphasis has been noted throughout history, as far back as Biblical times. For example, the common people, friars and monks wore the simplest of garments in contrast to the kings and queens, and their courts, which were filled with folks whom were set apart, identifiable by their richer and finer clothing. Even the military was clearly recognized by its distinctive garb. Throughout the ages, this focus on fashion has also been true in the Church, where distinctive clothing as been worn by popes, bishops, priests, and ministers, as well as altar-servers and choirs. Additionally, from its inception, we see that the Salvation Army has also employed the practice of wearing distinguishing clothing in the form of uniforms.
However, the uniform worn by Salvationists is more distinct than the vestments worn in other denominations, because many lay Salvationist people wear it and not just the Army’s leaders. Similar to military uniforms, the Army’s uniform sets it apart from the general population. Moreover, this idea of uniformity begins with prescribed Junior Soldier uniforms; so, from the ages of about seven or eight, children are groomed for the eventual wearing of the Army’s adult uniform. Furthermore, the Army’s uniform is recognized world-wide, especially for its visibility during service to soldiers during the World Wars, its social services in local communities and around the globe, and its service to countries and communities during natural disasters such as floods, tornadoes, and earthquakes.
The highly recognizable Army uniform means that those whom wear it are expected to conduct themselves in a manner that reflects the high standards that are associated with it. With the great emphasis on the Army’s uniform, the question that continues to be raised, including in the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship group on Face Book, is, “What happens when Army Officers leave Officership and are no longer wearing Officers’ uniforms?
The answer to the question of what becomes of former Army Officers’ uniforms may not be as simple as it seems. It is true that some former Army Officers resume fellowship, worship, and service at local corps. If they choose to continue wearing the Army’s uniform, they may do so. However, the Officers’ insignia must be replaced with the trim of Senior Soldiers’ uniforms. And what happens to Officers whom end up parting ways with the Army? In either case, there are challenges, because wearing the Army’s uniform becomes part of Senior Soldiers’ personal identity. These personal identity ties are even greater for Officers, whom have committed their lives to full-time service as pastors.
So, is it any easier for former Army Officers to resume wearing Senior Soldiers’ uniforms than for Officers whom part ways with the Army? Is changing back to Senior Soldiers’ uniforms possibly seen as a “demotion” by the former Officer or by others in Army?
There are many related questions that must be addressed during the post-Officership stage. It is a time of great soul-searching, and many individuals have struggled with questions, such as: “Who am I now that I am no longer an Officer?”; and, “How do I now serve God when I believed that I was called to be an Army Officer, and now—for whatever reason(s), that door is closed?” In the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship forum, we’ve attempted to answer these questions based on our own experiences and struggles to rebuild our lives. Each of us is at a different stage of this process, the process to define our identity apart from Officership, apart from our uniform, and apart from the Army.
Elizabeth Hogan Hayduk,
Guardians of the Truth, ‘85,
Former SA Officer
Canada and Bermuda
Sunday, July 17, 2011
THE FREEDOM TO SELECT MY LIFE PARTNER
I’m a married to a loving wife. I’m a white male living in middle class Australia, with two kids, two fish and a cat. I live in an inner city suburb of the largest city in Australia, Sydney. I was born in Australia (Adelaide, no less, but that still counts) and have lived here all of my life. All of those factors combined put me in a position of power. Power I didn’t choose, or fight for, but power I’ve been given nonetheless. Add to that the fact that I am an Officer in The Salvation Army, which as an institution has earned a powerful voice in this country and my position of power is enhanced dramatically.
I don’t have to fight for my voice to be heard. I don’t live on the margins of society, and by and large I’m not prejudiced against, except perhaps that I’m not allowed to become a member at a one of those "women-only" gyms… not that I really want to.
So that means that I need to be careful in the way that I speak. By virtue of who I am and where I’ve been born I need to be careful that my voice does not drown out the voices of those who are not in the same position of power as me. Because I’m male, I need to listen to the voice of women. Because I’m a parent, I need to listen to the voice of my children, but also those who do not have children (for whatever reason). Because I live in the city, I need to listen to the voice of those who live in regional areas. Because I live in a first world country I need to listen to the voice of those who do not. I need to be active in listening first before speaking, simply because my voice is louder than others. I may not necessarily like that, but this is the reality of the distorted world we live in. Some are in positions of power. Most are not. I just happen to be one who in many of life’s arenas has a powerful voice.
I have to be honest and confess that I’m not always good at using my voice wisely. It’s very easy to write a paragraph like the last one, but very difficult to live that way every day. It’s much easier to exploit a position of power than to use it for the benefit of all.
Which brings me to a very contemporary topic at the moment; that being marriage. In particular, whether or not marriage should be reserved exclusively for female and male couples or should legislation be changed to be opened to same-sex relationships.
On Sunday night the Compass program on the ABC aired a discussion on this topic between 6 people of various opinions, chaired by host Geraldine Doogue. For those who don’t know, Compass is a TV program that discusses religious issues. I didn’t see the full episode on Sunday night, but did manage to view it all online here. (The transcript is also available in case it cannot be viewed in other countries).
I found the discussion mostly helpful, with the relevant issues raised and many of the participants being very honest and open about their own experiences. Since Compass is a religious program it is natural that there be clergy present in the discussion. This was fair. It was also good that there were two homosexual people represented, and one father (and self-confessed, former homophobic) of a gay man present at the table. That was necessary and welcomed. I also appreciated the chosen forum – a meal table. This is something I think is worthwhile exploring in any debate. As a side issue, this is a consideration that rarely enters into sacramental theology. If Jesus did institute a participatory and memorial meal as a primary means of Christians retelling his death and resurrection and anticipating his return, then why did he choose a meal? It’s an interesting question, but one for another day. For this program, the meal worked because it acted as a leveller between all the parties involved.
What did concern me, though, was the abuse of power from the one who held the most of it. I don’t think there was an intention to be abusive, but nevertheless it was there. That’s the insipid way that power subtly takes over. I suspect the white, middle-class, heterosexual, married, male minister approached this discussion with every intention of being respectful, but I don’t know that he properly acknowledged that he was the one with the most power at that table and so he needed to be the one that listened better than anyone else. I’m speaking in this specific instance about Rt. Rev. Robert Forsyth, not to “name and shame” him but simply because he was representative of a view that has been most dominant in the church for a long time. I acknowledge that there are personality issues, and many other factors at play here (including how the discussion was edited by the ABC), but his voice was the most dominant one at that table.
And he made it known.
The number of times in this program where Julie McCrossin had to say to Rev Forsyth “let me finish” or “let him finish” on behalf of someone else was really quite disturbing. Furthermore, Prof Dennis Altman remarked (after having been prompted by the host) “I’m finding this very difficult actually to say anything.” Admittedly, there was some humour in his comment, and his exclusion from the discussion wasn’t all Rev Forsyth’s fault, but still I suggest that his comment was representative of how the LBGT community has been made to feel by the church on this and other related issues.
I’m not going to provide my own opinion on same-sex marriage. To be honest, I don’t have one. I’m waiting for the day when I can have an open conversation with homosexual Christians to help form and inform an opinion. Perhaps around a meal table or over a coffee, where I can listen respectfully to their views first. The problem is I don’t really know any homosexual Christians. I know they exist, but I just don’t know where. Shame on me. Shame on the Church for being so opinionated on the “issue of homosexuality” (way to impersonalise the discussion) that we’ve excluded the people themselves from the place where they should be the most included.
Forgive me Lord. Forgive us Lord. God help us to be more loving. God help me to be more loving.
What I do want to suggest, though, is a way potential forward for the church in these sorts of discussion when they arise. Here it is.
Shut up and listen.
Stop speaking over other voices. Stop interrupting. Stop having duelling monologues and actually enter into dialogue with the other voice. Please, just shut up and listen.
I’m not saying “don’t ever talk again about this matter”. That would be completely unproductive. What I am suggesting, though, is that the church has held the power when it comes to marriage for 2000 years and we’ve not been good in the way we’ve used (and abused) that power. We need to realise that we hold the balance of power in this discussion and we should be using it in the same way that Jesus did. Not to exploit it over and against the powerless, but rather to give them a voice. To give them that dignity. To listen to them. To even sit down and have a meal with them. Jesus didn’t “name and shame” people as “tax collectors and sinners”. The Pharisees did a pretty good job at that. Rather, he sat down to eat with them as an equal. Something tells me that the church could learn something from Jesus’ approach. Maybe, just maybe, we might learn what it means to be an inclusive community first, rather than a dogmatic one. Perhaps we might just be able to be a place that everyone, including the LBGT community, looks at and says “look how they love one another – they must be Christians.” (John 13:34-35)
Maybe.
Just maybe.
Adam Couchman
Bexley North, NSW, Australia
I am a Salvation Army Officer, living in Sydney, Australia. I am interested in discussing issues related to Christian faith and practice. You can contact me at adam@setapartinchrist.com
I don’t have to fight for my voice to be heard. I don’t live on the margins of society, and by and large I’m not prejudiced against, except perhaps that I’m not allowed to become a member at a one of those "women-only" gyms… not that I really want to.
So that means that I need to be careful in the way that I speak. By virtue of who I am and where I’ve been born I need to be careful that my voice does not drown out the voices of those who are not in the same position of power as me. Because I’m male, I need to listen to the voice of women. Because I’m a parent, I need to listen to the voice of my children, but also those who do not have children (for whatever reason). Because I live in the city, I need to listen to the voice of those who live in regional areas. Because I live in a first world country I need to listen to the voice of those who do not. I need to be active in listening first before speaking, simply because my voice is louder than others. I may not necessarily like that, but this is the reality of the distorted world we live in. Some are in positions of power. Most are not. I just happen to be one who in many of life’s arenas has a powerful voice.
I have to be honest and confess that I’m not always good at using my voice wisely. It’s very easy to write a paragraph like the last one, but very difficult to live that way every day. It’s much easier to exploit a position of power than to use it for the benefit of all.
Which brings me to a very contemporary topic at the moment; that being marriage. In particular, whether or not marriage should be reserved exclusively for female and male couples or should legislation be changed to be opened to same-sex relationships.
On Sunday night the Compass program on the ABC aired a discussion on this topic between 6 people of various opinions, chaired by host Geraldine Doogue. For those who don’t know, Compass is a TV program that discusses religious issues. I didn’t see the full episode on Sunday night, but did manage to view it all online here. (The transcript is also available in case it cannot be viewed in other countries).
I found the discussion mostly helpful, with the relevant issues raised and many of the participants being very honest and open about their own experiences. Since Compass is a religious program it is natural that there be clergy present in the discussion. This was fair. It was also good that there were two homosexual people represented, and one father (and self-confessed, former homophobic) of a gay man present at the table. That was necessary and welcomed. I also appreciated the chosen forum – a meal table. This is something I think is worthwhile exploring in any debate. As a side issue, this is a consideration that rarely enters into sacramental theology. If Jesus did institute a participatory and memorial meal as a primary means of Christians retelling his death and resurrection and anticipating his return, then why did he choose a meal? It’s an interesting question, but one for another day. For this program, the meal worked because it acted as a leveller between all the parties involved.
What did concern me, though, was the abuse of power from the one who held the most of it. I don’t think there was an intention to be abusive, but nevertheless it was there. That’s the insipid way that power subtly takes over. I suspect the white, middle-class, heterosexual, married, male minister approached this discussion with every intention of being respectful, but I don’t know that he properly acknowledged that he was the one with the most power at that table and so he needed to be the one that listened better than anyone else. I’m speaking in this specific instance about Rt. Rev. Robert Forsyth, not to “name and shame” him but simply because he was representative of a view that has been most dominant in the church for a long time. I acknowledge that there are personality issues, and many other factors at play here (including how the discussion was edited by the ABC), but his voice was the most dominant one at that table.
And he made it known.
The number of times in this program where Julie McCrossin had to say to Rev Forsyth “let me finish” or “let him finish” on behalf of someone else was really quite disturbing. Furthermore, Prof Dennis Altman remarked (after having been prompted by the host) “I’m finding this very difficult actually to say anything.” Admittedly, there was some humour in his comment, and his exclusion from the discussion wasn’t all Rev Forsyth’s fault, but still I suggest that his comment was representative of how the LBGT community has been made to feel by the church on this and other related issues.
I’m not going to provide my own opinion on same-sex marriage. To be honest, I don’t have one. I’m waiting for the day when I can have an open conversation with homosexual Christians to help form and inform an opinion. Perhaps around a meal table or over a coffee, where I can listen respectfully to their views first. The problem is I don’t really know any homosexual Christians. I know they exist, but I just don’t know where. Shame on me. Shame on the Church for being so opinionated on the “issue of homosexuality” (way to impersonalise the discussion) that we’ve excluded the people themselves from the place where they should be the most included.
Forgive me Lord. Forgive us Lord. God help us to be more loving. God help me to be more loving.
What I do want to suggest, though, is a way potential forward for the church in these sorts of discussion when they arise. Here it is.
Shut up and listen.
Stop speaking over other voices. Stop interrupting. Stop having duelling monologues and actually enter into dialogue with the other voice. Please, just shut up and listen.
I’m not saying “don’t ever talk again about this matter”. That would be completely unproductive. What I am suggesting, though, is that the church has held the power when it comes to marriage for 2000 years and we’ve not been good in the way we’ve used (and abused) that power. We need to realise that we hold the balance of power in this discussion and we should be using it in the same way that Jesus did. Not to exploit it over and against the powerless, but rather to give them a voice. To give them that dignity. To listen to them. To even sit down and have a meal with them. Jesus didn’t “name and shame” people as “tax collectors and sinners”. The Pharisees did a pretty good job at that. Rather, he sat down to eat with them as an equal. Something tells me that the church could learn something from Jesus’ approach. Maybe, just maybe, we might learn what it means to be an inclusive community first, rather than a dogmatic one. Perhaps we might just be able to be a place that everyone, including the LBGT community, looks at and says “look how they love one another – they must be Christians.” (John 13:34-35)
Maybe.
Just maybe.
Adam Couchman
Bexley North, NSW, Australia
I am a Salvation Army Officer, living in Sydney, Australia. I am interested in discussing issues related to Christian faith and practice. You can contact me at adam@setapartinchrist.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














