Thursday, July 28, 2011

Homosexuality and the Bible Part -2-


Hebrew Sexual Mores
Nevertheless, the Bible quite clearly takes a negative view of homosexual activity, in those few instances where it is mentioned at all. But this conclusion does not solve the problem of how we are to interpret Scripture today. For there are other sexual attitudes, practices and restrictions which are normative in Scripture but which we no longer accept as normative:

1. Old Testament law strictly forbids sexual intercourse during the seven days of the menstrual period (Lev. 18:19; 15:19-24), and anyone in violation was to be "extirpated" or "cut off from their people" (kareth, Lev. 18:29, a term referring to execution by stoning, burning, strangling, or to flogging or expulsion; Lev. 15:24 omits this penalty). Today many people on occasion have intercourse during menstruation and think nothing of it. Should they be "extirpated"? The Bible says they should.

2. The punishment for adultery was death by stoning for both the man and the woman (Deut. 22:22), but here adultery is defined by the marital status of the woman. In the Old Testament, a man could not commit adultery against his own wife; he could only commit adultery against another man by sexually using the other's wife. And a bride who is found not to be a virgin is to be stoned to death (Deut. 22:13-21), but male virginity at marriage is never even mentioned. It is one of the curiosities of the current debate on sexuality that adultery, which creates far more social havoc, is considered less "sinful" than homosexual activity. Perhaps this is because there are far more adulterers in our churches. Yet no one, to my knowledge, is calling for their stoning, despite the clear command of Scripture. And we ordain adulterers.

3. Nudity, the characteristic of paradise, was regarded in Judaism as reprehensible (2 Sam. 6:20; 10:4; Isa. 20:2-4; 47:3). When one of Noah's sons beheld his father naked, he was cursed (Gen. 9:20-27). To a great extent this nudity taboo probably even inhibited the sexual intimacy of husbands and wives (this is still true of a surprising number of people reared in the Judeo-Christian tradition). We may not be prepared for nude beaches, but are we prepared to regard nudity in the locker room or at the old swimming hole or in the privacy of one's home as an accursed sin? The Bible does.

4. Polygamy (many wives) and concubinage (a woman living with a man to whom she is not married) were
regularly practiced in the Old Testament. Neither is ever condemned by the New Testament (with the questionable exceptions of 1 Tim. 3:2, 12 and Titus 1:6). Jesus' teaching about marital union in Mark 10:6-8 is no exception, since he quotes Gen. 2:24 as his authority (the man and the woman will become "one flesh"), and this text was never understood in Israel as excluding polygamy. A man could become "one flesh" with more than one woman, through the act of sexual intercourse. We know from Jewish sources that polygamy continued to be practiced within Judaism for centuries following the New Testament period. So if the Bible allowed polygamy and concubinage, why don't we?

5. A form of polygamy was the levirate marriage. When a married man in Israel died childless, his widow was to have intercourse with each of his brothers in turn until she bore him a male heir. Jesus mentions this custom without criticism (Mark 12:18-27 par.). I am not aware of any Christians who still obey this unambiguous commandment of Scripture. Why is this law ignored, and the one against homosexual behavior preserved?

6. The Old Testament nowhere explicitly prohibits sexual relations between unmarried consenting heterosexual adults, as long as the woman's economic value (bride price) is not compromised, that is to say, as long as she is not a virgin. There are poems in the Song of Songs that eulogize a love affair between two unmarried persons, though commentators have often conspired to cover up the fact with heavy layers of allegorical interpretation. In various parts of the Christian world, quite different attitudes have prevailed about sexual intercourse before marriage. In some Christian communities, proof of fertility (that is, pregnancy) was required for marriage. This was especially the case in farming areas where the inability to produce children-workers could mean economic hardship. Today, many single adults, the widowed, and the divorced are reverting to "biblical" practice, while others believe that sexual intercourse belongs only within marriage. Both views are Scriptural. Which is right?

7. The Bible virtually lacks terms for the sexual organs, being content with such euphemisms as "foot" or "thigh" for the genitals, and using other euphemisms to describe coitus, such as "he knew her." Today most of us regard such language as "puritanical" and contrary to a proper regard for the goodness of creation. In short, we don't follow Biblical practice.

8. Semen and menstrual blood rendered all who touched them unclean (Lev. 15:16-24). Intercourse rendered one unclean until sundown; menstruation rendered the woman unclean for seven days. Today most people would regard semen and menstrual fluid as completely natural and only at times "messy," not "unclean."

9. Social regulations regarding adultery, incest, rape and prostitution are, in the Old Testament, determined largely by considerations of the males' property rights over women. Prostitution was considered quite natural and necessary as a safeguard of the virginity of the unmarried and the property rights of husbands (Gen. 38:12-19; Josh. 2:1-7). A man was not guilty of sin for visiting a prostitute, though the prostitute herself was regarded as a sinner. Paul must appeal to reason in attacking prostitution (1 Cor. 6:12-20); he cannot lump it in the category of adultery (vs. 9).
Today we are moving, with great social turbulence and at a high but necessary cost, toward a more equitable, non-patriarchal set of social arrangements in which women are no longer regarded as the chattel of men. We are also trying to move beyond the double standard. Love, fidelity and mutual respect replace property rights. We have, as yet, made very little progress in changing the double standard in regard to prostitution. As we leave behind patriarchal gender relations, what will we do with the patriarchalism in the Bible?

10. Jews were supposed to practice endogamy--that is, marriage within the twelve tribes of Israel. Until recently a similar rule prevailed in the American South, in laws against interracial marriage (miscegenation). We have witnessed, within the lifetime of many of us, the nonviolent struggle to nullify state laws against intermarriage and the gradual change in social attitudes toward interracial relationships. Sexual mores can alter quite radically even in a single lifetime.

11. The law of Moses allowed for divorce (Deut. 24:1-4); Jesus categorically forbids it (Mark 10:1-12; Matt. 19:9 softens his severity). Yet many Christians, in clear violation of a command of Jesus, have been divorced. Why, then, do some of these very people consider themselves eligible for baptism, church membership, communion, and ordination, but not homosexuals? What makes the one so much greater a sin than the other, especially considering the fact that Jesus never even mentioned homosexuality but explicitly condemned divorce? Yet we ordain divorcees. Why not homosexuals?

12. The Old Testament regarded celibacy as abnormal, and 1 Tim. 4:1-3 calls compulsory celibacy a heresy. Yet the Catholic Church has made it mandatory for priests and nuns. Some Christian ethicists demand celibacy of homosexuals, whether they have a vocation for celibacy or not. But this legislates celibacy by category, not by divine calling. Others argue that since God made men and women for each other in order to be fruitful and multiply, homosexuals reject God's intent in creation. But this would mean that childless couples, single persons, priests and nuns would be in violation of God's intention in their creation. Those who argue thus must explain why the apostle Paul never married. And are they prepared to charge Jesus with violating the will of God by remaining single?
Certainly heterosexual marriage is normal, else the race would die out. But it is not normative. God can bless the world through people who are married and through people who are single, and it is false to generalize from the marriage of most people to the marriage of everyone. In 1 Cor. 7:7 Paul goes so far as to call marriage a "charisma," or divine gift, to which not everyone is called. He preferred that people remain as he was--unmarried. In an age of overpopulation, perhaps a gay orientation is especially sound ecologically!

13. In many other ways we have developed different norms from those explicitly laid down by the Bible. For example, "If men get into a fight with one another, and the wife of one intervenes to rescue her husband from the grip of his opponent by reaching out and seizing his genitals, you shall cut off her hand; show no pity" (Deut. 25:11f.). We, on the contrary, might very well applaud her for trying to save her husband's life!

14. The Old and New Testaments both regarded slavery as normal and nowhere categorically condemned it. Part of that heritage was the use of female slaves, concubines and captives as sexual toys, breeding machines, or involuntary wives by their male owners, which 2 Sam. 5:13, Judges 19-21 and Num. 31:18 permitted--and as many American slave owners did some 150 years ago, citing these and numerous other Scripture passages as their justification.

About the Author



Walter Wink, is Professor of Biblical Interpretation at Auburn Theological Seminary in New York City. He has also taught at Union Theological Seminary and Hartford Seminary, and has been a visiting professor at Columbia and Drew universities. In 1989-1990 he was a Peace Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington, DC.

His published works include a trilogy on the Powers: Naming the Powers (1984), Unmasking the Powers (1986), and Engaging the Powers (1992), all from Fortress Press. Engaging the Powers received three "Religious Book of the Year" awards in 1993. Doubleday Books will publish a condensed version of the Powers trilogy in 1997 under the title, The Powers That Be.

He is also the author of The Bible in Human Transform ation (Fortress, 1973), Transforming Bible Study (Abingdon, second edition, 1990), and other works, including 134 articles.

Dr. Wink is a United Methodist minister, works for a Presbyterian seminary, and attends Quakermeeting. For five years he served as pastor of a church in southeast Texas.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Quite a dwelling in the OT. We are no longer under that covenant. It has been a problem for the Jews in these days because as a whole Jesus Christ is rejected as Savior.Many verses are actually meaningless in this day and age. Much of the OT has been misunderstood and as what happens often is that God gets blamed for slavery and all that man has practiced. All in all God is not silent on the affairs of mankind.The confusion and (seemingly confliction) is ours and we cannot blame God.
When people place the OT with the NT and it becomes a mixed bag a huge injustice begins to happen.Confusion and chaos begins.

When I am asked where someone should begin reading the Bible I never suggest that they begin in the OT. It is confusing and should be backtracked after understanding the Gospels and letters that also explain some of the OT.

The NT teaching about sin focuses on the power to overcome and the state of grace that we are in with a warning to not abuse it. The Apostle Paul speaks of a list of (sinful practices)and he points out that many were once this way but the people have been redeemed and their lives were changed.

The use of slaves for work and sexual pleasure in the OT was a practice that the foreign nations dabbled in around the (ever transit Hebrew nation). God has permitted certain things to happen. That does not mean that God approves of it. We see starving children today. Who is to blame? One day there will be no more suffering and God will judge it all because he knows all.

The reasoning and use of the OT to protect and defend the author's reasoning is a poor and chaotic way to defend his position.

There was reason for what was written at the time concerning OT law and teaching (much of it is history). But we must remember much of what was commanded was temporary and we would be fools to follow what was then to the here and now. My wife took some money from my wallet. I am not going to cut her hands off or stone her or divorce her and replace her with 3 other women.

USA Former

Anonymous said...

It was pointed out that Jesus was never married. The thought is that He should have been since he was a Rabbi. We must look at the overall picture. God is a Higher Law to begin with. Jesus was born to die . That was the plan. It was not the Plan of the Triune God for Jesus to marry. There was no reason for it. I think that we will find an exception to the thought and teaching that a Rabbi needs to be married or at what age.

USA former

Anonymous said...

I think the USA former in this thread is beginning to hit the nail on the head. We are not under the OT. Therefore, we should stop using it to define sin, to prescribe judgements etc. The only way we can condemn homosexuality is to appeal to the OT. If, as the author of the articles is ultimately arguing, the OT no longer applies to us, we can not appeal to anything in the Bible to support a position that homosexuality is sinful.

As for comments on bashing (see comments on part 1 of the article)....
I would put quite simply, that calling homosexuality a 'sin', and saying that it is a choice, and saying that people can change, IS bashing. If you say these things, you are a basher, because that is what gay bashing is (among other things). Just because a slave owner treated his slaves civily did not mean he was no longer a slave owner (to use another illustration).

People have a right to believe these things, but if you do, you need to explain the evidence that says no-one has ever changed their sexuality, no-one has ever successfully overcome their homosexuality (and this comes from exodus international). There is overwhelming evidence that homosexuals are born, that it is not in any way related to experience, or a process, any more than heterosexuality is. How many heterosexuals can say that at one point in their life they said 'I am going to choose to be a heterosexual'? (bi-sexuals are probably the only ones who could - but then, they are not heterosexuals). Why would you assume that homosexuals at some point 'choose' to be homosexual? No homosexual has ever 'chosen' to be so. If you do not acknowledge and explain this evidence, explaining why you think the evidence is wrong, presenting other evidence to counter this evidence, then your views will only ever be seen as the rantings of a religious lunatic. Sorry, but that is the way it is. I'm not calling you names, I'm just pointing out how you come across.

Yours in Christ,
Graeme Randall
Former Australian East

Anonymous said...

In your opinion I am a basher. But really am I? Because I disagree with some of your belief you lump me together with a bunch of people that would not even give a cup of water in Jesus name. With you it is all or nothing with your opinion and that is crude and do you know how OFFENSIVE that is ?
There is this fact. You and I disagree on some issues. We could go back and forth on the issues and Scripture but we will not convince one another of anything different.

Time to move on to something else.

USA former

Anonymous said...

I have shared before that we are beyond the OT and under a new covenent. However the OT pointed to the Messiah. We received the Ten Commandments in th OT.They were given for various reasons but one that I see is the fact that people needed to know more specifics as to what God wanted them to do or not do. There is sound teaching and true stories found in the OT but of course the primary focus was to prescribe to the Hebrews how to react to God. We live from the NT. The Book of Acts shows the acts of the Holy Spirit and the apostles -disciples response to the new covenent.

I did not want to discount the OT so that it was meaningless. I do agree that some parts are difficult to understand. One major reason is that much of it was directed to the Hebrews and not gentiles.That did not leave the gentiles off the hook because God spoke to them too. God used some pagan people (Abraham)and he became the father of a nation !

USA former

Anonymous said...

Sven,

Thank you so much for blogging the scholarly work of Walter Wink on your site concerning the subject of homosexuality. His work along with the work of Catholic theologian Daniel Helminiak (whom I'm going to quote at the end of this posting)is among the best I've ever read on the subject of what the Bible does and doesn't say about homosexuality. You're making available to many people in TSA resources that they might never have thought to read if you didn't first post it here on the FSAOF blog.

As I see it the largest impediment to change in TSA (especially in the states) is that most Salvationists (both officers and soldiers alike)have only read and/or listened to the prejudicial work of well known evangelical "leader/stars" without realizing that they are neither experts on the subject nor theologians. They also often times have a selfish agenda to their stubborness usually (though not always)connected to raising money! Two other issues also seem to be (as seen in several already embarrassingly made public cases)their own closeted self-hatred and (I'm at least convinced) in the case of one such leader the stubborness of having been an only child and insisting that what he learned and believed growing up as an adolescent in the 1950s is how the world works and by golly that's how it's going to stay working! (btw, are people aware that James Dobson's Board of Directors at Focus on the Family finally had enough of him and compltely gave him the boot last year---though to their credit they did cloak their well justified treachery in the usual to be expected guise/language of Xian love? Think 1929. lol!)

I grew up in (at the time)a very small corps on the southwest side of Chicago and though I didn't know it at the time I now realise that headquarters didn't always send us the brightest stars in the sky for officers. We sometimes got good officers who just happened to be in their first appointment but we also got people who were being watched very closely by HQ for some reason or another, (suspected mental illness, sexual addiction) people HQ was hoping to get rid of and people who were just plain dumb and had nowhere else they could be sent!

I remember one such dumb one (who in his next appointment was kicked out for misapproriating funds though he and his wife claimed they left to become Pentecostals because the Army wasn't "spiritual" anymore and was too concerned about money!)telling a group of us kids that blacks were inferior to whites and related it to the story of Ham in the Book of Genesis. They were according to him cursed by God to live inferior lives forever. What is so shocking about this is that at the time he and his equally dumb darling wife were far from the only evangelical and/or holiness people who believed this!

As a teen-ager I was able to see the injustice and prejudice behind such a belief---though to fit in and be accepted I did keep my mouth shut about what I was really thinking. (I need to do another posting due to space limitations)

Daryl Lach
USA Central

Anonymous said...

continuing... Later while reading the story of Sodom and Gomorrah in Genesis 18 in Sunday School it struck me as very odd that no one seemed to be upset that Lot offered his two virgin daughters to be raped and violated in every way possible in place of the two male visitors. I'm now sure that I wasn't the only one but that the same as me no one else wanted to rock any boats either!

Years later while reading a very similar story in Judges 19 about the concubine of Gibeah it struck me that this story was never even mentioned or known about in most Xian circles and almost totally overlooked by the Xian patriarchy! This powerless girl was not only offered up to be raped and abused by the men of Gibeah with the consent of her Levite master but after the all night abuse was over with she was lying half dead on the doorstep when her master then cut her up into 12 pieces of flesh!

With all of the emphasis that was put on Sodom and Gomorrah why weren't we ever told much (if anything) about the concubine of Gibeah? Wasn't she at all important in God's sight? Why just the emphasis on a story that was misinterpreted to have something to do with male on male sex? Doesn't anyone see something more than the "dividing the word of truth" here? Maybe an unjust patriarchy at work in all of it?

If what happened at Gibeah is something belonging to that day and age and culture and except for the evil of inhospitality in its most comprehensive form has nothing to do with us then why is Sodom and Gomorrah always being interpreted as a condemnation of male homosexuality? This is especially troubling to me in light of the fact whenever Jesus and the prophets spoke of the sin of Sodom they never once mention homosexuality only the selfishness of a bunch of people who in their prosperity had forgotten the poor and needy and strangers in their midst. This is something I've thought about often in recent years and I hope that in this posting I'm able to get someone else to think more deeply and out of the box about it too!

Lastly, I'd like to quote a paragraph from Daniel Helminiak that I find very appropriate to this discussion. (I'll do one more posting to be sure there's room for the whole quote.)

Daryl Lach
USA Central

Anonymous said...

continuing... "The Sin of Sodom Today"

Even Jesus understood the sin of Sodom as the sin of inhospitality. Other passages in the Bible come right out and say the same thing. Yet people continue to use the story of Sodom to condemn gay and lesbian people.

There is a sad irony about the story of Sodom when understood in its own historical setting. People oppose and abuse homosexual men and women for being different, odd, strange or, as they say, "queer." Lesbian women and gay men are just not allowed to fit in; they are made to be outsiders, foreigners in our society. They are disowned by their families, seperated from their children, fired from their jobs, evicted from apartments and neighborhoods, insulted by public figures, beaten and killed on the streets. All this is done in the name of religion and supposed Judeo-Xian morality.

Such oppression is the very sin of which the people of Sodom were guilty. Such behavior is what the Bible truly condemns over and over again. So those who oppress homosexuals because of the supposed "sin of Sodom" may themselves be the real "sodomites," as the Bible understands it. (Amen and Amen!)

P.S. Oh, and one other thing: God Bless the Concubine of Gibeah and the price she paid for ignorance. May she rest in peace. I hope to one day meet her in Heaven!

Daryl Lach
USA Central

"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand with Jesus in the Morning!"

Anonymous said...

Interesting, Daryle. Believe it or not I agree with much of what you are sharing. I believe that the sin of Sodom goes beyond hospitality.I have heard that before. I think all of our past thought maybe partly incorrect. I think the sin encompassed selfishness and sinful pride including all sorts of idolatry and sexual sin of all types. I think the place smelled of sin and perhaps human sacrifices.

As you wondered about Lot offering his daughters for sex to protect the (two men) (angels), I was shocked myself. That was a practice of foreigners that Lot was not to be involved with (another sin of the day). Abraham went in another direction where God blessed him.
I must add that the Bible does not pull any punches. Often detail is revealed without comment. By Lot offering his daughters did not make it right. The Bible reveals info here. It is the same as much of the slavery isssues and mistreatment of women also.

I want to state for myself that the list of unkindness and ill treatment of gays and Lesbians that you shared is not what I have been involved with. No one should be treated the way that you shared that people were treated. I still have some disagreement about the subject at hand but I get weary of being called a basher when I help all sorts of people without question. As I have stated before (as far as Salvation Army leadership), I am not in a position to accept gays as memebers or reject them. Yhay issue never came up in my tenure of over 25 years. I worked with gays and had conversation. I have always respected their opinions and have not been cruel.

The woman at Gibeah that was raped and cut into pieces was a terrible story that I wondered about also. It was so cruel! I do not believe that this was acceptable in anyway to God-fearing people of that day but again the Bible states many things that have little or no commentary.Because this story was shared does not make it acceptable in anyway or we would be serving a cruel God in which some people seem to deduct.

USA former

Anonymous said...

Dear USA Former!

Great! I'm glad we're finally able to find common ground and agree about something on this subject! God Bless You. (now if only the Tea Partiers in the U.S. House would hurry up and do the same!)

Daryl Lach
USA Central