How a changing landscape can strengthen our witness.
Russell D. Moore
Evangelical Christians, of almost all sorts, are a
narrative-driven people. Our evangelism often includes personal stories of how
we came to meet Christ. Our worship often includes personal “testimonies,”
either spoken or sung. To those outside the community, these can seem cloyingly
sentimental, and sometimes even manipulative. Even so, those who emphasize the
personal nature of knowing Christ often define following Christ in terms of our
past, what we’re leaving behind. But even without a spoken testimony, one can
often read what an evangelical is walking away from based on what he’s
reacting, or over-reacting, to.
Whenever I hear a Christian say that we shouldn’t emphasize
the imperatives of Scripture (the commands of God), but rather the indicatives
(who we are in Christ), I can predict that, almost every time, this is someone
who grew up in an oppressive and rigid legalism. By contrast, when I hear an
evangelical Christian wanting to build hedges of rules around the possibility
of sin, I can usually guess that this someone was converted out of a morally
chaotic background. The Christian who was converted out of a dead, lifeless
church often dismisses liturgy as “formalism” and contrasts “religion” with
“relationship.” At the same time, one who was converted despite an emotionally
exuberant but theologically vacuous church will often seek out the ancient
roots and structure of a more liturgically ordered church.
What’s true at the personal level is also true at the movement
level. We tend to ping back and forth between extremes—always seeking to avoid
the last bad thing. As David R. Swartz points out in his book Moral Minority, The
Religious Left of the last generation was, in many ways, a reaction from some
sectors of the “Jesus People” era to the empty consumerism and racism and
militarism of the post-World War II religious establishments. The old Religious
Right was in many ways a reaction to the awful consequences of a real or
perceived pietistic withdrawal of some in the church as the country veered into
Sexual Revolution and an abortion culture. As we move into a new era, the
church in America will seek to correct the course from some aspects of the
past. We should simply make sure that we correct in the right way.
Some will see any reframing of Christian public witness as a
“pullback from politics” or a withdrawal back into the enclaves. But this is
not the case, for several reasons. First of all, it will be impossible. It is
one thing for Christianity to correct errors in past forays into the public
square: triumphalist expectations, for example, or theatrical panic and
paranoia rooted in a victim-status siege mentality. It is quite another to,
with silence, constrict the liberty of future generations.
Total disengagement is itself a privilege of a cultural
Christendom that is fast passing away.
Total disengagement is itself a privilege of a cultural
Christendom that is fast passing away. A church can avoid taking controversial
stances on what it means to be human or what it means to be married only so
long as the outside culture at least pretends to share the same basic ideals. A
church can ignore the culture only until, as the divorce culture did in the
past, that culture reshapes the church in a way that obscures the gospel
itself. And a church can ignore the state only as long as the state respects
the territorial boundaries of Mr. Jefferson’s “wall of separation.” A state
that sees some aspects of Christian witness as bigoted and dangerous will not
long stay on the other side of that wall.
The primary reason I think evangelicalism will not go wobbly
on public engagement is the gospel. In the rising wave of evangelicals, one
hears the constant refrain of “gospel focus” and “gospel centrality.” Some
might dismiss this as just more evangelical faddishness and sloganeering, and
perhaps some of it is. But I think it is far more than that.
The focus on the gospel is tied up with the collapse of the
Bible Belt. As American culture secularizes, the most basic Christian tenets
seem ever more detached from mainstream American culture. There is, for those
who came and will come of age in recent years, no social utility in embracing
them. Those who identify with Christianity, and who gather with the people of
God, have already decided to walk out of step with the culture. These
Christians have already embraced strangeness by spending Sunday morning at
church rather than at brunch.
This is leading to a sort of mirror image of the Rapture
that the traveling evangelists warned us about. Those who were nominally
Christian are suddenly vanished from the pews. Those who wanted an
almost-gospel will find that they don’t need it to thrive in American culture.
As a matter of fact, cultural Christianity is herded out by natural selection.
That sort of nominal religion, when bearing the burden of the embarrassment of
a controversial Bible, is no more equipped to survive in a secularizing America
than a declawed cat released in the wild. Who then is left behind? It will be
those defined not by a Christian America but by a Christian gospel.
To understand why this leads to greater engagement rather
than to lesser engagement, we must understand what the slow-motion collapse of
the Bible Belt is about in the first place. This changes not just the number of
unbelievers, but the way that believers themselves think and relate to the
outside culture. Philosopher James K. A. Smith, in his book How (Not) to Be
Secular: Reading Charles Taylor, gives the example of an evangelical
church-planter relocating from the Bible Belt to a “post-Christian” urban
center in the Pacific Northwest. The church planter is equipped to evangelize
and make disciples by asking people diagnostic questions about what’s missing
in their lives.
A generation or two ago, that might have been what they were
trusting in to get to heaven. In more recent years, it would have been what’s
missing in order to grant meaning and purpose to their lives. The central issue
isn’t that the church planter isn’t adequately trained to answer their questions;
it’s that they are asking different questions. They do not feel “lost” in the
world, and they don’t feel as though they need meaning or purpose. The
effective evangelist must engage not only at the level of the answers, but also
at the level of the questions themselves.
The same will be true when it comes to the social and
political witness of Christianity in a new era. Older generations could assume
that the culture resonated with the same “values” and “principles.” They could
assume that the culture wanted to conserve their “Judeo-Christian heritage.”
Increasingly, the culture doesn’t see Christianity as the “real America.” If
Christianity is a means to American values, America can get by without it,
because America is learning to value other things.
This is, perhaps counterintuitively, both good for the
church and good for the church’s engagement with the outside world. In the
1920s, J. Gresham Machen warned the church his book Christianity and Liberalism
not only that bartering away orthodoxy wouldn’t gain the church cultural
credibility, but also that the great danger for the church is to see
Christianity as a means to some other end.
Christianity does indeed build stronger families, he argued,
and it does indeed provide an alternative to Marxist ideologies. But if
Christianity is embraced as a way to build strong families or assimilate people
into American values or fight Communism, it is no longer Christianity but an
entirely other religion, one he called “liberalism.”
In the last generation of Christian public engagement, there
were some genuine prophets and saints, who called the church out of isolation
but constantly warned against a political captivity of the church, a captivity
that would tap Christianity of its righteous zeal for the sake of power but
would, ultimately, drain it of what every culture finds most troublesome: the
exclusivity of Christ.
As American culture changes, the scandal of Christianity is
increasingly right up front, exactly where it was in the first century. The
shaking of American culture will get us back to the question Jesus asked his
disciples at Caesarea Philippi: “Who do you say that I am?” As the Bible Belt
recedes, those left standing up for Jesus will be those who, like Simon Peter
of old, know how to answer that question. Once Christianity is no longer seen
as part and parcel of patriotism, the church must offer more than “What would
Jesus do?” moralism and the “I vote values” populism to which we’ve grown
accustomed. Good.
This article is adapted from Onward:
Engaging the Culture without Losing the Gospel (B&H Books) by
Russell D. Moore. Used by permission.


No comments:
Post a Comment