Friday, April 3, 2015

Life on the Front Line



After this the Lord appointed seventy-two others and sent them on ahead of him, two by two, into every town and place where he himself was about to go. And he said to them, “The harvest is plentiful, but the labourers are few. Therefore pray earnestly to the Lord of the harvest to send out labourers into his harvest. Go your way; behold, I am sending you out as lambs in the midst of wolves.’ (Luke 10:1-3 ESV)

There is certainly something uniquely special about being sent out by God to work as an Officer in The Salvation Army. Having agreed to write an article on reconciliation, I wondered whether my rambling thoughts could be organised in such a way that they can be useful. I decided not! So my starting point is the comment I left on another post recently, and the end point is further ramblings that I’m sure will resonate with some and perhaps upset others.

Officership, in and of itself, presents a set of unique challenges.  There are many factors to be considered when serving as an officer, in part because of the unique calling but also because of the challenging context – both within the Army and outside in the complex world we operate in. The following are the points I raised previously, and I now offer a reflection on the cultural context.

1. Officership is unlike any job, and is a vocational calling. As such, achieving a work-life balance is much more difficult as the line between is mostly blurry.

2. Officership, like many vocational roles, is poorly paid and leaves little scope for well-deserved holidays. We also need to remember that officers kids were not called (in most cases) to a life of austerity, and are often disadvantaged (compared to their peers) by the calling of their parents.

3. DHQs are run by officers who are often burnt out themselves. There's a sense of being in the same boat, but rather than feeling that sense of sameness it is often the case that DHQ staff feel corps officers should suffer because they are suffering. On asking for support because we were struggling, we were told 'you are Salvation Army officers...you should just get on with it!' on another occasion, when our eldest son was being treated for cancer and we asked for practical support, we were told that staff at DHQ were 'running out of sympathy!' the compassion that the Army shows to the homeless, the poor, trafficking victims, the elderly, etc. needs to be shown more visibly and more actively to the officers offering that compassion.

4. In the olden days (when my parents were divisional leaders) their priority was the pastoral care of the corps officers in their care. If a corps officer was in distress, they would get in the car (no matter what time of day of night) and reach out to them. Legislation has, in recent years, changed the priorities of DHQs towards micro-bureaucracies, wrapped up in health & safety, legionella, child protection and finance. Rather than establishing a highly effective systems approach, the Army appears to have pursued a labour (or labor, for my American friends) intensive strategy, making Officership less vocation and more administration. This has to change!

Officers are the Army's greatest asset and, as they are not regular employees as such, they need to be affirmed, protected, nurtured, cared for, and loved beyond imagination.

Unlike the business world, you can't 'sweat the assets' without doing serious damage!

The Culture Within
It is said (by Dave Logan, Co-author of Tribal Leadership) that ‘culture eats strategy for breakfast!’ In other words, no matter how good the strategy is, if the culture is wrong then all striving is in vain.

The Salvation Army is a blessing from God. I feel I need to say that because, despite its problems, it has been raised up to do God’s work and fulfils this calling faithfully. That doesn’t mean it couldn’t be more effective at times. Indeed no organisation is perfect and none can claim to be without problems. But what are the big cultural challenges for the Army today? I believe there are a few areas that desperately need cultural change.

Considering the reasons that Officers resign their commissions, it is clear that many leave because of irretrievable breakdown in the relationship. This can be for many different reasons, but the result is a broken relationship. For Corps Officers – the front line troops – there appears to be an increasing feeling of isolation and hopelessness. There is a growing feeling that the ivory towers of DHQs and THQ are compromising the front line mission in order to pursue a divisional or territorial strategy. In a military context this could situation might be regarded by the higher officer classes as justified use of cannon fodder.

Cannon fodder is an informal, derogatory term for military personnel who are regarded or treated as expendable in the face of enemy fire. The term is generally used in situations where 
soldiers are forced to deliberately fight against hopeless odds (with the foreknowledge that they will suffer extremely high casualties) in an effort to achieve a strategic goal. An example is the trench warfare in World War I. (Source: Wikipedia)

To fulfil the calling God has made on The Salvation Army, there is a need for reconciliation between Corps Officers and those making the demands and decisions that impact them. And reconciliation needs to be embraced by the whole Army – from top to bottom. There needs to be unity of purpose and spirit, which means both sides understanding each other’s difficulties. As a Corps Officer, I just wanted someone to share my joy when things were going well and my pain when I was struggling. Alas, an inability to achieve this proved to be the undoing of my Officership.


For many Officers the appointment to DHQ or THQ is a blessing, but for others it is a curse. This may sound negative, but the fact is that most Officers want to fulfil their calling to save souls, grow saints and serve suffering humanity. I don’t believe any Officers were called for the purpose of frustrating their colleagues on the front line, nor were they called to upset headquarters staff. Nevertheless, there is a frustration building that I believe often happens because people end up in places they weren’t called to, perhaps without the necessary skills or resources.

In the same way that Corps Officers feel frustrated there will be headquarters staff frustrated by their own lack of support. With the average age of those entering training increasing over the past decades, the Army needs to acknowledge the experience and knowledge of its Officers gained in previous professional positions. Its Officers would become far more valuable assets if this knowledge informed the resourcing of the mission.

Corps Officership is hard work! Anecdotally, it appears that the attitude of Corps members is increasingly shifting towards ‘it’s the Officer’s job.’ With a substantial increase in administration over the past decade the role of the Corps Officer has developed into that of a spiritual civil servant. Smaller and older congregations perpetuate this problem, with many being unable or unwilling to take on committed roles in the Corps. This is manifest through increased pressure on Corps Officers that is not necessarily understood by headquarters staff.

Legislation has, in recent years, changed the priorities of DHQs towards micro-bureaucracies, wrapped up in health & safety, legionella, child protection and finance. Rather than establishing a highly effective systems approach, the Army appears to have pursued a labour intensive strategy, making Officership less vocation and more administration – or less like ministry and more like a normal low paid job. This has to change! And change can only happen if the relationships are strong.
It may be Biblical to suggest that suffering is an integral part of human existence, but this needs to be balanced. 1 Peter 5 says, ‘and after you have suffered a little while, the God of all grace, who has called you to his eternal glory in Christ, will himself restore, confirm, strengthen, and establish you.’ Officers of all ranks and appointments need to be restored and strengthened. The need for refreshment sometimes goes beyond divisional retreats, territorial councils and Brengle Institues, and the Army would benefit significantly from occasionally releasing the pressure on its Officers. I believe that sabbaticals, for example, are only open to Officers who have served over ten (or more) years. The work-life balance is becoming more important for people in full-time ministry, and this is evidenced by the number of Officers resigning or suffering work-related illness during the first few years of ministry.

I was shocked to discover, after resigning, that the Corps I had been appointed to had lost over 40 Officers to resignation, long term illness or requests for an early move, in just 120 years of its existence. This is an example of long term relationship breakdown that can only be resolved in a culture of love, grace and reconciliation.


Finally, whilst people do not enter Officership for financial gain, there is a need for valuing Officers in the context of their ministry. I have heard many apologists for the Army say that the overall package is considerable, but typically (still) Officers are paid significantly less that their contemporaries in other denominations. I believe that this, along with feeling unsupported and unvalued, causes the Army to be built on weak foundations, and is evidenced by the number of Officers resigning and the lack of Cadets in training worldwide.

The Culture Outside
‘Go your way; behold, I am sending you out as lambs in the midst of wolves.’
There is no doubt that the context in which the Army works is constantly changing towards a secular society. In Britain, for example, ‘the number of residents who stated that their religion was Christian in 2011 was fewer than in 2001. The size of this group decreased 13 percentage points to 59% (33.2 million) in 2011 from 72% (37.3 million) in 2001. It is the only group to have experienced a decrease in numbers between 2001 and 2011 despite population growth. The second largest response category in 2011 was no religion. This increased 10 percentage points.’ (2011 Census) 

The Salvation Army has always been, in my opinion, an adaptable innovator and now is the real test of whether it can be as relevant to the culture today as it was when it began in the 19th century. This will require some tough decision making to allow appropriately gifted Officers the opportunity to innovate the mission of the Army in such a way that it is faithful to its calling and relevant to 21st century society. The basic message of salvation has not changed, but the way in which it is communicated must change constantly in step with the culture.

Conclusion
The opening point about culture and strategy is of key importance. It seems that Corps and Headquarters are pursuing different strategies within vastly different Army sub-cultures. Whilst there is a refreshingly clear vision from the General – One Army, One Mission, One Message – the whole Army, from the tiniest outpost to the largest headquarters, needs to embrace this vision with a spirit of unity. This means reconciling differences and rebuilding relationships to allow a powerful culture of single-minded, soul-saving, saint-growing, humanity-serving to emerge.
We all know that the harvest is plentiful and that the labourers are few, which is why reconciliation is critical to the Army’s future mission. An Army that is expending energy and resources on friendly fire is not an Army that will win the war.
So my message to the Army is ‘reconciliation, reconciliation, reconciliation’ as the only way to secure a growing mission for the future.

Stuart Rivers
Former O
fficer

UKTI

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Alas, Stuart Rivers, you are asking for the impossible. If change and/or reconciliation was going to happen, it would have happened by now. We are still living like a stuck record in the heady days of yore, when all was a blue sky horizon and Army members were full of the fire of the Holy Spirit. All that is left today are just faded embers of 19th century zeal.

Anonymous said...

Spot on thoughts Stuart, thank you.