Rowland
Croucher was asked ten years ago how many ex-pastors he estimated there were
currently in Australia.
When
we started John Mark Ministries in 1991 our estimate was that there were 10,000
ex-pastors in Australia. That is, there are 10,000 people who were in parish
ministry of some sort, and are now in some other religious ministry or secular
vocation – teaching, truck-driving, cross-cultural mission, denominational
executive, hobo – you name it! They left parish ministry for reasons other than
retirement or death.
How
did I arrive at that figure? I had a ministry with World Vision, as you know,
as a kind of minister-at-large to the church in Australia and beyond. In the
many pastors’ conferences I addressed I would ask ‘How many of you can say that
in your exit/graduation/ordination year more have left than stayed in
parish/pastoral ministry?’
Among
the Pentecostals there was a significant drop-out rate: more leave than stay;
among the ‘Evangelical’ denominations (Salvation Army, Baptist, Churches of
Christ, etc.) about the same number stay as leave; in the mainline churches
(most Anglican dioceses, Lutheran, Uniting, Reformed, Presbyterian) more stay
than leave.
Why,
why, why? Well, many Pentecostal pastors are church-planters: a high-risk
vocation! In other denominations with a significant number of church-planters
(C & MA, Wesleyan Methodist etc.) there’s a similarly high attrition rate.
The
Evangelical churches’ clergy have a significant role in ‘attracting customers':
they grow by accretions to membership from other churches or none.
The mainline churches
look after their clergy better, financially. They are more secure. But the flip-side
of this is that some clergy who should possibly have left hang around until
retirement.
Harry
Ballis has done the definitive research on SDA pastors. During a period a
decade or two back, they lost more pastors in Australia than have left any denomination
at any time. That was when that denomination was turning itself inside out over
several issues…
Now,
back to the statistics: they are getting worse, in my opinion. More are
leaving. There are more options for those who leave, and there is less disgrace
in leaving (as has also happened in cross- cultural missionary work in the last
couple of decades).
Why
do they leave? We have isolated 40 different ‘presenting’ variables. That is,
when asked ‘Why did you leave?’ there are 40 different discrete answers. (See
the ex-pastors’ questionnaire on our website – http://jmm.org.au/articles/2001.htm
).
Beneath
these variables is the context of leaving – almost always one of conflict.
And
beneath that, I have discovered in my counseling of ex-pastors and their
spouses, is the ‘manhood factor': most men are not properly initiated into
manhood in our culture. They therefore have difficulties in relating to strong
women, in resolving conflicts, in espousing a ministry of ‘empowerment’ rather
than a clericalist model etc. etc.
All
generalizations, but there you are.

1 comment:
I think you've identified three crucial areas in your summary. Here in the UK Alastair McKay has just written his DMin thesis on conflict mediation skills and tools used and lack thereof in church leadership teams. The other two points were frequently heard groans of exasperation in the fresh expressions network we ran locally. Is there any other research going on in Australia?
Post a Comment