Does the carrot on a stick work on naïve, unsuspecting SA aspirants for officership?
Some idioms ("chase the carrot" / "carrot and stick") and a popular image implies that you can make a mule move forward (and even pull a cart), by placing a carrot hanging from a stick in front of its face.
A dictionary of urban idioms explains:
Chase the Carrot - never ever having any chance to reach the bait.
|
________________________________________
It would be helpful to have more acknowledgements by our leaders of the grief and sense of dislocation and disorientation involved in living with a frustrated vocation. It would help, perhaps, if dedicated resources such as retreats and ongoing support in vocational discernment were available. I'm able to offer a positive story of handling the situation.
I was turned down the first time about ten years ago, and the 'silence' afterwards from my church was deafening. I was already a trained spiritual director and that helped as I'd already gained experience accompanying others in this kind of situation. Each person responds uniquely, but it's a huge pastoral issue. I've now lost count of the times I've been put forward, and all to no avail. In the end a CO told me quite openly that he believed that regardless of the support from my corps I would never be accepted, and I would just be 'strung along' until I too old to reapply. Meanwhile I was becoming aware of the number of people in our corps who have at one time or another offered and been turned down. I wonder if some corps have a quarter or even a third of their soldiers in that situation? Where ever I go I keep finding more people.
So - how to handle it personally? Well there is hope. By the grace of God and thanks to supportive and encouraging ministers outside the army I'm now a recognised and accredited minister in another organisation and I'm getting on with a life of service in that framework. I 'moonlight' back to a local corps when I can, as I love the army so much. It's sad, and difficult as I know I was called to TSA, but being in ministry after years of lay service is wonderful - so freeing and enabling. It's the greatest possible missional adventure!
I'd like to offer some encouragement. First, get on with training up through a well regarded Bible college, many offer distance courses. No matter how slow your progress, you will grow and develop skills, tools for ministry, wider perspectives, better self-awareness and a wider network of support and potential referees for applications. There are independent and free churches, and there are many mission organisations out there.
Second, keep a detailed portfolio/file of the ministry experience you gain, whether it's leading a small group or preaching occasionally, initiating mission projects, visits and pastoral care, leading teams, evangelism experience, fundraising and funding applications, training up disciples or whatever. Evidence it with names, dates, places, and countersignatures with feedback to demonstrate accountability and reflective learning. Go on ministry professional development courses - many are open to lay people. I kept my record for ten years of lay ministry and in the end I had so much evidence I could do the job it was far too long for anyone to read. I can still draw excerpts from it for job applications when I apply for paid pastor posts, a process which can begin once you are over a year into your training. I'm now able to apply for a range of posts with a solid background. I'm sad to say I found two things don't help motivate committed people to volunteer time with the army as a soldier. Unless you are in the process for application for officership, they have no reason to bother evidencing what you are doing, so officers are usually not inclined to help, or it won't occur to them to offer. COs and established lay leaders can be very slow and reluctant to commission lay people for the roles they are actually doing. I spent two years setting up and leading some work with a particular age group, and if I hadn't chased down the CO just days before he was moved with a 'to whom it may concern' letter I'd hastily written for him to sign to confirm I'd done that work,that two years of experience I'd gained would have vanished without trace. I can tell you I learned early to ask the crucial questions and get it in writing before doing anything as a soldier at the army!
My third point here is this: start your ministry, just get on with it. Allow for plenty of miss-starts and tries and fails. In the process you will find out what kind of minister/missioner you are becoming, and where your strengths and weaknesses lie. As you go on, whether you are helping lead a small local congregation outside the army which cannot afford a minister, starting a church, or setting up an independent mission which has perhaps developed from your ecumenical volunteering, you will firstly (hopefully, and if you're a good leader) find and form your own team, and secondly you'll be able to research Christian organisations and find one which will accredit what you. There are routes into becoming a recognised (and paid) minister that are not limited by denominational background and the other usual factors. Trust God to put you in situations where you will develop into the minister he wants you to be; work hard to gain the qualifications and experience, if necessary thinking laterally how to do it, search for the work-arounds like mission agencies, starting new churches and so on. Obey Jesus in all things, making sure you can evidence consistent lifestyle and good character, and a well balanced and mature inner life through all the hardships, and commit to accepting and allowing him to find a solution for you which may not be what you were originally called to.
Maybe it won't, for you, take away the sense of frustrated calling or 'dislocation' - I know it hasn't taken away mine. However, I can testify from my own experience that I know God is working the messy horrible situations in our lives, and can bring something good and unexpected out of them. We are allowed to have outrageous confidence in God and unlimited hope. We can move towards forgiving ourselves for whatever mistakes we made in the process, and allowing for the church we applied to to have messed up and got it badly wrong as well. Church leaders and ministry selections boards do make mistakes, sometimes serious ones that impact people for a lifetime. Unless there's a genuine cause for grievance to do with the process, let it go and allow the army to have made a mistake or perhaps for your discernment to have been wrong. Let it go. Focus then on your calling and how to let God and your college and developing professional network help you find a way through. I'm praying today for all of us with frustrated vocations, and soldiers in particular, specially round commissioning times.
SA SOLDIER UK
(name on file)

11 comments:
Thank you for this article. You will never realise how much this has helped today. Watching the officers being commissioned at the weekend via website was so sad for me again.
Your words have given me great encouragement.
Dear SA Soldier UK,
Concerning this posting and the prelude you wrote to it on the 4th? Sorry, but I'm just not buying it lock, stock and barrel. My gut reaction is that you're not telling the whole story.
Having grown up in a territorial center and watching a myriad of cadets passing through the training college doors to get commissioned, not to mention the parade of C.O.s and one or two DYS' I've had to contend with, some of whom turned out to be serial adulterers, pedophiles, mis-appropriators of funds (a nice way of saying thieves), sadistic masters of cruelty and just plain dumbklucks, it has struck me through the years that the Army's leadership will just about give anyone a chance who says they're called, unless there is something glaringly wrong on paper to begin with.
A case in point: When I was in college the Envoy who ran the local corps and was originally commissioned an officer when he was 20, was crying to me one day about how he was trying to get his rank back and kept on being rejected during the re-application process. I think I even shed a tear or two and blew my nose for him a couple of times.
A year or so later I discovered that since he left officership he had been divorced not once but twice (his wife at the time was both his first and third wife--later he also had a third wife in a fourth marriage) and he had also gone bankrupt in business while with his second wife.
God Bless You UK Soldier and I'm delighted that you were able to create for yourself a full time ministry and find an outlet for your sense of calling but since the territory you're from is hurting for officers even far worse than any of the four American territories are, are you sure you haven't left out a few little details in your lamentation? Like I dunno, maybe something about a rap sheet that's more than two miles long?
Best Wishes for the future....
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand With Jesus In the Morning!"
No, I'm afraid I have to disappoint you. Far from a lamentation, I have been able to positively move past the church's 'no', and that's a great blessing, something for which I'm grateful. There is an element it wouldn't be appropriate to share, it doesn't involve any wrong-doing on my part, at least to the best of my knowledge! After my app. being rejected by the army I then went through the usual selection process with another conservative evangelical organisation and passed without difficulty, so I hope there wasn't anything terribly wrong with me as an applicant - though I'm sure I'm far from perfect. I can't comment on the other points you raise, I've no idea how many they turn down, though I've lost count of how many I've met over the years. You may be right there are fewer than there's seemed to be to me, but I still feel quite strongly there's work that needs doing around the area of frustrated vocations and lack of vocational development and discernment generally for soldiers. This isn't just for the benefit of individual soldiers - it's to shake up the underlying culture to make the whole setting of a corps more life-giving. I keep hearing our territory is short of leaders, but then my feeling is the army already has all the leaders it needs, the problems are far more deep-seated and to do with how the army relates to and engages with soldiers. Just my impression, for what it's worth.
Thank You For This... I Too Have Been Knocked Back So Many Times And For No Real Good Reason.. The Army Don't Want Me Simple BuT At Lest God Does.. The Army Needs To Remember The Spirit Use It Discern With It.. Not Use There Own Opnions.
For you who've been rejected by the Army, please try to count it as a blessing. The Salvation Army is not all that it seems to be. Maybe your refusal was God's protection for you. By the large amount of 'formers', their initial acceptance came at a price.
Just remember, God doesn't make mistakes. Whatever happens in our lives that we see as failures are just lessons along the way, and our steps are guided by God - He only wants the best for His children, and although there are many sincere people in the army, I do believe many of them are there because they are in love with 'the army' and all its quaint idiosyncrasies, and not with the Lord Himself. Take away all the trimmings and what have you got? A largely ineffective spiritual source (with apologies to those who aren't so ineffective). Go with God - there are other paths than the salvation army.
I visited a friend last week. We looked at her session photos. Not a single one of the cadets is still in service. At the same time we know that gifted, enthusiastic soldiers have not been accepted for TC. And they have not been told the reasons even if they wanted to know. I did not appply because our DC said "you will not stay for a year after training college" How could he know? I´m still an active soldier, have been local officer for quite a few years. And I still feel that I should have been an officer. Now it is to late, but I have heard of a territory accepting a 60 yr old lady as cadet.
H.R - still in service
To Commenter # 5:
So you believe that those who serve in the Army (with of course the exception of a few--always a few--of course--otherwise someone like me who's written several inspirational "Salvation" and "Looking Back In Faith" stories for Priority Magazine might be able to take you to task on that one, if you made it as a blanket one size fits all statement)are more in love with the Army's quaint idiosyncrasies than with the Lord himself and that the Army is largely an ineffective spiritual force in the world today.
Well, I guess that settles it bitter sounding person. But where exactly did you ever get the idea that one (you) can tangibilitate the spiritual and quantitate the Reign of God (kingdom), knowing exactly what's going on in anyone else's heart and mind when it comes to their relationship with God?
Though I could easily be wrong, you sound as if since leaving officership you may have been influenced by pentecostalism or something along those lines, where signs and wonders are a dime a dozen and occur every minute. Such a criteria for spirituality is paltry at best.
I remember reading Brengle in which he wrote about a schism in Scandinavia over 100 years ago where a number of officers and soldiers left the ranks because they didn't think the Army was "spiritual" enough---as was some tongue speaking group they were all attracted to at the time.
Brengle pondered the possibility that maybe it was true and eventually came to the conclusion that the Army's work among the downtrodden of the world was just as "spiritual" (if not more so!) than whether or not people were all hopped up in their own spiritual ecstasies all of the time or not.
What's that line in the old hymn sung in many churches throughout the past two centuries? "Through deeds of love and mercy the Heavenly Kingdom comes!" In that regard the Army takes a back seat to no other denomination--and probably vice versa.
I think someone may need to go back to the drawing board (the Gospels) and re-read what Jesus had to say about spirituality and the Kingdom of God!
Daryl Lach
USA Central
"You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross, To Stand With Jesus In the Morning!"
Daryl Lach - from commenter 5
You do like to make assumptions - yours about me are so way off beam they are almost laughable. Alas, I have not witnessed ANY signs or wonders at all, and I am not an armchair viewer of the salvation army - I am very much 'in the ranks of the dear old army' still, although not - and never have been - an officer.
Your comment 'someone like me who's written several inspirational "Salvation" and "Looking Back In Faith" stories' made me smile - did anyone not tell you that self-praise is no recommendation? Surely it's for others to decide if they were inspirational or not? Methinks a touch of humility wouldn't go adrift.
But the title of your article 'Looking back in faith' typifies all that's wrong with the army today. Everything is 'looking back' in celebration - 100 years of this, 150 years of that - 40+ years of loyal service rewarded (even though it was done voluntarily). It's quite sickeningly sycophantic.
You quote Brengle - what he actually said was this:
It is not enough to wear the uniform, to profess loyalty to Army leaders and principles, to give our goods to feed the poor and our bodies to be burned. We must love one another. We must make this the badge of our discipleship. We must wrestle and pray and hold fast that we do not lose this.
The Army is so thoroughly organized and disciplined, so wrought into the life of nations, so fortified with valuable properties, and on such a sound financial basis, that it is not likely to perish as an organization, but it will become a spiritually dead thing if love leaks out. Love is the life of The Army. 'If we love one another, God dwelleth in us, and His love is perfected in us.' But if love leaks out we shall lose our crown, we shall have a name to live and yet be dead. We may still house the homeless, dole out food to the hungry, punctiliously perform our routine work, but the mighty ministry of the Spirit will no longer be our glory. Our musicians will play meticulously, our Songsters will revel in the artistry of song that tickles the ear, but leaves the heart cold and hard. Our Officers will make broad their phylacteries and hob-nob with mayors and councilmen and be greeted in the market-place, but God will not be among us. We shall still recruit our ranks and supply our Training Garrisons with Cadets from among our own Young People, but we shall cease to be saviors of the lost sheep that have no shepherd.
I believe that is where the Army is today. And please - don't (predictably) tell me to leave - for reasons I am not willing to share, this is not possible for me.
Former USA East.
I just heard that the Western Territory USA is having something concerning Formers. Why fifty years later? Why has it taken fifty years. I'm too old now and outnd I give my doantions of clothign and usables to the Vets. of it so long I don't even feel conencted anymore. I give to the Catholic Church in which I raised my three children. But I am glad to hear they are finally recognizing Formers . Keep trying . Don't give up.
Dear Commenter # 5.
I wasn't blowing my own horn as I did not make the stories inspirational. They were already inspirational. I just wrote them---and here's the kicker---they were all about people who have been greatly influenced by the Army and who are connected to the Army today. This includes both the looking back in faith stories and the Salvation stories.
My points are that 1. You, me or anyone else can't tangibilitate the spiritual, 2. Nauseating SA crapehangers have been around since the days of William Booth and Brengle and have in the long run been proven wrong and 3. God's Holy Spirit has always been and is still at work through the Army today the same as he is in any other denomination.
The "feelings of ecstasy" part of faith is a nice little feature on the side that helps all of us along the way in our lives but is never constant and in the end is probably not at all that important in the light of eternity or eternal values.
And btw, I also read your comment by Brengle a long time ago too. Since he also wrote what I said he wrote that just proves one thing: Life is full of paradox, now isn't it?
Daryl Lach
USA Central
P.S. And I still can't understand why anyone would voluntarily stay in a group and constantly infect it with their negativity if they're convinced that it's spiritually dead. Uh duh.
Daryl - there you go, assuming again. Despite my views here, I don't - as you say - 'infect the army with my negativity'. I am not so insensitive. They are my private opinions. I don't see it as negativity - just realism - as the army today is definitely NOT the one I joined awhile back. If no-one ever questions anything, nothing will change.
I am not decrying that people are still influenced by and are connecting to the army today - praise God for that - BUT - can you HONESTLY say you are inspired by the leadership? I can't. I've been to some 'congress' type gatherings of late, and they have left me wondering why I went. Some of my corps compatriots have also said they would not go again. They were mainly pomp and ceremony, with dirge-like songs - all carefully orchestrated and ALL centred in the past, the leaders/organisers oblivious of the present. I'm glad you are happy worshipping along 19th century lines, but I think old William would be turning in his grave at the way the church side of the army is going. He was always revolutionary, and in his day he did thought the unthinkable and did the un-do-able. Not so today. Members are stuck with clothes that no-one else would dream of wearing, music sections that belong in the last century (all very melodic, as Brengle said), music that doesn't reflect our modern age - we haven't had a modern music makeover since the Joystrings - revolutionary in their time, but over 50 years hence. We sing out of non-Army music publications because ours are dated and largely uninspiring. I want better than that for us. I don't want people to look at us and say 'how quaint'. Our leaders should be modernising. I want us to be relevant today, not a remnant of days gone by.
Again to quote Brengle (you can quote anything to make a point):
"... can I be so confident for The Army? His guidance, His overruling Providence, His gracious and mighty deliverances in the past are unmistakable, are on record, known and read of all men …. He has overshadowed The Army with a pillar of cloud and fire as surely as He did ancient Israel; He has gone before and opened the 'two leaved gates of brass,' as He did for Cyrus, and empowered Army Officers and Soldiers and made them more than conquerors, as He did the Apostles and saints of the Early Church; but do all these wonders of His favor and grace give assurance for the future? Is The Army sacrosanct? Are we favorites and pets of the Almighty? …
The future of The Army depends not only upon God ---- but also upon man, upon men, upon you and me and all who have to do with The Army. …The Lord is with you, while ye be with Him; and if ye seek Him, He will be found of you: but,' and here is warning for us to heed, for here lurks danger, ' if ye forsake Him, He will forsake you.' And this is a timeless prophecy, eternally true, and not of private interpretation, as true today as it was three millenniums ago; as true of The Army, of you and of me, as it was of ancient Judah and Benjamin and their king Asa; …' Let us search our hearts, order our lives, and be admonished.
In so far in the past as we have sought God with our whole heart, walked in His ways, and lived and wrought in the spirit of our Lord and Master He has been with us, preserved us, prospered the work of our hands, fulfilled the desires of our hearts, and blessed us in the presence of our enemies. Can we still confidently expect His favor for the future? Yes, and only, if we continue to abide in Him …..The warnings, the exhortations, the example, the close and intimate instructions of our Lord given to His disciples … show us the plain path in which we must walk, if the future of The Salvation Army is to be happy and prosperous and its great promise come to ample fulfillment. … we must not simply endure the cross, but glory in it.”
I honestly don’t see this attitude in my corner of the army, that’s why I’ve commented here.
And - btw - you don't have to understand why I stay. Maybe for nuisance value!
Post a Comment