Monday, April 9, 2012

An Army led … or an organization managed? PART ONE


If you always do what you always did,
You always get what you always got.
Ronald Reagan, while President of the United States, said that “status quo is Latin for the mess we’re in”. We cannot afford to be satisfied with the status quo. We must be open to deep change.
Over the past twenty-five years The Salvation Army internationally has made numerous changes organizationally, but without the hoped for and needed results. Take my home territory, Canada & Bermuda Territory, as an example. In 1980 when the Canadian population was 24,350,000 the Army had a membership of 99,127, an average of 4.1 per 100,000. Just over twenty years later, membership stood at 85,500, an average of only 2.8 per 100,000 given the rise in Canada’s population to approximately 30,750,000. This translates into a 32.5% per capita membership decline over the last twenty-five or so years. A similar tale can be told in virtually every Salvation Army territory in the west. What is at the root of this decline?
The problem goes deep into the fundamentals of our leadership base, steadily eroding our influence as a Movement, preventing us from accomplishing the mission to which we have been called, reiterated by General Gowans as “…to save souls, to grow saints and to serve suffering humanity”.
I believe that at the centre of our leadership crisis in The Salvation Army is the system of organizational leadership we deploy, namely an antiquated command and control model based on position and maintained at a distance. More and more organizational entities have moved to a networking model built around relationships, where power and authority are derived from being accessible.
We need to move from a managerial mindset focused on maintaining the status quo and doing things right, to a leadership mindset that values entrepreneurial thinking and is more concerned with doing the right things. We must move beyond superficial change, beyond simply reworking the familiar, to deep change that prayerfully and willingly embraces the realm of the radically unfamiliar and even the unknown.
FROM ‘COMMAND AND CONTROL’ TO ‘NETWORKING’
The command and control model, also known as the pyramid or hierarchical model, is rooted in the 19th century organization in which only a select few were sufficiently educated and trained to make the effective day-to-day decisions necessary to keep things running smoothly. Employees of such organizations were functionally cogs in the machine whose task was to carry out the orders of those above them. As cogs they neither truly understood the organization – its aims and purposes and structure - nor were they expected to. For the most part, they were illiterate. Viewed as having limited value they were essentially dehumanized and considered disposable.
This form of organization reached its zenith in the days of Henry Ford and his development of the car assembly line: workers needed only to know how to perform their relatively simple, repetitive task, and nothing else. Interestingly, the perception of organization as machine, inanimate, rational, static, compartmentalized, closed and the estrangement of humanity from nature was seen by Wordsworth and other romantics of the Industrial Era as an earthly image of Satan’s enterprise in Hell.
This subordination of skill and imagination to the rigid architecture of the machine effectively disallowed workers from expressing their natural creativity and ignored the fact that humans are inherently relational beings, driven by principles that are organic rather than mechanical, who were created to live in dynamic relationship both with God and those around us.
The networking model serves and promotes the notion of relationship above all. It is this model of organizational life that naturally fosters more congenial working environments which are more nourishing and favourable to growth.


No comments: