Saturday, August 13, 2011

Proposed law in Hungary could jeopardize small, new religions Part 2

Part TWO

International Human Rights Law.


Proselytism and accusations levied against TSA and others.

“Those who support greater restrictions on the activities of missionaries (particularly foreign missionaries) object to proselytizing for several reasons.
1. Proselytizing attacks other religious beliefs and practices in order to assert that its own way is the only way to salvation.
2. It is often supported by financial resources and marketing techniques that make local religious activity seem second-rate and shabby.
3. It is frequently successful.”

Orthodox Churches have long been opposed to proselytism and raised this issue during negotiations for admission into the World Council of Churches. In 1956 the Central Committee of the WCC met in Hungary and discussed a report on "proselytism and religious liberty." A final version of this report was approved in 1961 at the third assembly of the WCC. It defined proselytism as a corruption of Christian witness: "

“International law, however, does not make any distinction between religious witness and proselytism. It simply affirms that everyone has the right to freedom of religion or belief and the freedom, individually or in community with others, to manifest this religion or belief "in worship, observance, practice and teaching." The freedom to manifest one’s religion or beliefs may only be limited by laws that are "necessary to protect public safety, order, health or morals or the fundamental rights and freedoms of others."

It is no surprise that legal attempts in Central and Eastern Europe to limit proselytism have been heavy handed. The 1993 Amendment to the 1990 Russian Law on Freedom of Conscience and Freedom of Religion restricts the freedom of non-citizens in Russian to express their religious faith, a distinction which runs counter to the nature of religious freedom as a fundamental human right. Moreover, the Amendment attempts to impose burdensome registration and organizational requirements on foreign religious movements.

A more promising approach might be grounded on the following three principles.
• Such restrictions must reflect a compelling state purpose. That is, they must be necessary for the public welfare and not merely reasonable due to political pressure.
• However, restrictions on the "business" aspects of religious activity need only be reasonable and non-discriminatory.
• Restrictions on religious expression cannot be based on legal status but must be clearly defined in terms of behavior.

The first principle requires that restrictions on religious expression not simply reflect the convenience of government officials or the pressure of dominant religious organizations. Under international law, religious expression is given the benefit of the doubt, because - as a fundamental human right - freedom of religion or belief is deemed necessary for human dignity.

The second principle means that in carrying on its business, religious organizations must abide by the rules for all comparable organizations. Religious organizations may be required to file reports with state agencies, register to do business in a new location, identify their income, etc. — if comparable organizations are required to do so. Foreign visitors or employees may be required to obtain visas or work permits, according to procedures that are non-discriminatory. Furthermore, there is nothing in international law that prohibits taxing the income of religious organizations, so long as this taxation is carried out in a non-discriminatory manner.

The third principle suggests implementing legally the kind of understanding expressed by the World Council of Churches and Vatican II, rather than passing legislation which limits the rights of foreign missionaries in order to protect the rights of citizens. If certain activities expressing religious conviction violate the rights of others or threaten public safety, the state may legislate limitations on these behaviors concerning the time, manner, and place of such behavior. For example, a religious worship service cannot legally be prohibited, unless it may be shown to be a threat to public safety. But it need not be permitted on the sidewalk in front of the headquarters of another religious organization. Distributing religious literature cannot be denied, but can be restricted to certain behaviors in certain public places at certain times.

Under international law foreign missionaries cannot be excluded from a country, nor can they be subject to restrictions on their freedom of religious expression, which are not also imposed on the citizens of the country. However, if there are compelling reasons the behavior of both foreigners and citizens in expressing their religious convictions can be limited in a manner that does not discriminate against the foreigners.
Nationalism

Anger at proselytizing fuels nationalistic threats to religious freedom. For many in Central and Eastern Europe, religion is inextricably related to culture and national heritage. Most Orthodox Churches identify strongly with a particular ethnic and cultural history, which is represented concretely by a nation. Thus an Orthodox Church expects the state which governs "its" nation to represent and protect the interests of the Church.

It is perfectly understandable that those, who were oppressed under Communist rule, now seek through representative government to create laws that will assist the recovery of their religious tradition. They will not easily be persuaded that a neutral state, which does nothing either to help or to hinder religious life, is a better alternative than a state that identifies with the dominant religious heritage. Yet in these newly independent nations there are one or more minority religious communities. How are their rights to be protected, if the dominant religious tradition receives privileged support by the state?

International human rights law does not explicitly require a "secular" state. It does not contain a provision similar to the first amendment of the constitution of the United States, which prohibits the establishment of religion. International law requires states to "prevent and eliminate discrimination on the grounds of religion or belief" and to "combat intolerance on the grounds of religion or other beliefs". International law leaves open the issue of "establishment" because special "church-state" relationships are deeply embedded in many cultures of the world, as in Europe.

International law names the evil as "intolerance" rather than as "establishment", implying that some sort of "tolerant establishment" of religion is possible. Put more precisely, it leaves open the question of special relationships between the state and one or more religious traditions to an evaluation of the effects of such relationships on religious freedom, rather than asserting in principle that any support for religion by a government will necessarily be discriminatory.


Robert Traer served as the executive director of the International Association for Religious Freedom from 1990-2000, and in that capacity represented the work of the IARF on religious freedom at the United Nations. Dr. Traer now teaches courses on ethics at the Dominican University of California in San Rafael. In 2002 he was a Resident Scholar at the Tantur Ecumenical Institute for Theological Studies in Israel. In the spring of 2005 he served with the Ecumenical Accompaniment Program in Israel/Palestine, which is sponsored by the World Council of Churches, and in June 2005 he participated in the Critical Moment Conference in Geneva convened by the World Council of Churches and also drafted the conference report. He is a retired minister in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) and a member of the Bar of the State of Colorado. His writings on human rights are available at http://religionhumanrights.net, and his writings on environmental ethics are at http://doingethics.com. His work on Christian faith, ethics and interfaith dialogue are at http://christian-bible.com.

No comments: