Thursday, February 25, 2010

Ordination and the Art of War Part -2-

To this day, the Monarch of England is the Head of the Church of England, and defender of the faith. We still have the concept of military training and spiritual defence being intertwined.







Military strategists today around the world are, in the tradition of the ancient warriors, constantly redefining warfare, rewriting doctrine, re-evaluating the art of war. This is done by people who are specifically set apart to make it their life’s work, specifically trained for the task. Warfare today is very different to warfare in ancient times, yet the basic understanding and psychology still remains.

Why this discussion on warfare? Since its’ inception, The Salvation Army has understood the corollary between the mission of the church and warfare. It has understood the metaphor that we are in a spiritual war. Its’ structure reflects this understanding. But this is just the latest incarnation of church/military relationship. All of the church’s hierarchy, structure, etc, throughout history reflects this relationship – the realisation that we are in a war.

However, the one thing the church has not done as a whole, which those practiced in warfare know is integral to their very survival, is constantly re-examine and redefine warfare and doctrine. The very discussion nowadays around ‘the priesthood of all believers’ – suggesting we ‘flatten the playing field and make everyone the same rank’ etc reflects this. If the analogy between our spiritual battle and warfare is correct, then we need to learn from those practiced in the art of war. There is a requirement for a select group of individuals to be specifically ordained and set apart to study the art of our warfare, to redefine our war, to rewrite and redefine doctrine on a continual basis, otherwise our war is lost, just as it was in ancient times. The war changes. The fight changes. Our understanding of warfare changes. Our doctrine needs to change to reflect the changing war. Without a group of specialists set aside to do this, our war is lost.

If we want to see our churches full again, if we want to see the tide of our battle change again, if we want to see a revival again, we need to re-engage with the art of war, and rediscover our military heritage that goes right back almost to the dawn of time. We need to re-evaluate our faith – which is the battleground for our warfare, we need to re-evaluate our beliefs – which are the tools of our warfare. There is still a place for the faithful soldier who fights the good fight, however they are called to do so. But the core of the fight must be those who are specifically ordained to engage in the art of war. Such people, like the Draculs, will be doing a work no other can do. Changing centuries of belief and doctrine is not easy. But if we want to win the war – we must do it.


Graeme Randall
Former
Australia

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Interesting musings the Spirit has laid on your heart- challenging reminders that the battle is raging and we are expected to take up arms.

Thank you Graeme for a very thought provoking read.

Active
London THQ

Anonymous said...

Graeme,

This sort of passionate thinking gives plenty of reason why we should not resort back to being 'The Christian Mission' as has been favoured in recent years. We're an Army !

Thanks Graeme may God continue to bless, keep and use you!

Former UKT

Cheryl Hagedorn said...

Am I misunderstanding your use of the word doctrine? I thought you were writing about strategy, then I bumped into beliefs. I agree wholeheartedly with the idea of set-apartness and with changing strategies. Let's see tomorrow if I can keep agreeing! :)

Anonymous said...

I think that's one of the most depressing things I've ever read. 'Ordination', the professionalisation of clergy, creating a deadening divide between believers has been the crippling effect of Christendom on the church worldwide. It creates passive, alienated laity and puts absurd demands and expectations on 'clergy'. As we leave Christendom in the West and move into a completely different missional context the first and most burningly urgent thing we need to do is recover the passionate missional discipleship of every believer. If you want a military model for spiritual warfare, I suggest you move on from these antiquated and medieval images of rows of cannon-fodder soldiers being moved around by 'heroic' (and usually loathed, despised and hated) officers, and look instead at Al-Qaeda and explore more organic models of church. Warmest blessings,

'Fletch' said...

What an interesting response from ' one of the most depressing things I've ever read.' to 'Warmest blessings' in the space of 12 short lines.
Congratulations Graeme on a very interesting article that outlines very well where there is a difference in perception between the Military metaphor and the missional discipleship model. What is lacking in the latter is something that we have often been lax in developing in the army; the concept of leadership. I would agree with the last respondent although I would not want to use 'loathed,despised and hated' rather 'puzzled bemused and disappointed' by those who are in follower category who are angry that their own perceived leadership skill have not been recognized.
Good words Graeme sounds like a good conversation over coffee.

Cheers

Anonymous said...

To 'Anonymous - who started by saying this was a depressing read'.

To some degree, I actually agree with you, and I would have perhaps made the article more explicit if I had the space and felt people could handle some of the 'gruesome' facts that might have needed to be added.

You are right when you talk about the unrealistic expectations placed on officers etc. That I think highlights the point I was making about a specialised select group of people who are capable of doing this. Not all Officers then perhaps should be Officers. In ancient times, the core of the army camped outside from the camp, away from the community because as individuals, they were very different from the rest of the community. Psychologically, they were very different. They were perfectly suited (psychologically) to understand and debate the realities of war. War is messy, ugly, stomach wrenching, challenges individuals to the very core of their being etc. If this isn't happening to you, then I would suggest you are not engaging in war - just good works. Only certain individuals can handle that, and these are the ones who should/need to be at the core of our Army, and be the Officers.

As for your comment about more organic models such as Al-quaeda, well... that is what I was getting at when I suggested we continually redefine our warefare, strategies, doctrine etc.etc.etc. When you look at Al-quaeda (for example), you still find a core of highly trained individuals set aside (ordained) for the task of their warfare, and all the others follow. When was the last time you heard a report of any of the Al-quaeda leadership involved in a suicide bombing? - never. I agree, re-define warfare, strategy etc., make it more organic, but we still need that core of people that are fundamentally different from everyone else who are capable of doing this task.

Yours in Christ,
Graeme.

Anonymous said...

Further to above....

Re-read the story of Gideon - particularly the part where he selected his men for the battle - how he whittled them down to a small band. Many wanted to fight, many were eager, but only a very small handfull were real soldiers, who understood battle/warfare. These were the ones he wanted. These people thought differently, behaved differently, reacted differently to everyone else.

Just a thought.

Graeme.

Anonymous said...

Sven,

Thank you for all the additional information you put on your blog, keeping us up to date with SA activities and initiatives. Thank you for keeping us in touch and reminding us, although sometimes painfully of what we have let go of. Love all the additions ... Thank you! Keep up the good work for our sakes!

Former UKT

Anonymous said...

Graeme,

I would agree much of what you say is true.
I wondered about the warfare and battle that you suggest that officers should be involved with. If officers were like that , don't you think that there would be a loss of funding and income because many would be offended. I reflect back on prior articles about fundamentalism. I also consider some of the stands that may be taken on injustice and in other areas of disagreement.

USA East former

Anonymous said...

USA East Former,

That all depends on what stand you take and how the fight is redefined. It may be that fundamentalists will be highly offended and the secular Governments will increase our funding. It may be that in re-examining our warfare, our fight, etc., we may discover that what we once thought was the fight, what we once thought was the evil in the world, is not our fight, is not evil, is not sin.

It can go both ways. I suspect we would become a lot more liberal if we were to do as I have suggested above.

Yours in Christ,
Graeme

Anonymous said...

Interesting to note that the Salvation Army in New York is being "monitored" in some specific
social service programs.The Army was accused of proselytizing:http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/17/settlement-in-salvation-army-suit-on-proselytizing/. I understand that you have to have a balance but it may just mean so much compromise that Jesus will have to just leave.
This is a touchy subject and the door is now open for more removal of a Christian witness.
I became an officer almost 30 years ago to preach Christ in a non-combative way and to assist the needy. To me this dual role is very important and I wouldn't have served when I did without this dual purpose. An alternative is to not accept government funds. Maybe that should be the stand in New York. Time will tell.

Blessings

USA East former

Anonymous said...

from an article by Comm. Joe Noland


BEWARE! | The Spirit of Prophecy

Following is the opening sentence in a New York Times column dated February 17, 2010:

“To settle a longstanding suit alleging that The Salvation Army preached Christianity in the course of its government-financed social services work, an agreement has been reached to ensure that it does not do so.”

“An agreement has been reached…” that The Salvation Army “not” preach Christianity - A principle so many sacrificed and some even died for?

BEWARE!

The article goes on to say the SA “Agreed to be monitored”. What! Other agencies to monitor the nonfulfillment of its mission statement: “…to preach the gospel of Jesus Christ and to meet human needs in His name without discrimination.”

BEWARE!

It’s not about losing $50 million in government contracts is it? It’s not about preserving the bureaucracy is it? It’s not about partnering, secularly, to enhance a broken down, bureaucratically protected foster care system is it? It’s not about survival is it? It’s not about compromise is it?

BEWARE!

Believing that every spiritual leader is to be prophetic by Divine appointment, I do have a “beware” segment about the dangers and pitfalls of compromise in my book, Lean Right, Love Left: Balancing the Body. Getting involved with government contracts in this country always requires compromise, one way or another. This explanation prefaces the following excerpts (written in 2002):

This is the deeper problem for me, personally, and for these reasons I have never initiated a government contract in any appointment. I have inherited them, however, and some of the horror stories have only strengthened my resolve to abide by those first instincts. Over the years I have found that it is easy to enter into a government-funded contract but very difficult to exit from one, as we are beginning to witness. And when we are forced to make the exit, everyone loses.

As an aside, let me give a warning of caution to any organization thinking about wading into the bureaucratic federal-funding quagmire. When the funding is received (quite substantial amounts sometimes, especially in the large cities), an agency begins to broaden its employee base and enlarge its infrastructure. Increasingly, over time, the organization becomes dependent upon this additional funding for its very survival, not only at the local level, but also right on up through the hierarchy. What happens when a new political regime comes into office and the priorities change? What happens when new restrictions come into play, which are contrary to the mission and fundamental beliefs of the organization? What happens when those dollars are no longer available? These are hard questions that are better asked with foresight rather than in hindsight.

The full scope and ramifications of President Bush’s “Faith-Based” Executive Order are yet to be tested. You can be assured that it will continue to be challenged vigorously from the left.

The solution? Two choices: Christ or compromise. Compromise was not part of the Army’s founding ethos. But then, in those days, they were not “America’s Favorite Charity” either.

Anonymous said...

We sold our soul to the devil for a few United Way bucks.