Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Am I Really In ? (2)


I quote from that Officer article I wrote some years ago: Now this is not just true of The Salvation Army. Jim Peterson, writing in Church Without Walls, considers the question: We are accustomed to defining the church within a certain circle. We work at clarifying who is in, who is out; what the leadership structure is to be and not to be; what we believe and do not believe; which activities belong, which do not; and what behavior is appropriate and what is not. So the line between insiders and outsiders is clearly drawn.

This is defined by Paul Hiebert as “bounded-set thinking.” There is a boundary that sets the standard. As long as you fit within the boundaries, you are in. And often the boundaries tend to be behavioral, rather than of the heart.

But a second way of looking at church is what Hiebert calls a “centered-set,” one that is defined by how the members are moving in relation to the center. Belonging, Peterson tells us, then is not “a matter of performing according to an agreed-upon profile, it is a matter of living and acting out of commitment to a common center”. The centered set is one of both direction and motion. There is no one measuring stick that allows one person in or keeps another out.

And here’s our dilemma. We have both kinds of sets, both structurally and theologically, and there is a tension between them. We invite people in with a “come, just as you are” summons, which indeed is the call of Christ, and yet when they enter the path towards Christ, they run into the walls of the bounded set that say – “you can’t really get in – you’re in, but you have to do A, B and C in order to belong”. We are a holiness movement, and holy people don’t do ___________ (fill in the blank).

At its best, the Salvation Army is a picture of the words of Ephesians 2 from The Message: The Messiah has made things up between us so that we’re now together on this, both non-Jewish [non-Salvationist] outsiders and Jewish [Salvationist] insiders. He tore down the wall we used to keep each other at a distance. He repealed the law code that had become so clogged with fine print and footnotes that it hindered more than it helped . . . The cross got us to embrace, and that was the end of the hostility.

But we are not always at our best. We have developed our own law code, we hang onto the old ways because we love them, or we demand to sing only praise and worship choruses because we can’t stand that old fogey music. We are less than kind to each other. At times our attitude is “us four and no more”. We invite people in, but put up barriers to their membership. In too many cases, we don’t want “those people” to join. We are content with a bounded set as long as we are on the inside (end quote).

If this concept fits congregationally, it also is applicable to the ranks of officership. As long as you fit within the boundaries, you are in. Once you step outside, apparently regardless of the reasons, you’re out. You no longer have the right to wear red on your shoulders. Now does anyone outside the organization really care about that? No. But I’ve listened as a friend described her anxiety the first time she entered a corps in soldiers’ trim. There is a bounded set, and she didn’t belong anymore.

It is what it is, and we don’t have the power to change how others perceive. What has helped me as I’ve made peace with those days of uncertainty is my determination to live as a centered set woman. As I focus on living and acting out of commitment to a common center, that being Christ, I become less and less mindful of what are really the peripheral ways of belonging. In fact, I kind of like life on the edges. A post-it on my office computer reminds me daily of Father Andrew Greeley’s words: “I understand that to be on the margins of the academic world and on the margins of the Church is a grace, a blessing, great good fortune. The “stranger” who is not constrained by rigid structures may be a wonderful inkblot for the sick or the troubled. He is also blessed with freedom.”

In or out? Perhaps, like the post-modernist, I ended up chosing the both/and rather than the either/or. It’s been a hard won determination, but here it is: I can be both in – and out – and healthy, holy, content. When the set feels closed against me, I can re-model in a new, centered set that brings two or three people together whose sole purpose is to move together towards Christ. It may start with a prayer fellowship, or a discipleship group, but it is a set that understands Richard Rolheiser’s description of ecclesiology: “walking to God within a community.”

So, my precious reader. You bring a fellow struggler, and I will too. It may be that we’ll meet William and Catherine (themselves ex-New Connectionites), and maybe a Martin or two as we go. And as we walk together towards Jesus, we will sing a song and tell a story, and others will join us as well.

Christ be with me, Christ within me,
Christ behind me, Christ before me,
Christ beside me, Christ to win me,
Christ to comfort and restore me,
Christ beneath me, Christ above me,
Christ in quiet, Christ in danger,
Christ in hearts of all that love me,
Christ in mouth of friend and stranger.
Hymn – St. Patrick’s Breastplate

Major JoAnn Shade
USA ET

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

JoAnn,

Thank you for both the challenge and the encouragement of your articles. I am now sat here with a very strong sense of 'we are IN this together' whether we are former or active Officers. 'IN' it together because of our identity in Christ. Let me share a benediction with you and all other readers:

'Go in peace,
And may the Christ who walks on wounded feet walk with you on the road.
May the Christ who serves with wounded hands, stretch out your hands to serve.
May the Christ who loves with a wounded heart open your heart to love.
May you see the face of Christ in everyone you meet.
And may everyone you meet see the face of Christ in you.
This both now and forevermore.'
Amen

FORMER SALVATION ARMY OFFICERS FELLOWSHIP said...

Further to my post of yesterday, wherein I mentioned the questioning of some that our fellowship is becoming more "inclusive"... accepting articles from active officers.

The majority of the private emails received are supportive/encouraging in opening the blog to active officers; accept and post their articles.

The blog counter we employ clearly identifies the country of each visitor and in most cases the home city. In many instances it also identifies the "server" and we know that many SA centers visit and read the articles. This is very encouraging as it demonstrates the interest the organization to which we faithfully gave many years of our lives has in our fellowship and activities. 



Most of us will know the name JoAnn Shade, a prolific and excellent SA author and regular contributor to THE OFFICER. I'm delighted, as I'm certain you are, that this (very) active officer has shown interest and taken the time to share with this fellowship. This first contribution from an active officer is most relevant. I have also received an article from an active UK officer, and yet again, one that speaks specifically to our unique fellowship. (Will be posted in mid-April)

There are many levels of inclusiveness, of belonging to our army. And many, if not most, perhaps even some of us, see officers as being those who "most belong", or think of themselves as being the "inner circle".

No longer being "in", "belonging", for whatever reason, can indeed cause angst. However, every article written to date speak to the center of our belonging, Jesus Christ. He is the Captain of our salvation and the Spirit that invites all to fully and completely belong to Him, and in so doing, belong to each other. The SA is incidental in this inclusiveness. In Christ there is no east or west –no exclusivity -nor any separation no matter the rank or duration of devotion. Christ is all, yes all in all. 



This Spirit uniting fellowship is open to all… "Whosoever will may come..."

Blessings, Sven

Anonymous said...

I welcomed the invitation from Sven to provide an opening point of dialogue between an "active" voice and the FSAOF internet community. As one who has been labeled from time to time as a radical or dissident voice, I rarely hold fast to the party line, so hope that my voice can be one that is between those who are 'in" and those who are "not in".

I also hope that as an active SA officer, I can have some role in effecting changes in policy that will provide some relief for those who desire to continue in officership, such as in the areas of single spouse officership, and in being able to maintain rank (and pension) if an early retirement is a needed choice (and to do so in a way that is financially realistic for the officer).

I am convinced that if the Army is going to move with a viable, effective presence into the future, we must as an organization wrestle with providing more kinds of options for service, as I believe was John Gowans' intention with the Lt. concept. There must come a day when song 780 is banished from the songbook (I cannot leave the dear old flag, 'twere better for to die). People change. Organizations change. Callings change. Think of Paul and Barnabas . . .

I appreciate being able to sit at this table of fellowship.
JoAnn

Anonymous said...

Thank you JoAnn for sharing of yourself through this blog.

Yes, when on the Sunday we leave the citadel and the trappings so familiar and dear to us, we must do so recognizing that, that is all they are...

When the music fades
All is stripped away
And I simply come
Longing just to bring
Something that's of worth
That will bless Your heart

I bring You more than a song
For a song in itself
Is not what You have required
You search much deeper within
Through the way things appear
You're looking into my heart

I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You
It's all about You, Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You
It's all about You, Jesus

King of endless worth
No one could express
How much You deserve
Though I'm weak and poor
All I have is Yours
Every single breath

May God bless all who come to this fellowship and all those whom we serve...

Two Servants of Jesus
UKT

Anonymous said...

Thank you Major (Sister) JoAnn, for sharing your voice, and thank you too for joining with what I have learned is a truly catholic fellowship. For many years I felt excluded, hurt, bruised, and alone until they "took me in".

I am certain I speak on behalf of many when I say, please continue to share your thoughts with us. It means a lot to have "actives" show concern...

Bless you, Former Officer
UK

Anonymous said...

It strikes me that a number of officers find that their first encounter with TSA is when someone had "taken them in." That early embrace is a wonderful one, and a holy one, and it makes a lot of sense as to why, when that relationship is severed, the pain is so deep. Even coming from a healthy family and a church background, the embrace of the Army for me was powerful, especially through working at summer camp.

Imagine the child or teen from a troubled home, who finally finds a place of safety and care in the Army. Even years later, that attachment that began so long ago still matters, and so when it is ripped apart, a void occurs that hurts. Perhaps a key is to separate those early, precious memories in some way - kind of like being able to keep the photo album after the divorce. Even though the ending may be painful, it doesn't change the earlier days when the sun was bright and life seemed good.

JoAnn