Issue Analysis: Is Evangelical Opposition to Homosexual
Behavior and Same-Sex Marriage Collapsing?
May 20, 2014
Evangelicals will, inevitably, "change with
times," "adapt," "get with the program," "finesse
their position" on homosexuality and same-sex marriage, some say. Historically, however, the churches that changed with the
times have not fared well.
Opposition to same-sex marriage and the belief that
homosexual behavior is sinful is "collapsing" among religious
adherents, William
Saletan wrote May 1 for Slate. "Theology is adapting.
Resistance to same-sex marriage is dwindling, and there's no end in
sight."
Saletan finds support for this contention from the recent
"Faith Angle Forum Conference on Religion, Politics & Public
Life" hosted by the Ethics and Public Policy Center.
He pointed out that Michael
Gerson, a Washington Post columnist and a graduate of the evangelical Wheaton College, said it "seems unfair" to expect "a heroic ethical
standard" of celibacy from church members with same-sex attraction.
Additionally, Cornelius Plantinga, a Calvin
College theologian who has written
books about sin, told Saletan over dinner that a lot of virtues, such as love,
commitment and stability, can be found among same-sex couples.
Saletan also noted that Russell
Moore, president of the Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics & Religious
Liberty Commission, "continues to view homosexual behavior as sinful"
but called for a change in tone in how evangelicals talk about the issue of
homosexuality.
"Maybe Moore and his remaining flock can sustain a
moral case against homosexuality in the face of these concessions. But I doubt
it," Saletan wrote. "Once you accept the reality and persistence of
the orientation, particularly within your congregation, you're on the way to
the crisis Gerson described."
The "crisis," in Saletan's view, is that those
with same-sex attraction are asked to remain celibate while, for instance, a
glutton can still eat food and adulterers can still have sex with their spouse.
Based upon that, Saletan reasons that the Evangelicals who believe
homosexuality is a sin hold an "unsustainable" position.
Gerson and Saletan are likely correct in pointing out that
some sinful desires are harder to resist than others. But all Christians are
asked to resist sin. What is missed in their assumptions is that a sinful
desire for gluttony will not be satiated by eating a normal amount of food and
a sinful desire to cheat on one's spouse will not be satisfied by g sex with
one's spouse.
Evangelicals are "pretty good at ditching unsustainable
positions," Saletan continues, because many Evangelicals do not hold a
Young Earth Creationist viewpoint. (Saletan uses the word
"Fundamentalists" here, but from the context he appears to mean
"Evangelicals.") If Evangelicals can hold different views about the
age of the Earth, there must be some wiggle room on homosexuality, he
concludes.
The comparison with Young Earth Creationism is a poor one.
Young Earth Creationism, rising in response to modern geological findings, is
only about 100 years old. (There were, of course, theologians, philosophers and
scientists before that, who attempted to date the Earth and came up with "young"
numbers, but that is different than the modern phenomenon to which Saletan is
referring.) The dominant Church teaching on homosexuality, on the other hand,
is as old as the Church itself. The teaching found in some churches today that
homosexuality is an "identity" that should be embraced rather than
sin, a symptom of the fallen nature of mankind, is new, about 50 years old, in
the history of the Church.
Saletan correctly points out, though, that the trend in
public opinion has been toward greater acceptance of same-sex marriage. So,
will the Church die if it does not change its position on homosexuality? The
Christian Post asked Moore that question in a May 12 interview.
"This is what the media have always said about
Evangelicals and they've always been wrong," Moore answered.
Instead of Young Earth Creationism, Moore brought up the
examples of miracles and the virgin birth. During the Fundamentalist-Modernist
debate of the early 1900s, Moore noted, people were making the same arguments
that Saletan and others are making today. Instead of homosexuality, however,
they were saying the Church must no longer hold to the views that Mary was a
virgin when she gave birth to Jesus, Jesus performed miracles, and Jesus was
resurrected from the dead.
There were some churches, of course, that did
"adapt" to the "changing times" by abandoning Church
teachings on the virgin birth and miracles. Those churches, Moore pointed out,
are the ones that have been dying.
If changing Church teaching in order to be culturally
acceptable is the way to grow the church, "we would see a booming
Unitarian or Presbyterian Church (USA) church planting movement. We don't.
"Instead, the only Christianity that has survived is
authentic, Gospel Christianity. Which means that ... you can't grow Christian
churches by becoming sub-Christian," he said.
Further, Moore argued that if the Church abandons the
concept of sin, it will not have much to offer the world. Those who do not need
to repent of sin have no need for grace.
"If we don't call people to repentance for sexual
immorality," he said, "we are not Gospel preachers, we are leading
people in sin and in condemnation and in the accusation of the Devil. The only
way we can reach a lost world is by speaking clearly about what sin is so that
we can speak clearly about what grace is."