Saturday, March 12, 2011

WE'VE GOT IT WRONG SINCS WE BEGAN... PART 1


Street corner bands, trucks collecting repairable items, red kettles, ringing bells at Christmas time, and soup lines are well-known marks of the internationally publicized Salvation Army. This is an organization that is hailed as a paragon of virtue by most religious people.
The Salvation Army is widely acclaimed for its charitable trust. It operates hostels for homeless men and women, employment bureaus, general hospitals, dispensaries and clinics, leprosaria, homes for unwed mothers, children’s homes, boarding schools, and hotels. It publishes periodicals in many languages and serves meals to the hungry. Many would conclude, therefore, that such an institution is worthy of the highest praise. And we would be unfair if we failed to point out that there is much to admire in the humane disposition that characterizes those of the Salvation Army.
However, it is a fact that is undeniable to any informed student of the New Testament that the Salvation Army is a human organization unauthorized by the Bible. Many of its doctrines are totally contradictory to New Testament teaching, and therefore cannot be ignored. The welfare of eternal souls is at stake.

The Origin of the Salvation Army

The founder of the Salvation Army was William Booth. Booth was born in Nottingham, England, in 1829. As a young man he joined the Methodist Church and shortly thereafter, about 1844, he allegedly had some sort of “conversion experience” which led to his becoming a revivalist preacher a couple of years later. In 1862, he left the Methodists to “evangelize” among the poor. Booth started the East London Christian Mission in 1865; the name was changed to “The Salvation Army” in 1878.
According to its charter issued in New York State in 1899, the Salvation Army is an organization “designed to operate as a religious and charitable corporation” whose paramount purpose “is to lead men and women into a proper relationship with God”(What Is the Salvation Army?, pp.8-9).

The Organization of the Salvation Army

The organizational structure of the Salvation Army bears not the slightest resemblance to that of the church revealed in the New Testament. Rather, it is more akin to the hierarchical system of Roman Catholicism. The international headquarters is in London and is under the authority of the international “General.” The General operates through a “Chief of Staff” into various overseas departments where limited administrative decisions are made.
“In the United States, the Army is divided into four Territories, with headquarters in New York, Chicago, Atlanta and San Francisco. Each has its own commander with rank of Commissioner or Lieutenant-Commissioner. There is also a National Commander with headquarters in New York. . .” (What is the Salvation Army?, p. 10).

The Doctrine of the Salvation Army

The official creed book of the Salvation Army is The Salvation Army Handbook of Doctrine, published by the International Headquarters in London. The “General Order” which prefaces the book states:
“This volume contains an exposition of the principle Doctrines of the Salvation Army as set forth in its Deed Poll of 1878.”
“These Doctrines are to be taught in connection with all Salvation Army Officer’s training operations, both preparatory and institutional. It is required of officers of all ranks that their teaching, in public and private, shall conform to these eleven Articles of Faith.”
Their claim that the Scriptures constitute the only “divine rule of Christian faith and practice” is therefore, misleading (Article 1). The doctrines and practice of the Salvation Army give evidence that they do not have a correct view of the authority of the Scriptures, which leads one to ask this question: What is the virtue in filling a man’s belly with bread and beans, if, at the same time, you are poisoning his soul with false doctrine? The good deeds of the Salvation Army are not to the glory of God, for Jehovah is to be glorified through the church for which Christ died (Eph. 3:21). Indeed, their publicized charitable works only compound their potential for doing eternal harm to innocent souls.


About the Author



Wayne Jackson has written for and edited the Christian Courier since its inception in 1965. He has also written several books on a variety of biblical topics including The Bible and Science, Creation, Evolution, and the Age of the Earth, The Bible on Trial, and a number of commentaries. He lives in Stockton, California with his dear wife and life-long partner, B

Monday, March 7, 2011

Euthanasia and Human Organ Harvesting - Counterpoint II



The above discussion (see part 1) needs to happen first so that we can begin to remove some of the peripheral issues that cloud the subject of euthanasia.  We can now begin to look at the subject of Euthanasia as its’ own subject.  One first needs to define what Euthanasia is before we can even begin to argue one way or the other.  The medical definition of Euthanasia is:
1. an easy or painless death. 
2. mercy killing; the deliberate ending of life of a person suffering from an incurable disease.  

The legal definition is; ‘The putting to death, by painless method, of a terminally-ill or severely debilitated person.’  Colloquially, Euthanasia has come to be simply understood as ‘the ending of a persons’ life on compassionate grounds to alleviate suffering, where there is no possibility of cure or of returning the individual to an acceptable level of functioning.’  Yet this is by no means a simple statement.  There are at least four concepts in that one statement that are highly subjective, and grounded in cultural and religions relativity.

Note that in both the medical and legal definitions, there is no mention or allusion to the concept of suicide in any form.  A form of manslaughter may be implied – however, this is very difficult to prove.  It is only in the moral and religious debate that euthanasia is interchangeably used with assisted suicide, suicide, and murder.  These are very different concepts and cannot be argued in the same debate or with the same logic or arguments.  In other words, when one is talking about ‘Euthanizing an individual in order to make use of their organs’, they are talking about manslaughter or murder of some sort – not euthanasia.  Remember – in any medically related debate (which includes Euthanasia), the mantra of the Hippocratic Oath ‘first, do no harm’ must be pre-eminent.

Since the conception of medicine in ancient times, the ability to extend peoples’ lives has complicated the very concept of when life ends – or when it is supposed to end.  By extending life, are we usurping the divine authority of God to take life?  Are we setting ourselves above God by intervening in the natural order of things?  Does prolonging life inflict unnecessary harm to an individual, thereby violating the sanctity of life?  I cannot and won’t answer these questions for the general population or for the church – they must be individually wrestled with.

One of the arguments presented by those who oppose euthanasia is that there is always the option of palliative care for the final days of the dying.  However, palliative care cannot adequately relieve the pain of those suffering towards the end of a terminal illness or the end of their life in general.  It can take the edge off the pain, make the patient as comfortable as they can be, but it cannot relieve their pain without causing their death.

Psychological interventions have proved useful in being able to significantly improve the subjective quality of life for women with metastatic breast cancer (final stage) for a period.  However, at some point, all women, regardless of the intervention received, find themselves in the same place as those with no intervention (see Barbara L. Andersen ‘Psychological Interventions for Cancer Patients to Enhance the Quality of Life’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1992. Vol. 60 – Other references can be supplied).

Even still, medical science has created a situation where many people can live longer, productive, symptom free lives, where previously they would likely have died years ago.  In the 1800’s you could die from a broken bone.  Today, diseases such as Diabetes, heart disease, HIV, Hep. C, etc. can all be treated extremely effectively with medication, resulting in individuals living symptom free lives until they die of old age. There are many body parts that can be replaced with either biological or mechanical parts.  People have steel hips, artificial hearts, mechanical ears.  The first generation of mechanical implants to restore sight are being tested in human subjects.  Surgeons can transplant hands, and even a face.  One can envisage that in the not too distant future, the question will become ‘when do we stop replacing broken and non-functioning body parts and allow the individual to die?’  In other words, euthanasia is only an issue because of the culture we live in – with all its’ medical and scientific breakthroughs.

We cannot discuss the morality of euthanasia without discussing the morality of extending physical life.  

If God has given humans the ability and responsibility to be able to extend life, treat, and cure all manner of ills, then surely we have also been divinely given the responsibility to know when not to extend life, or when to end it.  This even extends to people who are suffering degenerative conditions such as Alzheimer’s and other dementia related conditions.  Such conditions can be argued as simply being a consequence of modern life.  We have created a situation where such conditions exist.  Surely then, people have the divine right to decide when enough is enough.

Another argument that is raised against euthanasia is that it undermines the morals and values of society.  The argument is one of moral relativism.  It is argued that for Christians to accept any form of euthanasia is to submit to the moral relativism of secular society.  However, when we look at Christianity closely, we realise that the argument against moral relativism does not have a place in this or any Christian debate as Christianity has always been, since its’ inception, a religion of moral relativism.  Let me explain.
In the book of Acts – at the council of Jerusalem (Acts 15:19), we find the apostles instructing the new converts – in particular the Gentiles – to abstain from food offered to Idols.  However, in the later part of Pauls’ ministry, we find the Apostle Paul having no trouble eating food offered to Idols.  ‘I am all things to all people’ (1 Corinthians 8:1-13, 9:22).

Throughout the history of the church, moral teaching has altered to fall in line with society.  At the beginning, the early church accepted the Jewish tradition regarding marriage – where girls as young as 12 were offered as wives to men 3 and 4 times their age.  Even in William Booths day, the church supported keeping the age of consent at 14.  It was only the campaigning of William Booth and the early day Salvationists, along with moral reformers at the time, that raised it to 16.  The church originally supported slavery, and the holocaust by the Nazis.  It was secular movements which largely brought about social and moral change.  Church teaching was altered to lend weight to, and come into line with, the emerging secular morality.  Yet even that was often seen as a form of fringe theology at the time.  Today we could not conceive of a Christian theological moral teaching that does not condemn slavery or the actions of the Holocaust, or underage sex.  The list goes on and on and on.  There has never been a uniquely Christian morality (with the exception of a morality of love – whatever that may mean).  So, one cannot argue against euthanasia on the grounds of Christian morality.

What perhaps is most disturbing in this debate amongst Christians is the assumption that we are talking about ending life.  Yes, all life is sacred.  To end life is sacrilegious.  But to a people who believe in the immortality of the soul, how can we end life?  Surely, from a Christian theological perspective, to end life is to eternally remove oneself from the love of God.  Ending someone’s suffering will not have that effect.  The deeper question to ask is ‘what is life?’  Is human life the same as animal life?  If it is, then how do we justify our treatment to animals?  If it isn’t, then why do we assume that ending physical life is the same as ending life?  When we say that man is made in the image of God, we cannot mean mans’ physical image or life as we are so imperfect.  If physical life is the image of God, and that is why euthanasia is wrong etc (as is the traditional argument), then we are in effect saying that God is imperfect.  By argument then, we have proven that God doesn’t exist.

The issue perhaps is not about the ending of a persons’ physical life, but about our own understanding and acceptance of death.  A very good study for someone to undertake might be to compare peoples’ views on euthanasia with their concept of death and the afterlife.  And then compare those results with their willingness to accept the loss of a loved one.

The debate around Euthanasia is not about whether it is right or wrong to end a persons’ physical life, but about our own inability to accept death, and the loss of those we love.  And if we must couch the debate in terms of the sufferer, then let us make a distinction between ending suffering and any form of suicide and/or murder.

Euthanasia is a complicated enough debate as it is.  It does not need to be complicated further by confusing it with some form of suicide or manslaughter or murder.  Neither does it need to be further complicated by bringing into it the discussion of human organ harvesting.  These are all separate debates.  When we examine the legal, medical, and ethical issues surrounding human organ harvesting, we realise that the debate cannot be linked to euthanasia without repealing laws around human rights which are a corner-stone of the western world.  The debate around euthanasia needs to be carefully defined – and anything falling outside of that needs to be considered either a form of suicide or manslaughter or murder.  Carefully defined, there is nothing in the concept or practice of euthanasia which is contrary either to the dignity of life or biblical teaching.  However, as mentioned in the introduction to this article back in part 1, these concepts must be wrestled with by the individual.







Graeme Randall
Former
Australia

Friday, March 4, 2011

Euthanasia and Human Organ Harvesting - Counterpoint I

The subject of Euthanasia is extremely controversial.  Advancements in science and medical treatment has meant that the subject is discussed in contexts which until modern times was unthinkable.  The debate has been confused through poor definitions and understanding as to what Euthanasia is, interchangeably using terms such as suicide, assisted suicide, and murder.  Add to this confusion and controversy, the growing pressure for human organ transplantation, the black market in human organ sale, and you have an extremely complicated and quite messy debate.  This article will attempt to briefly touch on these subjects.  It will look at some of the legal questions around human organ harvesting, outline some of the complexities in the modern Euthanasia debate, and propose a different understanding as to what Euthanasia is in the modern world.  It is not my intention to answer any of these questions, but to ask them in such a way as to stimulate debate in a different direction.  These questions must be wrestled with and answered by individuals.  It must be noted that the two subjects being discussed – Human Organ Harvesting and Euthanasia – are two totally separate subjects.  It is only because of the fear that one might lead to or stimulate the other that the two subjects are being discussed in this one article.

Human Organ Donation and Organ Harvesting
Recently, there have been media reports about Governments receiving pressure to change the process of human organ donation to relieve the shortage of acceptable donor organs for transplantation, and combat the growing black market in human organs.  It is feared that this may in fact stimulate the black market in Human Organ trade – leading to people either being pressured to end their lives or being involuntarily euthanized in order to harvest their organs.  The change that is being agitated for is to remove the requirement for consent for organ transplantation.  What is not understood is that due to a misunderstanding of international and federal laws, such a change could never be seriously considered in any western country, or any country which aligns itself with international law.  In essence, the legal confusion stems from the concept of ownership of deceased persons and their organs.  In order to understand this, we need to go back to the days of slave trading.

In countries were slave ownership and slave trading were legal (which at one point in time included the whole world), there was a very well defined concept of ownership of slaves.  The slave was legally the property of the slave owner.  The slave owner could do what they wanted with the slave.  Beat them, sell them, kill them, etc.  This included owning the body of dead slaves.  With the abolition of slavery, came the concept that no human can be owned either in whole or in part by any person or groups of persons – including the state.  It wasn’t only slaves who were owned or considered property of another person.  Women and children were considered the property of the closest male relative.  It wasn’t until the emancipation of Women, and the establishment of legal rights for children, that the concept that no human could be owned was universally applied to all humans.

These laws even extend to the deceased person.  It means that the only person who can ‘own’ a human organ, is the person in whom that organ originally resides – unless they have voluntarily transferred ownership (by donation or sale) to another person.  In cases where consent is sought for organ donation of a deceased person, the consent is not sought because the next of kin (or state) is the legal owner of the person and their organs, but because they have a responsibility to act in the best interest of the person when they are incapacitated.  It is the same reason why parents are able to make reasonable decisions on behalf of their children because a child is legally unable to speak for themselves, or carers of mentally disabled on the grounds of diminished mental responsibility.  The important point to note here is that the decision must be in the best interest of the deceased person for the decision to be legal.  Without repealing laws regarding slavery and the rights of women and children, the current movement towards removing the requirement for consent for organ removal can only be seen as scare mongering at best.


Another consideration in this subject is the legal implications resulting from poor medical decisions regarding organ harvesting.  There is no way of accurately knowing who has diseased organs and who doesn’t.  By the time tests were done to determine this to a satisfactory level, the viability of the organ would be severely compromised.  An example.  It is estimated that approximately only half of those men over 50 who are HIV+ have been diagnosed.  In other words, there are a lot of people in society who do not know they have HIV (USA CDC&P.  Further references can be supplied).  If organs from those people were transplanted into relatively healthy persons, they could be infected with the virus.  Yes, the implantation process almost certainly destroys any blood-borne virus (including HIV).  However, viruses such as HIV can hibernate in the fatty tissues of human organs.  When the organ is transplanted, the virus is then free to replicate itself in the blood stream of the new host.   The legal implications for this would be astounding.  That is just one example.  Multiply that by the number of other diseases in our society for which there is no cure and we have a legal nightmare on our hands.  For this reason alone, no such change to a system of consent for organ removal could be considered.  One could argue that testing for disease become mandatory for all individuals, and that a database be established with such results.  That would satisfy the above legal problem.  However, it would constitute a major breach of human rights and freedoms which no Government (at least in the west) would be prepared to commit.  Such an action would inevitably end in the destruction of any such political party.  Just look at the various uprisings around the world in support of human rights to see that this is true.


The medical profession itself would have to oppose any such change.  The Hippocratic Oath by which all doctors and medical professionals are bound not only applies to living patients, but to deceased patients as well.  In other words, the mantra of ‘first, do no harm’ paradoxically applies to the dead as well as the living.  Implicit in the Hippocratic Oath is the concept of the eternal nature of human beings.  When a doctor is removing an organ from a deceased person, they must ask ‘is this harming the individual?’  It is for this reason that medical professionals cannot release the body of a devout Catholic for cremation without violating the Hippocratic Oath as this violates the sanctity of the individuals’ eternal identity.  The same applies to organ removal in regard to some beliefs and practices.

A popular alternative to the current system of consent in places like the UK and Australia (the US has a similar but slightly different system) is that of presumed consent or ‘opt-out’ – where all persons in that country are presumed to have consented unless they have actively ‘opted-out’.  Yet even with this system, there is still a form of consent.  In those countries which have this system, there is no significant difference in level of organ donation with those who don’t – in fact, Sweden (which has presumed consent) has a lower level of organ donation than the UK (which doesn’t).  Neither is there a significant and sustained increase in the level of organ donation after implementation of presumed consent that cannot be attributed to other factors.  In fact, due to the medical and medical ethical considerations above, medical professionals in those countries generally still seek some sort of consent from next of kin, and obtain a medical and lifestyle history of the deceased from available family and friends before harvesting organs.

There will always be a black market in this field.  The problems associated with the black market in organ donation cannot be solved through attacking the practice, but by addressing the situation which leads to the practice.  This means ensuring that all people are adequately compensated for the work they do (something William Booth tried to address with the cab-drivers charter) – so that people are not tempted to buy and sell human organs in order to make some money, and investigating alternatives to organ transplantation – such as using suitable animal organs, or mechanical alternatives.  No alternative to the consent laws regarding organ donation will adequately solve the problem.  We also need to ensure that current laws are enforced regarding the unlawful harvesting and sale of human organs by various means.

Graeme Randall
Former
Australia

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

BODY PARTS NEEDED: TO CONSIDER...



Ronald Reagan, while President of the United States, said “status quo is Latin for the mess we’re in”.

As Christians a great deal of the blame for the  ‘mess we’re in’, the status quo, can be laid directly at the feet of our local churches, our Pastors and in the lap of our politicians. Rev. John H.W. Stott says that our dissatisfaction with the status quo, if of sufficient consequence, ought to move us to action formulating in our minds a new vision for our society, culture and generation. Christians (Salvationists) ought to act steadily to thwart the erosion of our traditional values, to accomplish that to which we have been called, “…to save souls, to grow saints and to serve suffering humanity”. We need to return to a mindset that is concerned with sustaining traditional human values. And in moving to do so we will need to engage and team with those who don’t share our faith or values.

Many postmodern people say they believe in God, but their faith is vague and undefined. When they are asked what they believe about God, they are unable to articulate anything specific. Their non-creedal spirituality leaves them knowing little about the God we worship, adore and serve. Their spirituality passes for religion allowing a social tolerance that boggles intellectual tolerance. In the sight of God we are all equally valuable and we all have certain fundamental rights that are either God given or that we grant to one another in order to create harmonious communities.

In the postmodern world, all beliefs and belief systems are considered to be relative. We are told that there is no absolute truth; faith is simply a matter of private opinion. Consequently, one person's faith is no more valid or unique than anyone else's. 
So, how do we preach in a world that is culturally pluralistic? We do so by being aware of: 
1. The spirituality of postmodern people 
2. The uniqueness of Christianity 
3. The need to be spiritually faithful yet also socially tolerant 

The result is the postmodern belief that (1) faith is whatever a person makes it to be and (2) each person’s faith is valid, but not unique. 

When we reach out to postmodern people, we should never assume that they understand basic Christian doctrine. They’ve been bombarded with postmodern spiritual psychobabble and ‘self-actualization’ leading many to wrongly assume that all religions are the same, when in fact each religion is unique because each reflects a fundamentally different worldview. Salvationism, in this sense, along with many Christian strains, is unique among the world’s religions because in it God’s holiness and love are one. The Christian worldview teaches that we need to be spiritually grounded yet love all; to be tolerant. 

We need to be aware that Christian as well as humanist circumstances alter virtues; a precept where a quality which is admirable in one society may be seen as suppressive to another.  The ‘good will’ we as Christians intend (Emmanuel Kant) might be seen as corrupt(ed) by others; not the ‘good will’ that they would expect of us.  An extension of reason is necessary (tolerance), and it is always the extension of an area in which we can exercise responsibility.  Freedom in this regard is extended in accordance with an increased understanding. 

This is an area that many conservative Christians will find difficulty in accepting.  For us to become relevant in questions of social values (salt and light) we cannot remain blinded by out-dated teachings, notions or taboos.  No doubt many Christians today considered abortions and divorce abhorrent to their religious doctrine just 25 years ago.  Yet, today it is seen by them as a matter of choice; free will. The decisions can be made without judgment and condemnation

I believe the answer lies in our adopting both a “social tolerance” and also an “intellectual tolerance”. If a society is to continue to function it is important that the limits of the social toleration of each cultural and ethnic group is explored and acknowledged.

Those who believe in the Christian notions of God will cling to a truth (logos) that morality is defined by the very nature of God; an inherent, unchangeable quality of the universe created by God. Those who do not believe in a God will argue that social conditioning creates morality. What they term morality is in fact ethics; the current acceptable values practiced in a society (culture-religion). However, ethics, the values that bind a society to act with tolerance, are constantly changing. And as they change, compromises are enacted that further move society from what was an earlier moral compass. Often these winds of change will even effect a society’s/country’s laws, e.g., slavery, immigration policies, apartheid, euthanasia and infanticide.

We are all individuals and in the sight of God we are all equally valuable and we all have certain fundamental rights that are either God given or that we grant to one another in order to create harmonious and pleasant communities. One of these rights is the right to have privacy in some (but not all) areas of our lives. 

Life is a gift of God, but one must consider that once gifted, the life belongs to both, the Giver and the receiver. And that life is also shared, gifted, to family and friends. And it is in this sphere where we exercise our free will. The best way to return our life to the Source is by offering it to our neighbor.

The will to live is strong. Why then would some people willingly choose an early or expedient death? Or does such decisions find peace in God's perfect plan? Many will answer, ‘When it is our time to die, we will go’. Does our God given gift of our free will ever allow taking one’s own life or that of another? Is mental anguish or unceasing physical torment not sufficient forms qualifying as acceptable moral motivators? 

The basic religious disposition is that there ought to be authoritative norms. In this view, efforts to promote personal freedom must always serve a higher loyalty rather than simply clear away obstacles to self-expression. This inclines the religious person to identify with the party of established mores.
·  Does an affirmation of moral and religious authority give us the hope of something greater for ourselves?
·  Does it create conditions for a culture of responsibility and a sentiment of solidarity based on concern for the well being of others?
Does it affirm an abiding authority of moral norms that encourages building social capital?  (American Grace: How Religion Divides and Unites Us, Robert Putnam and David Campbell)

FOR REFLECTION
Societies prohibit acts like euthanasia and suicide for one or both of two reasons - protecting the individual losing his or her life, and preventing development of culture and values harmful to the society in the long run. 

The issue of organ transplantations is important and calls for profound theological reflections and discussion, so that the Church (TSA) can utter its substantial position on an all-Christian, rather than on solely parochial levels. 
 

1.     Can we exclude the possibility of a miracle as an unlikely event?
2.     Can a Godly intervention be excluded?
3.     Can the Church support the removal of organs before the definite dissolution of the interrelation between soul and body? 
4.     Who can know the moment the soul departs from the body?
5.     Should any intervention to remove the donor's organs before his/her definite death be unacceptable because it means taking away the donor's life?
6.     Is it morally acceptable if this is done for the sake of curing another person?
7.     Does the end not justify the means?
8.     Does the value of saving a life outweigh that of the life being naturally snuffed out, even if helped a bit in the process?

Medicine is faced with a dilemma and is called to proceed in deciding, if the one can ultimately build his/her life with the ruins and remnants of the other's life, ought they not rush to complete the harvest and transplantation? 

 

Is there a religious tradition that assists in answering if or what might give someone the power to ask for his/her heart to be stopped by doctors instead of letting the heart stop on its own later? 

The Church text is quite clear recommending intervention on a living being. The "Prayer in the agony of death" in the "Mikron Euchologion” includes the sentence: "Free Thy servant from this intolerable grief and his/her pursuing bitter disease, and comfort him/her among the souls of the righteous". 

 Book of Wisdom 3:1 But the souls of the righteous are in the hand of God, and there shall no torment touch them.
3:2 In the sight of the unwise they seemed to die: and their departure is taken for misery,
3:3 And their going from us to be utter destruction: but they are in peace…

Who will assume such a responsibility, or is it the logical assumption that man’s free will is supported by ancient church’s position and recommendation? 

When asked in an interview on 12 February to respond on the growing secularism and militant atheism characterizing Western Europe General Elect Linda Bond responded; “It’s essential that we look at our teaching resources.  The SA must make sure it has in place a program of teaching and training … we need not only to know Jesus but also to be convinced of our standing as Christians, and convinced of our mission as Salvationists.

Around 60.000 people enter SA buildings for various weekday activities in the UK; considerably more than we see in our halls on a Sunday. Ought we not to capture this opportunity in sharing those issues that concern our society and us as Christians?

Monday, February 28, 2011

BODY PARTS NEEDED Conclusion C


Since the 1970s, when organ transplantation was still in its infancy, a spirit of altruism was promoted in organ procurement programs, and at least initially successfully implemented. However, voluntary organ donation fell far short of the need for human organs. Only 28% of the potential UK donor base has joined the Organ Donor Register. The most recent statistics available at the time of writing; ((February 28, 2011) in the last 11 months, 
• 2,383 people have received transplants 
• 7,735 people are still waiting for transplants.
Of these, approximately 10%  will die while waiting as there are not enough organs available. 

The debate about acceptable approaches to human organ acquisition focus on the four main methods of acquiring human body parts: 
• donation (expressed and presumed) 
• abandonment 
• sale 
• societal appropriation 

Today, four decades since the debate ensued, all four methods are generally deemed culturally acceptable although two ethical concerns remain; is selling one's organ a justifiable means to fight poverty and the right to decide what to do with one's corpse. 

Another more recent ethical concern is assisting in the expedient departure of those existing at less than acceptable living conditions. Do Christian ethical standards clash with those espoused by humanists and secular society? 

Transplant surgery is saving lives, and concurrently has created a ‘lively’ trade in human body parts spurred in large part due our innate desire for longevity. The supply-and-demand is feeding the frenzied booming international black market of body parts and brings together the rich recipients and the destitute, and sometimes helpless donors. Surprisingly, the biggest participant in the trade are unscrupulous Western pharmaceutical companies seeking to profit from marketing their latest products that have derived from the procurement of human body parts. 

Two differing views are commonly heard in the debate on euthanasia: 
1. That it is wrong to take someone else's life or to urge someone else (eg a doctor) to do so to alleviate suffering 
2. That humans should have the freedom to ask others to give them help to end their lives to alleviate their suffering 

Euthanasia (Grk = good death) implies that there is a benefit to the person involved. However, there is a great difference between reality and what they are supposed to be. Therefore, prior to deciding on which side to come down about euthanasia we need to be clear about what constitutes euthanasia and how it is to be executed. 

Active or voluntary euthanasia 
Generally this describes a decision by a patient, with the support of others, to end his/her life, because a terminal or degenerative illness has led to a painful existence with a very poor quality of life. 

The following views on euthanasia appear to be shared by most Christians. Any positive action to speed up the demise of a person that will lead to (painless-good) death should not be encouraged or legalized. Conversely, withdrawal of treatment - particularly the life support system of intensive care units - should be legalized, when the patient desires it. This system is already in wide use.

Christians base their beliefs mainly on the Bible, where, they believe, they can find God's teachings for all people of all cultures and at all times.

Can we dismiss the Old Testament words where
 God’s key instructions were given to the Hebrew people:
1.     ‘Let us make man in our image, in our likeness.' - Genesis 1:26

2.     You shall not kill (one of the Ten Commandments) - Exodus 20:13

3.     The life of every creature and breath of all people are in God's hand - Job 12:10 
We find the same importance placed on human life in the New Testament in these words:

1.     Look at the birds of the air.....are you not more valuable than they? - Matthew 6:26

2.     Even the very hairs of your head are numbered (by God, that is). - Matthew 10:30 

Can the Nazarene healer’s words, ‘no greater love than that a man lay down his life for his friends’ be translated as encouragement to us in offering our lives to save the physical life others? He is the founder of our faith and example in holy living, and cared for people who had a poor quality of life and for those who were regarded as vulnerable, living on the edge in his society. Each person mattered to him. Life is God-given and therefore has intrinsic sanctity, significance and worth. In a near to death scenario with two of God’s children struggle to live, but with only one having even a remote chance of life, should the other die and his body parts transplanted, ought we to approve of euthanasia? Or ought the Christian watch both die? Would it make a difference if the person being ‘saved’ was a loved one? When asked if they would support speeding up death through withdrawal of treatment in order to harvest organs for restoring one’s own or a family member’s quality of living most Christian would express a willingness based on the ‘greater good’ argument. 

Christians are called to a relationship with all God’s children characterized by such words as respect, responsibility and duty. Human beings, as moral agents were assigned the highest value above all other creatures in that we have the capacity to make free and responsible choices. Our reason for being is found in our relationship with God, in the exercise of freedom and in our relationships with one another and the wider community. 

We know that one day the 'sting of death' (1 Corinthians 15:55) will be removed forever. Until then we have a God appointed mandate to care for the weak and needy, to visit those who are sick and in prison, to clothe and warm the naked and to provide dignity for the dying. 

We need to ask ourselves if our actions are helpful or harmful; to ask, is this what a Christian should be doing. Just because sinful things are being practiced more and more, it doesn’t make them less sinful, and we need to stop and think about how we are being affected by this negative influence. We need to remain unaffected recognizing that sin is sin no matter how popular our society says it is, and even though it may be practiced legally. No amount of legislation will ever make wrong into right. 

While serving in Moscow, Russia in the 1990s I asked a newly arrived senior Dutch Salvation Army officer during a coffee break at the CIS HQ about his early impression of Moscow. The topic was the new ‘openess’ evident in Moscow society as reflected by the open cannabis smoking, prostitution, and practiced gay lifestyles. He replied, “for someone who has spent their life in the Netherlands nothing is ever surprising or shocking”. He was then asked, “do you think Holland is too liberal and have things been allowed to go too extreme?” His response? “We’re not liberal, we like to think that we are instead among the most tolerant of all Western nations…” 
  
Tolerance is a word that has become increasingly fashionable in the last few decades. Tolerance is most often the result of another factor, compromise. The word tolerance is never used in relation to the things that we deem good and pleasing. Rather, the aspects of life that we tolerate are things that annoy us or that we do not like. And, accepting them results from lessening our resolve, compromising our values, our standards. . If we choose to tolerate something it’s generally in the form of some tradeoff; we do so because we perceive that there is some greater good that we wish to attain/maintain or some greater evil that we wish to avoid. Often, for tolerance to succeed it requires stages of acceptance and in those stages controversial issues are passed through the process of compromises. 

Yet, there is more to tolerance when it comes to looking at it through the lens of one’s faith. There is tolerance that endangers one’s faith, and there is tolerance that lends to and enhances it. Tolerance and compromise are attributes that are not always synonymous with virtuous characteristics or actions. Too often they signal a compromise achieved at by giving up too quickly; not having a solid enough argument pro or con. Often, it’s nothing more than a cloak for cowardice. We lack the conviction that our faith and causes can be communicated effectively and convincingly. 

A simple definition of tolerance is that it is, "a fair, objective, and permissive attitude toward opinions and practices that differ from one's own.". Being tolerant, according to this definition, is to be non-judgemental. The Bible tells us in Matthew 7:1, "Do not judge or you too will be judged" (NIV). Christians need to demonstrate love and avoid putting conditions on that love, yet recognizing that a neutral perception of the limits of tolerance is nigh impossible.

 For the time will come when people will not put up with sound doctrine.
Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them
 a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to hear.
They will turn their ears away from the truth…    2 Timothy 4:3-4 (NIV) 


Does Christian tolerance require us to be active? In view of the many modern media concepts and processes ought we to exercise a more active tolerance? Tolerance has a fine line, one that blurs both the humanists’ and Christians’ sense of fairness when seeking the other’s viewpoints. None should argue or negotiate from false or an undefined position with the intent to proffer false compromises; we should be tolerant of one another enough to listen and love one another despite our difference. 

John Stuart Millís On Liberty (1859) is unanimously considered as the milestone of modern liberal tolerance. Tolerance is a fair, objective, and permissive attitude toward those whose beliefs or personal characteristics (race, religion, nationality, etc.), differ from one's own. Further, tolerant means not harming the other. This harm can be emotional, mental, physical or economic, and can be caused by condemning the other, insulting him, making him feel uncomfortable, avoiding his presence, discriminating against him and so forth. 

Surely this is what we are all supporting and working for in our journey as a risen community.

In view of our responsibility as witnesses of the Gospel, recognizing that the present day western European culture dismisses the Bible’s validity in defining human values we must know our own, the bible’s, and the receptors culture. 

We must explore and establish proper channels of communication by which we can share our Biblically mandated principles. 

We must begin at the felt need of the receptors and we must initiate communication immediately because the receptors base values continue to shift and erode. 

Christians need to enter a covenant solidarity to battle the cultural collective solidarity of a people. Insensitivity to a cultural evil is often the consequence of denying its existence in one’s own society or the distance from its current threat. Covenant solidarity ultimately reflects a people’s commitment to the Gospel and the ability to have that understanding impact on other fellowships. It means communicating; points of effective contact to points of effective attack. 

In the New Testament the verb epistrepho translates as the verb shub. It means to turn, bring back or return. It is used in relation to the turning of unbelievers and erring believers into a right relationship with God. Another term used in the New Testament is metanoeo which means to change one's mind or to regret. Both these experiences can lead to repentance. However, in this instance the emphasis is on the conversion to a new set of thinking, accepting a new form of values. 


Is there a lesson to be taught here? Is there still sufficient time to make a difference?



Dr. Sven Ljungholm
Govan Citadel Corps

Friday, February 25, 2011

BODY PARTS NEEDED Conclusion B








Conclusion B

As virtuous men pass mildly away,  

And whisper to their souls to go,  

Whilst some of their sad friends do say, 

"Now his breath goes," and some say, "No."
John Donne

There exists great ambiguity of the transition between life and death, and for practical and ethical reasons we, as a society, have had to define life and death, and we do it in various ways. The definition turns on various philosophical and theological issues focusing primarily about using people for the benefit of others, prior to their death. Many argue that the definition be adapted to facilitate doctors’ need to get human organs before they become unusable; dead.

Most organ donors on reading the phrase ‘after my death’ assume all life is absent. What it really means is that the person is comatose and apneic but in fact all other organs are working fine and that the removal of organs can begin with my heart spontaneously beating and blood circulating.

The  rationale for equating “brain death” with death remains controversial. Thus, information highly relevant for the potential donor’s moral decision making is systematically withheld. According to Dr Robert D. Truog, Professor of Child Anaesthesiology at Harvard University and director of ICU at Children’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston “ ‘brain death’ remains incoherent in theory and confused in practice.” He suggests that the only purpose served by the concept is to facilitate the procurement of transplantation organs

Assistant Professor of Neurology at the Ohio State University, Dr Robert M. Taylor, defines death as “the event that separates the process of dying from the process of disintegration” and emphasizes that “the proper criterion of death in human beings is ‘permanent cessation of the circulation of blood’. Dr Emmanuel Panagopoulos, assistant director of the 2nd Surgery Clinic at “Agios Savvas” Hospital in Athens  and Professor of Surgery at the University of Athens, explicitly states  that  “ ‘brain death’ is a process of death but not death”. Biological death is not a continuous process but an instantaneous event.

A person is dead if he shows:

·      irreversible cessation of circulation and breathing
·      irreversible loss of all the functions of the entire brain, including the brainstem.

Nonetheless, the  ‘brain death’ criteria is not universally accepted. The difficulties in diagnosing ‘brain death’ were shown in a 1989 study concerning doctors and nurses involved in the harvesting of organs for transplantation. The study proved that “only 42% of the doctors and 25% of the nurses correctly identified the legal and medical criteria for the definition of death, which revealed the confusion around the issue.” Furthermore,  a more recent study in 1999 presented to the Society of Critical Care Medicine demonstrated that “only 39% of pediatric attending physicians correctly defined brain death…
______________________________________

Defining Death for the Purpose of Effecting Organ Transplantation:
Religious and Humanist Ethical Considerations

The concept of ‘brain death’ has come to be considered as a state of relative neurological inactivity and as an approximate diagnosis. Professor Shewmon writes that the diagnosis of death is not something that we can discover by any scientific method, but rather something we must choose, based upon our religious and philosophical values”. For the Christian human death is not a process but an instantaneous event during which the ‘logical soul’ leaves the human body.
The conclusion which follows the presentations of the above data is that the concept of ‘brain death’ is a construct which was basically invented for social reasons. Nonetheless could it not serve the Christian community well: ‘brain death’ would signal that one is no longer able to continue in a state of communication with God and all worship, adoration and honor will have ceased.

The Harvard criteria listed two reasons for trying to sort out brain function criteria for certification of death: (in determining an appropriate time for organ removal)

·      The burden of futile treatment.
·      The facilitation of organ donation.

According to Jim Hughes, a bio-ethicist at Trinity College in the United States, the idea of brain death has distinctly cultural, utilitarian origins.

Under the law and our general moral revulsion to the idea, killing somebody to take their organs out wasn’t acceptable until a person was declared dead. As a result a kind of a social compromise was constructed to serve the needs of the living.

There has been a small but growing collection of voices questioning whether the brain dead are really dead at all. One of those dissenters is Alan Shewmon, Professor of Neurology and Pediatrics at UCLA Medical School in the United States;
”Well, the term itself is kind of ambiguous from the start, because in one sense it could simply mean death of the brain as an organ, just like you can have necrosis or death of a finger, if you cut off the blood supply to it

It is clear that hearts can beat independently without brain function, and many other organs continue on their own, even without life in the remainder of the body. But what we’re talking about here is not just the functioning of individual organs or tissues, but a more unified holistic functioning. Many patients in the state of brain death… these patients are deeply comatose, permanently comatose but they’re still living human beings.

Those practices which hasten death or bring about the direct termination of life, in order to harvest organs for transplantation trivialize the human person and lead society down a slippery slope. Most of us would happily donate one of our organs after death, for the sake of another human being. But are we prepared to have our organs removed while the heart is beating and blood circulating; to be removed at the time of the so-called ‘brain death’? How was the term ‘brain death’ coined? Why all this controversy in the Greek and international medical community? Why do some doctors deny that ‘brain death’ is equated with the definitive biological death?

Since the concept of ‘brain death’ is not unanimously accepted by the national or international medical community many suggest that the equation of ‘brain death’ with death should be re-examined. And, that such reexamination be removed from any and all interests whatsoever.

The issue of organ harvesting for transplantation is important and calls for profound philosophical and theological reflection. Any intervention to remove a donor's organs before his/her definite death is unacceptable because it means taking the donor's life, even when this is done for the sake of curing another patient. Or does the end justify the means. Is there no longer any mystery of death?

By all means our life is the field of exercising our free will. In order for change to be meaningful for the Christian, indeed society, it must be definable and sustainable and making a positive difference. Dare we say it must be Spirit-led, yet in some circumstances radical, pushing us beyond our comfort zone, the status quo. Can we see the Lord’s leading in having us reanalyze our life moving along horizontal axis of man-to-man relations and agree with those whose motives are plainly humanist driven?

Can we Christians see as the goal, one of obtaining organs for transplantation only after a declared ‘brain death’ and where the heart may yet be living and the donors’ giving of an organ is as an expression of Christian love or simple altruism. Or is the proper criterion of death in human beings the permanent cessation of the circulation of blood, even if  adopting this criteria life saving organs can not be harvested causing death to waiting recipients?

"Life is a gift of God, but not one that belongs to the donor only. It also belongs to its receiver. Life is ours as well. It is the paramount field of exercising our free will. Life is not donated to us in order to live in selfishness and possessiveness, but is rather offered to us so that it can be so much our life that we can even offer it. This is the reason why we love and take care of our life more than anything else. This is done both with great caution, because it is God'’s gift, and in our free will, because it is our life. The best way to return it to God is by offering it to our neighbour." (Saint Macarius the Egyptian).

Dr. Sven Ljungholm
PhD Ethics; Human Values