Thursday, January 6, 2022

God and the Gay Christian


 

Matthew Vines, God and the Gay Christian(New York: Convergent Books, 2014) 213pp

 

The response of churches to lesbian, gay, bi-sexual and transgender people is a hotly debated subject, both within and without church communities. In the churches, opinion is somewhat polarised between those accepting of people in same sex relationships and those opposed. The dividing line between or sometimes within churches is often drawn between those who take a conservative view of scripture and theology, and those of a more liberal persuasion. The former usually point to certain texts in both Old and New Testaments as prohibiting same-sex relationships, while the latter are sometimes more likely to regard such prohibitions as irrelevant to modern life, like the Levitical rule against eating shellfish.  

What is distinctive about Matthew Vines’ defence of gay Christianity is that it is written by a gay Christian who is also a conservative evangelical with a high view of scripture. His claim is that “Christians who affirm the full authority of Scripture can also affirm committed, monogamous same-sex relationships.”

There are six passages in the Bible which are taken as referring to homosexual behaviour, three from the First Testament and three from the New:  Genesis 19:5, Leviticus 18:22, Leviticus 20:13, Romans 1:26-27; 1 Corinthians 6:9 and 1 Timothy 1:10. Vines sets each in context and brings to bear upon them the consensus of scholarship. His conclusion is that none of them addresses the phenomenon of “committed monogamous same-sex relationships” as understood today. He supports this with an examination of the ways in which sexual relations were viewed over the centuries. In fact Vines claims that the Bible does not address, or condemn, same-sex orientation, which was not actually recognised as an issue until the twentieth century.

Naturally not everyone will be happy with Vines’ conclusions. It might be argued that he is just selectively defending his own preference from Scripture and history. Quite apart from the fact that the same accusation could equally well be levelled at people taking the opposite position, it also has to be said that this writer is able to examine and critique unsustainable claims made by some sharing his own views. Others will suggest that regardless of the scholarship he brings to bear upon the particular Biblical passages in question, Vines misses the whole drift of Scripture which would lead to different conclusions. He, of course, argues precisely the opposite. The reader must judge.

Vines’ introductory chapter sets his arguments in the context of the experience of young gay people growing up in conservative churches and trying to find their way, often with unhappy consequences as they often lose their faith and sometimes their lives. Those most willing to examine his arguments may be their friends and families, whose pain no-one should minimise. Claims to love the sinner while hating the sin can sound a little hollow when real people are involved. Vines’ own parents, who did not at first accept his position, came in due course to support him, even though it eventually meant leaving their church community for another. 

Vines also suggests that we learn to adopt more eirenical language in our debates. He suggests that rather than “pro-gay” and “anti-gay” or “homophobic” or such expressions, all parties might adopt terms like “affirming” and “non-affirming”. This might help temper attitudes on both sides of the debate with a modicum of mutual respect. 

This is a divisive topic for many church fellowships. Salvationists have the options of ignoring it and hoping it will go away, or of seeking to inform themselves as to the arguments and their implications. Recently the New Zealand Moral and Social Issues Council conducted a survey of Salvationist attitudes towards same-sex relationships, the Tri-Territorial “Thought Matters” theological conference in August is about “a Christian view of sexuality” and may therefore discuss the matter,and there is an unofficial ‘Salvos for a More Inclusive Church’ Facebook group on the web [Ed—email the editor for more information].All of these suggest that some are paying attention to this subject.  

Salvationists ought to be well-informed and it would be a good thing if we were able to discuss the issues, about which inevitably there will be differences of opinion, without the painful and personal divisions encountered in some other places. Matthew Vines’ God and the Gay Christianis a book which could be recommended to conservative Christians who want to work out a balanced view of the matter and are prepared to consider respectfully and dispassionately views and arguments with which they may not agree. 

  

 

Monday, October 11, 2021

REFLECTION 

Major Howard Webber encourages us to trust  Jesus amid the storm  

‘WE’RE all in the same boat’ is the claim made by many about the coronavirus pandemic in these past few months. But is that true? We are definitely in the same storm – we are all affected by what is happening – but are we really in the same boat?

In Mark’s account of Jesus calming the storm (4:35–41) he tells us something that neither Matthew nor Luke mention in their accounts: ‘There were also other boats with him’ (v36). Why did those people launch their boats? Jesus didn’t appear to command them to take to sea and cross to the other side as he did his disciples.

We are told nothing further about those boats or what became of them. Were they swamped by tumultuous waves? Did they sink? Did they make it back to shore? We’re certainly not told that any of them arrived safely on the other side.

Whatever their fate, of one thing we are certain: the boat carrying Jesus did make it. When Jesus said, ‘Let us go over to the other side’ (v35), there really was no question that they would not arrive there, just so long as Jesus was in the boat.

However, it’s not easy when what you are experiencing is frightening, when your life is falling apart, when things you value are stripped away and when you can’t see where it is all leading but the real danger of being sunk without trace and losing everything is clear.

Our boats in this situation are very different. While some of us have experienced the worst that this storm can throw at us, for others the experience has been milder. For many this storm has meant the loss of loved ones or pain and suffering from the virus. For others it’s meant the loss of jobs and income, isolation, the inability to meet up with friends or family and all sorts of stress, fear and uncertainty. The storm may not now be as strong as it was, but there is little sign of life returning to the calmness and order we once knew. Although we are all affected, some of us are far more affected than others.

‘Where is the Lord in all this?’ we may well ask. We are probably not too judgmental towards those fearful disciples who woke the sleeping Saviour so aggressively with, ‘Teacher, don’t you care if we drown?’ (v38). But did anyone ever care more for them than Jesus?

He surely knew what lay ahead before they all got into the boat. He led them into that storm. Was it to show them that, even in the worst of circumstances, all will eventually be well if they have him on board? Or, as he slept on the cushion, that they could know peace in even the most violent of storms?

Jesus revealed his power over the elements by calming the tempest, but had he not done so and had the waves gone on to break up the boat, would he not have saved his disciples and got them to where he planned?

When Paul experienced a wild storm off Malta that lasted more than a fortnight, all the cargo was jettisoned overboard before the ship eventually broke up (see Acts 27:18–41). Yet everyone aboard survived. The Lord was with Paul and had told him in the midst of the storm that he would stand before Caesar. However perilous, frightening and destructive the storm, Paul knew he would come through and get to where God would have him be.

Saint Pio of Pietrelcina said: ‘Stay in the boat in which our Lord has placed you, and let the storm come. You will not perish. It appears to you that Jesus is sleeping, but let it be so. Don’t you know that if he sleeps, his heart vigilantly watches over you?’ That thought is echoed by an anonymous writer in the devotional book God Calling, edited by Arthur James Russell: ‘Life with me [God] is not immunity from difficulties, but peace in difficulties.’

In one storm after another, Job, that ‘blameless and upright’ man of God (Job 1:8), was stripped of all that was dear to him with no explanation. Yet he said of God, ‘Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him’ (13:15 King James Version).

You and I, like John Newton, will experience ‘many dangers, toils and snares’ (SASB 453), but with Jesus aboard God’s grace will surely lead us home.

 

 

MAJOR WEBBER LIVES IN RETIREMENT IN BOURNEMOUTH