Wednesday, August 12, 2015

ABUSE BY INDIFFERENCE II



Due the hundreds of comments, pro and con, from 'formers' and actives, we are unable to link them by subject or territory and share them ad hoc and unedited.
The FSAOF
__________________________
A symposium of officers and lay people was held a number of years ago at Jackson's Point Conference Center when the Canadian territory had two relatively enlightened leader Christine McMillan was the TC and Glen Shepherd the CS.

Out of that Symposium came a vision and recommendations for the future of the Army in the Canadian territory. In particular there were recommendations about changes in governance, transparency and accountability.

My understanding is that McMillan and Shepherd presented these recommendations to the General Shaw Clifton and they were turned down flat. Their successors in the Canadian territory were the relatively conservative Commissioners - Bill and Marilyn Frances from the USA.

 Where did the good recommendations from that symposium end up? Probably buried in a filing cabinet somewhere. Such a shame - there was potential for significant change after that Symposium. Instead the conservative reins were pulled in by Clifton and TSA is far past the critical point.

We are continuing to follow the path of the YMCA on route to becoming a social organization with Christian origins run by employees. The fact that we still exist is interpreted as God's blessing on us. How misguided can people be? Many secular organizations run very successfully. Even as a charity in Canada we have been publicly given C and D ratings in all categories - exception one B, no A ratings. The edge of the cliff has long since been fallen off of - the time for change passed us many years ago.

I guess miracles can happen but with this archaic autocratic structure it makes even miracles impossible where loyalty and obedience to a system is so valued.

Sven, I fear you and your colleagues are preaching to the converted. It is clear to me that the SA leaders have their heads buried in the sand and are far more concerned about their position if power than realistic changes that need to happen for the Army to move forward. Who in their right mind would want to stay in such a movement? Movement, that's a joke.
UKT

Just to add to the stories of ill-treatment of Officers - although slightly outside the main stream.

 My father-in-law was an Auxiliary-Captain in the then Salvation Army Assurance Society in the UK. A full-time appointment with provided quarters.

He had a heart-attack and died very suddenly one morning at 5.50am. 

ontaining a few trite words of condolence and a request that she vacate the premises as it was needed for the next appointee!


There is nothing new about the Army's callous treatment of Officers and their families.
UK


What have I missed? I'm a newcomer to this discussion alerted to it by a fellow officer.

I know many ex-officers and some have spoken with me about this group, but I never realized that they represented such a large number of former officers, and from so many territories.

 Are our leaders blinded by the numbers, the sophistication, the wisdom, the unique insight, the growing strength, the pure resource that the Former SAA Officers  Fellowship offers? Am I to understand that no attempt has been made to enter dialogue?



The recruitment and retention of officers is one of the most critical threats to our Army's future. Let's move out of our complacency and accept the fact that we don't always know best! 

An offer of help has been extended - We don't have the advantage of time on our side and need to accept this magnanimous gesture from a group that seemingly has all the answers at their fingertips.

 Active SA Officer

USA DHQ East

I fear debate about the structure is to miss the point: the problem is the people within it. I firmly believe that the current structure, at all levels, serves the organisation well.

I do not believe that the approach and attitudes of some of the people that serve within it best further the cause of the movement in either the presentation of who and what we are to the public or, sadly, enables us to stride further and effectively in a cause ‘to win the world for Jesus’. 

A previous commentator is quite correct, the Canadian territory, at that time, was led by ‘enlightened’ leaders; perhaps, ahead of the time but courageous enough to see that the territorial situation demanded changed approach.

Unfortunately, the General of the day, and the succeeding territorial leaders, were known for their conservative, risk-averse approach and, as stated, ‘the time for change passed’.
Canada is now led by a leader who was pulled out of relative obscurity and tracked up the ladder by … General Shaw Clifton. It is therefore unsurprising that some of the traits that obviously caught the previous General’s attention – conservative, safe-pair-of-hands, - are now manifest in his leadership of the territory. 

To my mind, the issues of officer retention and recruitment hinges on trust and confidence.

Sadly, the movement is riddled, in every area, with deficiencies on both wings. The structure is merely a framework and the problem is that many of the people who sit-at-desks lack the skills and, in too many cases, the personal integrity to allow trust and confidence to grow and flow from them. The system seemingly, in too many cases, prospers, however that might be defined, the wrong people: how can a field secretary that would not know the truth if it hit him the face and, at the same time, be utterly bereft of inter-personal relational skills end up at that desk? Yet it happens and far too many times to make it an aberration. How do we end up with people in financial management roles that, when they were corps officers, had reputation for being somewhat opaque when it came to handling the corps’ monies and could not complete a bank reconciliation either? How do we end up with a DC that when he was a corps officer could barely manage to successfully and effectively command his corps? Yet, we all know of the round-pegs that fill the organisational square-holes. Too many, over too long a period of time and confidence dissipates and trust breaks down and before we know such deficiencies are endemic and we have a organisational culture defined by mistrust and fear. 




I fear for the movement’s future. I would not go back: sadly, I think I could say that if I knew then what I knew now, I would have not gone in the first place. I do agree with the previous writer, I think we are past the critical point unless … and it is a big ask, and I do not believe the time of miracles are past, there is something that only the Almighty can do. The corresponding effort of those of us ‘here below’ will have to be herculean and courageous. 

I do sense there is a move afoot: there is something stirring that is enabling people to speak out. Forum such as this, energise and enthuse a far broader constituency than the group was established to resource as it deals with issues and approaches subjects that are dear to the hearts of many Salvationists who might feel that the organisation marches to a beat that is not quite the same as theirs. Pioneers rarely benefit, choosing to forge a path and create a circumstance for the betterment of those who follow in their wake. It could be that those who seek to make the biggest change succeed when they ensure that their children do not suffer the same organisational injustices and personal hurts as experienced by many of us. Grace has kept us and will continue to so. Let’s keep on, keeping on! 

DW

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

THE ABUSE OF INDIFFERENCE!

Anonymous said...
A similar scenario played out in Canada. A very capable, popular young officer was heading up a capitol financial campaign in Vancouver, while his wife and small children were in Toronto. He had a heart attack, dying on the spot. The next morning the Personnel Secretary arrived at the quarter's doorstep and informed the widow that she was to pack up and leave as an officer couple would be taking possession the next day.



She was homeless, but was able to rent a one bedroom unfurnished apartment. The mother and the children slept on the floor, until the TC heard about it from some of her colleagues. He was outraged. Apparently, the TC had a discretionary fund, so he gave her a cheque and told her to go out and buy the furniture she needed.


Do I need to say there were no further promotions for the Personnel Secretary, he found himself in a dead end job. 
I can vouch for the truth of the story, because I heard it from the widow herself.The discussion of aftercare and consideration of our own reaction to resignations and terminations is the beginning of better transitions "away" from the Army. 
____________________ Prior to my termination due to separation and divorce, I too needed to reach out more to fellow officers leaving the work. But busyness and awkwardness also kept me from always doing the right thing of keeping contact and offering support. 
The painful experience of being "cast out" has changed me entirely. Rather than seeing people through my former legalistic, judgmental lens, I see that true grace is practiced by enduring awkward situations to show love and choosing people as a priority. Grace should be offered to all whether terminated or some other situtaion beyond a person's control. This needs to apply to former officers, soldiers as well as former church going Christians. 


As a former officer and current Presbyterian, I accept your challenge "to support, confort, confront and care for each other." I feel uniquely qualified to understand the painful and difficult transition from the Army. Thank you for the reminder to practice grace both to all types of "formers" as well as Army administration at every opportunity. 


USA West, 'former' residing in California.
*************************

When three of William Booth's children decided that the SA was no longer for them, Booth cut them off completely. No contact, no love, no inheritance - they were even banned from family occasions such as funerals and weddings.

 Basically that sort of thinking is still ingrained on the Army's psyche. (USA former)

To leave the ranks was seen by Booth and Bramwell as an act of betrayal for which there could be no forgiveness and no way back.

 Sadly, things haven't changed much in 150 years.


(Former 

UKT)

I honestly think that Booth's refusal to forgive his own children was a heinous sin, and completely contrary to the "purity of heart" that he loved to preach. 

Christianity begins in the home, and for that reason, and some others, I think that Booth may have a bit of trouble on judgment day. (Former UK)



Somewhere in the Army history, some basic Christian principles were abandoned for the sake of organizational survival. Perhaps care and concern for officer personnel was never in the basic DNA of the Army - especially if we accept the premise presented that Booth totally alienated his own children. 

I suppose it becomes a matter of priority.

If we take liberty to apply the Scripture text, "where your treasure is, there your heart will be also", it is quite obvious that the organization does not treasure its officer personnel as demonstrated by the lack of pastoral care to active officers.

 The excuse of being too busy is unacceptable. The problem is a mixed-up priority list, and a distinct focus on self-preservation, self-centeredness, and self-aggrandizement
(Former USA East)

Would the introduction of, or change to current practices in the following areas, help stem the loss of officers and the cost to TSA, and of eternal significance, the number of souls lost to the Kingdom through the loss of 50% of our Pastors and Teachers?

• A change in the current Sabbatical regulations (allow more often and with fewer restrictions)
• Allow leave-of-absence (up to 3 months) without pay after 5 years of service
• Allow officers greater say in the appointment process
• Appoint spouses to different appointments/commands
• Allow and support married Female officers to assume leadership roles even if deemed more responsible than the appointment held by the spouse
• Examine single spouse policy effect before abandoning it
• Introduce a sophisticated Mentorship program
• Encourage face-to-face encounters between those contemplating resignation and select ‘former’ officers
• Include a discussion session in officer councils focusing on the ‘cost of resignation’
• Include a session in officer councils focusing on single officer spouse with non-officer spouse as guest speaker
• Include non-officer spouses in officer councils; private sessions where they become familiar with what’s demanded of of officers and how they can ‘share in ministry’
• Re-establish an 'early resignation' policy to honor officers who have given a minimum of 25 years of unbroken service
------------           
I recently re-read the letter from THQ accepting our resignation. In it we were told of the Army’s appreciation for our 21 years of service, immediately followed by the perfunctory reminders that our healthcare would cease at the end of the month, to turn in our identification cards and not to in any way represent ourselves as SA Officers. Sadly there was nothing encouraging us to stay connected with the Army as potential soldiers, no offer of counsel or advice to assist in the financial, emotional, practical, and spiritual transition…no more,
                 
If the Army says that it loves a person at the beginning of their officership, that love if genuine must follow them out of officership, or one must question its authenticity. (Former USA East)
____________________

COMMENTS LEFT ON THE FSAOF FACEBOOK SITE

Anonymous said...
For me, as a former, Facebook was the tool that allowed me to reconnect with so many of my Army friends - active officers, former officers, and Salvationists. 

It is sad, however, that the isolation I felt when I resigned as an officer was not filled by Salvation Army leaders pastoring me or just checking to see how I was doing. It took a social network called Facebook for me to begin the healing process and rediscover friends who really cared about me but had no idea where I was. I even found my favorite 9th grade Math teacher who had been such a mentor to me - what a blessing!-------
Anonymous said...
It took me almost two years to get spiritually connected again after resigning as a SA officer. And where did I find it ? Online; the Former SA Officers Fellowship. That is now my spiritual home and I'm thankful God led there.


Former 
US Central
------
Anonymous said...
Me too, if it hadn't been for 'formers' and Sven's specific pastoral ministry I hate to think where I would be. Why oh why, does 'The Army 'not care and leave it to a fellow former to pastor us and help us get our heads back in the right place. Sven, you will never know how much your being there (even though we have never met and possibly never will) means to me, and how much I believe that without you I was at real risk of loosing my sanity. You helped me to believe in God again, the SA, and myself. Thank you!


Former UKT

 ‪Anonymous said...
What have I missed? I'm a newcomer to this discussion alerted to it by a fellow officer.

I know many ex-officers and some have spoken with me about this group, but I never realized that they represented such a large number of former officers, and from so many territories.

 Are our leaders blinded by the numbers, the sophistication, the wisdom, the unique insight, the growing strength, the pure resource that the fellowship offers? Am I to understand that no attempt has been made to enter dialogue? 

The recruitment and retention of officers is one of the most critical threats to our Army's future. Let's move out of our complacency and accept the fact that we don't always know best! 

An offer of help has been extended - We don't have the advantage of time on our side and need to accept this magnanimous gesture from a group that seemingly has all the answers at their fingertips.


Active SA Officer
 USA DHQ East


 ‪Anonymous said...
Within hours of handing in my resignation and officer showed up at the door of my quarters demanding the keys to the vehicle and giving me three days to vacate the quarters. I got a fax from THQ giving me slightly longer to vacate, but the car was gone that day. 

After that? Never again heard anything from the organization.

"Cherished"? I rather think not.

I fear for the movement’s future. I would not go back: sadly, I think I could say that if I knew then what I knew now, I would have not gone in the first place. I do agree with the previous writer, I think we are past the critical point unless … and it is a big ask, and I do not believe the time of miracles are past, there is something that only the Almighty can do. The corresponding effort of those of us ‘here below’ will have to be herculean and courageous. 

I do sense there is a move afoot: there is something stirring that is enabling people to speak out. Forum such as this, energise and enthuse a far broader constituency than the group was established to resource as it deals with issues and approaches subjects that are dear to the hearts of many Salvationists who might feel that the organisation marches to a beat that is not quite the same as theirs. Pioneers rarely benefit, choosing to forge a path and create a circumstance for the betterment of those who follow in their wake. It could be that those who seek to make the biggest change succeed when they ensure that their children do not suffer the same organisational injustices and personal hurts as experienced by many of us. Grace has kept us and will continue to so. Let’s keep on, keeping on! 



 ‪Anonymous said...
DW

What an excellent post, It is obvious that in your leaving the Army lost the potential for great leadership.


You ask how such present leadership can be? I am sure you know the answer. Peter Drucker put it simply when he called it "The Peter Principle":
"People rising to the level of their incompetence"!

What an indictment you have made of the present leadership in Canada and Bermuda: how very sad.

<)))><
Tuesday, 26 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous said...
The jhierarchical structure i9s a problem because it's success depends totally on the smarts and goodness of the people at the top.
You'd think we might have learned from the RC church that church governance based on hierarchy of rank and position by its very nature is far more vulnerable to power abuse than a more democratic structure.

We all know the pitfalls of democracy and the tyranny of the majority but even with it's pitfalls democracy has more accountability and is less vulnerable to power abuse. 


TSA needed to change it's structure and governance system long ago. Its appointment and transfer system might have been a good place to have started.
Tuesday, 26 February, 2013


Drucker's 'Peter Principle' analysis can be applied to persons in any large organization, especially when their employees number in the hundreds of thousands worldwide, as in the case of the SA.


Four decades on Drucker says; "The Salvation Army is America's most effective charity" He gives the Army top marks for "clarity of mission, ability to innovate, measurable results, dedication and putting money to maximum use. No other charity "even comes close." 

Can Drucker’s observations be applied to today’s Army officer leadership or is he referring to the overall achievements directed by advisory boards guided by successful corporate leaders and professional staff, rather than those in SA uniform?
And do accolades for its effectiveness in fund raising rest in the public’s long held nostalgic sentiment of 'hot coffee and donuts' in the trenches, coupled with today's slick PR campaigns and and media releases?



________
Tuesday, 26 February, 2013

 ‪Anonymous said...
Carrying on from the previous two references to the Peter Principle, some will be familiar with Rev. Richard Stazesky’s contributions in seeking reconciliation in the UMC during the turbulent segregation era. Here’s a brief outline of the characteristics of a highly effective leader as he illustrates Washington's genius as a leader in his roles as commander in chief of the Continental Army. (speech given in 2000)

'What can we learn from him and how can we identify the “Peters” …

The visionary leader, first of all, has very 
clear, encompassing and far-reaching vision in regard to the cause or organization involved. This vision includes ideas and goals which remain constant no matter how long it takes to realize them and regardless of the difficulties which the leader encounters.
Furthermore, the leader never allows any of the means or actions along the way to violate or invalidate this vision and its constituent values.

Secondly, the visionary leader is skillful in designing and creating an organizational culture which will make possible the attainment of the leader's vision and ideas. In fact, creating this organizational culture may be the most lasting contribution of the leader for it will consist of the enduring values, vision and beliefs that are shared by members of the organization.

Thirdly, the visionary leader is also a person who can attract others to follow him/her in seeking attainment of the vision. But more than that, this charismatic person is able to instill in others the ideas, beliefs and values of the vision so that they become empowered to move beyond the leader's and their own expectations.
In brief, the visionary leader has a vision into the far future, can develop an effective organization and can attract others to strive also for the attainment of his/her vision so that it becomes a shared vision and they all work together in an organization that sustains the vision, its beliefs and its values.'
________


Where and who are the ‘Peters’ who have violated and stifled actions and invalidated the Army’s vision and its constituent values?

Former
US West
Tuesday, 26 February, 2013


 ‪Anonymous said...
Just to add to the stories of ill-treatment of Officers - although slightly outside the main stream.

My father-in-law was an Auxiliary-Captain in the then Salvation Army Assurance Society in the UK. A full-time appointment with provided quarters.

 He had a heart-attack and died very suddenly one morning at 5.50am.

At 10am that same day my mother-in-law, instantly and unexpectedly widowed and left with two youngish children, had a letter from the Area Superintendent containing a few trite words of condolence and a request that she vacate the premises as it was needed for the next appointee!


There is nothing new about the Army's callous treatment of Officers and their families.


 ‪

Friday, August 7, 2015

A Series on the FSAOF experience

THE BLAME STOPS HERE!
Christian commitment and experience grounded in truth.

Seven years ago I received a private e-mail from a former officer, NHQ, USA that stated; 'of Sven's many notable SA activities as an officer in the USA and abroad, the creation of the FSAOF (created following his resignation as an officer)  is by far the most important one to the SA.' And, I've been told that those comments have been shared with Comm. Barry Swanson, the then incoming Chief of Staff.

The FSAOF is entering its ninth year of offering support to The Salvation Army at every level from the IHQ, London to the newest corps plant in rural Zimbabwe and Australia’s outback, to active and former officers, from new Christians and clergy of other denominations, from social workers, psychologists and those wrestling with moral and ethical questions and concerns. More than million visitors have from our and have shared comments.

Only invited/approved 'former' officers are allowed to join the FSAO Fellowship, consequently none but those in the fellowship know the identity of the 1,200+ current members, however, by scrolling down the right side of our blog page you’ll find hundreds of names, many perhaps known to you. Many formers share membership in our fellowship anonymously for personal reasons, most being SA employees and/or holding senior local positions in their corps and fear retribution and discrimination.  Many SA Commissioners publicly and some tacitly assure us of their support, and the Chief of the Staff has instructed us on how to proceed in effecting a more supportive program from within and among HQs worldwide. And one never fails to enquire about the FSAOF’s latest mission initiatives whenever me meet or touch base. And his interest is shared by many stationed in the UKIT THQ.

Equipment and financial donation to the SA Corps and rehab centre
Tallinn, Estonia - May 2015
FSAOF blog articles, fund raising, mission projects and funding of projects are under the oversight and direction of an elected Board of Directors and appointed Executive Committee. And issues of general/common concern to all members are shared for comments and consensus. The FSAOF posts a monthly audited finance report and is available free upon request.

Tomorrow we’ll provide an overview of the many reasons why officers step out, but one of my favourite quotes is that; “YOUR BUCKET LIST ALWAYS HAS ROOM FOR REVISIONS.” 

The FSAOF’s mission is broad and multi-faceted and includes support for those members seeking a return to full time service in the SA. Dozens have returned to officership while scores live out their calling serving as pastors in other denominations. Some have entered the teaching profession and write regularly for Christian publications including the War Cry. 
 In fact, many of the devotionals and other articles shared in the FSAOF blog have been used in SA periodicals and even in sermon form verbatim.  

Our 1,200+ members average 15 years of officership behind them and represent an aggregate of more than 18,000 years of theological, social service, evangelical experience and ministry. Positions of responsibility in the SA 

include pioneering SA work in countries where there was never a SA presence, Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine, and re-0pening the Army in Russia, Divisional and Regional Commanders, Directors of SA social services commands, Medical missionaries, SA Editorial responsibility, Training College staff/lecturers, and many more.


 Tomorrow: Indifference is a major form of abuse!

OPENING FIRE - UKRAINE 1993
Sven Ljungholm
Liverpool

Thursday, August 6, 2015

IT'S THURSDAY 6 August 2015


NUMBER 35

Thursday 6 AUGUST 2015

'Pharaoh said to Joseph, 'I had a dream, and no-one can interpret it. But I have heard it said of you that when you hear a dream you can interpret it.'

I cannot do it,' Joseph replied to Pharaoh, 'but God will give Pharaoh the answer he desires.' Genesis 41:15,16.

If Pharaoh's cup-bearer had remembered Joseph when he left prison and returned to Pharaoh's service, Joseph would probably have been released and headed straight back home to the land of the Hebrews, (40:15). He would never have known about Pharaoh's dream, or played his pivotal part in God's plan of salvation for the Egyptians. Stuck in that prison for a further two years with no sign that he would ever be released, Joseph would not have known that God was preparing him through the hardships and injustice to be the man he needed for the plan he had for him, yet Joseph remained faithful. Don't be discouraged by your own view of things. In the valley, your view of where you are and where you are going or not going, is very different to the One who looks down from the mountain-top and sees what is beyond the hills that seem to tower above you.

Pharaoh, having heard how Joseph accurately interpreted the dreams of the baker and cup-bearer, complimented Joseph and expressed his certainty that Joseph could do the same for him. But the pride and vanity we saw in the younger Joseph is gone. Thirteen years have passed. The young 17 year old who was sold into slavery (37:2), is now 30 (41:46). God has done a wonderful work in Joseph. He is now very humble and recognises his ability to interpret dreams to be a gift from God.  He wants God to be given the credit due, and he witnesses to Pharaoh.

All that we have is only ours because of God's provision. None of us have anything to boast about. You have good looks? You have intelligence? You have a particular talent? You have good health? You have money and worldly goods? All these things are God given treasures. They are good; given by God to enrich the recipient as well as the lives of others, but they do pose a danger. Many measure themselves and other people by the treasures they possess. Sadly, many who are so blessed, long for the compliments and relish the credit that comes their way instead of humbly acknowledging that what they have is not of their own making but due to God's grace. That which he gives can so easily be taken from us. May we, like Joseph, acknowledge that it is God who ought to be praised and worshipped rather than the earthly vessel he chooses to use and bless. 

God bless you all.


Wednesday, August 5, 2015

FRIDAY - SUNDAY

SA BULLYING KNOWS NO BOUNDS



FORMER OFFICER WEIGH IN---- Attn: SA Officers!

Sunday, August 2, 2015

PROMISES, PROMISES

Some time ago I read a story of a wealthy family whose son, Bill, was about to graduate from high school. It was the custom in the affluent neighbourhood in which they lived for parents to give the one graduating a car.

For months before the graduation, Bill and his father looked at many different cars and a week before the graduation they found the perfect one.

On the eve of his graduation, Bill's father handed him a gift-wrapped Bible. Bill was so angry that he threw the Bible on the ground and stormed out of the house. What about the promised car?

Bill and his father never saw each other again.


Many years later, his father's death brought Bill home. As he sat one night going through the possessions that he was to inherit from his father, he came across that same Bible.

He brushed away the dust and opened it, to find a cheque—dated the day of his graduation—for the exact amount of the car they had chosen together.


It makes me wonder how many people may have done exactly the same sort of thing with God—tossed aside a wonderful promise from God because they didn't understand it, or they didn't believe it was possible.

We so often hear, 'If it sounds too good to be true, then it probably is.'

Some of us may have been taken in, at some point in our lives, by empty promises that tell us we can have something for nothing. We see ads on TV that promise us we can be rich, attractive or famous if we buy whatever it is they're selling.

It doesn't take long for us to realise that many of the promises we're given are empty. But God is different.

God has never made a promise that was too good to be true. Instead of promises that are empty, at Easter God gave us 'emptiness' that is full of promise.

There was the empty cross—the promise of God's love and forgiveness. There is the empty tomb—when Jesus rose again he conquered death and promises new life in relationship with God. There are the empty burial clothes in the tomb—Jesus is alive and the promise of Jesus desire to know us and be part of our lives.

The fact that each of these things is empty assures us that God's promises are real. The cross, the tomb, the grave clothes, could not contain Jesus.

These three 'empty' things are promises of fullness for our lives. We just need to accept the promises given freely to us. 


By June Knop
Australia