Saturday, December 14, 2013

Joseph's Prayer


Joseph's Prayer by Max Lucado from On This Holy Night
Joseph... did what the Lord’s angel had told him to do. — Matthew 1:24
The white space between Bible verses is fertile soil for questions. One can hardly read Scripture without whispering, “I wonder...”
“I wonder if Eve ever ate any more fruit.”
“I wonder if Noah slept well during storms.”
“I wonder if Jonah liked fish or if Jeremiah had friends.”
“Did Moses avoid bushes? Did Jesus tell jokes? Did Peter ever try water-walking again?”
“Would any woman have married Paul had he asked?”
The Bible is a fence full of knotholes through which we can peek but not see the whole picture. It’s a scrapbook of snapshots capturing people in encounters with God, but not always recording the result.
So we wonder:
When the woman caught in adultery went home, what did she say to her husband?
After the demoniac was delivered, what did he do for a living?
After Jairus’s daughter was raised from the dead, did she ever regret it?
Knotholes and snapshots and “I wonders.” You’ll find them in every chapter about every person. But nothing stirs so many questions as does the birth of Christ. Characters appear and disappear before we can ask them anything. The innkeeper too busy to welcome God — did he ever learn who he turned away? The shepherds — did they ever hum the song the angels sang? The wise men who followed the star — what was it like to worship a toddler? And Joseph, especially Joseph.
I’ve got questions for Joseph.
Did you and Jesus arm wrestle? Did He ever let you win?
Did you ever look up from your prayers and see Jesus listening?
How do you say “Jesus” in Egyptian?
What ever happened to the wise men?
What ever happened to you?
We don’t know what happened to Joseph. His role in Act I is so crucial that we expect to see him in the rest of the drama — but with the exception of a short scene with twelve-year-old Jesus in Jerusalem, he never reappears. The rest of his life is left to speculation, and we are left with our questions.
But of all my questions, my first would be about Bethlehem. I’d like to know about the night in the stable. I can picture Joseph there. Moonlit pastures. Stars twinkle above. Bethlehem sparkles in the distance. There he is, pacing outside the stable.
What was he thinking while Jesus was being born? What was on his mind while Mary was giving birth? He’d done all he could do — heated the water, prepared a place for Mary to lie. He’d made Mary as comfortable as she could be in a barn and then he stepped out. She’d asked to be alone, and Joseph had never felt more so.
In that eternity between his wife’s dismissal and Jesus’ arrival, what was he thinking? He walked into the night and looked into the stars. Did he pray?
For some reason, I don’t see him silent; I see Joseph animated, pacing. Head shaking one minute, fist shaking the next. This isn’t what he had in mind. I wonder what he said...
This isn’t the way I planned it, God. Not at all. My child being born in a stable? This isn’t the way I thought it would be. A cave with sheep and donkeys, hay and straw? My wife giving birth with only the stars to hear her pain?
This isn’t at all what I imagined. No, I imagined family. I imagined grandmothers. I imagined neighbors clustered outside the door and friends standing at my side. I imagined the house erupting with the first cry of the infant. Slaps on the back. Loud laughter. Jubilation.
That’s how I thought it would be.
The midwife would hand me my child and all the people would applaud. Mary would rest, and we would celebrate. All of Nazareth would celebrate.
But now. Now look. Nazareth is five days’ journey away. And here we are in a... in a sheep pasture. Who will celebrate with us? The sheep? The shepherds? The stars?
This doesn’t seem right. What kind of husband am I? I provide no midwife to aid my wife. No bed to rest her back. Her pillow is a blanket from my donkey. My house for her is a shed of hay and straw.
The smell is bad; the animals are loud. Why, I even smell like a shepherd myself.
Did I miss something? Did I, God?
When You sent the angel and spoke of the Son being born — this isn’t what I pictured. I envisioned Jerusalem, the temple, the priests, and the people gathered to watch. A pageant perhaps. A parade. A banquet at least. I mean, this is the Messiah!
Or, if not born in Jerusalem, how about Nazareth? Wouldn’t Nazareth have been better? At least there I have my house and my business. Out here, what do I have? A weary mule, a stack of firewood, and a pot of warm water. This is not the way I wanted it to be! This is not the way I wanted my son.
Oh my, I did it again. I did it again, didn’t I, Father? I don’t mean to do that; it’s just that I forget. He’s not my son... He’s Yours.
The child is Yours. The plan is Yours. The idea is Yours. And forgive me for asking but... is this how God enters the world? The coming of the angel, I’ve accepted. The questions people asked about the pregnancy, I can tolerate. The trip to Bethlehem, fine. But why a birth in a stable, God?
Any minute now Mary will give birth. Not to a child, but to the Messiah. Not to an infant, but to God. That’s what the angel said. That’s what Mary believes. And, God, my God, that’s what I want to believe. But surely You can understand; it’s not easy. It seems so... so... so... bizarre.
I’m unaccustomed to such strangeness, God. I’m a carpenter. I make things fit. I square off the edges. I follow the plumb line. I measure twice before I cut once. Surprises are not the friend of a builder. I like to know the plan. I like to see the plan before I begin.
But this time I’m not the builder, am I? This time I’m a tool. A hammer in Your grip. A nail between Your fingers. A chisel in Your hands. This project is Yours, not mine.
I guess it’s foolish of me to question You. Forgive my struggling. Trust doesn’t come easy to me, God. But You never said it would be easy, did You?
One final thing, Father. The angel You sent? Any chance You could send another? If not an angel, maybe a person? I don’t know anyone around here, and some company would be nice. Maybe the innkeeper or a traveler? Even a shepherd would do.
I wonder. Did Joseph ever pray such a prayer? Perhaps he did. Perhaps he didn’t.
But you probably have.
You’ve stood where Joseph stood. Caught between what God says and what makes sense. You’ve done what He told you to do only to wonder if it was Him speaking in the first place. You’ve stared into a sky blackened with doubt. And you’ve asked what Joseph asked.
You’ve asked if you’re still on the right road. You’ve asked if you were supposed to turn left when you turned right. And you’ve asked if there is a plan behind this scheme. Things haven’t turned out like you thought they would.
Each of us knows what it’s like to search the night for light. Not outside a stable, but perhaps outside an emergency room. On the gravel of a roadside. On the manicured grass of a cemetery. We’ve asked our questions. We questioned God’s plan. And we’ve wondered why God does what He does.
The Bethlehem sky is not the first to hear the pleading of a confused pilgrim.
If you are asking what Joseph asked, let me urge you to do what Joseph did. Obey. That’s what he did. He obeyed. He obeyed when the angel called. He obeyed when Mary explained. He obeyed when God sent.
He was obedient to God.
He was obedient when the sky was bright.
He was obedient when the sky was dark.
He didn’t let his confusion disrupt his obedience. He didn’t know everything. But he did what he knew. He shut down his business, packed up his family, and went to another country. Why? Because that’s what God said to do.
What about you? Just like Joseph, you can’t see the whole picture. Just like Joseph, your task is to see that Jesus is brought into your part of your world. And just like Joseph, you have a choice: to obey or disobey. Because Joseph obeyed, God used him to change the world.
Can He do the same with you?
God still looks for Josephs today. Men and women who believe that God is not through with this world. Common people who serve an uncommon God.
Will you be that kind of person? Will you serve... even when you don’t understand?
No, the Bethlehem sky is not the first to hear the pleadings of an honest heart, nor the last. And perhaps God didn’t answer every question for Joseph. But He answered the most important one. “Are you still with me, God?” And through the first cries of the Godchild the answer came.
“Yes. Yes, Joseph. I’m with you.”
There are many questions about the Bible that we won’t be able to answer until we get home. Many knotholes and snapshots. Many times we will muse, “I wonder...”
But in our wonderings, there is one question we never need to ask. Does God care? Do we matter to God? Does He still love His children?
Through the small face of the stable-born baby, He says yes.
Yes, your sins are forgiven.
Yes, your name is written in heaven.
Yes, death has been defeated.
And yes, God has entered your world.
Immanuel. God is with us.
 * * *
Your Turn
Lord, help us to obey You! During confusion. When our story is full of questions. When the world seems to have gone haywire. When God's plan looks so different from anything we ever imagined it would. Help us to authentically bring our questions to You, to be real with You, and then, even if we don't hear a clear answer to the "I wonders", to choose to obey You. We trust in the promise that You are with us!
Do you have "I wonders" in your life, questions that make no sense that remain unanswered by God? Does your life seem off-track? Are you grappling with whether or not God is still with you? Join the conversation on our blog! We would love to hear your story of obedience through a season of questioning God! ~ Devotionals Daily








Thursday, December 12, 2013

ADVENT




00:13


00:29



Last week we lit the Candle of HOPE. This is now the second Sunday of Advent and today we light the second candle. This is the Candle of PEACE.
This Traditional second candle is often associated with the biblical reading from Isaiah 9:6-7:
“For a child has been born for us, a son given to us; authority rests upon his shoulders; and he is named Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.”

Much has been said about the violence of our world. The media sensationalizes it on a regular basis. We can turn on our TV’s, computers, smartphones and other devices and easily tune into the violent scenes all over the globe. Have you ever stopped to think how this has affected us? Is it not an amazing thought that 100 years ago the average person had never witnessed a person being killed, yet today the average 3-year-old has because she can see it on TV? From that initial shock he is then subjected to it literally thousands of times before he even reaches adulthood.

Christianity and other religions all teach us a message of HOPE and PEACE yet as a people have we learned from that teaching? Most, if not all religions and traditions have been besmirched with violence, pain and suffering. Why is that? Why is it that history has seen the Crusades, the Salem witch burnings, shameful cover-ups, jihad and so much more. Every honourable Christian, Muslim, Buddhist, New Ager would like to bury this in the past and leave it there. But it keeps coming back to haunt us. It keeps coming from history to present itself to us at the dinner table through the medium called News. Certainly not Good News.

Recently I was stunned by a show I was watching with friends called XXX. This show made me realize that years ago when you picked up the Newspaper you would read feel good stories. That was the news of the day; not war, rape and other crime. True, we do live in a different age. We live in an age that sensationalized these things. It is almost as if they have become our idols of the present era.

Reaching back to my own roots I see a man who came to bring a message of peace to a world that was embroiled in a time of violence. I see a man who came to clean up his religious roots and expose hypocrisy, theft, violence and more (sound familiar?) Although I take note. He did not come to hide the shame of his tradition. He came to expose it. How does that bring peace, especially when we see, in contrast, how it ended his life with such violence?

History is not for us to hide. History is not for us to judge. History is not for us to feel shame; because shame has no real purpose. History is His-story. I apologize to the Feminists but this is what it’s called. Perhaps if it was called herstory it would have turned out differently, I don’t know. But the point I make is that it’s not MY STORY. My story starts now, this morning as I type this, watching the soft snow fall outside my living room window, oh so gentle and pure white. My Story is about PEACE. Because  True, my own personal history is not always pretty to look at. But in this moment I recommit to that message of peace. Why? Again I say it, PEACE BEGINS WITH ME.

James Latour
Former Officer
Canada

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET!


Thanks for a very good article Major Shade. "Oh the memories!" (and we aren't even on Hoarders!) - FSAOF blog.

I think we all have our kettle "sea stories." I have one in particular and I'm not sure if I ever told it before on this site (maybe a few years back? I dunno. I can't remember.) but just in case I haven't this is probably the perfect occasion to do so.




On Dec. 11th 1968 I was playing 1st cornet from the old green Carolers Favorites tune book on my Eb Alto outside of Kresges at the Oakbrook Shopping Mall west of Chicago.




A businessman from NYC threw some money in the kettle and then stopped to tell me about the then world's largest kettle that he saw in Times Square. He told me that a large band was playing and men and women in uniform including "girls in those funny looking hats your women wear" were singing carols and getting passers-by to join in, and all about the great fun he had participating in it!




Since I was turning 18 in two weeks and leaving for the Navy in one month I decided to take my savings, hop on a plane and experience the world's largest kettle milieu for myself. (I was sort of an SA history buff and fanatic back then.) 


I told my C.O. that evening on the way home what I was going to do and not to expect me to work the next day. He laughed and gave me a quarter to throw into the kettle for him.

The next morning I left the house at 5:30 a.m. and went to the airport, telling only my grandmother about my trip (she too gave me a quarter!) and left my mother a note saying I'd be back that evening and why. 


I'd never flown on a jet before and always wanted to see NYC so it was really exciting for me---but most of all I wanted to see that kettle!




By 12 noon I was in Manhattan's Times Square but never once saw any kettle, just the corps on West 49th Street. No one was there but I was impressed that the storefront corps really did look like it was right out of "Guys and Dolls!"




Anyway to make a long story short I took the subway down to 14th Street saw the Centennial Memorial Gates and NHQ and was finally told by an officer at the Trade Dept. on 15th Street that the world's largest kettle was outside of Macy's in Herald Square. Finally! 


So I traipsed off to 34th Street and sure enough, THERE IT WAS! 

Unfortunately, there was a girl in her 20s standing next to it singing "Hark the Herald Angels Sing" and "Silent Night" through her nose, totally oblivious to the fact that people were laughing at her as they passed by. 

I then threw my quarter, my C.O.'s quarter and my grandmother's quarter into the pot, smiled and asked her what corps she was from. She replied, "What's a corps?" 

Oh well, if nothing else, whatever welfare line they got her out of at least she wasn't standing there smoking a cigarette......




Daryl Lach


USA Central



P.S. Btw, the day wasn't a total loss. I bought a LP of the NYSB Male Chorus singing "You Must Go Home By the Way of the Cross", went to the observation deck on the top of the Empire State Building, and saw the Tree Lighting ceremony in Rockefeller Center that evening before hailing a cab to LaGuardia. I was home that night by 10:45P and back at my kettle stand bright and early on the 13th!



Highly Reluctant Jesus Follower


J



Fox News' Highly Reluctant Jesus Follower
Of all people surprised that I became an evangelical Christian, I'm the most surprised.

Kirsten Powers

Just seven years ago, if someone had told me that I'd be writing for Christianity Today magazine about how I came to believe in God, I would have laughed out loud. If there was one thing in which I was completely secure, it was that I would never adhere to any religion—especially to evangelical Christianity, which I held in particular contempt.
I grew up in the Episcopal Church in Alaska, but my belief was superficial and flimsy. It was borrowed from my archaeologist father, who was so brilliant he taught himself to speak and read Russian. When I encountered doubt, I would fall back on the fact that he believed.

Leaning on my father's faith got me through high school. But by college it wasn't enough, especially because as I grew older he began to confide in me his own doubts. What little faith I had couldn't withstand this revelation. From my early 20s on, I would waver between atheism and agnosticism, never coming close to considering that God could be real.

After college I worked as an appointee in the Clinton administration from 1992 to 1998. The White House surrounded me with intellectual people who, if they had any deep faith in God, never expressed it. Later, when I moved to New York, where I worked in Democratic politics, my world became aggressively secular. Everyone I knew was politically left-leaning, and my group of friends was overwhelmingly atheist.

I sometimes hear Christians talk about how terrible life must be for atheists. But our lives were not terrible. Life actually seemed pretty wonderful, filled with opportunity and good conversation and privilege. I know now that it was not as wonderful as it could have been. But you don't know what you don't know. How could I have missed something I didn't think existed?

Very Open-Minded
To the extent that I encountered Christians, it was in the news cycle. And inevitably they were saying something about gay people or feminists. I didn't feel I was missing much. So when I began dating a man who was into Jesus, I was not looking for God. In fact, the week before I met him, a friend had asked me if I had any deal breakers in dating. My response: "Just nobody who is religious."

A few months into our relationship, my boyfriend called to say he had something important to talk to me about. I remember exactly where I was sitting in my West Village apartment when he said, "Do you believe Jesus is your Savior?" My stomach sank. I started to panic. Oh no, was my first thought. He's crazy.

When I answered no, he asked, "Do you think you could ever believe it?" He explained that he was at a point in life when he wanted to get married and felt that I could be that person, but he couldn't marry a non-Christian. I said I didn't want to mislead him—that I would never believe in Jesus.

Then he said the magic words for a liberal: "Do you think you could keep an open mind about it?" Well, of course. "I'm very open-minded!" Even though I wasn't at all. I derided Christians as anti-intellectual bigots who were too weak to face the reality that there is no rhyme or reason to the world. I had found this man's church attendance an oddity to overlook, not a point in his favor.

As he talked, I grew conflicted. On the one hand, I was creeped out. On the other hand, I had enormous respect for him. He is smart, educated, and intellectually curious. I remember thinking, 

What if this is true, and I'm not even willing to consider it?
PAGE:123NEXT
A few weeks later I went to church with him. I was so clueless about Christianity that I didn't know that some Presbyterians were evangelicals. So when we arrived at the Upper East Side service of Redeemer Presbyterian Church, I was shocked and repelled by what I saw. I was used to the high-church liturgy of my youth. We were meeting in an auditorium with a band playing what I later learned was "praise music." I thought, How am I going to tell him I can never come back?

But then the pastor preached. I was fascinated. I had never heard a pastor talk about the things he did. Tim Keller's sermon was intellectually rigorous, weaving in art and history and philosophy. I decided to come back to hear him again. Soon, hearing Keller speak on Sunday became the highlight of my week. I thought of it as just an interesting lecture—not really church. I just tolerated the rest of it in order to hear him. Any person who is familiar with Keller's preaching knows that he usually brings Jesus in at the end of the sermon to tie his points together. For the first few months, I left feeling frustrated: Why did he have to ruin a perfectly good talk with this Jesus nonsense?

Each week, Keller made the case for Christianity. He also made the case against atheism and agnosticism. He expertly exposed the intellectual weaknesses of a purely secular worldview. I came to realize that even if Christianity wasn't the real thing, neither was atheism.

I began to read the Bible. My boyfriend would pray with me for God to reveal himself to me. After about eight months of going to hear Keller, I concluded that the weight of evidence was on the side of Christianity. But I didn't feel any connection to God, and frankly, I was fine with that. I continued to think that people who talked of hearing from God or experiencing God were either delusional or lying. In my most generous moments, I allowed that they were just imagining things that made them feel good.

Then one night in 2006, on a trip to Taiwan, I woke up in what felt like a strange cross between a dream and reality. Jesus came to me and said, "Here I am." It felt so real. I didn't know what to make of it. I called my boyfriend, but before I had time to tell him about it, he told me he had been praying the night before and felt we were supposed to break up. So we did. Honestly, while I was upset, I was more traumatized by Jesus visiting me.

Completely True
I tried to write off the experience as misfiring synapses, but I couldn't shake it. When I returned to New York a few days later, I was lost. I suddenly felt God everywhere and it was terrifying. More important, it was unwelcome. It felt like an invasion. I started to fear I was going crazy.

I didn't know what to do, so I spoke with writer Eric Metaxas, whom I had met through my boyfriend and who had talked with me quite a bit about God. "You need to be in a Bible study," he said. "And Kathy Keller's Bible study is the one you need to be in." I didn't like the sound of that, but I was desperate. My whole world was imploding. How was I going to tell my family or friends about what had happened? Nobody would understand. I didn't understand. (It says a lot about the family in which I grew up that one of my most pressing concerns was that Christians would try to turn me into a Republican.)

I remember walking into the Bible study. I had a knot in my stomach. In my mind, only weirdoes and zealots went to Bible studies. I don't remember what was said that day. All I know is that when I left, everything had changed. I'll never forget standing outside that apartment on the Upper East Side and saying to myself, "It's true. It's completely true." The world looked entirely different, like a veil had been lifted off it. I had not an iota of doubt. I was filled with indescribable joy.

The horror of the prospect of being a devout Christian crept back in almost immediately. I spent the next few months doing my best to wrestle away from God. It was pointless. Everywhere I turned, there he was. Slowly there was less fear and more joy. The Hound of Heaven had pursued me and caught me—whether I liked it or not.

Kirsten Powers is a contributor to USA Today and a columnist for Newsweek/The Daily Beast. She is a Democratic commentator at Fox News.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Postal Grinch who stole Christmas


Nineteen years ago, The Washington Times kindly published my opinion piece on the possible removal of a Madonna-and-Child Christmas stamp from the U.S. Postal Service's roster of holiday adhesives. The story made some headlines, and caused the USPS of 1994 to reverse its decision.

PLEASE NOTE: This is almost 20 years AGO, (today). Mr. Runyon has since passed to his rest, and the crisis of 1994 WAS averted!



The Washington Times

Postal Grinch who stole Christmas
November 20, 1994

Byline: Mark Kellner 

Marvin Runyon, the white-haired Tennessean who is postmaster general, looks more like a kindly grandfather than a Dr. Seuss character. But following the announcement last Thursday of the 1995 commemorative stamp program, Mr. Runyon is now front-runner for the title of "The Grinch Who Stole Christmas." Not to mention Hanukkah. After more than three decades of tradition, the U.S. Postal Service has disclosed it will cancel its annual custom of releasing a specific "Christmas" stamp. Printed literally in the billions of copies each year, the miniature reproduction of the Madonna and Child is balanced by secular "Greetings" stamps that portray holiday themes.

Either stamp sells well in the two months leading up to Dec. 25. As the holiday approaches, mailboxes - perhaps yours - fill with cards and letters from friends and family, usually adorned with one of the stamps. Each design - religious or not - sells many times the number of popular Elvis Presley commemoratives the agency released in 1993.

Next year however, the artistic adhesive bearing the image of Mary and Jesus will be no more, ending a tradition began in 1970 to supplement nonreligious designs first issued in 1962. Chalk it up to the forces of political correctness - and the apparent complicity of Mr. Runyon, who has the final say over the U.S. stamp program, even above that of the Citizen's Stamp Advisory Committee.

What's more, starting next year, post offices won't be allowed to display signs reading "Merry Christmas" or "Happy Hanukkah," since these allegedly would offend nonobservers of these holidays.

In October, the USPS' Postal Bulletin, a fortnightly for postmasters, contained a laundry list of dos and don'ts for holiday decorations in 1995. Under rules that raise political correctness to new heights, postmasters are ordered to bid farewell to displays of nativity scenes, crosses or the Star of David.

"Displays should relate to the business of the Postal Service," the Bulletin said. "The Postal Service must avoid the appearance of favoring any particular religion or religion itself."

Post offices will be allowed to display "evergreen trees bearing nonreligious ornaments," or a menorah, a traditional Hanukkah symbol, but only "when displayed with other seasonal matter," the USPS declared. It is permissible to have a display for the Afro-American festival of Kwanza, the agency stated.

According to Linn's Stamp News, a weekly collector's publication, the USPS was poised to extend the Christmas ban to stamps, ending decades of tradition. Before the unveiling, Postal Service spokeswoman Robin Minard said Thursday's stamp design announcement was to determine "if the C-word will be on a stamp." So now "Christmas" has become "the C-word"? Humbug!

Although Christmas stamps have attracted various protests over the years, principally from atheist groups, the dozen or so postmasters general who preceded Mr. Runyon have ignored the gripes. After all, the USPS once said, if you don't want to use a Christmas stamp, we've got plenty of other designs to sell.

Now, for reasons best known to the USPS' senior management, the agency has decided to worship at the altar of political correctness. Instead of advocating freedom of religion (featured on a Norman Rockwell commemorative this year), the Postal Service is taking a stand for freedom from religion.

It's sad to contemplate that so tiny a thing as a Christmas stamp, which has been popular for more than three decades, is now deemed an anachronism. That post offices, long a center of life in the communities they serve, can't have Christmas or Hanukkah displays that would reflect their community's tastes, is equally disappointing.

In an age when society needs all the positive symbols we can get, it's distressing to envision a Yuletide without a stamp-sized reminder on holiday mail, or a wintry post office bearing a "Merry Christmas" sign. The quiet, PC-rich excision of these stamps and displays insults all people of faith and reflects poorly on the Postal Service.

Public protest - and perhaps a nudge from the White House and Congress - might persuade Mr. Runyon to drop his Grinchlike pose. There's still time to return Christmas stamps to the schedule and Hanukkah displays to post offices. Such moves are not an establishment of religion, but rather a simple recognition of the role faith plays in American's lives.



Mark A. Kellner has been a stamp collector since 1970 and has published articles on philately in the United States, Canada, Great Britain and Australia. From 1991 to 1993, he was capitol correspondent for Stamp Collector newspaper.

Mark is also a former Salvationist having served in the New York Central Citadel Corps along with his wife Jean, a former SA officer.

Monday, December 9, 2013

For most of the last 2,000 years, most Christians weren’t reading the Bible at all.


Christians have not been ‘reading the Bible this way for 2,000 years’
November 24, 2013 By Fred Clark


Whenever I write something critical of the relatively recent dogma of “biblical inerrancy,” someone always responds by insisting that Christians have been reading the Bible this way for 2,000 years.

That’s not true. It’s not possible.

Christians haven’t been reading the Bible this way for 2,000 years, because for most of the last 2,000 years, most Christians weren’t reading the Bible at all.

For the first of those 20 centuries, Christians weren’t reading the New Testament because it was still being written. Even 1,900 years ago, many of the texts we refer to as the New Testament were still a work in progress.

For much of Christian history, many of the biblical texts read by most Christians were neither texts nor biblical. (“Descent of Christ to Limbo,” church fresco in Florence by Andrea di Bonaiuto, ca. 1368.)

It took another 200 years after that for those texts to be collected into anything like a formal canon. That only came about after Emperor Constantine made Christianity Rome’s official religion. The next step, then, was to translate the Bible into Latin so that every Roman-therefore-newly-Christian could read it. Jerome didn’t finish that project until 405.

At that point — 1,600 years ago — it might finally have become possible for Christians to start reading the Bible in the same way that white evangelical inerrantists read it today, but that’s not how they read the Bible. Take a look at Augustine or any of the other early church writers from the first five centuries of Christianity and you’ll find all kinds of approaches to the text — wildly inventive allegorical schemes, symbolism, reinterpretations of the New Testament almost as radical as the NT authors’ reinterpretations of the OT — that would give contemporary defenders of “biblical inerrancy” the howling fantods.

Well, then, what about after Augustine? How did Christians read the Bible in the next several centuries?

They didn’t. Not most of them, anyway. The Western Roman Empire fell in 476 and literacy in western Europe collapsed right along with it. During the Dark Ages, books were hard to come by, and people who could read and understand them were too. Christians were reading the Bible during those many long centuries, but not most Christians. It was read by, and within, the church. The prevailing hermeneutic, in other words, was nothing like the individualistic, face-value literalism that characterizes the approach of modern inerrantists. The prevailing hermeneutic was to interpret the Bible as meaning what the church says it means.

The majority of Christians during those centuries didn’t read the Bible at all, lacking both the ability and the opportunity to do so. They heard bits of the Bible read to them — in Latin, which they may not have understood — and they learned a lot of biblical lore from songs, statuary, pageants and plays. That was mixed in, of course, with a lot of other lore that was likely regarded as biblical, even though it came instead from, say, the Gospel of Nicodemas or the Vision of Tundale.

That’s how things remained for about half of those 2,000 years during which Christians have supposedly been reading the Bible in just exactly the way we’re reading it today.

The big changes didn’t come until more than 1,000 years after St. Jerome finished his Latin translation. The biggest change didn’t have anything to do with the church itself. The biggest change was technological — the invention of the printing press and the publication of the Gutenberg Bible in 1454.

Another big change came with first the Geneva Bible and then the King James Version in 1611 — more than a century after Gutenberg’s invention of the printing press, these made English translations of the Bible widely available for the first time. And thus, for the first time in the English-speaking world, it became possible to begin reading the Bible the way that proponents of “inerrancy” read it today.
So if we can’t say that most Christians have been reading the Bible this way for 2,000 years, can we at least say that some Christians have been reading the Bible this way for 400 years?

Yes, I think that’s fair. I think the same hermeneutic now championed by Al Mohler’s Southern Baptist faction and by things like the “Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy” first began to take shape about 400 years ago.

And here’s a brief timeline of some of that theological development:
1607: Jamestown founded in Virginia.
1611: King James Bible published.
1619: First 20 Africans sold into slavery in Jamestown.
1620: Plymouth Bay Colony founded in Massachusetts.
1636: The Desire, the first North American slave ship, built and launched in Massachusetts.
1643: Plymouth adopts a fugitive slave law.
1657: Virginia adopts a fugitive slave law.
1661: King Charles II of England calls for the Christian conversion of African slaves.
1667: Virginia passes law saying that slaves who convert to Christianity will remain slaves.

From there on it’s just a matter of filling in the details.

The shape of contemporary white evangelicalism — including the way it reads and interprets and wields the Bible — flows from that. That’s where the argument began and that’s where the argument remains.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Has fiction lost its faith? Part Three of Three



Scene  5 – Oh Lord: The Church is in league with the Devil
Back in the prison cell with the ever-silent Jesus, the Grand Inquisitor acknowledges that because of the excessive burden of freedom of conscience, “We have corrected Thy work and founded it on miracle, mystery and authority.” This is why the Grand Inquisitor says, “Why has Thou come to hinder us?”

Then comes the truly revelatory moment in the Grand Inquisitor’s monologue, which Jesus knows already (obviously, because he is God). Knowing that he knows, the cardinal says, “Perhaps it is Thy will to hear it from my lips. Listen, then. We are not working with Thee, but with him – that is our mystery.” The Church is league with the Devil. It sits astride the Beast and raises aloft the cup marked “Mystery.” The Grand Inquisitor is diabolical. This explains why he is so fascinated with the temptations that Jesus faced in the desert. The Church has been seduced by those temptations in Jesus’ name.

The paradox is that the Church accepted those temptations in the hope of finding — as the Grand Inquisitor elegantly puts it — “Some means of uniting all in one unanimous and harmonious ant-heap.” The dream of a universal church, or a universal state, or the unity of all nations, or a cosmopolitan world order founded on perpetual peace, or whatever, is Satan’s most persuasive and dangerous temptation. The freedom proclaimed by Jesus is too demanding and makes people unhappy. We prefer a demonic happiness to an unendurable freedom. All that human beings want is to be saved from the great anxiety and terrible agony they endure at present in making a free decision for themselves.

Scene 6 – The kiss and the curse
And so, all will be happy, except those, like the Grand Inquisitor, who guard the mystery and know the secret. They will be unhappy. But it is a price worth paying. The true Christians, by contrast, see themselves as the elect, the 12,000 from each of the 12 tribes  who will be the company of saints in the millennium that follows Christ’s second coming. This is why the Grand Inquisitor says, “I turned back and joined the ranks of those who have corrected Thy work. I left the proud and went back to the humble, for the happiness of the humble.” This is why Christ hinders the work of the Church and why he must burn like a heretic.

At this point, the Grand Inquisitor stops speaking. Silence descends. The prisoner Jesus continues to look gently into the old Cardinal’s face, who longs for him to say something, no matter how terrible. Jesus rises, approaches the old man and softly kisses his bloodless lips. The Grand Inquisitor shudders, but the kiss still glows in his heart. He stands and heads for the door, saying to Jesus, “Go, and come no more…Come not at all…never, never!”

Scene 7 – Demonic happiness or unbearable freedom?
Back with the two brothers: Ivan immediately disavows the poem as senseless and naïve. But Alyosha upbraids Ivan, claiming he is an atheist and saying, “How will you live and how will you love with such a hell in your heart.” As Father Zossima — whose recollections and exhortations are intended as a refutation of Ivan in the following chapters of the book — says, “What is hell? I maintain that it is the incapacity to love.” The scene ends with Alyosha softly kissing Ivan on the lips, an act that the latter objects to as plagiarism.

RELATED
Read previous contributions to this series.
Dostoevsky in no way wants to defend the position that Ivan Karamazov outlines in his poem. But Dostoevsky’s great virtue as a writer is to be so utterly convincing in outlining what he doesn’t believe and so deeply unconvincing in defending what he wants to believe. As Blake said of “Paradise Lost,” Satan gets all the best lines. The story of the Grand Inquisitor places a stark choice in front of us: demonic happiness or unbearable freedom?
And this choice conceals another, deeper one: truth or falsehood? The truth that sets free is not, as we saw, the freedom of inclination and passing desire. It is the freedom of faith. It is the acceptance — submission, even — to a demand that both places a perhaps intolerable burden on the self, but which also energizes a movement of subjective conversion, to begin again. In disobeying ourselves and obeying this hard command, we may put on new selves. Faith hopes for grace.

Scene 8 – In which doubt and faith unite
To be clear, such an experience of faith is not certainty, but is only gained by going into the proverbial desert and undergoing diabolical temptation and radical doubt. On this view, doubt is not the enemy of faith. On the contrary, it is certainty. If faith becomes certainty, then we have become seduced by the temptations of miracle, mystery and authority. We have become diabolical. There are no guarantees in faith. It is defined by an essential insecurity, tempered by doubt and defined by a radical experience of freedom.

This is a noble and, indeed, God-like position. It is also what Jesus demands of us elsewhere in his teaching, in the Sermon on the Mount, when he says, “Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you or persecute you.” If that wasn’t tough enough, Jesus adds, “Be ye therefore perfect, even as your father which is in heaven is perfect.” This is a sublime demand.  It is a glorious demand. But it is, finally a ridiculous demand. Inhuman, even. It is the demand to become perfect, God-like. Easy for Jesus to say, as he was God. But somewhat more difficult for us.

Scene 9 – In which the Grand Inquisitor is, finally, defended
So what about us human beings, feeble, imperfect, self-deceived — the weakest reeds in nature? Does not Jesus’ insistence on the rigor and purity of faith seem, if not like pride, then at least haughtiness? The Grand Inquisitor, and the institution of the Church that he represents, accepted Satan’s temptations not out of malice, but out of a genuine love for humanity. This was based on the recognition of our flawed imperfection and need to be happy, which we perhaps deserve.

If the cost of the pure rigor of true faith is the salvation of the happy few, then this condemns the rest of us, in our millions and billions, to a life that is a kind of mockery. The seemingly perverse outcome of Dostoevsky’s parable is that perhaps the Grand Inquisitor is morally justified in choosing a lie over the truth.

The Grand Inquisitor’s dilemma is, finally, tragic: he knows that the truth which sets us free is too demanding for us, and that the lie that grants happiness permits the greatest good of the greatest number.  But he also knows that happiness is a deception that leads ineluctably to our damnation. Is the Grand Inquisitor’s lie not a noble one?

Scene 10 – In which the author expresses doubt
To be perfectly (or imperfectly) honest, I don’t know the answer to this question. Which should we choose: diabolical happiness or unendurable freedom? Perhaps we should spend some days and nights fasting in the desert and see what we might do. Admittedly, this is quite a difficult thing to sustain during the holiday period.

Happy Holidays!


Simon Critchley teaches philosophy at the New School for Social Research in New York. He is the author of, most recently, “The Faith of the Faithless,” and the forthcoming “”Stay, Illusion!” on Shakespeare’s “Hamlet,” co-written with Jamieson Webster. He is the moderator of this series.