Wednesday, October 16, 2013

There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak



When not saying enough could be dangerous?

The Bible tells us that we will account for every idle word we speak - Matthew 12:36
‘But I say unto you, That every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account of them in the day of judgment’.  

One part of the meaning of idle is "careless."  

Besides careless words, a careless silence can also be dangerous. It can be a form of condoning an action we witness that is wrong. Silence, when a warning is needed, is something that we hold people responsible for. God, too, holds people accountable for being silent when they ought to cry out. 


WAITING AT THE HH - An uncertain future-

Ezekiel was set as a spiritual watchman over the nation of Israel to warn the people with a message from God to repent and return to the paths of righteousness. Notice what God said in Ezekiel 3: 17 - 21: ‘Ezekiel, son of man, I have appointed you to stand watch for the people of Israel. So listen to what I say, then warn them for me. When I tell wicked people they will die because of their sins, you must warn them to turn from their sinful ways so they won’t be punished. If you refuse, you are responsible for their death. However, if you do warn them, and they keep on sinning, they will die because of their sins, and you will be innocent. Now suppose faithful people start sinning, and I decide to put stumbling blocks in their paths to make them fall. They deserve to die because of their sins. So if you refuse to warn them, I will forget about the times they were faithful, and I will hold you responsible for their death. But if you do warn them, and they listen to you and stop sinning, I will let them live. And you will be innocent’.


A watchman was a key figure in the towns of the ancient world. He would be stationed to guard the maturing crops in the field to see that they were not stolen by bandits or ravaged by wild animals. From his position on the walls, he would observe the traffic of society moving each day in and out of the city, sometimes announcing the approach of strangers on the roads leading in. In time of war, the watchman would warn of enemy troops coming against the town to lay siege. His vigilance meant life or death to the city's inhabitants. How people responded to his warning message was critical.

There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak (Ecclesiastes 3:7). 
Wisdom is knowing the difference, and character is applying that knowledge.

ST. PAUL HOSPITAL CLOSES AFTER 123 YEARS

God provides watchmen for His people in today's world, too, and I see the role of FSAOF and the supporters who have contributed to the Howard Hospital issue as that of spiritual watchmen - or 'watchpeople' if you wish to be PC. No individual or organisation is perfect, and we all stray from the 'pure' path. We all need reminding of God's standards. They are our moral and spiritual guides for faithful Christian service.

It is disheartening and frustrating for such a concerted effort as this (to try to bring TSA leadership to acknowledge the wrongdoing at HH) to have yielded nothing but silence until the publication of the Tariro story. This article, although laudable in concept, contained so much that can only be labelled ‘spin’, and left out the ‘heart’ of the hospital – the contribution of Dr Thistle. Truly – a wasted opportunity.

There is a basic spiritual discipline at stake here which, as Major (Dr) Watt says, threatens the very future of our beloved Army – it is repentance - - and it beggars belief that senior leaders have not yet acted upon it in this case. However unpalatable the truth is, God says wrongdoing must be confessed and laid at the foot of the cross. Not until then will this story cease. Unconfessed sin is a barrier to spiritual progression, and the leaders should know this and act accordingly.

Former Officer
Canada





We were abandoned on short notice!



October 15, 2013 
ZIMBABWE

CANADIAN medical doctor Paul Thistle has carved himself a niche in the medical fraternity, especially at mission hospitals where he has blended well with the rural folk wherever he is posted.


When he left the Salvation Army-run Howard Mission Hospital in a huff last year, villagers protested violently against his forced departure.

One year down the line, Thistle has found himself a new home at Karanda Mission Hospital in Mt Darwin where in no time, he has drawn patients from all corners of the country for the “magic touch” that is synonymous with him. The hospital falls under the Evangelical Church of Africa.

NewsDay (ND) reporter Moses Matenga yesterday spoke to Thistle (PT) on what he thinks about the Chiweshe community and why people were now flocking to Karanda for medical care and the number of patients the hospital attends to on a daily basis at his new workstation.

ND: You made news headlines when you clashed with the Salvation Army leadership at Howard Mission Hospital in Chiweshe last year. You have now settled here, how has been your stay so far?

PT: It has been a good experience, I have been received very well and we, as a team, are very busy these days. It has been a good transition from the days at Howard Mission (in Chiweshe).

ND: Judging from what we have at Karanda Hospital, people seem to be flocking for medical attention here some from far-away places, what do you attribute that to?

PT: Most of the people are non-locals. Most of them come from Bulawayo, Harare, Rusape, Mutare and all over the country. For me, I feel that we have a big task ahead of us and we continue to pray for guidance in the discharge of our duties here.

They come for consultations, surgeries and other various reasons. Others tell us they can’t afford what they pay in other institutions and have no access for various reasons, I can’t speak of others, but those are the main reasons they tell us why they come to Karanda Hospital.

ND: How many people do you attend to a day and of that number, how many are locals and non-locals?

PT: A day we attend to between 200-300 patients and like I said, half of them will be non-locals, the numbers increase on some days and that keeps us extremely busy at times. We are used to it and we have a dedicated staff that stands ready to assist the patients who have faith in our works and competence. When they come here, we engage them and make sure they are attended to in time and to the best of our ability.

ND: What’s your staff complement like at Karanda Hospital?

PT: We have four doctors and between 35-40 nurses; all trained and competent enough to assist in any way possible.

ND: Any challenges that you would need the government to deal with?

PT: We do a lot of work outside of medical catchment, we do advertisements calling people to Karanda and we involve ourselves in a lot of social work, but the resources from the Health and Child Care ministry do not take into account the extra work that we do. We do nurses’ training, but when they graduate, we don’t get as many as we would want according to the work that we would have done. We advocate for more staff and more resources.


ND: Do you sometimes get assistance from the government and are you satisfied with that?

PT: We have had assistance from the Health and Child Care ministry and the National Aids Council; we work closely together quite well. We have training for the University of Zimbabwe medical students and internal surgical internship and we need to lobby for extra resources.

ND: Given the manner you left Chiweshe and the violence that followed when villagers protested against your departure and the attachment you had created, do you miss Howard Mission?

PT: I had become attached and was getting used to people in Chiweshe and Howard Mission. We had developed an attachment on several projects including social work, children work, among other issues. It was a strong relationship, so we do miss people in Chiweshe. We were providing health care at Howard and abandoned such on short notice.

ND: In your view, why do you think people prefer mission hospitals to other ‘big’ public hospitals in cities?


PT: It’s unaffordable for most people yet mission hospitals continue to provide accessible, affordable care. At least that’s what the people say and I can’t speak for other hospitals.

___________________________

MAY 2013
After having to put money raised for Howard Hospital on hold after turmoil there, Canadian Langley Rotary clubs in British Columbia are ready to send the $57,642 they raised to Karanda.
“The last four months of 2012 certainly was a tumultuous period for our Rotary effort in Zimbabwe,” said Langley Rotarian Dr. Brendan Martin who founded International Health Langley — a fundraising arm of the Rotary Clubs that help hospitals in poor nations.
Thistle gave up a lucrative career in Canada and dedicated 16 years as the chief doctor at Howard Hospital when he was fired in August.
“His strict adherence to proper accountability and ethical principles resulted in an impasse,” said Martin.
Thistle was abruptly fired and told to leave the countryby the leadership of the Salvation Army there.
Thistle questioned the leaders over fundraising dollars and where the  money was going. “The Salvation Army leadership wants all the money raised to pass through their bank accounts in Harare. There was a pattern of the money not arriving at the hospital or arriving late,” said Martin in August.
Thistle was being punished for being a good steward of those funds, he said.
Thistle refused to leave the country, but couldn’t return to Howard Hospital.
“Unfortunately Howard Hospital has imploded since his removal and is only functioning at a small fraction of its former level,” said Martin recently.
The $57,642 will purchase the medical equipment and medicines originally intended for Howard Hospital, confirmed Martin.
“It’s a well-run hospital,” he said of Karanda.


Tuesday, October 15, 2013

THE SA CULTURE AND ETHICS Part Four


Ethics alter across borders and the SA in Zimbabwe, Russia and other countries with 'third world' domestic economic issues know the struggle first hand. But first, a flash back to 2012.

SA General Linda Bond, formerly head of the Salvation Army, active in 126 countries, with headquarters in London, England, issued the letter advising Capt. (Dr.) Paul Thistle of his removal from the Howard Hospital, Zimbabwe, stating that his “re-assignment” is all part and parcel of normal procedure within Salvation Army ranks. Retired Salvation Army officer Allan Bacon, the 75-year-old former Director of Overseas Development for the Salvation Army Canada and Bermuda Territories, home territory of both Bond and Thistle begs to differ, stating in a letter to International Headquarters, that Dr. Thistle’s “re-assignment” is far from normal procedure, particularly in the case of medical personnel, usually because the Army has no one to replace them. Just last week I read a tribute to a SA officer-nurse from the ‘west’ be thanked for her almost 50 years of service in India. And the list of ex-pat SA officers who've served in Zimbabwe beyond the 'normal procedure' includes two Generals and many others. And one General and his wife spent the first 19 years of their officership serving in South Korea. Why the spin? 

General Bond, a Canadian who rose through the ranks to become head of the Salvation Army, declares that “systems of internal and external audit are in place and that a team under her direction will be heading to Howard Hospital as soon as possible to review and analyze the situation further,” but this investigation should have been conducted as soon as concerns were raised about missing funds and equipment. 

Reports of corruption and missing funds are all too familiar in places like Africa, especially in dictatorships run by despots, but yet we expect religious and charitable organizations to live up to their principles and deal appropriately with the offenders. In their shameful handling of this disgraceful affair, the Salvation Army has made a huge mistake, tarnishing its good name and jeopardizing future fund raising, including internally. SA institutions and individuals railed against IHQ's decision and misleading announcement. 


Repercussions were felt immediately when the SA USA let it be known that they were withholding promised millions. General Linda Bond, in the days prior to her sudden retirement announcement, had been in the US leading a SA congress in St. Louis. Is it unreasonable to believe that there was a final showdown; the General making a last ditch attempt to loosen the clenched fists holding the millions necessary to rescue HH? And sensing that she’d lost a key battle decided to step out. FSAOF blog followers may recall that we shared confidentially with members in our Facebook pages that HH was at the very least an issue. IHQ must have felt they were losing control of one of their own institutions. Nobody wanted Howard to fail, but it would have struggled early on if Paul Thistle had not taken the initiative to raise his own funds. 


And, interestingly the new General brought the USA SA National Commander to London as his Chief of Staff; 2nd in Command worldwide. Only weeks later IHQ sent a team to HH to reinvigorate the reconstruction of the abandoned ‘new’ hospital, with, you guessed it, the funding in large part guaranteed, along with the necessary operating costs, coming from the Army, USA.

On a similar but much smaller scale-

From experience and confirmed by others who have served on the mission field, the personal and private fund raising activities practiced by Captain Thistle is indeed a ‘common practice’. Without the strong tacit ‘direct financial support’, cash and checks, much of it coming from USA SA National Advisory Board members, we received in Russia and later in Ukraine, a bare pittance of God’s intended work would have been achieved; God provided the necessary resources, with a little help from His friends.
When charged to ‘open fire’, or more correctly, re-open fire as my grandparents had been stationed in Moscow in 1919 to initially open the SA’s work there, we (my then wife and I) departed Leningrad following a brief stint there. We were  charged by General Eva Burrows to re-establish the SA in Moscow, IHQ recognizing that the Russian Command ought to be located in the capital. With the princely sum of $200.00, a SA banner, a few boxes of Russian language Bibles and with the promise of a comfortable apartment awaiting us, (and nothing else) off we went! The first use of our cache was used to bribe a trucker to sell us non-watered down petrol a hundred miles into our drive. And a dollar or two effected a quick ‘pashaltsta’, “Please proceed” at the many barricaded check points on the 8 hour evening journey.

A comfortable flat, space-wise by Russian standards indeed, but no bed, with the last occupants having ‘fled’ to the ‘west’ months earlier abandoning the flat without cleaning off their dinner plates (still on the table) or cleaning out the fridge – left open for critters and rats to enjoy rotting pork, borsht and dark bread. We constructed a bed using our 4 spare winter gyres, placing card board boxes and blankets on top. That was our ‘dom’ – home, office and recruit centre for the first two months, until a visit by the then TC, Norway (John Ord) termed our living conditions ‘reprehensible’. And our then home territory TC (Robert Thompson) ordered us to ‘purchase whatever you need, and ‘we’ll’ pay for it’. 


And so we did, adding to the several thousand dollars already owed on our Amex/Visa cards, money spent on SA relate expenses, including the obligatory bribes and protection money: the Russian mafia accepts Visa!


Our line supervisor had ignored our request for an increased budget to purchase the bare minimum of necessary furnishings. He and his officer wife lived in a 'western renovated' furnished Leningrad apartment with security guards and a high wire secure parking lot, at a cost to the Army 16 times greater than the cost of an equivalent Russian apartment.  Live in the midst of those you came to serve?
  
In the first 18 months we, the SA Moscow, accumulated a tax return (VAT) on items purchased and delivered through vendors in Sweden. It was money included in our preliminary budget, 40% of our annual budget, but it got ‘lost’ in the SA Sweden’s internal workings and our many request for information were ignored. And substantial earmarked donations from SA DHQ’s in the USA are still ‘in transfer’ two decades later. 

Later this week: BLACK MARKET GOODS - BARTERING WITH THE MAFIA - CURRENCY EXCHANGED ON THE RUN - BUYING BACK ITEMS STOLEN FROM US







Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer
Liverpool

Monday, October 14, 2013

TSA has historically encountered issues of corruption


Every newly commissioned SA officer encounters TSA internal 'tithing' system in which funds received into SA coffers are subjected to a 'centage' charge, generally ten percent.  The subordinate unit (corps, institution, etc.)is expected to pay this fee as an operating cost  much in the same manner a franchise business (McDonalds?) pays in order to  enjoy the name, reputation and public acceptance of the product or service. The financial survival of TSA bureaucracy is almost wholly dependent upon this pyramidal support system.  The funds extracted by this means are theoretically earmarked to pay the costs for supervision of the subordinate unit: From corps (or institution) to DHQ, to THQ and, presumably, to IHQ. In theory $100 to a Corps results in $10 to DHQ to $1.00 to THQ and $.10 to IHQ.

There has historically been a tension between those from whom this tithe is extracted and their superior officers whose financial existence is predicated on enforcing the policy. Yet there have always been exceptions made in the paying of this 'tithe', particularly when extaordinary donations (Kroc) or large government grants became more common for supporting some SA programs. The supervision of expenditures from specific grants became a shared task between the government entity providing funds and TSA overseers seeking to insure funds were expended according to 'regulations'. Some contracts specifically excluded the payments of such (in their view 'unnecessary') supervisory costs.  So the tithing system of TSA bureaucracy has never been entirely satisfactory or wholly enforceable as TSA has become more integrated into the societies, mores and cultural norms of an international entity.

TSA has historically encountered issues of corruption and graft (an operating norm in many underdeveloped countries) from its inception as an international organization. Superimposing a Canadian cultural norm upon Zimbabwe invites tension and conflict. TSA has attempted to operate with black and white principles where everything is done in shades of gray and where a 'gift' is expected in return for a favor.

It will take a leader, a General of of extraordinary courage and ultimate faith in the mission of TSA to invite an honest evaluation of what has transpired in the 'Thistle affair'. An open investigation would reveal the concessions, exceptions and contradictions in Zimbabwe which have allowed TSA to operate in Africa, India, Haiti and every other developing region of the world. Money, how it's generated, how it's spent and by whom and with what controls lies at the root of this matter and with most conflicts of mankind. Is anyone at IHQ prepared to invite absolute tranparency in the investigation how TSA raises and spends billions of dollars annually? Can we tolerate the shades of gray that exist?   

Art Johnstone
Former Officer
USA West

Sunday, October 13, 2013

update from the field - SUNDAY PM



We just learned that Major Dean Pallant (IHQ inspector) and another visitor (not in uniform) were out inspecting developments at the new hospital site this past week, saying that they intended to start the necessary changes and 'open it soon'. This will include new equipment for the laundry, kitchen and maintenance departments, and rebuilding the mortuary, as well as moving forward with water, electricity and sewage.


The local population an staff are wondering how they will maintain and staff the new hospital, as there is little money available to even maintain the present hospital. Many major sources of funding have withheld support due the tragedy that ensued following Dr. Thisle's unfair dismissal 14 months ago. And staff who have left or died have not been replaced; 'open it soon'? 

Consider this: at three times the size of the present facility, the new hospital will require at least three times the funding.  It is likely they will have to increase the fees.  Will it then become a private hospital, like the Secondary School? And will the local people tolerate that (they own the land, not the Salvation Army) ?   'Open it soon'? 


Alternatively, if unable to support it, they will be forced sometime in the future to abandon it, a repeat of an earlier fiscal boondoggle, but the next one at up to three time the cost, (then) a 4-5 million dollar bungle. 

It would be interesting to know what, if any, financial advice from outside the Army was sought. The present occupancy of the hospital and capacity of its staff certainly does not warrent this expansion. Has the Zim government, THQ Canada, IHQ, or USA Territories guaranteed the funding? Has USA AID or the SA's SAWSO been allowed to loosen the sanctions in place with reference to trade and support of Zimbabwean domestic projects controlled, even in part, by 
President Robert Mugabe's government;  'open it soon'? 

As yet, there is no policy to transfer patients to Karanda.  That would immediately improve the reputation of the hospital, increase its numbers, and could be of some assistance to Karanda Mission Hospital in providing on-going care in return.

Saturday, October 12, 2013

THE SA CULTURE AND ETHICS Part Three


Within hours of the release detailing the IHQ team’s findings from Zimbabwe questions began to pour in from persons who had served at Howard Hospital or who had 1st hand contact and knowledge. And, the one question that should have been asked, and which the FSAOF would like answered is, where’s the rest of your findings?

Here’s what we know and where we feel the team fell far short in both their fact finding and reporting:

1.    Donations made through "official" Army channels were delayed and often not properly documented. There has NEVER been any accusation that monies given directly to Dr. Thistle or hand-delivered to Dr. Thistle by volunteers coming to Zimbabwe were anything less than fully accounted for with receipts into the Army books. It is a known fact that other SA mission-based operations in Zimbabwe had been assessed as much as a 30% fee by THQ Zim.
2.    We have had a first-hand account from staff at Howard, who report that as of November 9, 2012 there was no sign of a container of medical/ pharmaceutical supplies and in fact, the pharmacy hasn’t even ha the basic much needed drugs in its inventory such as Ibuprofen and Amoxicillin.
3.    There are a total of approximately 144 beds at Howard. On November 9, 2012 five of the thirty-two beds in the male ward were occupied, seven of the thirty-two beds were occupied in the female ward, twenty of the forty beds were occupied in the Children’s and Therapeutic wards. 

These are wards that under Dr. Thistle’s leadership were full to capacity every day and in many cases there were makeshift beds set up on the floor to accommodate overflow.
4.    The morning of November 9th there were 30 people lined up at the outpatient clinic when the hospital opened. This is in stark contrast to 100 on a slow day and 200-300 on a normal day, every day, some even sleeping on the ground overnight to be first in line. So you see, although the numbers may not be as low as they originally were when the crisis first started, they are still abysmal compared to Howard’s better days when it was serving the community and doing what it was meant to do.
5.    You reported that The Salvation Army’s International Headquarters sent a fact-finding team to Zimbabwe to examine the processing and use of donations to the hospital and you reported their findings. It is fundamentally important that any internal investigations be conducted from an objective, independent, third party approach. The only way to determine if this has in fact been the case The Salvation Army needs to release the report to the public in order for us to make our own informed decision. That is being accountable and transparent. However, if The Salvation Army has not conducted this investigation with a third party approach then the report is self-serving and unreliable.
6.    To say that there have not been problems with funds and resources being diverted and delayed is incorrect. It is a well-known fact. The Salvation Army is what it is because the people have built it, donated and sacrificed yet a few hierarchal administrators speak against the will of the people.
7.    HJ Retired SA officer – missionary HH 
November 11, 2012 at 11:21 pm 

I would assume that outside auditors have been asked to go to Howard in order to gain the confidence of donors. If allegations of misused funds are false then The Salvation Army will need to do all it can to gain back the confidence of supporters. When there are allegations of wrong doing in a company it is understood that outside auditors are used. Surely this also applies to Howard Hospital.
8.    EA 
November 13, 2012 at 11:08 am I believe that the SA tells the truth but only by a glaring act of omission. By saying that “There was no sign that goods or funds donated directly to The Salvation Army in Canada for use by the Howard Hospital were diverted from their original purpose.” they are being truthful. 
However, the majority of projects at Howard do not go through the SA in Canada. They were run (channeled) directly from donor to hospital, eg, USAID, Stephen Lewis, Global Fund. This is also the policy of the Zimbawean Association of Church Hospitals, an umbrella organization of 120 mission hospitals. 
These direct donor projects are where the discrepancies occur.
 An independent audit would certainly reveal this. 
When you know how to spin the press release, you can make the water look good on the surface even though it’s a cesspool underneath.
9.    LS 
November 17, 2012 at 5:21 pm Has anyone been following Doug MacLellan’s photo blog? Having been to the Howard four times in previous years, the Army has used his photos in the past in their periodicals for articles on the Howard. 
Doug went back to Zimbabwe last week, however, he was denied access to the Howard compound on November 15th, I wonder why? One would think TSA would be happy to have a photographer confirm their story that “• Media reports that the hospital is functioning at 10% are false.” 
Mr. MacLellan has posted photos on his internet blog at the following link http://dougmaclellan.tumblr.com/ 
Not allowed in the compound, this Canadian photographer posted a photo taken Nov. 15th outside the main entrance of the Howard. His comment says that normally it would be a scene of people crowding at the entrance waiting for admission. The scene is empty of people. That very day statistics coming out of the Howard by phone call to Canada, report the following staff estimates: of inpatients, and they are somewhat up: Male Ward: 3, Female Ward 8; Children’s Ward: 10; Maternity 12, total 33 – still far less than the normal average of inpatients, maybe a little over 10%, but not by much.
10.Could TSA kindly answer the following questions:
Why was this photographer (known to them) barred entrance to the Howard compound Nov. 15th?
 Why is TSA standing by as people die for needed surgery (according to reports coming out of Zimbabwe) while TSA has a surgeon on the ground but have removed him from his practice?
This is obviously a huge ethical question especially as TSA has forced a physician to break his oath by forcing him out of his practice without a suitable replacement in place.
 I agree with HJ’s comment above that TSA should have had an external investigation conducted given the seriousness of this situation. SA officers conducting an internal investigation obviously have a conflict of interest.

11. BN 
November 17, 2012 at 5:56 pm We mistakenly believed that if we gave people the correct information (told the truth about Howard Hospital and corruption) that it would lead to right action. We were proven wrong by The Salvation Army. Lying or telling the truth is a choice and we are left raging against the lies in this press release. I feel solidarity with the people of Cheweshe who are left to suffer without adequate health care, and anger towards The SA who are standing by and watching this happen.
12.“There are a few misconceptions here.  First, the corruption is very real.  Tens of thousands of dollars are, indeed, missing.  The only reason "no evidence was found" was that the books, both at THQ and the hospital, are a mess.” The reason they are in a mess is neither incompetance nor lack of time.  It is lack of committment to both accuracy and SA regulations.
13.Captain (Dr.) Paul Thistle was "wrong" in accepting direct aid to the hospital (even though all donation were recorded through the hospital books), but as government grants were worthless (rampant inflation) and donations were hijacked in full or part, not getting through THQ Zim to the hospital.
14.Commissioner Chigariro was not unlike other Commanders elsewhere, who could see the big picture more clearly than those in the trenches.“It’s reported that at one time THQ Zim was demanding 30% of donated funds.  THQ staff (including Commissioner Ward) were complaining it was being "run by children", young men and women trained by the Jesuits as AIDS counsellors.  Now (2013) it is the residence of three officer couples, $30,000 in debt for electricity alone, vehicles used as personal vehicles by the officers, water cut off, largely idle, no longer sponsoring children's camps.” 
15.Over the past several days, Dr. Lorraine Irvine, a retired doctor from Victoria, B.C., has been visiting Howard Hospital, or rather, trying to visit as THQ has done everything they can to stop her ("we don't want Canadians at the hospital").  She has taken donations for school fees for orphaned children at Howard Secondary and Nyachuru schools, but has been forbidden to pay them to the headmasters.  She has been ordered to give the donations to THQ Zim.  This is "right", but if she does, there is little likelihood the children will see any of it.  She may end up bringing the money back home to Canada. 
16.IHQ, for whatever reason, is complicit in this.  Two Norwegian nurses ran into the same problem earlier this year, and wrote to Commissioner Hodder then in the legal departement, who replied that he had sent their letter to the Africa section.  He may as well have thrown it in the wastebasket.  The nurses have said they will never give to the Salvation Army again, as have others who are hopping mad about this situation.  It amounts to stealing from orphaned children.

Findings - conclusion:

There is a need for better general governance in the Army in Zim. The Army puts far too much faith in the fairness and transparency of its senior staff. And it has no checks and procedures in place to deal with them when things go terribly wrong.

Further, the concept that a group of colleagues can be called together to constitute a board of directors demonstrates a dangerous lack of awareness on separation of power, responsibility and duties.  Decision-making and its consequences are far different in the 21st century than they were just a decade or two ago.

We live in a far more transparent world. The social media, governments/NGOs, support groups/agencies, and oversight agencies will not hesitate to challenge our credibility if the Army doesn't meet their ethical expectations and demands. And it’s naïve to believe that corruption or deceit in any form, witnessed by and committed against credible foreign individuals, institutions, governments and other SA bodies will be overlooked or dismissed simply on the basis that the ‘entire country is corrupt’. 





Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer
Liverpool


Friday, October 11, 2013

THE SA CULTURE AND ETHICS Part Two


Of concern to many following the HH debacle is why an independent investigation was not conducted, or at the very least include an outside auditor and management consultant.

Although an independent investigation may not be the perfect solution to the problem of corruption (finances-equipment, bribes, etc.), at least the question of bureaucratic-political corruption, while perhaps not on the list of concerns, could have been observed and reported. Many suspect that this concern should have been a key focus. The ‘insiders’ report said nothing about the control exerted by officer bureaucrats, and which was perhaps at the very root of the problems the SA Zimbabwe was experiencing. Any hope of reducing corruption of any kind ought to include the use of independent investigators.

Questions:

Did those in Zimbabwe who were complicit in the allegation made, or those assisting in the investigation, have administrative power, or a kind of spiritual authority (senior rank) that compelled the obedience and acquiescence of any of the visiting inspection team members?

Did the team members possess superior ethical training, insight, standards and intuition?

INITIAL RESPONSE

 The report states: “Over recent months, The Salvation Army has been maligned and falsely accused of wrongdoing. Allegations have been made concerning the administration of donated funds and goods at Howard Hospital. “

“….Reports have circulated in the media that the Thistles were moved because they brought accusations of corruption against The Salvation Army in Zimbabwe. These reports are simply not true and at no time were such concerns shared with Salvation Army leadership by either of them.”

1. The team was charged with investigating;  ‘the administration of donated funds and goods at Howard Hospital.’

2. The team was charged with investigating;  ‘that the Thistles … brought accusations of corruption against The Salvation Army in Zimbabwe.’

The ‘charges to perform’ issued to the IHQ Team have not been shared with the general public nor, more  importantly with SA stakeholders. Fair enough, but the team’s responses (2 above quotes) confirm at least a portion of what they were assigned to investigate. Perhaps that is all there was? Yet, other questions remain unanswered that would add, at least partial credibility, to the team’s integrity and transparency.

The following are fundamental concerns relative to any and all professionally conducted internal investigations.

·      Who made the allegations of wrongdoing concerning the administration of donated funds and goods at Howard Hospital?
·      Who selected the team members; their respective roles and credentials
and what was the criteria used in their selection?
·      What was the ‘charge’ made to the fact finders; the focus and details of the agenda the team was assigned to investigate?
·      Were non-SA officers and/or SA lay-employees included in the team at any stage of the investigation?
·      Who were the contact/source persons in Zimbabwe, SA and others; their profession and role in the investigation?
·      What were the instructions given to THQ Harare and HH staff by IHQ with reference to providing access to the IHQ Team?
·      Which team member penned the report and to whom was it submitted?
·      Is a copy of any of the findings available?

The FSAOF has learned and is encouraged that IHQ is sending out yet another fact finding Team. While we hope that they will observe and abide by professionally recognized guidelines, we include them for their review and as a guideline to others.
1.    Examine responses/reports/finding to Past Situations: anything needing a re-visit?
2.    . What previous situations have been similar to the newly assigned charge?
3.    How did management resolve these issues? This step is important because it ensures that you act fairly, and in a way that’s consistent with past SA practices.
4.    Determine whether there is any self-interest in the action being considered.
5.    Will there be personal gain or will someone potentially loose personal status/integrity by the decision to be made?

The key to returning with an effective report begins with the delegate selection and identifying the strengths of each member of the team, and capitalizing on them. ‘Find out what each team member enjoys doing most. This will not only prove to your team that you trust and believe in them, but will also free up your time to focus on the higher level tasks, that should not be delegated. It’s a fine balance, but one that will have a huge impact on the productivity of your business.’ (Lecture notes – CCSU)

Consider factors such as race (culture – social standing), gender, age, education level, and seniority. Also, consider are relationships with the person(s) causing problems. Are friendships, colleague or professional relationship affecting any team member’s judgment?

Would you be happy with safeguards in place?

·      Having an outsider (auditor/experts) witness all interviews.
·      Make an audio recording of all interviews.
·      Provide a general release of the findings/outcome to stakeholders.
·      Announce all necessary changes/corrections; personnel, financial oversight and reporting, inventory channeling, reporting and warehousing and scheduling parameters by which all changes are to be instituted.
·      Date(s) of return visit to review that all corrections are in place, with an independent auditor.

Examine what you believe your Covenant guides you to do prior to departure from IHQ, share with your immediate supervisor and detail in a report (file) for follow-up; your intent and carry it with you. Add to this report at each step of the fact-finding mission. How are your instincts telling you to proceed? Detail any and all deviation from your initial intuitions?

Proceed on your knees – as Christ’s obedient disciples.

Then Soldiers of Christ, arise, and put your armor on. Arm yourselves with all the mind that was in Christ, your head. Pray always; pray and never faint; pray, without ceasing, pray!
(Translated from the Russian devotional; TSA Moscow 1991) 




Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer
Liverpool