Wednesday, October 9, 2013

THE SA CULTURE AND ETHICS Part One




PRESS RELEASE Oct 7, 2013

EVERY year over US$1 trillion goes missing from the global economy through bribes, dishonest deals and tax evasion. This impacts the world's poorest people most.

That’s why The Salvation Army is supporting EXPOSED – a global call to action against corruption, greed, secret deals, bribery and abuse of public influence.

And it's not just money lost – corruption kills. It is predicted that illegal tax evasion will be responsible for 5.6 million children dying in developing countries between 2000 and 2015. That’s some 1,000 children every day.

Colonel Geanette Seymour, Director of The Salvation Army’s International Social Justice Commission explains: ‘Corruption undermines good governance and the rule of law, leads to violations of human rights, distorts markets and erodes the quality of life. Corruption is a key element in economic under-performance and a major obstacle to poverty alleviation and development. It goes against the tenets of justice, human dignity, empathy with the needy and spiritual stewardship.’

With our partners, we are seeking 1 million people to sign the Global Call – a petition for integrity. You can add your voice here: https://signup.exposed2013.com/p/saisj 



Also, during the week 14–20 October 2013 there will be 2,000 vigils worldwide, including opportunities for creative prayer and action for a world free of corruption. Officers and staff from The Salvation Army's International Headquarters have been invited to attend the high-profile vigil at nearby St Paul’s Cathedral in the City of London, UK.

 * * * **************************** * 

The FSAOF applauds IHQ’s commitment and we too support the Global Call petition; advocating the Army’s tenets of justice, human dignity, empathy with the needy and spiritual stewardship.’ 

Many visitors to our blog site in addition to members of the Former Salvation Army Officers Fellowship have encouraged me to weigh in on the subject of Howard Hospital and the Dr. Paul Thistle debacle. Some suggest I have a responsibility to do so as the creator and administrator of the FSAOF. Others suggest I don my professorial robes and write in the guise of my former life as a professor of business ethics. Others yet recommend I put on my Salvation Army hat, the one I wore while serving in Russia and Ukraine and speak to the issue of cultural ethical applications in Third World countries.

“Corruption is worse than any sin... it hardens the heart against feeling shame or guilt & hearing God's call for conversion.” Pope Francis

It’s both ironic and prophetic that the IHQ NEWS FEATURE: EXPOSED: THE $1-TRILLION IMPACT OF CORRUPTION AND BRIBERY, 07 OCTOBER 2013 coincides directly with the FSAOF’s research into absolved corruption detailed in a 14 month old IHQ release. Therein the Army disavows any corruption or collusion. However, the findings of the FSAOF, HH insiders, friends, officers and employees tell a different and far more believable story.
The genesis of the tragic culmination of the HH ethical fall-out dates back almost two decades. One might question, why revisit this sorry tale more than a year after IHQ closed its books on it? It's because The SA’s official statement giving the Army in Zimbabwe a clean bill of health, a blanket denial of any ethical breaches, begs belief by any rational adult.

Corruption in Zimbabwe is endemic within its political, private and civil sectors. And Zimbabwe’s rank in Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index continues to fall placing it at 163rd out of 176 countries in the 2012 ranking. On a scale of 0 (highly corrupt) to 10 (very clean), the Corruption Perceptions Index marked Zimbabwe 2.0, a decrease from its high in 1999, when the country ranked a damnable 4.1.  To believe, suggest or confirm that THQ Harare or the HH staff and its many suppliers are without guile is both naïve and irresponsible!

And to hijack and sabotage stakeholders’ expectation the opportunity and option to respond and to question the report is despotic. The report’s outcome reflects a complete melt down of the assigned values in conducting a professional enquiry and circumvents the ethical standards that ought to have been in place. At the heart of each investigative probe should have been a desire for truth; exhibiting internationally ethical standards. From start to finish, as a professor of business ethics and Salvationist, I find them sadly lacking. 
St. Paul writes, 
“Here is a trustworthy saying, if anyone sets one’s heart on being an overseer,
 one desires a noble task”. (1 Tim. 3:1)

Pastoral leadership (officership – ministry) isn’t for everyone. It’s spiritually, emotionally and physically demanding. To end each day asking:  “Did I do justice, love kindness, and walk humbly with my God”, and to do so day in and day out, bound by a solemn lifetime commitment, can break a man. In some men it’s his lifetime commitment and for many others, a lessening in their resolve to ‘do justice’. They sever familiar ties and comforts to go where the Army sends them, “to win souls, care for the poor, and love the unlovable’, equating this to Christian discipleship, but at what cost?




SALVATION ARMY RELEASE
Posted on November 8, 2012 in Newswire
The Salvation Army’s vision for Howard has always been that of a rural hospital providing the best possible primary care to those seeking its services. These sustainable goals remain the vision for the future, and for the good of all people.
Over recent months, The Salvation Army has been maligned and falsely accused of wrongdoing. Allegations have been made concerning the administration of donated funds and goods at Howard Hospital. In response, The Salvation Army’s International Headquarters sent a fact-finding team to Zimbabwe to examine the processing and use of donations to the hospital.
The team reported that:

·      There was no sign that goods or funds donated directly to The Salvation Army in Canada for use by the Howard Hospital were diverted from their original purpose.

·      The hospital continues to operate with qualified medical personnel serving thousands of people each month.

·      Media reports that the hospital is functioning at 10% are false
·      Patients continue to be treated at Howard and more difficult cases are being referred to other facilities.
For the past 17 years, Dr. Paul Thistle, a Canadian-born medical doctor trained at the University of Toronto, has served at Howard Hospital. He, along with his wife Pedrinah, a Zimbabwean-born nurse/midwife, are also Salvation Army officers.
Salvation Army officers are regularly transferred to different appointments. Captains Dr. Paul and Pedrinah Thistle have done an extraordinary job in Zimbabwe and we are grateful to them for that service. Effective September 2012, they were released from their duties at Howard Hospital in order to return to Canada.
Reports have circulated in the media that the Thistles were moved because they brought accusations of corruption against The Salvation Army in Zimbabwe. These reports are simply not true and at no time were such concerns shared with Salvation Army leadership by either of them.
The Salvation Army Canada remains committed to the work of Howard Hospital. Over the past few weeks and months, the organization:

·      paid for a shipment of medical supplies worth $300,000;

·      paid overdue bills totaling $30,000 to keep the electricity on;

·      paid $15,000 for much-needed pharmaceutical supplies.
The Army in Canada is also eager to work with all willing partners to support the work of Howard Hospital. Countless Canadian donors support the Army’s work in developing countries and by following strict Canadian governmental regulations for all such projects, The Salvation Army in Canada is confident that the public will continue to support this vital facility in Zimbabwe.
Furthermore, arrangements are being made for Canadian Salvation Army staff to be on the ground to assist in the development of a proposal to address specific sustainability concerns over the next number of months.

Sven Ljungholm, PhD
Former Officer
Liverpool

We call for a visionary leader


We call for a visionary leader who would throw out all the baggage attached to TSA hierarchy and actually change the Army for the greater good.

We call for a visionary leader who will put people and communities first before the self-serving trappings of rank and 'power'.

We call for a visionary leader who would subjugate the secular ‘One Army’ and give pre-eminence to ‘One Lord’.

We call for a visionary leader with the spiritual gift of discernment: ‘Teach me good judgment and knowledge (Psalm 119:66)  

We call for a visionary leader to inspire us to recapture the evangelical fervour of the early day Salvationists.

We call for a visionary leader to restore solid biblical teaching to our young people, many of whom we prize as ‘Army’ but who are largely spiritually illiterate and ill-equipped to recognise the dangers and temptations that would take them away from Christian service.

We call for a visionary leader who will peel back the layers of the Army’s worldly wealth and corporate influence to find the soul of the people beneath, and to stand up for the gospel of Christ and not bow to demands for conditional spiritual nihility.

We call for a visionary leader who will instigate a Biblically authenticated democracy within the ranks for everyone, regardless of age – a leader who will allow challenges to be raised, and challenging questions to be asked, and who will put an end to the constant positive spin that exists in Army media today. It is just not realistic.

We call for a visionary leader who will put an end to the totalitarian practices that exist, where soldiers, adherents, friends are denied a voice to challenge what they see as wrong.
There is more for which we could call, but the above list shows there is much within our Army which needs addressing.

It isn't 1929 anymore! People can be trusted with and can deal with unpalatable truths, people can forgive, and extend grace to each other, and in so doing we can build up the kingdom as we each are strengthened in faith and encouraged by each other and guided by God so to do. We are all less than perfect. But church leaders do not sit spiritually far from the flock – they are not elevated to Godlike-status just because they are leaders. Pope Francis said he is a sinner first and foremost – and so are we all. We all fall from grace, but we are also all one in Christ Jesus, and each one of us must abide by the spiritual guidelines we are all called to follow in His Word – there are no exceptions.

Here are some ‘General’ words:

We have a gospel that matches the hour,
We have discovered the true source of power,
Man is a weakling, but he can be strong,
Choosing the right and refusing the wrong.
Man has no meaning, no purpose, no soul,
Till he discovers that God is his goal.
This is the gospel that claims all our powers,
This is good news for this age of ours.

General Cox – we have the gospel that matches the hour. Are you the man for the hour? I pray that you are.

FSAOF

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

GENERAL COX: A DEEPER SPIRITUAL LIFE Part Two


GENERAL COX: YOU HAVE CALLED US TO A DEEPER SPIRITUAL LIFE.

Very recently at the New Zealand Congress, General André Cox said he dreams of a Salvation Army that is ‘vibrant, committed and on its knees before God. He said ‘Deepening the spiritual life of Salvationists is essential to moving forward as an Army. If we want to see our world change, we ourselves must be changed by God’. The General is correct regarding this continuous need for personal and corporate holiness. There is no doubt that we are not as zealous as those who first served in The Salvation Army. We cannot expect to grow or change this present age without first deepening our personal spiritual lives. Without the Holy Spirit’s guidance and direction we will find ourselves divided by winds of discouragement and discord.

SALVATIONISTS ARE CALLING FOR SPIRITUAL CHANGE:

From The Salvation Army’s ‘Central Youth Network’: We are an Army rich in both worldly resources and intelligent, passionate people. The answer is not more money, more soldiers, more officers, or the like; the answer is a fresh anointing of the Holy Spirit’s power and presence in each of our lives! The answer is more sensitivity and submission to God’s leading, over our own interest and self-preservation. The answer is a more radical abandonment of our earthly loves and concerns, for the sake of God’s will, finding fruitful expression in the lives of every soldier and officer. Let’s encourage and spur one another on towards that.

YOUNG PEOPLE ARE ASKING –

‘How can we avoid the swamp of irrelevancy, of reputation-protecting at all costs, and of division? How do we find an authentic True North that serves the vision, but might call upon us to change, which might seem unnatural or risky? But … extraordinary leaders … seek a more nuanced understanding forging solutions that embrace both the principles they hold dear while at the same time acknowledging real-world factors. The Salvation Army was not created to be risk-averse …’

TO THAT END -

We call for a visionary leader who would throw out all the baggage attached to TSA hierarchy and actually change the Army for the greater good.

We call for a visionary leader who will put people and communities first before the self-serving trappings of rank and 'power'.

We call for a visionary leader who would subjugate the secular ‘One Army’ and give pre-eminence to ‘One Lord’.

We call for a visionary leader with the spiritual gift of discernment: ‘Teach me good judgment and knowledge (Psalm 119:66)  

We call for a visionary leader to inspire us to recapture the evangelical fervour of the early day Salvationists.

We call for a visionary leader to restore solid biblical teaching to our young people, many of whom we prize as ‘Army’ but who are largely spiritually illiterate and ill-equipped to recognise the dangers and temptations that would take them away from Christian service.

We call for a visionary leader who will peel back the layers of the Army’s worldly wealth and corporate influence to find the soul of the people beneath, and to stand up for the gospel of Christ and not bow to demands for conditional spiritual nihility.

We call for a visionary leader who will instigate a Biblically authenticated democracy within the ranks for everyone, regardless of age – a leader who will allow challenges to be raised, and challenging questions to be asked, and who will put an end to the constant positive spin that exists in Army media today. It is just not realistic.

We call for a visionary leader who will put an end to the totalitarian practices that exist, where soldiers, adherents, friends are denied a voice to challenge what they see as wrong.


There is more for which we could call, but the above list shows there is much within our Army which needs addressing.

It isn't 1929 anymore! People can be trusted with and can deal with unpalatable truths, people can forgive, and extend grace to each other, and in so doing we can build up the kingdom as we each are strengthened in faith and encouraged by each other and guided by God so to do. We are all less than perfect. But church leaders do not sit spiritually far from the flock – they are not elevated to Godlike-status just because they are leaders. Pope Francis said he is a sinner first and foremost – and so are we all. We all fall from grace, but we are also all one in Christ Jesus, and each one of us must abide by the spiritual guidelines we are all called to follow in His Word – there are no exceptions.

Here are some ‘General’ words:

We have a gospel that matches the hour,
We have discovered the true source of power,
Man is a weakling, but he can be strong,
Choosing the right and refusing the wrong.
Man has no meaning, no purpose, no soul,
Till he discovers that God is his goal.
This is the gospel that claims all our powers,
This is good news for this age of ours.

General Cox – we have the gospel that matches the hour. Are you the man for the hour? I pray that you are.

Salvationist UKT

Sunday, October 6, 2013

Francis sends strong message to the Curia PART ONE


Francis sends strong message to the Curia and the Vatican high life
A last-minute no-show by Pope Francis at a concert where he was to have been the guest of honor has sent another clear signal that he is going to do things his way and does not like the Vatican high life.


Amid allegations of mismanage-ment erupting in the Vatican, and accusations of impropriety shaking the Vatican bank – both problems blamed on the secretive administrative body, the Roman Curia - the new Pope has been asked to usher in major reforms that would decentralize power.
Pope Francis has already signaled his independence from some of the Vatican’s traditional channels, and his biggest governance move, as yet, has been the creation of an advisory group of eight outside cardinals to help him usher in Curial reform. He specifically stated that the Curia should be at the service of the church, the bishops and the pope — not vice versa.

But he has hinted that bigger changes could be coming, including possible structural changes to the conferences of bishops - the synods. He also pointedly warned that certain departments in the Curia, when functioning poorly, risk ‘becoming institutions of censorship’. ‘For too long’, he said, ‘the people in the pews have felt distanced from their priests, bishops and the Vatican. That is not the gospel of love and service that Jesus preached and shared with the world in word and deed’.

He has attacked his own church leaders. He said 'Heads of the church have often been narcissists, flattered and thrilled by their courtiers. The Curia is 'Vatican-centric', serving its own interests and neglecting the world around us. I do not share this view and I'll do everything I can to change it'.

His comments could have been describing SA leadership, especially in the light of the decisions made in the Howard Hospital issue. The Curia has its equivalent in the Salvation Army in the General and his ‘inner circle’ of Commissioners at IHQ. They, too, forgot the suffering world around them in the choice of serving self and Army first, and in not considering the plight and human dignity of the Chiweshe people.

If the world leader of 1.2billion members of the Roman Catholic church can contemplate a much-needed change in leadership style – a style on which TSA leadership is modeled, why can’t our own leaders grasp the nettle and instigate change? God knows, change is long overdue in our quaint, old-fashioned institution – called by God in the 19th century, and still holding fast to many of its rules today, especially those of leadership.

SALVATIONIST 
IUKT



A Straight Southern Christian Redneck on Homophobia


A Straight Southern Christian Redneck on Homophobia


128415128
I'm not judging homosexuals. The Bible clearly states that it's wrong, so these people are making a conscious choice to live a life of sin. That's why they can't be Christians, and if they're allowed to marry, it will destroy our society.
This is the argument I have heard many times, mostly from dear friends in the South. It amazes me how they perceive this one sin as a conscious choice, but not the other 660-plus sins listed in the Bible. Let me be very clear: All sins are on purpose. No one has ever tripped and accidentally fallen into a sin. To sin is human, regardless of whether it's planned or spontaneous. Sin is not synonymous with right and wrong. If it were, Heaven would be an empty place.

To be fair, some of my gay friends make the argument that their love and same-sex marriage is not what the Bible is referring to, and hence not a sin. I don't know. I am familiar with every passage regarding homosexuality and have read them many times, but I guess I lack the intelligence to fully understand it. That point, however, is moot. The most dangerous things in any society are hate, fear, prejudice, and intolerance.

Let us assume, for sake of this argument, that homosexuality on any level is a sin. Making gay marriage illegal does not un-gay people, so it saves no one. Jesus said that thinking an action is the same as acting upon it, so even if a gay person does not ever engage in homosexual sex, it would not matter. So this anti-gay position, which perceives homosexuality as an unforgivable sin, changes nothing.

The Bible is very clear that there is only one unforgivable sin, and it's not homosexuality. The fact is that we are all born incapable of living a sin-free existence, and I'm certain that most of us are guilty of sexual sins. I don't know one heterosexual guy who hasn't fantasized about some woman he's not married to, be it a neighbor, a co-worker, a celebrity, etc.,and if we're to believe Jesus, then not acting on these desires does not excuse the sin. That's right: We're all the same.

This means all anti-gay arguments are based solely on personal prejudice, and this is easy to prove. For example, there are over 1 million divorces in the U.S. every year. The number-one reason listed is "irreconcilable differences." Adultery makes up a small percentage.

But Jesus, who never said anything about homosexuality, was adamantly clear on divorce. He said that if a man divorces his wife for a reason other than adultery or fornication, the divorce itself causes her to commit adultery, and any man who marries her after that commits adultery also. That means that approximately 1 million people in this country alone every single year are not only choosing to live a life of sin but condemning possibly 1 million more to sin too. Yet how many times have you heard of people petitioning the government to outlaw divorce?

In fact, when a woman leaves a man for his drinking, gambling, or being abusive, etc., we totally support her and commend her for having the courage to get out of a bad marriage. Why do we do that when the Bible is crystal clear on divorce? Why does the Bible suddenly not seem important?

Divorce is a sin that affects many more people than homosexuality, and yet we ignore the teachings of Jesus here.

The New Testament is very clear about how to conduct your life. The Bible is not a weapon, nor is it a measuring unit with which to prove that you are a better Christian than someone else. It never instructs you to ignore your own sins while singling out others' sins that you don't like. It makes it clear that your sins are the same as those of others.

The Bible is the ultimate DIY book. It explains that you are to let your life be an example to others, a light, a beacon. Even Jesus met with the worst sinners He could find. Those were the people He came for. Those were the ones who needed His love and light the most. So if someone truly believes that being gay is worse than other sins, although this in not backed up by the Bible, they should embrace homosexuals, love them, and let their life shine for them.

Ironically, if anyone chooses to see homosexuals as different, if they believe that gay people do not deserve the same basic rights as everyone else, if they choose to take any anti-gay stance at all, they're making a conscious choice to live a life of sin.

Friday, October 4, 2013

DEAR JOHN… WELCOME!


Dr. John
In response to the appointment of the Rev’d. Canon Dr. Jeffrey John
as the Dean of St. Albans Cathedral

Much (too much?) has been said and written about the appointment of the
Reverend Canon Dr. Jeffrey John as the Dean of St. Albans Cathedral. The debate, inevitably, has focused largely on Dr. John’s homosexuality.
First things first, I would like to offer a personal and public welcome to Dr. John. I realise even as I write that I will probably be disappointing a number of my colleagues in Christian ministry by offering a strong welcome to a professing homosexual, but I’m afraid I make no apology for doing so, for under what circumstances can it ever be wrong to welcome a stranger and a newcomer to an area? Common courtesy demands at least that much of me, and how can I make a valid profession of loving my neighbour if I insist upon their sexuality being the same as mine (I am heterosexual) before I am prepared to make them as welcome as I possibly can? Do I carry out an audit of my new neighbour’s sexual preferences before welcoming him or her to the neighbourhood? Of course not, and I refuse to be drawn into such uncharitable behaviour.

Therefore, Dr. John, welcome!

Secondly, I am appalled that there has been such an amount of hostility directed towards Dr. John. As a Christian minister of ten years’ experience, I find it depressingly sad that a person who is brave and honest enough to make an open declaration of his homosexuality is treated with suspicion, fear and unkindness. This is all the more disappointing (and hypocritical) when it is cloaked under the veneer of Christianity. (This, I would point out, is the same Christianity that operates from a basis of Jesus’ teaching that we should love one another.) Such hostility, I suspect, has more to do with insecurity and self-righteousness than authentic righteous indignation.

Thirdly, it seems to have gone largely un-noticed that Dr. John has chosen to remain celibate for several years now. I respect him for this. Celibacy is not a calling I would easily cherish! To bring one’s sexual inclinations under submission (voluntarily) is an act of strength and dignity, and I am wondering why Dr. John remains the target of abuse when he is proving himself (present tense) to be a leader of conviction. I should imagine this conviction is carried with some degree of personal pain and heartache, and I for one have no right to add to that pain by weighing in with my opinion, however pious it might make me feel to do so.

I would like to make it clear that I regard homosexual practice to be sinful, and contrary to Biblical teaching. I am not convinced by the arguments put forward by some practising Christian homosexuals that they are free to indulge their passions without being guilty of contravening God’s standards, and I would be very happy to discuss the matter with anyone who cares to take issue with me, providing they are prepared to refer to the Bible as their yardstick.

Having said that, I am acutely aware of the fact that Jesus himself taught that only he who is without sin is fit to cast the first stone. I am also aware of the fact that Jesus taught that we are not to judge. From the amount of judgment that has (regrettably) been cast in Dr. John’s direction, I can only assume that some Christians have decided to conveniently forget what Jesus said about judging other people, or that there are whole churches full of people out there, stones poised, who have led perfectly sinless lives. When did it suddenly become permissible to cast those stones or make those judgments, all the more so when the majority of us know nothing whatsoever of the struggles faced by Christians with undeniable homosexual tendencies?

And finally! Even a cursory reading of the Bible, especially the NewTestament, will reveal that the practice of homosexuality is but one of many sins that upset and sadden God. Why, then, do we never hear public calls for Christians who gossip, criticise and malign to be removed from the Church, or prevented from holding office, when the Bible strongly condemns such offences (at least as much as it condemns the practice of homosexuality, if not more so)? Why are we so strident (and thoughtless) in our condemnation of homosexuals when much more common sins such as gluttony, fornication and adultery, for example, are, when carried out by heterosexuals, frequently looked upon in a much more sympathetic and altogether more humane light?

Could someone please tell me what makes homosexuals and their sin any more wicked than heterosexuals and theirs? By what token do we condemn the person whose thoughts include fantasies of a homosexual nature, whilst at the same time hardly giving mention to heterosexuals whose thoughts often play host to lust, anger and backbiting, to name but three offences? If we really cannot help throwing stones at Dr. John, let us at least be consistent and avoid the peculiar but all-too-common tendency towards singling out one sin and area of human weakness at the expense of many others. It was said of Jesus that he was full of grace and truth. It would be a shame indeed if truth was concentrated on to such an extent that any element of grace in our dealings with one another was gradually eroded. We might discover that that would upset and sadden God more than we realise.

Stephen Poxon
Former Officer
IUKT

Bright Hope for Tomorrow (conclusion)


FSAOF Commentary
Tariro – An ongoing story of hope
Conclusion 

Bright Hope for Tomorrow (conclusion)

The biggest humanitarian issue caused by the departure of Dr. Thistle was that the people who counted on the Howard for surgical skills suddenly found themselves without.  It cannot be said that it was only Dr. Thistle’s skills that brought people to Howard Hospital – rather, it was the on-going availability of advanced surgical skills having been available to the people of Chiweshe for almost 50 years. Even in times of great distress and war, people were still able to have their surgical needs taken care of at an affordable price. Then, in the blink of an eye, this was ripped away.

For the Tariro article to single out a specific period of time (2004-2012) and infer that was the only period of time that advanced surgery was available is misleading. The article states "Before 2003, the hospital operated at the level of a rural district hospital...The intention is to return to this sustainable level of working."   

It appears as if the intention is to discredit Dr. Thistle's excellent care, but remember he started in 1995.  Certainly the level of surgical expertise was available when he started at Howard. The hospital ceased to be sustainable at this time (2003 and forward) due to blockages at THQ.  Donations stopped coming through or were severely delayed.  Concurrently, Zimbabwe government grants became valueless due to run-away inflation.  So Dr. Thistle appealed for, and received, more direct donations to the hospital, all of which went through the hospital books but bypassed Zimbabwe THQ and IHQ, to their displeasure.  Had he not done so, aware of THQ’s history of controlling the hospital’s funding,  HH would have closed long ago.  As for sustainability, it appears that the hospital, having lost these donors, is now running largely on IHQ reserves.  How sustainable is this?

But the year 2004 does have a milestone associated with it. That was the year that the Howard moved into the public spotlight, at least in Canada. Dr. Thistle delivered conjoined twins, Tinashe and Tinotenda, in 2004, and arranged with Canadian doctors and The Hospital for Sick Kids in Toronto to take on the case of Tinashe and Tinotenda. The twins, along with a nurse from Howard Hospital, flew to Canada, where they underwent the processes necessary to separate them. The surgery was successful, and today the boys are healthy and well.

If there was any lack of capacity at Howard Hospital to support the work, which is disputable, one could point to the difficulties faced with internal Army processes and procedures, most notably those involving the disbursal of funds for salaries, supplies and equipment.

Also, another point to keep in mind – in 2004, Dr. Paul and Pedrinah Thistle were not yet Salvation Army officers. The invitation from the Army to the Thistles to become officers was not extended until 2005. They were commissioned in 2007. Their time in appointment at Howard Hospital as Salvation Army officers was 5 years, a considerably much shorter period of time than that of Major Gibson, and Dr. Thistle’s predecessor.

Another Salvationist, retired Swedish Dr. Per-Gote Lindgren  has been brought onboard at Howard Hospital. From reading the description of his duties, it seems that quite a load has been placed on Dr. Lindgren. He will be providing advanced surgical training, coordinating the move into the new hospital facility when it is completed and developing management and clinical systems.

One has to wonder, if the Salvation Army is moving away from advanced medical care and away from hospital facilities with state-of-the-art surgical provisions, into a primary-care focus, why is Dr. Lindgren going to be teaching advanced surgical procedures? This presents a dichotomy in what the Salvation Army’s statements about the future role of health care provided will be, in SA medical care facilities. And would not these advanced surgical procedures once again put the Howard Hospital right back to where it was in the period of 2004-2012? Will the staff, support services and laboratory be able to keep up with this level of surgical service? Will it be “sustainable”? It is hard to tell what the real path for Howard Hospital is – a mostly primary care facility that refers more difficult cases to the provincial governmental hospitals or a true hospital providing multiple types of surgery at varying levels of difficulty?

Also, if as the article states, Dr. Lindgren will not be working as a general medical officer, who will be providing the follow-up care of the patients who receive the advanced surgical procedures that are going to be taught? It would seem to be obvious that follow-up care after advanced surgery will have to be taught as part of the overall procedure. Or is the intention to show the trainees how to do the surgery and leave it up to them to do the follow-up care on their own?

The Tariro programs for HIV, tuberculosis and the ARV program for expectant mothers are said to be operating in the same manner as before August of 2012. The absence of statistics indicating the numbers of patients under treatment provides no context to judge the validity of this statement.

Additionally, the USAID-funded ARV program is seemingly financially supported independently of any constraints of the Salvation Army Zimbabwe THQ, although it is unclear who generates the “independent” reports submitted to USAID for the funding and to which entity the funding is paid, or if any deductions are made at the Zimbabwe THQ level for “administrative costs” when the funding does arrive.

Lastly, the article touts the soon-to-be launched Howard Hospital website, as if this was a new development. There is no mention of the previous Howard Hospital website that was shut down the beginning of 2013 without warning or explanation.

The Tariro article closes by saying “as the Salvation Army works to improve the services at the hospital."  The wording should actually state,  "restore" rather than "improve",  as the Howard Hospital history from 1965 until mid-2012 showed a hospital that was one of,  if not the best, mission hospitals in Zimbabwe, with a reputation for excellence in care and medical services. The reported restoration process over the last few months, though, is praiseworthy. 

It is the sincere hope and prayer of many people who have followed the events at Howard Hospital over the years, and particularly the scores of thousands in the last 12-14 months, that the Howard Hospital returns to its reputation as a place of hope, healing and restoration for the people of Chiweshe.


Jolinda Cooper
Former SA Officer
FSAOF USA South

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Silence Isn’t Golden


Silence Isn’t Golden

Confronted by headlines about truly questionable practices at a few dozen charities, the response of too many nonprofit leaders has been to bury their heads in the sand and try to pull the hole in after them. What these leaders fail to appreciate is that silence in response to scandalous behavior is neither golden nor in their best interests….

Declining confidence in charities isn't in anyone's interests. Unfortunately, it's likely to become a fact of life if national and local nonprofit leaders refuse to speak up. Trying to sidestep the issue instead of condemning selfish and uncharitable behavior is an abdication of both public responsibility and private organizational stewardship.

…. We need nonprofit leaders willing to work to restore Americans' confidence in the sector’s ability to serve the common good and to embrace the fact that a principal function of charity is to connect us to each other and our communities. Expanding and strengthening such connections surely will increase the level and effectiveness of charitable giving.

It's critical that nonprofit leaders find their voice on this issue, and not simply because the silence of good people serves to encourage the bad actors. In the current environment, public officials, be they tax authorities or attorneys general, lack the resources and/or legal power to prosecute malefactors; they need our help. Speaking out against sleazy practices and shameless operators is the least we can do. The interests of the sector, and the public, demand it.
Mark Rosenman

(Mark Rosenman is an emeritus professor at the Union Institute & University and directs Caring to Change, an initiative that seeks to improve how foundations serve the public. He urges readers to assess how they value the things they value.)
__________________________________________

Silence is a primary tool of concealment, and is usually implemented by whatever means are available, no matter how unethical they might be.

The most immediate lesson is that the phrase, “Silence is golden,” is most often spoken by people who have ugly things to hide, attitudes and behaviors that they want neither exposed or changed. Silence is the golden goal of abusers, liars and criminals.

The reason is simple. They don’t like having their corruption brought to any kind of accountability.

Everyone who does evil hates the light, and will not come into the light for fear that their deeds will be exposed. But whoever lives by the truth comes into the light, so that it may be seen plainly that what they have done has been done in the sight of God. (John 3:20-21)

Any time a leader preaches that silence is golden, there is likely something sinister to hide.

Speaking out helps to prevent further abuse.

In contrast to the effects of silence, speaking out can accomplish much. Pressure brought to bear by public opinion is usually an effective deterrent to abuse. Once abuses become common knowledge, leaders have an opportunity to repent and change. If they repent, their ministries will be stronger for it. If they do not, at least many others will be warned. This is the reason for Paul’s admonition to Timothy:
“But those elders who are sinning you are to reprove before everyone, so that the others may take warning.” (1 Timothy 5:20)

The case could be made that when we have the freedom to speak, then we have an obligation:
“But if the watchman sees the sword coming and does not blow the trumpet to warn the people and the sword comes and takes someone’s life, that person’s life will be taken because of their sin, but I will hold the watchman accountable for their blood.” (Ezekiel 33:6)

Bonhoeffer had it right. Silence is not a virtue. Silence when corruption is affecting the lives of other people is evil. Not everyone can speak. Those under the pressure of oppression may not have the freedom to speak or to use their voice, but if you do, then use it. 

It turns out that truth is golden. At best, silence is fool’s gold.

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

FSAOF Commentary Tariro - An ongoing story of hope – PART Five


FSAOF Commentary

Tariro – An ongoing story of hope
PART Five

Bright Hope for Tomorrow - Continued

The balance of the final section of the Tariro article focuses medical services delivery – past, present and future. Once again, one needs to stop and consider each topic carefully for what is being said and the way it is being presented.

Beginning with the volunteer program, the article claims that the volunteer program was halted after the “disruption” in 2012.  This is false.  A letter dated May 16, 2012, long before the disruptions in August, was issued which stated that the volunteer program had been suspended "to develop a program that will be more manageable". In other words, THQ Zimbabwe wanted to control the volunteer program at Howard Hospital.  

There are only future plans for volunteers and only at a scaled down level.  It will be interesting to see what these future plans contain. It is uncertain if those organizations and volunteers that have supported Howard Hospital in the past will consider supporting it again, or if they’ll even be welcome. 

In the middle of September 2013, once such volunteer was refused admittance to the hospital grounds and facility. This happened to a medical professional who has served multiple-month long volunteer engagements at Howard Hospital every year since 1993. The volunteer was trying to see a long-time Salvation Army officer friend who had been admitted to the hospital. Fortunately, the volunteer stood their ground and was able to see their friend before his death.

This incident is not an exception. Others who have previously volunteered at and/or donated to Howard have been denied permission to visit the hospital. This is an objectionable policy, particularly for a public hospital, and it is uncharitable in light of all that these donors and volunteers have contributed in terms of skills, talents, time and money.

The search for a replacement Chief Medical Officer (CMO) was outlined in the article. It is certainly understandable that the Army would seek to replace Dr. Thistle with a Zimbabwe national. However, a Zimbabwean was not available. This is not surprising, as there have been many newspaper articles which report that many doctors leave Zimbabwe after completing their required residencies. They seek out better opportunities in other countries.

Because of this, the Army reached out and asked another Salvationist who served as CMO in an Army hospital. The young doctor, along with his wife and children are from India. While his curriculum vita is impressive, it leans more toward the administrative side of things. Under his administration of Howard Hospital, the numbers are improving, which is a good sign.

A report from the local community indicates, however, that he does not seem, they feel, as skilled as the two Zimbabwe doctors, who had additional training from Dr. Thistle.  It is not clear how long the Zimbabwe doctors will stay now.  They still are asking for Dr. Thistle to be returned, feeling that without him, Howard will be just another clinic.

It must be pointed out that Dr. Pachuau was not even approached until October 2012, more than two months after Dr. Thistle was given his marching orders, and wasn’t officially on staff until the end of August 2013.

Would it not have been more practical, professional, compassionate and reasonable to have left Dr. Thistle in place, with a plan of transition of care between Dr. Thistle and Dr. Pachuau? Doing so would have ameliorated a large percentage of the issues caused by the abrupt dismissal and departure of Dr. Thistle.

…to be continued

  Jolinda Cooper, Former Officer - USA