Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Are these the last times for us?


Hardly anyone could have escaped being affected by the (dramatic) presentation of the SA's dwindling members development in recent decades, a TV feature some time ago. There was no intent by the TV network to damage the SA. It was simply a factual description.

Nonetheless it caused caused sadness and angst , when the evidence was presented in black and white, although all now have a color TV!

Many issues came to the surface such as; Are these the last times for us? Is there any point in continuing? How did it come to this, etc.?

Emotions are also a factor. Sadness of course, and maybe even a smattering of shame. What is wrong with us?

I remember even as a cadet in the early 70s hearing that ”we only had about 10 years of life left ”. As we all know that did not happen. And it will not be the case this time either.

Well, it's true and well known that membership numbers are decreasing in all organization, trade unions, political parties, etc. For the church's part, the numbers are consistent across Europe. The number of church members is falling. We don’t deny this, of course, and we experience the pain.

‬However, there is another statistic that is also interesting and important, namely that which concerns 'attendance' i.e., the number of people attending religious services, attend get-to-gethers, participate in programs of various types and are involved in the SA's various programs. This figure increases steadily and has done so for many years. Through these type activities the number of people with whom the SA has contact in one way or another has never been greater.

This applies to Europe. Looking at the global scene we know that we (the SA) are now active in 126 countries, Cambodia is the latest country where we’ve 'opened fire'. We have never in our history worked in so many places as we do now, and never been larger in numbers than now. In the last 15 years in Europe alone work has recommenced, or initiated in 13 new countries. I don’t call this decline: it’s expansion!

Therefore, my impression of the SA is that we are more God-oriented than SA oriented. This means that we are more focused on our mission than the organization itself.

For my own part, it leads to my being disappointed but not fearful. Let me try to explain. The lessening of membership  expansion saddens me, but had I sensed a lessening in our mission resolve, then I’d be very fearful. It is my absolute conviction that we, the SA in Sweden, Europe and the world, are heavily focused on fulfilling the mission God gave us from our very beginning. Have faith, we do what we’re called to!

It would be comforting if we could explain that we are becoming fewer and fewer, but it turns out that it is not so easy. Those among us who are most guiltridden tend to think in terms of, there’s something wrong with us, there’s something that we’re not doing right, and that God therefore won’t bless us with an increase in our members.

Personally, I believe much in the explanation. Of course, we could all be more committed, mature, full of the Spirit, more Christlike, etc. But I'm not at all convinced that the reasons for declining membership lies with us as individuals or as a denomination.
‬
Rather, it has to do with the spirit of this world in the community. When I worked at (SA International Secretary) IHQ and had reason to study and reflect on the SA in Europe, I remember that I came to see Europe as a lost son, who we read about in Luke 15; broke from his roots, such as Christian faith and tradition, but eventually came back to what he’d once left.

I pray, hope and believe that we will see such a return in Europe and in Sweden. Until then we will do as the father in the parable, persevere and carry on!


Hasse Kjellgren, Commissioner
Stockholm South Corps
Commanding Officer 

Translation: Sven Ljunghom

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

We Need Officers... Part Three


God has already supplied the Army with all the evangelistic tools needed to fulfill that part of His great commission assigned to us.  There are however, two resources lacking; the abundance of time and well-trained, committed Salvation Army officers. 

The next two articles in this series will share additional statistics; reasons why FSAOF resigned their officerships and the vast available resource represented to advance the salvation war.

Ever since the FSAOF's inception a principle intent and goal was to serve alongside SA leaders. The USA West TC, Commissioner Jim Knaggs  is known, with respect as a 'mover and shaker', and an effective and superb innovator. I pray that we, the FSAOF, can together with the US Western territory introduce new thinking to thwart attrition and indeed, to effect a return of 'formers' to substantive rank.




General Shaw Clifton’s concern was expressed in his article, “If Crosses Come” in a 2009 The Officer article.

‘Each year I receive the global annual statistics for officer resignations and dismissals. Those, for the calendar year of 2007 show that fewer colleagues left officership than in 2006. Of approximately 16,500 active officers, 257 or 1.6% left in 2007 (274 or 1.9% in 2006).’

Today's stats will speak to the unique quality of our ‘formers’. They're SA trained, and the additional education, experience, professionalism and maturity gained since their resignation signal out many as the ideal resource to bring on board in order to put in motion some of the Commissioner's visionary plans. The re-hiring of professionals who's skills have been further honed elsewhere is one of the most effective means of moving an organization that's settled into complacency to return to a vibrancy and to move forward again. Look at what happened right down the street from the USA West’ THQ when Apple brought back Steve Jobs! 


The General details the cause and effect (%) of resignations: 

Domestics, marital or family; 25.29 %
Dissatisfaction; (appointment/remuneration); 21.01%
Misconduct; 19.06%
Unsuited for further service; 9.7%
Transfer to another church; 6.23%
Marriage to non-officer; 5.8%
Feeling discouraged; 5.4%
Health issues; 5.4 %
Health of spouse; .4 %)
Doctrinal issues; 1.55 %

The General's comments reflect a positive position and consequently, one of lesser urgency than those shared regularly by officers in the field, SA soldiers generally, and those shared in the FSAOF blog. One must remember though the General was addressing the world- wide army and needed to put on the best possible face. However, two UK denominations challenged TSA’s official claim, with one calling us ‘naïve’ and the other ‘self-deceptive’.

Assuming the resignations remain at a percentage level of between 1.5 and 2 %, one must also remember that each departing officer often represents a significant number of years of active service; experience and commitment.

The average number of years of service represented by members of the FSAOF is approximately 12-14, or a combined 15,000 years (1,000+ members worldwide). Further, at the current rate of departure, this represents a staggering 2,500 experienced and tested officers ‘leaving the work’ every decade. And the cost?

In 2011 it costs the UKIT between £50 and 60,000 per annum to train a Cadet. ($80,000.00+ USD) – confirmed through THQ sources. Over a two-year period the cost will be a minimum of £100,000 per commissioned officer ($160,000.00). The cost is, when tested against the provision of a similarly capitol city institution very modest! Yet, if the current attrition rate continues it translates as a ROI loss of more than £1,000,000.00 per year.

It's unlikely that anyone knows for certain the exact numbers of those who have resigned their officership, or the cost to the army. However, a simple statistical review will reveal that the total number is well over fifteenthousand, and perhaps it's to everyone’s advantage to keep the count and cost private. Nonetheless, there's little doubt that the count exceeds the number of those still in active service. FSAOF members share that typically, fewer than 50% of their session mates remain in active service.

The personal loss to those resigning cannot, of course, be measured. The private FSAOF FB site includes hundred of statements (15 – 25 per day) detailing family break-ups, financial ruin, spiritual derailment and much more. Not all of the misery experienced could have been prevented but only a very few of the hundreds of formers speaks to any effort being made by TSA to provide counseling or other practical assistance.

A quick review of the FSAOF survey results; their profile and why they resigned…









TSA ADVANTAGES IN RECRUITING & REINSTATING
FORMER SA OFFICERS

A first and key step in formulating a successful strategy in seeking the return to active service is acknowledging that reconciliation and reform is necessary, identifying where and what ought to be the immediate objects of our focus. One need only take a cursory look at the many comments by former officers to recognize where a spirit of mutual respect and concern for the overall mission of TSA might have averted the alarmingly high percentage of officer resignations.





Survey results follow that speaks specifically to the suitability of scores of officers relative to their potential effectiveness should they be encouraged to seek a return and be re- accepted. 
More than 80% of former officers are college graduates with 40% having completed or working towards a post graduate degree. I don't believe there's a modern day organization that wouldn't envy the potential 'production boost' represented by the above credentials.


Sven Ljungholm

We Need Officers Part Two




“Part of the Army’s God-given genius is to move with the times. We were born out of a specific time and specific culture in English history, but God has moved Salvationism on and outward through many generation and into countless cultures ever since”. (Shaw Clifton)

‘If the future is to be improved, the present must be disturbed.’ 
Catherine Booth.

The Army’s Salvationism does indeed appear to move with the times. However, at times we appear to be our own enemy by not having our Army’s troop strength move in keeping up with the demands of time! Our ‘present’ is disturbed!

George Bernard Shaw, himself both an ardent critic and admirer of our movement since our fledgling days, wrote:  ‘You see things and say ‘why?’  But I dream things that never were, and I say ’why not?’  The people who get on in this world are the people who get up and look for the circumstances they want, and if they can’t find them, make them.’  Although his musings were not directed at the Army, we would do well to take them to heart today.  Could it be we need to change our circumstances; change our thinking; change our ways of operating?

My father, a SA officer and CPA was promoted to glory while the Territorial Financial Secretary in the USA Central Territory. He said to me when I was promoted to District Sales Manager of a large transatlantic airline, “If you want your sales people 
to remember key points, shock them with memorable statistics – percentages, whether positive or negative!”

Here’s a look at both ends of the scale:

The International Salvation Army

1910;     34 Territories*  30,000 active officers   1,600,000 SA Soldiers (not confirmed)

2010;    121 Territories   17,145 active officers    1,124,760 SA Soldiers

Using the simplest of equations: 100 years ago there was an officer corps of approximately 1,000  officers per country/territory.

Today the officer strength has been reduced by approximately 80% and the soldiers’ strength halved as it pertains to territories/commands.

(The Army’s explosive growth a century ago resulted mainly through the Junior War. The Training College curricula required to be taught cadets in Training Garrisons in 1894 had already (and much more) been taught in the SA junior schools. Cadets in 1910 understood as much of Army spirit, method and teaching as the staff officers did in 1894. Booth’s principles of self-sacrifice and love for souls were the spirits that increased as the years rolled on. Had General Booth not undertaken the Junior War that world won by the SA might have been lost forever!) 


Is it time to revamp our Junior War programs? What are they and their effectiveness?
 

Here’s what General Eva Burrows said about Army activities and our organization at The Salvation Army USA Eastern Territorial Congress 25 years ago:  ‘The Salvation Army has become more task orientated than vision orientated – we are spending too much time in our various tasks and not enough time seeking God’s will for the future of our movement … We must change our priorities!’ 

Have we become too ‘organizational’ and less ‘visionary’?  The writer of Proverbs warns us in no uncertain terms as you well know:  ‘Without a vision the people perish.’  Was ever a Biblical warning more relevant!

Dwindling membership is not unique to the Army.  Other church leaders struggling to find answers concur with our own leader’s assessment that our priorities need to be reconsidered.  Oswald Chambers shares his insight in ‘Shadows of Agony’ as it relates to organizations like ours:  ‘God has no concern about our organizations (in themselves).  Organization is a great necessity, but not an end in itself; and to live for any organization is a spiritual disaster.’  Could it be that we have become too busy living for the organization and that we haven’t given ample time seeking the leading of God, the Holy Spirit?

What’s needed to turn the tide on the widening gulf between enlistments and resignations, retreats and retirements is a vision for the future.  John Stott says:  ‘Vision is the result of a deep dissatisfaction with the status quo’.  I believe our ‘present’ is sufficiently disturbed:  our dissatisfaction with the status quo deep enough that our indignation is already moving us to shape and focus visions for our future.

Blood and fire evangelism has never consisted simply of maintenance.  Our evangelistic stewardship as Salvationists lies not in ‘maintaining’ what we already have, our status quo, but in visualizing, allowing God, the Holy Spirit to project for us what we can become.  Evangelism translates as ‘progression’, never ‘caretaking’.  Army evangelism by its very definition speaks of conversion; sinners being saved, sworn in as soldiers, and sent to serve.  There’s nothing stagnant about evangelism.

The FSAOF has in the last 12 months met with SA leaders/representatives in two USA territories. And our mission will soon be known in the Canada and Bermuda Territory as our host at the USA East seminar takes on the mantle of CS in Toronto.

Tomorrow a senior administrator of the FSAOF USA West, Tony Hussey will meet with a THQ representative from the USA Western territory who’ll travel to their private fact finding meeting in Las Vegas, Nevada. We are grateful to Commissioner James Knaggs, the Territorial Commander for responding to Tony Hussey’s initiative.

Commissioner Knaggs is known as an especially creative, energetic and effective visionary. His interest and concern in ‘former’ officers has been demonstrated in private email exchanges with me, through his endorsement of our blog initiative, in meeting privately with ‘formers’ and in a public apology on behalf of the SA in 2011.

And what’s the status in the USA West?

1994  727 officers    93 Cadets   238 corps

2013  652 officers  105 Cadets   247 corps

In an era where most western world territories and commands are witnessing attrition rates that must make Booth shake both his head and fist, the USA West with its largest session of officer potential ever provides both a standard and vision for the future.

What then is a vision?

Vision perceives God’s will in the ongoing life of His Church.  It is the act of seeking to translate God’s will in the progressive life of His body.  Vision occurs as we earnestly focus on God’s ‘alternative’ to our status quo.  And the vision must never be confined to present circumstances or the ‘vision’ will forever be small.  Elton Trueblood stated, when speaking of the Church in an interview 30 years ago:  ‘Christ did not seek to build a little thing.  The chief way you and I are disloyal to Him is when we make small what He intended to make large.’

God, the Holy Spirit sees us as we are, assesses our needs and then supplies all we need.  Our stewardship lies in the acceptance of who we are, perceiving what we have been given by God, and with His leading, utilizing and making it ‘large’ for His glory.  God has already supplied the Army with all the evangelistic tools needed to fulfill that part of His great commission assigned to us.  There is, however, one thing lacking and that is an abundance of time.  And here I don’t want to imply Christ’s imminent return – I have no such insight.  I mean only that we ought to have about us both a sense of urgency and a sense of indignation.


Glad and Sven Ljungholm
Birkenhead Corps UKTI

Saturday, June 1, 2013

“We need Officers ... -1-




"We need Officers ...



Officership by its nature is about availability and mobility... We need people who are available. So the more officers the better!"
General Linda Bond

Two years earlier General Shaw Clifton wrote in his New Year 2010 Pastoral letter...

“This season of new beginnings allows us to place before the Lord also the hopes we have in our hearts concerning our daily work. Many of you reading this are Salvation Army officers making plans for the spiritual advancement of those you lead and those you serve in Christ's name. I say to you, 'May God bless those plans, those sacred ambitions for the souls of others.'

Today, just over two years later, more than 700 of the officers addressed in that Pastoral letter are no longer serving in the Army, having giving up their sacred ambitions in the role of SA officers committed to supporting General Bond’s appeal.

 ********************
A LOST VISION 

Twenty years ago while serving as a reinforcement officer in Sweden the then Chief Secretary, Colonel Gote Lindgren, lamented that the Swedish territory was experiencing the highest attrition rate in the Salvation Army world, a 78% decline. It was the army I’d grown up in as child, and had, at age 40, left a successful career in the airline industry to invest my life and that of my family in its ranks”.

The CS’s remark prompted me to put my professional market analysis skills to work. With some 20 – 25 SA Year books and other resource material at hand I set to work and analyzed soldier, officer and corps attrition rates of every SA territory worldwide. It was a four-month long labour of love;  joy coupled with disappointment.

What followed were a series of articles that I wrote for the Swedish Salvation Army “The Officer”, and subsequently translated in large part and published in a series in the International SA, The Officer.

Since those studies were completed 25 years ago, I have moved 11 times and to 5 different SA territories on both sides of the Atlantic. Nonetheless, those many sheets of typewritten pages (pre PC era) detailing SA officer statistics have somehow always found a place in my ‘must have files’. And in gleaning those old stats regularly through the years it's clear that the attrition problem not only remains to this day, but regrettably, it’s snowballing, and some would add, is out of control.

Had major changes been made three or four decades ago they might have prevented, or at the very least, stemmed the losses to large degree; thousands of officers have left their SA calling. True, many are faithfully serving God in other denominations, local corps and fellowships. However, the root of our (SA) problem then and now is that we’ve become mired down in maintaining the status quo, burdened by regulations that ought to have been rewritten and implemented from the day that they were first given even cursory attention.  And many also argue that the SA needs to study progressive Christianity and perhaps adapt and/or adopt certain provisions.

Studies conducted by the FSAOF indicate that the majority of those who went through the pain and anguish of divorce had wished to continue in active service. Had this in some form been permitted or the restrictions relaxed the army would have had opportunity to provide much needed counseling and spiritual support. And without question hundreds of officers would have returned to service, restored, reconciled with the Army and colleagues at the very least. It needs to be added that the regulations were applied with obvious and extreme partiality.

Concurrently, the dearth in the number of Candidates and accepted Cadets in western countries, coupled with the mandated retirement of officers at ages directed by law or TSA, casts a troublesome providence when witnessing the increased shortage of officers for today and the future.

                 *********************

THE HISTORY, MISSION AND ACTIVITIES OF THE FSAOF

 General William Booth, Field Officer (December 1900) pp. 453-4.

“The ex-officer, no matter what was the cause that resulted in his loss to our fighting forces, is still a child of the Army. He entered the sacred circle. He became one of us, sharing our joys and sorrows, losses and crosses. He received the commission of a divinely- appointed authority to proclaim Salvation, build up men and women in their most holy faith, and help to win someone to God.”




General Linda Bond wrote a year ago in the May-June 2012 issue of The Officer that the “way we (officers) lead still bears the mark of our life experiences.”

 The General shared that our spiritually charged leadership skills are honed through conferences attended, formal study, books read and advice from our mentors... realizing that what she does now is not much different from what she did as a corps officer; the relational challenges are not dissimilar. “So much has changed. Yet so much has not. We still lead as officers for him (God), for them, for life!”

If TSA were to use the accepted formula across Christian denominations acknowledging that; Fifty percent of all Pastors/Ministers resign from their appointed ministry role within a decade of their ordination they would have to acknowledge that there are at least 10,000+ former officers in the world with the majority living in North America and Western Europe. And, where are those thousands upon thousands of officers who have quit the field? The FSAOF has found 1,100 in our six years of existence. Is it worth the Army’s effort to find the other 14,000?

Next is to analyze why they resigned, and what did they do subsequent to leaving the ranks, and are their ‘spiritually charged leadership skills honed through conferences attended, formal study, books read and advice from mentors’ available to the Army as we seek to strengthen, restructure and realign a weakened band of officers?

In the last two decades the Army has opened fire in an additional 26 territories, a 26% increase but with only a 1% increase in its officer strength. More alarming is the realization that we’ve experienced an overall loss of 22% in the number of Cadets, the Army future leaders.

 Many will argue that reality is not as bleak as I’ve painted it; employees with appropriate professional skills have assumed many of the tasks previously held by commissioned officers.

Provided that it hasn’t cost us a great deal in additional financial expenditures I suppose that’s all well and good. However, employees assuming roles that require a spiritually committed, and ministry-focused person, i.e., a Salvation Army officer, should not be viewed as providing an equally valuable contribution to our overall mission, but rather as a loss. 

Accepting and agreeing with the Army’s mission statement may well qualify one as a Salvation Army employee but is a far cry from signing up and joining in the battle!

END PART ONE

Dr. Sven and Major Glad Ljungholm
Liverpool

The Future of TSA…


July 17, 2012


I am increasingly becoming certain of something that I have suspected for a while now – the future of TSA is in new converts; those who have been born again. Now that may be something that seems obvious, but for a long time now TSA has relied on the biological growth of corps (by that I mean those born into corps) and the longevity of existing soldiers. What we are now seeing in many parts of TSA (particularly Western cultures) is a decrease in soldiery and the shutting down of corps. Those born into TSA are not staying around and our older soldiers are being promoted to glory. Inevitably, if this trend continues, there will cease to be anyone to worship and spread the Gospel in many of our corps.

We are seeing, in many corps, an army whose soldiers are more interested in creating and maintaining a “worship service” where they come to get what they want out of it. If it is not the way they like it, they will complain. Worshipping God or introducing the unsaved to Jesus has become an afterthought (if any thought at all) to singing along to the songs that they like on a Sunday. This attitude is seen mainly in corps where very few people, if any, have been saved in the last ten years (or sometimes even more). There has been no growth from outside the four walls of the corps and once we start to see second and third (and more if applicable) generations of Salvationists, we increasingly see a separation from the outward mission focus TSA should have and a more inward selfish focus. The soldiers start to lose touch with the world and the covenant they signed and begin focusing on the things they want and like in meetings. The uniform is worn to distinguish and separate them from the ‘common people’. The attitude that TSA is there to serve them starts to manifest and genuine spirituality is replaced with rigid tradition. With this generally comes a refusal to change from those traditions and any attempts to implement anything new is met with the distressed but ironically errant cry of “It’s not the Army!”



While this isn’t always the case (there are many notable exceptions) there seems to be a complacency that is bred into subsequent generations of Salvationists. Growing up in the Church seems to, at times, veil the concepts of God’s omnipotence, omniscience, omniprescence. The fear of God is no longer taught and a familiarity with Jesus is over-emphasised, which hides the majesty of Christ from their minds and hearts. The recognition of their need for salvation is tainted by what they think they know of salvation and who it is for (it is for the sinners of the world, those separated from God. Unfortunately, they fail to recognise that they are part of that group). Consequently, worship becomes about personal preference and the benefit that they gain from it rather than giving God glory and honour and praise simply because He deserves it. Their passion and love for the Lord has grown cold and they have no desire to spread the gospel they don’t even truly understand.



This is why the future of TSA is found in new converts (those born again). You will not meet a more passionate and excited follower of Christ than someone who truly understands who they are in relation to Christ and exactly what Christ has done for them – those who have felt hopeless and lost, only to find that Christ is the answer to their lost and wretched lives. These are the people who will become the soldiers who will move TSA forward. These are soldiers who will fight for the heart of King Jesus, the ones who will fight for the salvation of the multitudes of poor souls going to hell every day. They recognise how lost they were, how in need they were of salvation and subsequently understand how desperately the lost, broken and hurting people of this world need their Saviour.


Above all, Jesus wants passionate soldiers who will fight for Him.
Soldiers who understand the urgency of spreading the Gospel to the lost souls of the world – people who stand condemned in their sin. Soldiers who are willing to sacrifice everything that they are, and have, to save people from hell. Soldier who are willing to give all of themselves to Him, because of their love for Christ and their gratitude for what He did at Calvary.