In Letter 13, Screwtape writes about how to encourage believers to claim anything they want, as long as they don’t convert their convictions into actions: “Let him, [the Christian] if he has any bent that way, write a book about it; that is often an excellent way of sterilizing the seeds which the Enemy [God] plants in a human soul. Let him do anything but act.”
While he’s referring to destroying or deferring virtuous living, his words apply to the many issues surrounding prayer as well. Knowing how to pray, versus actually praying, is like knowing how to eat properly but living on donuts. Common wisdom suggests that diets don’t work unless they become lifestyle changes and the same is true of praying. Screwtape says the enemy of your soul loves it when you learn how to pray, as long as you don’t pray.
Through the ages, millions of sincere practitioners have attempted to corral the “secrets” of prayer and countless more have attempted to teach others “how to” pray. Because praying is personal communion with God, contrived prayers using other’s words can leave you feeling frustrated and empty, not alive and brimming with faith. Martin Luther understood this when he prayed, “Grant that I may not pray alone with the mouth; help me that I may pray from the depths of my heart.”
Pay close attention to the words Jesus’ disciple used when asking Him for help with prayer, “And it came to pass, that, as he was praying in a certain place, when he ceased, one of his disciples said unto him, Lord, teach us to pray…” It’s not a great leap to suggest that the disciple’s desire was to learn to pray, not how to pray. He didn’t want a primer on techniques; he wanted to understand the desire that drove Jesus to pray as He did. Contrary to common belief, prayer is not an art form to learn, it’s an association to pursue. We need to activate personal motivations that cause us to want to pray more than learn “how to” pray. And we need less information and more inspiration about heightening spiritual desire to do whatever it takes to spend time with God.
Circumstantial Praying
Jimmy was driving down the street in a sweat because he had an important meeting and couldn't find a parking place. He was at a critical crossroad of circumstances, so he looked up to heaven he said: "Lord take pity on me. If you find me a parking place I’ll go to Church every Sunday for the rest of me life and give up drinkin’ and any other of my vile sins!" Miraculously, a parking place appeared. With that, Jimmy stopped, looked up again and said, "Never mind Lord, I found one."
Given the abundance of life’s crossroad moments, there’s plenty of fodder for meaningful and unceasing prayer, but too often we settle for praying about parking places. In Jimmy’s defense, any circumstance is an opportunity for prayer and the things that cause them, I call Prayer Triggers.
This book is my offering to help you learn to see and redeem circumstances, large or small, as the means of beginning meaningful communion with God. I’m not sure praying for a parking place is the best use of your time, but if it’s a need, go ahead and pray. However, don’t stop looking if one doesn’t suddenly appear and be prepared to walk a few blocks if necessary. Sometimes prayer doesn’t work like we think it ought to.
Creating a Thirst
Motivations to pray come many times a day, often disguised as challenges, callings, compulsions or conundrums. When life changes unexpectedly, usually for the worse, those changes act as either salt on your spiritual tongue, or like ipecac that makes you want to vomit. Using them like salt creates a thirst for God. David cried out: “My soul thirsts for You; My flesh longs for You in a dry and thirsty land where there is no water.” Note his cry was a metaphor about his dry and thirsty soul, not his back yard. More like a walking desert than a garden, David knew that God alone restores life.
The great Henri Nouwen understood the necessity and power of strong spiritual desire, and in The Only Necessary Thing: Living a Prayerful Life, he observes, “Our greatest desire should be to desire God. The more we pray-in the sense of living a prayerful life–the more we will want to pray.” A.W. Tozer, another powerful man of prayer, often quoted an unidentified source as saying the key to praying is to: “Pray until you pray.” Note, neither of these great hearts uttered one word about techniques because both understood that prayer is ultimately about need and desire, not about method or technique.
From such great men and women we learn that the essence of successful praying is knowing God before asking Him for anything. In other words, seek His presence before seeking His presents. Since that pretty much spills the beans about what prayer is, I’ll go ahead and add that any means of communion with God that reveals who He is and brings you into intimacy with Him is a great system.
Praying when Prayer Doesn’t Work
God’s primary purpose in your life is not to restore reputations, vindicate failures or sponsor your personal happiness. That’s your job. His first intention is much more profound than that. He wants to redeem your brokenness, transform your character and prepare you for eternal life. Psalm 65:5 says that God answers payers “…with awesome deeds of righteousness.” C. S. Lewis writes in The Problem of Pain that “God labors to make us lovable…what we would here and now call our happiness is not the end God chiefly has in view: but when we are such as He can love without impediment, we shall in fact be happy.” He wants to plant the seeds of righteous that will transform your character and make it like His. So He’ll use your surrendered pain (He doesn’t create it) to achieve your greatest good, something not found in temporary comforts or fickle happiness. Jonathan, our son-in-law’s email signature says it this way: “I had good plans for my life, but God has great plans for it.” (See 2 Corinthians 4: 17-18)
Here’s how that works: When I ask God for improvement in my circumstances, He gives me discernment. When I ask for vindication over painful and damaging slander, He teaches me to forgive. When I ask for individual power to impress others, He gives me spiritual authority to write or teach the truth.
Good News!
The good news about circumstantial praying is that the pressure’s off. There’s no need to experience confusion or frustration from unfruitful praying; there’s no need to try to explain God’s silence; there’s no need to believe you have to ride in second-class; there’s no need to wonder how pray formulas work. Best of all, there’s no need to lower your expectations to match your disappointments. Why? Because none of these negative spiritual reactions represent the mind or the heart of God. Just look at how boldly Jesus speaks when He promises things about praying, “Whatever you ask in My name, that will I do, so that the Father may be glorified in the Son. If you ask Me anything in My name, I will do it.” Notice, He says whatsoever and ask anything and I will do it. I think that means you can assume He’s either pulling your leg or very serious about wanting to answer your prayers.
End Part One
A Sliver of Light
In Praying When Prayer Doesn’t Work, I share the light that I received about successful praying. Its significance is not about gaining better techniques but in raising desires and expectations about God. The Holy Spirit’s light excites me. It ought to. Why? Because it provides the hope for even the most cynical or discouraged seeker to know that prayer-like life-builds success upon success. So the more you do it, the better it gets.
Prayer is not about convincing God to care about what you think you need most. He already knows that. And placing your piles of good or bad stuff on His lap isn’t what moves Him to respond. He’s moved to respond when your spirit opens to His because you learn to trust Him with any circumstance. Sometimes those spirit openings are pleasures, but most often, they’re borne by pain. The sad truth is that for virtually everyone, prayer is something we do when we’re in trouble or afraid, not when we’re okay.
C.S. Lewis on Writing About Truth
“…if you simply try to tell the truth (without caring two pence about how often it has been told before) you will, nine times out of ten, become original without ever having noticed it.”










