Wednesday, February 13, 2013

"Homophobia in the Salvation Army" GLBT Series 2013


"Homophobia in the Salvation Army"

The broadcast last week of, "People and Faith" on Swedish Radio featured a program entitled 'Homophobia in the Salvation Army' that highlighted the Swedish State Government financial subsidy to EKHO's efforts to change the Salvation Army’s Bible interpretation-position relative to homosexuals (being accepted as full fledged church members).

The program participants are:

- Stefan Gustavsson, director of the Swedish Evangelical Alliance, who questions why the government pays money to an organization in order to change the biblical vision of a Christian community.

- (Commissioner) Marie Willermark, leader of The Salvation Army in Sweden / Latvia, who clarifies the Salvation Army's position on the issue.

- Patrick Olterman, Corps Commanding Officer Malmö, who think it is tragic that the debate is about EKHO's grant application and not on how (church) congregations receive homosexuals.

- Cay Lennart Larsson, ‘Rainbow Priest’ (Lutheran Church), bisexual and former member of the Salvation Army, who says he loves the Salvation Army but not their ethical position condemning homosexual relationships.

My comments: (focusing on the broadcast’s content)

‘But hey, Cay Lennart, I understand that you think that the Salvation Army should have another Biblical viewpoint, but how can you say that the Salvation Army’s ethical position condemns homosexuals? The closest reference I can find that touches the question is this statement’: "We believe that God's view of sexuality is that it is expressed (lived) lovingly and mutually between a man and woman in marriage, and further, that it should be characterized by mutual consent and free will."

How can you call this ‘condemning homosexuals’?

It is as faulty as saying that, "the Salvation Army condemns heterosexuals who are not married." But the Salvation Army condemns neither heterosexual or homosexual or bisexual persons for that matter.

But there is no human right (stipulating that one has a claim) to be a Salvationist. All associations, churches and organizations have some form of restrictions on who may (qualify to) be a member or not.

What is the reason that people living in a homosexual relationship may not be accepted as Salvationists (SA soldiers) or officers in the Salvation Army? Let me say that I am no official spokesman on behalf of the Salvation Army; I simply have the right to my opinion.

The reason that those who are living in sexual relationships outside of marriage between a man and a woman cannot be a Salvation Army soldier or SA officer is that the Salvation Army still believes in the authority of the Bible. It is expressed clearly in the Salvation Army's first doctrine: "We believe that the Old and New Testament Scriptures were given by inspiration of God, and that they only (alone) constitute the Divine rule of Christian faith and practice."

If one does not believe in the Bible, of course, then one need not worry about what is written there. However, if one believes in God and the Bible there must be consequences in how one live their life.

From my perspective three things are required to (qualify to) become a Salvationist:
·      One must be saved
·      One must accept the Salvation Army’s articles of faith
·      One must be willing to live by the Salvation Army's ethical values.

This applies to heterosexuals, homosexuals and all others.


(Translation: Sven Ljungholm)
·       
▼ February (11)

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Homosexuality, Bible Interpretation, and Authority by Paul Dean



There is yet another defection from the authority of Scripture in the evangelical communion in the form of invoking Scripture to defend homosexuality. The Archbishop of Armagh asserted not too long ago that “reason” may be applied to Scripture texts that seem to condemn homosexuality so that a different interpretation may be gleaned. Such a notion is flawed on a number of counts.

First, while reason must be applied in bible interpretation, what is meant by the Archbishop’s assertion is that human reason apart from God’s presuppositions trumps God’s word. Such is a logical impossibility if God’s word is God’s word in that it would necessarily be grounded in God’s presuppositions.


Second, the reason to be applied comes from contemporary notions of whether or not homosexuality is deemed natural or unnatural. Human reason apart from God’s revelation is fatally flawed in that it is affected by sin. Man apart from God has been given over to a darkened understanding. That does not mean that man cannot understand anything. It does mean that he cannot understand spiritual truth apart from a new nature.

Third, to say that homosexuality is natural and therefore cannot be viewed as sinful is a rejection of the moral character God Himself has ascribed to homosexuality. Human sophistry may be used to define homosexuality as natural but it cannot get around God’s moral pronouncements.


Fourth, as always, the problem lies in attempting to sit in judgment on God’s word. Attempting to find answers to moral questions apart from God is not only flawed and impossible, but essentially sinful.


Fifth, authority is the issue. What is our source of authority when it comes to the question of whether or not homosexuality is sinful? Is it God’s word or something else? Will we allow scientists who presuppose the naturalness of homosexuality to simply explain away God’s word with the imposition of their worldview upon the interpretation process? Or, will we affirm the presupposition that God’s word is true and leave it there in terms of whether or not homosexuality is sinful? Even if homosexuality were due in part to certain genetic factors, understanding that a so-called “homosexual gene” is a scientific impossibility, does that negate its sinfulness? Are not all sins and the propensities of all men affected by genetics? And yet, God holds us accountable for sin.


Sixth, certainly, the Archbishop’s argument is that those who commit homosexual acts who are not naturally homosexual are in sin but those who are naturally homosexual and commit homosexual acts are not in sin because they are not going against nature. Again, this position cannot be sustained from the text but must be imposed upon the text.
Unfortunately, the Archbishop is in spiritual danger. Bible teachers are charged to rightly divide the word of truth and are admonished to be careful in the handling of Scripture for they will receive a stricter judgment.


Let us love the homosexual enough to tell him the truth that he might be saved. And, let us do ourselves and the world a favor by not getting things backwards. It is not worldly reason that must be applied to Scripture but Scripture that must be applied to worldly reason. We don’t understand in order to believe. We believe in order to understand. 

Monday, February 11, 2013

The Homosexual Debate: Separating Fact from Fiction GLBT Series 2013


There are very few topics that polarise people like the subject of homosexuality and related topics.  It is a topic that sparks emotional reactions in people on both sides of the debate.   Such emotion tends to make reasoned debate on the subject very difficult.  For many people, to even consider another side of the argument means going against beliefs and ideologies that strike at the very core of who they are.  In short, for many people, to even engage in discussion results in challenging who they are as an individual.  It presents not only a crisis in faith, but a psychological crisis of identity.

However, much of these beliefs are learned.  We are not born with a pre-disposed understanding of Theology or psychology etc.  We learn it.  We learn right from wrong.  We learn what our views are on various topics.  We attend to various stimuli which educate our opinions.  Based on these, we develop a sense of who we are, and what we believe.  When we encounter something that challenges our past experience and learning, we are forced to challenge our perception of who we have come to believe we are.

Before we even begin to engage in this debate, we need to step back and re-examine much of the information we have inculcated over our lives, honestly looking at its authenticity, relevance, and accuracy etc.  With this in mind, this article seeks to briefly look at some of the common conservative arguments and perceptions against homosexuality, hopefully shedding light on the background of this very divisive debate.

1.    There is a plethora of research that supports the conservative position: Whilst there are a number of research papers that refer to findings that seem to support the conservative position, there has only ever been one actual study conducted in this area.  That study is ‘Sexual Gradualism: A Solution to the Sexual Dilemma of Teen-agers and Young Adults’ (1978), commonly referred to as ‘The Cameron Report’. It was written by Paul Cameron, who established the Institute for the Scientific Investigation of Sexuality (ISIS), now known as the Family Research Institute (FRI).  Since then, every article and research paper that has produced findings consistent with those found in the Cameron Report has used the Cameron Report as its source, or used the data from the Cameron Report in its analysis.  The problem with this is that this report has been very soundly discredited.

There are two main problems with this report. 1) Paul Cameron changes his definition of homosexuality part-way through the report.  At the beginning of the report, he defines a person as homosexual only if they are currently in a long-term, monogamous same-sex relationship for a minimum of 2 years.  If you do not fall into that category, no matter how you define yourself, for the purposes of his study, you are heterosexual.  Part-way through the report, when investigating the behaviours of homosexuals, he re-defines homosexuals as anyone who has engaged in same-sex sexual activity of any description.  This alone nullifies any of his findings on the subject, and nullifies any of the findings of subsequent research that either uses his research for support of their argument, or re-analyses his data to confirm his findings. 2) Much of his data was falsified.  It was discovered that much of the ‘research’ (questionnaires, interviews etc) collected by Cameron and his research team was made up.  The people never existed.  He and his research team made up fictitious responses to questionnaires, and fictitious interviews, in order to ensure their results were consistent with what they wanted to show.  As a result of these ethical allegations into his research, an inquiry was established by the APA.  Cameron refused to produce any evidence to contra these allegations, or even respond to them.  The APA subsequently disbarred him from membership in 1983, effectively meaning he can no longer professionally refer to himself as a Psychiatrist or Psychologist.

There is no credible research that supports the common claims of conservatives. It is important to note here that almost all of the research from the FRI is similarly problematic. As such, any argument that uses research from the FRI to support its claims will generally be dismissed.

2.    The percentage of LGBT person’s in the population is extremely small, proving that it is a minority choice: This is a very difficult question to examine.  It has only been very recently that Governments have been gathering statistics regarding the sexual orientation of individuals in Census documents.  These documents do suggest that the population of LGBT persons in any given country is around 2 – 5 per cent.  However, we need to acknowledge the difficulty in gathering such information. 

3.    Only those who are openly LGBT, and who do not fear retaliation (either in the form of social, work, or family pressures) will admit on a Census that they are LGBT.  It is important to note that there are a lot of closeted married persons, as well as other closeted individuals who feel they must remain closeted in order to protect their family, job, financial, and social standing etc.  Other research that is more anonymous, consistently suggests the figure is closer to between 10 – 25 per cent of any given population (depending on the population sample used), with an understanding among social and health care workers that a 20 per cent figure is closer to reality.  This indicates that the LGBT population is very large.

The Cameron Report (mentioned above) came up with the statistic that around 2 per cent of the population was gay.  However, given his definition, he showed that 2 per cent of the population was in a monogamous, long-term same-sex relationship for a minimum of 2 years.  If we assume that the same percentage of homosexuals are in long-term relationships as heterosexuals, then the actual number of homosexuals (not including those that are Bisexual or Transgender) is considerably higher.  One could estimate on this basis, the number of LGBT persons in any given population is between 20 – 25 per cent.

4.    All homosexuals are extremely promiscuous, engage in degrading and perverted behaviour, and are incapable of long-term relationships: No one is denying that a part of the homosexual population engages in promiscuous behaviour, or even fetish behaviour.  However, we also need to acknowledge that heterosexuals equally engage in such behaviour. 

Based on point 2 above, promiscuity is no more rampant among the homosexual population as it is among the heterosexual population.  In fact, when we look at divorce statistics for heterosexuals, it would seem that homosexual relationships are more likely to last longer, and survive harder trials, than heterosexual marriages.  In short, homosexual relationships (at least statistically) are more stable than heterosexual marriages.  This possibly has to do with the adversity that homosexuals face almost daily, and need to overcome, which makes them and their relationships stronger.  However, there is no research in this area.  Research would shed light on this.

5.    Homosexuals are more likely to be paedophiles – proving that they are deviant: This is an outright lie.  Looking at the number of convicted paedophiles in the prison system, approximately 99 per cent of them are heterosexual.  For it to be evenly distributed between the LGBT and heterosexual populations, you would have to have a percentage of approximately 80 percent being heterosexual.  For this point to have any credibility, we would have to have a much lower percentage being heterosexual.  This shows that statistically, if you leave your child with a heterosexual, there is a much higher chance they will be exposed to paedophilia than if you leave them with an LGBT person.

6.    Homosexuality is a choice – it can be cured, proving that it is a mental disorder: It’s difficult to know where to begin in answering this question.  No-one would consciously choose to be gay given the amount of discrimination and difficulty which is encountered when one comes out, and subsequently, for the rest of their lives.  The number of people who spend years trying to rid themselves of their homosexuality, with no avail, should be proof enough that no-one chooses to be LGBT.  It is no more a choice than choosing to be heterosexual.  Engaging in actual sexual activity of any description however, is a choice.  Homosexuality though is more than just engaging in physical sexual activity.  Likewise, ‘repenting’ of homosexuality is more than just abstaining from physical sexual activity.

There are no recorded incidents worldwide of anyone having been cured of homosexuality.  Various leaders of Exodus International (the worlds’ largest ex-gay movement) have all stated that there has been no-one in the history of their organisation who has ever changed from being gay to straight.  What has happened, is that LGBT persons have forced themselves to deny that part of themselves in an attempt to find acceptance, and have all (without exception) found themselves developing chronic mental illnesses such as chronic depression etc. 

In short, attempts at curing homosexuality ALWAYS end up causing severe mental illness, and destroying the lives of people around them.  It is no more a mental disorder than being heterosexual is a mental disorder.  It is important to note that all professional psychological and psychiatric bodies around the world have long ago removed homosexuality from its list of mental disorders, recognising that it is not a mental disorder.

7.    Homosexuals are they way they are because they were sexually abused as children: Again, an outright lie.  No more needs to be said.  No more LGBT people were sexually abused as children than heterosexuals were.  If we make this claim, we may as well say that heterosexuals are heterosexual because they were sexually abused as children.

8.    Legitimising homosexuality and legitimising same-sex marriage would undermine the fabric of society and bring about the downfall of society: This is a very complex question.  To begin with, we need to understand that legitimising homosexuality or same-sex marriage does not mean it will become mandatory that all people become gay.

The marriage debate is very complex.  Marriage has different legal definitions in different countries.  It is a legal concept – not a religious concept.  However, it can have religious significance attached to it.  When we look at the history of marriage throughout the history of the world, we see that the modern understanding of marriage as between one man and one woman is a very modern concept (less than a couple hundread years old).  A major article is required to explore this concept more deeply.  Here are some dot points on the subject of marriage:
a)    Legal definition of Marriage is country specific. Eg, Australia specifically defines marriage as between a man and a woman.  The UK has always legally defined marriage as between two persons.
b)   Different cultures have historically had different understanding of marriage.  For example, Before white people came to the Americas, many native American tribes maintained a fluid concept of sexual identity and marriage.  Children were neither male nor female until they reached puberty – where they chose for themselves whether they were going to take ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ roles.  An anatomical male could chose to take a feminine role in the tribe, and marry any of the ‘males’ in the tribe.  Likewise, an anatomical female could chose to take a masculine role, and marry any of the ‘women’ in the tribe.
c)   The Old Testament had a number of definitions of marriage.  It included concubinage (taking a slave girl as a wife for various reasons), Leverite (where a brother married his dead brothers childless wife, and had children on behalf of his dead brother who were not considered his), polygamy (multiple wives), paedophilic (arranged marriages of young girls – as young as 8 – with older, often widowed, men).  The list goes on.

The point here is that the view of traditional heterosexual marriage as the only acceptable view of marriage is a relatively recent phenomenon.  Challenging this view will not undermine society per se.  It will destroy the world of those who cling to it, but it will not destroy society.  It will only build society up as it fosters more loving relationships.  It will also reduce the prevalence of mental illness as a vast number of people are not forced to hide who they are.  As a result, it will also result in a drop in suicide statistics as people no longer feel they have to end it all because they cannot live a heterosexual life.  Discrimination will decrease, along with incidents of hate crimes.  All of these things will support and build up society.  It will not bring about its’ downfall.

9.    Accepting homosexuality forces discrimination on to those who disagree: This is difficult to answer.  Where there are diametrically opposing views which both require action, there will always be disagreement, and one side will always feel like they are being discriminated against.  There are only two ways forward here.  Either one side changes its views (this is where historically much of the debate has centred), or we separate belief from civil responsibility.  If you have a public role, you must adhere to the code of the organisation and/or country that you work for or receive funding/pay for.  This does not prevent you from having your own views or beliefs.  However, it does dictate how you can express those beliefs.  For many people, this is what is unpalatable.  For this reason, we need to seriously examine what we believe and why we believe it.  Examining this question begins to get at the very heart of the homosexual debate, and why it is so divisive.  Everything else is peripheral and can be easily argued against with little consequence.  This strikes at the heart of individual and corporate identity, and strikes blow upon blow to individual and corporate psyche.

One way around this problem (as I have argued in previous articles), is to accept that what is right and just for one person, is not right or just for another.  What is sinful for one person, is not sinful for another.  We need to see everyone as individuals, with an individual and unique relationship with their creator God, which is different for everyone.  There is no one-size-fits-all relationship with God.  Here, a person can easily maintain that homosexuality is wrong and sinful for themselves, and that they should never engage in it, but it is OK for someone else, and for them to engage in heterosexuality would be sinful.  Here, both sides maintain their integrity, while respecting the uniqueness and individuality of each person.

10.The Bible explicitly rejects homosexuality: It is only tradition which maintains this view.  There are numerous books, articles, research, documentaries, etc, which highlight a more accurate way of interpreting ancient language.  When interpreted in that light, we find that there is not a single verse in the entire bible which speaks against homosexuality, or even implies that it might be improper.  What we do find however, is a number of God blessed relationships which with today’s understanding of homosexuality, would be considered homosexual relationships.  The only way we can maintain a stance that the Bible speaks against homosexuality is to maintain a traditional interpretation of the ancient languages that it was written in, which is completely inaccurate.  This has the effect of nullifying the Bible, and its message of Salvation, as it reduces the Bible to a fictional book, written in a fictional language.
Again, this is linked to personal identity.  If a person came to salvation, and develops a particular understanding of themselves as a Christian from receiving a particular interpretation of scripture, then contemplating anything else will spark a crisis of faith and identity.  It will cause them to question their salvation, question their life, question their ministry, etc, etc, etc.  This also begins to get to the heart of the homosexual debate.

The current debate is about more than just whether homosexuals should be fully included in every part of church life, or whether society should fully accept LGBT persons.  It is about identity.  Not just the identity of LGBT persons, but about the identity of those who maintain traditional views.  It is not just about the rights of the LGBT persons.  Any parent who holds a traditional view of sexuality, and has a child come out as gay, will understand the blow this delivers to their sense of identity.  Focussing on other issues such as; marriage, equality, right/wrong, will only end up in the debate continually going around in circles.  We will never reach consensus on any of these issues if the real issue is our own sense of identity.  Only when we understand that it the personal and individual identity of people on both sides of the debate that is in question, will we ever begin to move forward in this discussion.  Every other argument is nothing more than a smoke screen, obscuring us from seeing the true nature of the debate.  Identity.

Graeme Randall
Former SA Officer
Australia East

residing in London

Pope Benedict XVI RESIGNS ON FEB 28, 2013





Pope Benedict XVI during a mass at the Vatican on 9 February 2013.
Pope Benedict XVI during a mass at the Vatican on 9 February 2013. Photograph: Alessandro Bianchi/Reuters

The news seems to have come as a complete surprise
 to everyone. My colleague Sam Jones has just spoken
 to a spokeswoman for the Roman Catholic church in
 England and Wales, who told him they were looking
 into reports to establish whether they were true. It seems
 they are.

Reuters, which broke the news of the pope's resignation
 this morning, is reporting that the pope has said in a statement
 that his strength is no longer adequate for him to continue
 in office due to his advanced age. He says he is resigning in
 "full freedom" and says he is "fully aware of the gravity of this
 gesture".

Pope Benedict XVI is to resign, the Vatican has confirmed.
Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger's papacy began in 2005. This is
 reportedly only the second time a head of the Catholic
 church has stepped down.

Sky News is reporting that the pope will leave his office
 on 28 February.


WELCOMING VS. AFFIRMING CHURCHES/CORPS GLBT Series 2013


For someone who friends say never shuts up I find it difficult to talk about myself at times. And yet it seems everyone and their brother has a blog these days, and I have something to talk about, so why not?

I started this blog because there is a need for it. There is a lot of misinformation on the internet, especially about the Salvation Army and its responses to the LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender) community. If you were to search the web right now on information regarding the Salvation Army and gays, a lot of what you will find are attacks on The Salvation Army as a whole for being homophobic. This is not the case.

I was born to officer parents and dedicated (given back to God), as is the custom in the Salvation Army, as an infant. Through the years I have held various titles and ministry positions: Junior Soldier, Senior Soldier, Corps Cadet, Sunday School Teacher, Nursery Leader, Kettle Collector and Member of the Junior Band. I had to give up that last part early on as, my brother so lovingly put it, my tuba playing was only sufficient for bringing ships into port. Throughout this time my faith in God grew and I became proud of the good work I was associated with through being part of this church. Since ‘coming out’ this has not changed.

Regardless of what some LGBT activists have said, the Salvation Army stands ready to serve anyone who needs help. If you are transgender you CAN be admitted into a Salvation Army shelter. If you’re a lesbian you CAN receive your children’s free Christmas gifts or a food hamper. And if you’re gay you CAN attend a Salvation Army church. How welcome you feel will depend entirely on the person you speak with and how willing they are to demonstrate the love and compassion our Saviour Jesus Christ Himself emitted.

Like most complex issues, we need to know what we’re talking about. When I say a church is ‘welcoming’ what I mean to say is that LGBT individuals are free to come and worship at a church; however being a minister, part of ministry or getting married in the denomination is limited to those who either are heterosexual or LGBT and willing to commit to lifelong celibacy.

A church that is ‘affirming’ allows LGBTs to minister, serve and get married in their denomination. The Salvation Army is welcoming, but not affirming as can be seen through it’s positional statement:

This causes some problems as there are people such as myself who wish to continue in ministry but also have hopes of getting married one day, one of many issue that will be addressed in later posts.

Ultimately, there are three purposes to this blog. One is to educate people on issues they are ignorant about so they can make informed choices. Another is to allow dialogue between the Salvationist and Gay communities in order to bridge the gap that is sadly common in the Christian church. And last, but by no means least important, this blog serves as a light to LGBT

Salvationists that they are not alone. There is nothing quite as soul-crushing than having this part of you that you believe no one else understands. Believe me, I’ve been there. In gathering my thoughts for this very first post A bible verse has sprung to mind.

Jeremiah 29: 11-14 “For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the LORD, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future. Then you will call on me and come and pray to me, and I will listen to you. You will seek me and find me when you seek me with all your heart. I will be found by you,” declares the LORD, “and will bring you back from captivity. I will gather you from all the nations and places where I have banished you,” declares the LORD, “and will bring you back to the place from which I carried you into exile.”

I hope God will be able to bless you as we gather to go through this journey together.
http://gaysalvationist.wordpress.com/category/gay/

Sunday, February 10, 2013

The Clobber Passages


“The issues about homosexuality are very complex and are not understood by most members of the Christian church,” according to Bernard Ramm of The American Baptist Seminary of the West. 

This evangelical authority on biblical interpretation says that, “to them, it is a vile form of sexual perversion condemned in both the Old and New Testaments.” But as Calvin Theological Seminary Old Testament scholar Marten H. Woudstra says: “there is nothing in the Old Testament that corresponds to homosexuality as we understand it today” and as SMU New Testament scholar Victor Paul Furnish says: “There is no ‘text on homosexual orientation in the Bible.” Says Robin Scroggs of Union Seminary: “Biblical judgments against homosexuality are not relevant to today’s debate. They should no longer be used … not because the Bible is not authoritative, but simply because it does not address the issues involved. … No single New Testament author considers [homosexuality] important enough to write his own sentence about it.” Evangelical theologian Helmut Thielicke states: “Homosexuality… can be discussed at all only in the framework of that freedom which is given to us by the insight that even the New Testament does not provide us with an evident, normative dictum with regard to this question. Even the kind of question which we have arrived at … must for purely historical reasons be alien to the New Testament.”

Ideas and understandings of sexuality have changed greatly over the centuries. People in biblical times did not share our knowledge or customs of sexuality; we do not share their experience. In those days there was no romantic dating as we know it today; marriages were arranged by fathers. The ancients, as MIT’s David Halperin notes: “conceived of ‘sexuality’ in non-sexual terms: What was fundamental to their experience of sex was not anything we would regard as essentially sexual: rather, it was something essentially social — namely, the modality of power relations that informed and structured the sexual act.” In the ancient world, sex was “not intrinsically relational or collaborative in character, it is, further, a deeply polarizing experience: It serves to divide, to classify, and to distribute its participants into distinct and radically dissimilar categories. Sex possess this valence, apparently because it is conceived to center essentially on, and to define itself around, an asymmetrical gesture, that of the penetration of the body of one person by the body, and, specifically, by the phallus — of another. …. The proper targets of [a citizen's] sexual desire include, specifically, women, boys, foreigners, and slaves — all of them persons who do not enjoy the same legal and political rights and privileges that he does.” In studies of sex in history, Stanford classics professor John J. Winkler warns against “reading contemporary concerns and politics into texts and artifacts removed from their social context.” This, of course, is a basic principle of biblical hermeneutics.
In spite of all of this, some preachers continue to use certain Bible verses to clobber lesbians and gay men today.

Saturday, February 9, 2013

BOYCOTT LEADS TO RESPECTFUL DIALOGUE GLBT Series 2013


AND A FEW MONTHS LATER...


Dan and Me: My Coming Out as a Friend of Dan Cathy and Chick-fil-A

Posted: 01/28/2013 12:58 pm

I spent New Year's Eve at the red-blooded, all-American epicenter of college football: at the Chick-fil-A Bowl, next to Dan Cathy, as his personal guest. It was among the most unexpected moments of my life.
Yes, after months of personal phone calls, text messages and in-person meetings, I am coming out in a new way, as a friend of Chick-fil-A's president and COO, Dan Cathy, and I am nervous about it. I have come to know him and Chick-fil-A in ways that I would not have thought possible when I first started hearing from LGBT students about their concerns over the chicken chain's giving practices.
For many this news of friendship might be shocking. After all, I am an out, 40-year-old gay man and alifelong activist for equality. I am also the founder and executive director of Campus Pride, the leading national organization for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender (LGBT) and ally college students. Just seven months ago our organization advanced a national campaign against Chick-fil-A for the millions of dollars it donated to anti-LGBT organizations and divisive political groups that work each day to harm hardworking LGBT young people, adults and our families. I have spent quite some time being angry at and deeply distrustful of Dan Cathy and Chick-fil-A. If he had his way, my husband of 18 years and I would never be legally married.
shane windmeyer chickfila

Why was I now standing next to him at one of the most popular football showdowns? How could I dare think to have a relationship with a man and a company that have advocated against who I am; who would take apart my family in the name of "traditional marriage"; whose voice and views represented exactly the opposite of those of the students for whom I advocate every day? Dan is the problem, and Chick-fil-A is the enemy, right?
Like most LGBT people, I was provoked by Dan's public opposition to marriage equality and his company's problematic giving history. I had the background and history on him, so I thought, and had my own preconceived notions about who he was. I knew this character. No way did he know me. That was my view. But it was flawed.
For nearly a decade now, my organization, Campus Pride, has been on the ground with student leaders protesting Chick-fil-A at campuses across the country. I had researched Chick-fil-A's nearly $5 million in funding, given since 2003, to anti-LGBT groups. And the whole nation was aware that Dan was "guilty as charged" in his support of a "biblical definition" of marriage. What more was there to know?
On Aug. 10, 2012, in the heat of the controversy, I got a surprise call from Dan Cathy. He had gotten my cell phone number from a mutual business contact serving campus groups. I took the call with great caution. He was going to tear me apart, right? Give me a piece of his mind? Turn his lawyers on me?
The first call lasted over an hour, and the private conversation led to more calls the next week and the week after. Dan Cathy knew how to text, and he would reach out to me as new questions came to his mind. This was not going to be a typical turn of events.
His questions and a series of deeper conversations ultimately led to a number of in-person meetings with Dan and representatives from Chick-fil-A. He had never before had such dialogue with any member of the LGBT community. It was awkward at times but always genuine and kind.
It is not often that people with deeply held and completely opposing viewpoints actually risk sitting down and listening to one another. We see this failure to listen and learn in our government, in our communities and in our own families. Dan Cathy and I would, together, try to do better than each of us had experienced before.
Never once did Dan or anyone from Chick-fil-A ask for Campus Pride to stop protesting Chick-fil-A. On the contrary, Dan listened intently to our concerns and the real-life accounts from youth about the negative impact that Chick-fil-A was having on campus climate and safety at colleges across the country. He was concerned about an incident last fall where a fraternity was tabling next to the Chick-fil-A restaurant on campus. Whenever an out gay student on campus would walk past the table, the fraternity would chant, "We love Chick-fil-A," and then shout anti-gay slurs at the student. Dan sought first to understand, not to be understood. He confessed that he had been naïve to the issues at hand and the unintended impact of his company's actions.
Chick-fil-A also provided access to internal documents related to the funding of anti-LGBT groups and asked questions about our concerns related to this funding. An internal document, titled "Who We Are," expressed Chick-fil-A's values, which included their commitment "to treat every person with honor, dignity and respect," including LGBT people. Dan and his family members had personally drafted, refined and approved the document.
Through all this, Dan and I shared respectful, enduring communication and built trust. His demeanor has always been one of kindness and openness. Even when I continued to directly question his public actions and the funding decisions, Dan embraced the opportunity to have dialogue and hear my perspective. He and I were committed to a better understanding of one another. Our mutual hope was to find common ground if possible, and to build respect no matter what. We learned about each other as people with opposing views, not as opposing people.
During our meetings I came to see that the Chick-fil-A brand was being used by both sides of the political debate around gay marriage. The repercussion of this was a deep division and polarization that was fueling feelings of hate on all sides. As a result, we agreed to keep the ongoing nature of our meetings private for the time being. The fire needed no more fuel.
Throughout the conversations Dan expressed a sincere interest in my life, wanting to get to know me on a personal level. He wanted to know about where I grew up, my faith, my family, even my husband, Tommy. In return, I learned about his wife and kids and gained an appreciation for his devout belief in Jesus Christ and his commitment to being "a follower of Christ" more than a "Christian." Dan expressed regret and genuine sadness when he heard of people being treated unkindly in the name of Chick-fil-a -- but he offered no apologies for his genuine beliefs about marriage.
And in that we had great commonality: We were each entirely ourselves. We both wanted to be respected and for others to understand our views. Neither of us could -- or would -- change. It was not possible. We were different but in dialogue. That was progress.
In many ways, getting to know Dan better has reminded me of my relationship with my uncle, who is a pastor at a Pentecostal church. When I came out as openly gay in college, I was aware that his religious views were not supportive of homosexuality. But my personal relationship with my uncle reassured me of his love for me -- and that love extends to my husband. My uncle would never want to see any harm come to me or Tommy. His beliefs prevented him from fully reconciling what he understood as the immorality of homosexuality with the morality of loving and supporting me and my life. It was, and remains, an unsolvable riddle for him, hating the sin and loving the sinner.
My relationship with Dan is the same, though he is not my family. Dan, in his heart, is driven by his desire to minister to others and had to choose to continue our relationship throughout this controversy. He had to both hold to his beliefs and welcome me into them. He had to face the issue of respecting my viewpoints and life even while not being able to reconcile them with his belief system. He defined this to me as "the blessing of growth." He expanded his world without abandoning it. I did, as well.
As Dan and I grew through mutual dialogue and respect, he invited me to be his personal guest on New Year's Eve at the Chick-fil-A Bowl. This was an event that Campus Pride and others had planned to protest. Had I been played? Seduced into his billionaire's life? No. It was Dan who took a great risk in inviting me: He stood to face the ire of his conservative base (and a potential boycott) by being seen or photographed with an LGBT activist. He could have been portrayed as "caving to the gay agenda" by welcoming me.
Instead, he stood next to me most of the night, putting respect ahead of fear. There we were on the sidelines, Dan, his wife, his family and friends and I, all enjoying the game. And that is why building a relationship with someone I thought I would never understand mattered. Our worlds, different as they can be, could coexist peacefully. The millions of college football fans watching the game never could have imagined what was playing out right in front of them. Gay and straight, liberal and conservative, activist and evangelist -- we could stand together in our difference and in our respect. How much better would our world be if more could do the same?
This past week Chick-fil-A shared with me the 2011 IRS Form 990, filed in November for the WinShape Foundation, along with 2012 financials. The IRS has not released the 990 to the public yet, but the financials affirm Chick-fil-A's values a year prior to the controversy this past July. The nearly $6 million in outside grant funding focuses on youth, education, marriage enrichment and local communities. The funding reflects Chick-fil-A's promised commitment not to engage in "political or social debates," and the most divisive anti-LGBT groups are no longer listed.
Even as Campus Pride and so many in the community protested Chick-fil-A and its funding of groups like Family Research Council, Eagle Forum and Exodus International, the funding of these groups had already stopped. Dan Cathy and Chick-fil-A could have noted this publicly earlier. Instead, they chose to be patient, to engage in private dialogue, to reach understanding,and to share proof with me when it was official. There was no "caving"; there were no "concessions." There was, in my view, conscience.
This is why, after discussions with Dan and Chick-fil-A, Campus Pride suspended our campaign. Like Dan, we had faith. It took time to be proven publicly.
Now it is all about the future, one defined, let's hope, by continued mutual respect. I will not change my views, and Dan will likely not change his, but we can continue to listen, learn and appreciate "the blessing of growth" that happens when we know each other better. I hope that our nation's political leaders and campus leaders might do the same.
In the end, it is not about eating (or eating a certain chicken sandwich). It is about sitting down at a table together and sharing our views as human beings, engaged in real, respectful, civil dialogue. Dan would probably call this act the biblical definition of hospitality. I would call it human decency. So long as we are all at the same table and talking, does it matter what we call it or what we eat?