Today's article is 'borrowed' from the ArmyBarmy Blog site. Stephen Court, the blog's creator must be counted as the most creative, industrious and influential 'army' blogger in the world. He's blogged every day, for several years, without fail. And, I believe that he, more than anyone in the SA, has been the pioneer that's moved scores of others, including the FSAOF, to appreciate just how effective a 'cyberspace soapbox' can be in sharing messages deemed significant.
Today, the FSAOF, will have its 90,000 visitor- 4 1/2 years of blogging.
Welcome Steve!
______________
Today, the FSAOF, will have its 90,000 visitor- 4 1/2 years of blogging.
Welcome Steve!
______________
Sven Ljungholm at Former SA Officers Fellowship
blog decided to test our suggestion last week about officers repaying training
expenses if they leave before having served 20 years:
The responses are here: http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=8664794015642071822&postID=6323582974991702043&isPopup=true
Admittedly it is asking former officers if they
should pay the money back (and not a broader spectrum of salvationists), but
there are some good arguments made against the idea. So maybe we should
toss it.
Two outflow discussions:
a.
That said, we are told that in at least one place,
if the Army pays for you to study for a higher degree and you leave within a
certain period you are meant to pay that back.
So, a Captain studies for a MSW or a MBA or something and
the Army picks up the tab. And within a couple of years of securing the
designation the officer leaves (and benefits in the job market with the MSW or MBA for
which the Army paid). Should s/he pay the Army back for that expense?
b.
Why on earth is training so expensive? Until
fairly recently you could score an Ivy League four-year degree for the cost of
two years in CFOT. (Canada) And, as much as Ivy League, and in fact most
post-secondary education, is ridiculously over-rated, isn’t it still in a
different stratosphere than most (all?) training colleges today?
Why should it cost more to create a Lieutenant than
a Harvard BA? (a premise that may now no longer be extant)
Surely we can train cadets much better through
incarnational apprenticeship – faster, better, and cheaper.
Wouldn’t it be interesting to test the claim?
You could take two comparable territories – say USV and USX (you can guess
which US territories we mean). And USV goes with the incarnational
apprenticeship model and USX stays with the current residential model.
Within a decade the territories would no longer be
comparable. USX would have continued in its incremental growth –
hallelujah.
But USV would be completely different. Here
are some of the changes:
a. ‘new officer’ corps would be much bigger than
they were at the start of the experiment because new officers are much better
than they had been in the old model;
b. cadet sessions will have exploded. Instead
of 40-something there’d most likely be well over a hundred and maybe over two
hundred in each session;
c. the flow-on effect of ‘b’ is that there will be
many more corps – hundreds?
d. ‘c’ implies that there will be heaps more
conversions, soldiers, made, candidates made (multiplying the positive
effect…), outposts started…;
e. how will they pay for all these new corps?
Well, training will cost a fraction of what it costs in USX – let’s say
half. So, starting with the benchmark of 40 cadets, saving $80,000 EACH,
USV has an extra $3.2 MILLION to invest in new corps the first year
alone! Money is actually a bonus of the new system;
f. We said it was faster – because USV has an entry
officer profile cadets who are trained in the new system can be commissioned as
soon as they match the profile, typically in one year (as in the ‘good old
days’) rather than two – oops, save another 50% of training costs!
We could go on, but you get the idea…
Why is such an experiment unlikely?
Well, here’s a quick stab on it:
a. The General is 66 (today – holy birthday to the
General). The Chief of the Staff is 62. Without running through the
whole year book the average age of potential high council delegates is likely a
shade over 60.
b. Our ten-year experiment would put them all into
retired officer residences. Outside of Korea and General Larsson’s bold
2010 goal, we just don’t set campaigns beyond our terms. And our terms
are too short for any long-term plans.
That said, Canada and Bermuda has a 54 year-old TC,
so he could potentially be around in one appointment long enough to test this
thing out. How about it, Commissioner?
c. And those potential High Council
delegates? They all went to training college. Don’t discount how
personal experience and nostalgia can play in to such a decision.
Stephen Court
Major
Stephen Court
Major







