Monday, September 19, 2011

'THE OLD WELLS’

“Isaac reopened the wells that had been dug in the time of his father Abraham, which the Philistines had stopped up after Abraham died, and he gave them the same names his father had given them.”
Genesis 26:18 (NIV)

Isaac – like Abraham and Jacob – was one of the Israel’s children’s progenitor fathers.  We read that God spoke about Himself as Isaac, Abraham and Jacob’s God.

Abraham has been called ‘The Father of Faith’. He was and became an example of faith and obedience and was allowed to experience that God blessed him with land and riches.

In comparison to his father, Isaac was a rather pale figure. But on a quieter level Isaac was a man of faith.  In the letter to the Hebrews much is written about Abraham however, about Isaac it is only written, “By faith Isaac blessed Jacob and Esau in regard to their future. (Heb. 11:20)  Isaac too had faith and he passed on the torch of faith further to his son. 

It’s not always easy to be the second generation in a family. Bramwell Booth probably didn’t find it very easy to succeed his father, William Booth, was a passionate soul (on fire), a well-known, gifted speaker, and a courageous and talented field commander who created The Salvation Army.  Bramwell had a totally different temperament. He was the administrator, the diplomat.

However, it’s not quite that easy to simply label a person.  The story is told of Bramwell Booth and how in his youth he arrived in a city in England, alone, to conduct an open-air meeting.  But no one stopped to listen to him. So he then flexed open his umbrella, limped awkwardly along the street, closed his umbrella and then flexed it open again. And immediately a crowd gathered and Bramwell was able to read God’s word and testify. Those persons who remember our aged General Bramwell, with his white hair and large hearing apparatus, that he put to his ear to hear better, find it difficult to imagine him when young and attempting to rally folk in this manner.

In a meeting I conducted in Stockholm a few years ago there was a man seated in the front bench in the hall and he eyed me very critically.  Following the meeting I greeted him and he asked me then: “Are you a son of the old Commissioner Wickberg”? – “Yes,” I answered.  Then he looked at me even more critically and after a few moments said:  “That man could preach …”!

No, it’s not so easy to be the second generation.  It’s not easy to be Isaac when people remember Abraham.
However, there was one thing that Isaac did that we ought never to forget.  He sought out the old wells and had them dug up anew and named them, giving them their old names again (to be cont’d)

(Uppdraget p. 37, ‘The Commission’)




Erik Wickberg
Uppdraget 1990 FA Press

(translation; Sven-Erik Ljungholm)


Saturday, September 17, 2011

We are called to be pioneers of the Kingdom


GENERAL E WICKBERG

International Leader of TSA 1969-1974

A series of articles will be posted beginning September 19, 2011 translated from General Wickberg's book; THE COMMISSION (UPPDRAGET), 1990
"There are certain things which The Salvation Army can spare and still be The Salvation Army -- citadels and other meeting places, for instance. Money, too, can be done without. The advantages of organization are not entirely essential. One thing, however, The Salvation Army cannot spare. The Army, which William Booth gathered together out of the most impossible material, to the astonishment of the world, cannot do without the pioneer spirit. 

The pioneer spirit is as necessary now as ever, for left to itself a movement tends to stagnate. Uniformed officers and soldiers we have in encouraging numbers -- but too many seem to have forgotten that they are not to be known as 'members'. We can say without equivocation that were we to lose the daring and the determination of the pioneer spirit we should no longer be The Salvation Army. 

There are plenty of churches and congregations. They have their own special work to do, but we are called to be pioneers of the Kingdom"

Wickberg, E. (2007) The Officer, January/February 2007

Friday, September 16, 2011

Questions Matter; MORE BELL


Questions matter. They can help you to grow deeper in your knowledge of the truth and your love for God—especially when you’re dealing with the harder doctrines of the Christian faith. But questions can also be used to obscure the truth. They can be used to lead away just as easily as they can be used to lead toward.  Ask EVE.
Enter Rob Bell, a man who has spent much of the last seven years asking questions in his sometimes thought-provoking and often frustrating fashion. And when he’s done asking, no matter what answers he puts forward, it seems we’re only left with more questions. This trend continues in his new book, Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived, where Bell poses what might be his most controversial question yet:
Does a loving God really send people to hell for all eternity?

The questions you probably want answers to as you read this review are these: Is it true that Rob Bell teaches that hell doesn’t exist? Is it true that Rob Bell believes no one goes to hell? You’ll just need to keep reading because, frankly, the answers aren’t that easy to come by.
How he asks the question is just as important as the question itself. “Has God created billions of people over thousands of years only to select a few to go to heaven and everyone else to suffer forever in hell? Is this acceptable to God? How is this ‘good news’?” They say that the person who frames the debate is going to win the debate. That is especially true when the debate is framed in this way, through these particular questions. You’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t. No offense, and no pun intended.
The Toxic Subversion Of Jesus’ Message
Bell begins the book with surprising forthrightness: Jesus’ story has been hijacked by a number of different stories that Jesus has no interest in telling. “The plot has been lost, and it’s time to reclaim it.” (Preface, vi)
A staggering number of people have been taught that a select few Christians will spend forever in a peaceful, joyous place called heaven, while the rest of humanity spends forever in torment and punishment in hell with no chance for anything better…. This is misguided and toxic and ultimately subverts the contagious spread of Jesus’ message of love, peace, forgiveness, and joy that our world desperately needs to hear. (ibid)
You may want to read that again.
It really says that. And it really means what you think it means. Though it takes time for that to become clear.

Heaven Is A Place On Earth—and We Are Making It
Bell frames much of the book around time and place, around what the Bible means when it speaks of the when and where of heaven and hell. He points to Revelation 21, citing that the heavenly city, the New Jerusalem, is coming down to the new earth. He also affirms that heaven is a real place where God’s will alone is done and that at present, heaven and earth are not yet one (pp. 42-43). These are points that few Christians could seriously question.
His argument progresses to this: Because heaven will eventually come to earth, if we’re to take heaven seriously, we must take the suffering that exists in the world seriously now. Therefore, we are called to participate “now in the life of the age to come. That’s what happens when the future is dragged into the present” (p. 45). In light of this, humanity’s role within creation is redefined so that we are not so much stewards as we are God’s partners, “participating in the ongoing creation and joy of the world” (p. 180), and engaging in creating a new social order with Jesus (p. 77). This language of partnering and participating is frequently applied by Bell to causes of social justice.
But what about hell? Is hell a future reality or a present one? Is it an earthly reality or one that exists elsewhere?
Hell appears to be more about what we do to each other than what we’ve done to God. Bell reads Jesus’ warnings of divine punishment as addressing only the temporal, rather than both the temporal and the eternal. These warnings were for the religious leaders of the day, and had very little to do with some other reality or some other time, he argues (pp. 82-83). Instead, hell is “a word that refers to the big, wide, terrible evil that comes from the secrets hidden deep without our hearts all the way to the massive, society-wide collapse and chaos that comes when we fail to live in God’s world God’s way” (p. 95). There’s no fire and no wrath, at least, none that is extrinsic to us.
Does Rob Bell deny the existence of hell? He would say no. We would say yes. He affirms, but only after redefining. And that’s just a clever form of denial.
Exegetical Gymnastics
Understanding what Bell truly believes and what he is truly seeking to teach can be a battle. The reader will find himself following many rabbit trails and arriving at several dead ends. It seems that where Bell’s arguments begin to break down, he simply walks away instead of pursuing consistency and logic. This book could not stand the rigors of cross-examination. It has little cohesion, little internal strength.
The reader will also find broad statements offered as fact. “At the center of the Christian tradition since the first church has been the insistence that history is not tragic, hell is not forever, and love, in the end, wins.” Is that true? It is easy to say, but can it be proven? Again and again Bell turns to the original languages but he quotes no commentaries, points to no sources. He says things like “‘forever’ is not really a category the biblical writers used.” But he offers no proof. Again, it is easy to say, but can it be proven? Can it be proven from a legitimate source?
Throughout the book he engages in what can best be described as exegetical gymnastics, particularly in dealing with the Greek word aion, a small word that is crucial to his arguments.
While this word is commonly translated as “eternal” or “everlasting,” Bell argues that it can also mean “age” or “period of time,” or even “intensity of experience.” Using this approach, he briefly argues from the parable of the sheep and the goats (Matt. 25:31-46) that eternal punishment isn’t eternal, but rather an intense period of pruning.
Now here’s the thing: aion and aionos definitely can mean “age” or “period of time,” they also mean “eternal.” The word’s context helps us to determine its meaning. So if we assume that these words primarily mean “age” or “period of time,” what happens when we apply that definition to John 3:16 where aionos is used?
For God so loved the world that He sent His only Son so that whosoever believes in Him will not perish but have life for a period of time.
Not as encouraging, is it? While Bell might argue here that “life abundant” might be a better fit (playing on the “intensity of experience” angle and tying it to John 10:10), at the end of the day, we’re left with an approach that gives more credence to living your best life now than it does to worshipping Jesus.
The Good News Is Better Than This
Throughout the book, there are a number of points where we would agree with Bell, particularly when he identifies some of the goofy things that people have concocted to make God’s absolute sovereignty palpable. But his answers are equally unsatisfying. Even his good critiques are simply a bridge to bad conclusions.
As he makes his case, Bell seems to delight in being obtuse, creating caricatures of opposing views that lack logic and compassion. He paints himself as the victim of the hateful, toxic, venomous denizens of certain corners of the Internet that believe “the highest form of allegiance to their God is to attack, defame, and slander others who don’t articulate matters of faith as they do” (p. 185).
Thus, Rob Bell appoints himself a martyr for his cause, and anyone who disagrees with him is preemptively silenced. It’s a useful technique, that, but hardly a fair one. Meanwhile he acts as if those who hold to the belief that, in Bell’s words, “we get this life and only this life to believe in Jesus,” a view passionately held to by the vast majority of Christians throughout history, are blowing smoke rather than dealing honestly with the Scriptures. He subtly redefines the questions and answers, and in doing so, also shifts the battle lines.
As he moves those lines, he moves closer and closer to outright blasphemy. Turning on 1 Timothy 2 (where Paul states that God desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth) Bell reflects on a traditional (orthodox) view of hell and asks:
How great is God?
Great enough to achieve what God sets out to do,
or kind of great,
medium great,
great most of the time,
but in this,
the fate of billions of people,
not totally great.
sort of great.
a little great.
A God who would allow people to go to hell is not a great God, according to Bell, and the traditional belief that He would is “devastating … psychologically crushing … terrifying and traumatizing and unbearable” (pp. 136-7).
God is at best sort of great, a little great—great for saving some, but evil for allowing others to perish. Dangerous words, those. It is a fearful thing to ascribe evil to God.
So what of the gospel? Where is the gospel and what is the gospel? Ultimately, what Bell offers in this book is a gospel with no purpose. In his understanding of the Bible, people are essentially good, although we certainly do sin, and are completely free to choose or not choose to love God on our own terms. Even then he seems to believe that most people, given enough time and opportunity, will turn to God.
In This Is Love
If Love Wins accurately represents Bell’s views on heaven and hell (at least if our understanding of the book accurately represents his views on heaven and hell), it reveals him as a proponent of a kind of Christian Universalism. He would deny the label as he tends to deny any label. But if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, well, you know how it goes.
As soon as the door is opened to Muslims. Hindus, Buddhists, and Baptists from Cleveland, many Christians become very uneasy, saying that then Jesus doesn’t matter anymore, the cross is irrelevant, it doesn’t matter what you believe, and so forth.
Not true.
Absolutely, unequivocally, unalterably not true.
What Jesus does is declare that he,
and he alone,
is saving everybody.
And then he leaves the door way, way open. Creating all sorts of possibilities. He is as narrow as himself and as wide as the universe.
…
People come to Jesus in all sorts of ways.
…
Sometimes people use his name;
other times they don’t.
…
Some people have so much baggage with regard to the name “Jesus” that when they encounter the mystery present in all of creation—grace, peace, love, acceptance, healing, forgiveness—the last thing they are inclined to name it is “Jesus.”
…
What we see Jesus doing again and again—in the midst of constant reminders about the seriousness of following him living like him, and trusting him—is widening the scope and expanse of his saving work.
That is what we know as universalism. And it is cause for mourning.
Christians do not need more confusion. They need clarity. They need teachers who are willing to deal honestly with what the Bible says, no matter how hard that truth is. And let’s be honest—many truths are very, very hard to swallow.
Love does win, but not the kind of love that Bell talks about in this book. The love he describes is one that is founded solely on the idea that the primary object of God’s love is man; indeed, the whole story, he writes, can be summed up in these words: “For God so loved the world.” But this doesn’t hold a candle to the altogether amazing love of God as actually shown in the Bible. The God who “shows His love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us” (Rom. 5:8), who acts on our behalf not so much because His love for us is great, but because He is great (Isaiah 48:9, Ezekiel 20:9,14,22,44, 36:22; John 17:1-5).
That’s the kind of love that wins. That’s the kind of love that motivates us to love our neighbors enough to compel them to flee from the wrath to come. And our love for people means nothing if we do not first and foremost love God enough to be honest about Him.
This review was co-written with my friend Aaron Armstrong who writes at Blogging Theologically. All quotes are taken from an Advance Reading Copy of the manuscript that was provided specifically for review purposes; they will be verified against a final bound copy of Love Wins following the book’s release.



About the Author Tim Challies

Tim ChalliesI am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband to Aileen and a father to three young children. I worship and serve as a pastor at Grace Fellowship Churchin Toronto, Ontario, edit Discerning Readerand am a co-founder of Cruciform Press.
This review was co-written with my friend Aaron Armstrong who writes at Blogging Theologically. All quotes are taken from an Advance Reading Copy of the manuscript that was provided specifically for review purposes; they will be verified against a final bound copy of Love Wins following the book’s release.

Thursday, September 15, 2011

WHAT PRETTY A PEARL



       “Again, the kingdom of heaven is like a merchant in search of fine pearls, who, on finding one pearl of great value, went and sold all that he had and bought it.”Matthew 13.45
Many of us who claim the name of Christ today are so in love with the world we cannot find an interest in the humble attributes of Christ. He asks too much. He isn’t worth the price. The cross and his suffering awaken nothing but boredom. Our time, effort, and money are spent on ourselves, our homes; our own “well-being” rather than on the one thing that God counts as real wealth, Jesus Christ and his character.
Many ministers of the gospel find more time for their sports and entertainments than for prayer, bible study, and ministry to the poor. Who is this Christ who calls me to give? What value will such a humble life add to my needs for pleasure?
Video games, movies, ESPN, fantasy football, and countless other activities fill our lives. We will waste their Lord’s money on the largest flat-screen, watch the most corrupt films, amusement parks, take expensive and extravagant trips, and should I say, have all the latest gadgets, yet give the very least to missions at home or abroad. Then we will wonder aloud why we have so little influence or power in the pulpit. What’s wrong with those people? Don’t they understand the gospel? The restraint of Christ, who had the wealth of a universe at his hand, meets no answering chord in the hearts of world-loving shepherds of the flock. More like wolves, we spend the tithe given us on pleasing ourselves. Who will ask where they stand compared to the self-sacrificing, bleeding Son of God?
The lack of spiritual power in the churches today has a simple answer: pride and self-indulgence. Who will bear the cross of Christ in self-sacrifice for the benefit of others instead of self? Who will deprive themselves to meet the needs of others? Who even begins to take the life of Christ as their own? 
I exempt here, as does the word of God, those humble people who are working their souls to the bone for the salvation of souls. I’ve known a few such strangers on the earth. These need no condenmation or applause, but they do need the support of those who could not answer the call of service themselves. They need our free and generous offerings to keep their missions going. All of our prayer should be poured out for the master’s servants who trace his steps with blood of their own. 

       But if you want to speak in generalities, if you would boast of how well the churches are doing, then show me the fruit of something more than lazy seed. Show me fruit that bears at least some resemblance to the sacrifice of Christ. Let me see the blood. Or tell me about the pot-lucks that are filled with the poor, the lame, the blind, and the hungry instead of over-fed, corpulent Christians who for years haven’t had the will power to put down their spoon. Let me see some people who truly put self aside and suffer for the name of Christ. 
“Do not love the world or the things in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him. For all that is in the world—the desires of the flesh and the desires of the eyes and pride of life—is not from the Father but is from the world. And the world is passing away along with its desires, but whoever does the will of God abides forever.” I John 2.15-17
I’ve even seen ministers of the gospel buying their wives jewelry and other “nice” things, feeding a love for worldliness rather than giving a example of sacrifice to their fellow-Christians and the unbelieving world. Are you looking for us to help you? Look around the theater, go to Disney World, try the golf course, basketball court, or tennis club. Many put down the tools that give real health years ago. You’ll find few in the field. How much is wasted in the name of Christ! What has the faith of Christ come to? 

     (Now I’m not against healthy exercise. I’ve even tried some myself lately. City-dwelling, desk bound workers need it. But the simple things will do. Jesus was big on walking. He was raised with a hammer in his hand.) 

      Wonderful things are expressed about our readiness for the coming of the humble Christ, who’s glory is in his humility. Who of us are truly ready, who can really stand, who can abide the coming of this kind of glory when the love of self and the world are so firmly rooted in our hearts? Who is repenting, confessing their sins with an anguish of soul only the cross could inspire? Who will then rise from their knees and tear-stained sheets to “seek and save the lost” in the name of Christ and Him crucified?
When I think of the years I’ve wasted, of the time and money and abilities God has given I can hardly believe he would find a place in the kingdom for me. What time do I have no to waste in things that may even be good in themselves, but are counted as nothing compared to the surpassing worth of knowing Christ and sharing that knowledge with others?
A hedonist extaordinaire, I have run from the cross nearly all my life. How could God patiently search me out decade after decade? Why the patience with a gross sinner?
If we want to know the love of God we must know our love of sin, for it is our sin that put him on the cross, it is our sin that keeps him working as our priest in the temple of God, and is is our sin that has stained the earth with his tears and blood. What manner of love is this, that God should give his Son a sacrifice for ones such as us? What is left for us but to die with him at Calvary and rise again, having only one new purpose to glorify the God who loved us so, to spend and be spent for that one “Pearl of great price”? 
Jan McKenzie
Confession: I live a very comfortable life. My cross is so small it can hardly be seen, let alone felt. I speak out of the conviction of God’s Spirit leading me to a deeper repentance for my neglect of others. I have no excuses that would be acceptable to God.


Wednesday, September 14, 2011

NEW COACH NEEDED



John Feinstein recently wrote an article for The Sporting News regarding the turnover among coaches. He quoted heralded college coach Steve Spurrier as saying, “Coaching is a lot like preaching. After about nine or ten years you need to move on to another church. People have heard your message enough times that you need to find a different place to take your message.” Spurrier, I should add, is the son of a preacher.
His comment reminded me of some research we conducted among churches and pastors, examining longevity and impact. We found that church leaders have their greatest impact on the lives of congregants during years five through fourteen of their tenure at a church. Prior to year five they are clarifying, articulating and seeking buy-in of their vision. After year 14 they tend to get stuck in a routine that produces diminishing returns.
Some pastors remain fresh and effective after year 14, but they seem to be the exception to the rule. It is quite easy to become complacent and comfortable in the lead role after a decade and half in the same ministry. Leaders can often justify to constituents their continuation in a comfortable role, but Christian leaders must remember that they answer to the God who called them to leadership – and He will not be fooled.
Great leaders keep reinventing themselves, stimulating both themselves and their organization to reach new levels of impact. That means continually looking at the vision in new ways – coming up with a new vision, but adapting the organization to the ever-changing realities the ministry faces and implementing the vision in new ways and contexts.
But we also discovered that most leaders have a ceiling they must recognize for their leadership abilities, and work within those parameters. Certainly a great leader grows, but part of what makes them great is being realistic about themselves and responding intelligently and honestly to their limitations. Too many leaders engage in denial about their limitations, to the detriment of everyone involved. Great leaders seek situations in which their gifts and abilities are a perfect fit – and they are savvy enough to depart when their abilities are no longer a good match for the circumstances. Operating within one’s limitations is a sign of wisdom not defeat; staying beyond the time when one can add value is selfish and bad stewardship. Learning about these matters from some of the excellent research on the stages of organizational growth is helpful in this regard.
George Barma

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

DEATH SWARM -2-

Death Swarm  pt2

Before the death swarm laid me waste, like barren dessert or parched and dry riverbed, I didn't realize how deep my roots penetrated the earth. Down deep in the soil I sensed life movement. Ever so small, threadlike root fibers were moving, drawing nourishment, living, not dead. In the darkness and noise of the death swarm the power of clattering jaws could not reach my roots. The sensation of life is faint and fragile. Faint, fragile, my clutch on life continued for seasons. I knew that I needed to protect my survival.

I feared that anything could come, steal away the little I had left. Oh, again just existence, afraid, afraid that even a small storm would snatch away the last, weak, and desperate signs of life. Stubble and death haunted me. My end did not come about, though at times it would have been easier to give in and allow disease and death to find their completion, their ultimate triumph. Yet, I knew, No, my roots knew, that life must find its way back to the surface. Slowly working towards the surface, life is surviving, growing. I am still filled with fear. Fear of the paralyzing buzz filling my ears. Fearing I could never survive another attack. For fear has clamped a vice around my throat, causing my stomach to churn.

Realization also brings another fear. Realization that I must live, but in living would have to find some sense in fresh horror. Questions begin, unanswerable, haunting and without end. Questions pile up all around me. Soon even the questions block my vision. I argue and argue, I search and search, the answer of, no answer haunts me. The swarm, clacking of jaws, stubble, despair, and now, life, why God? I must find that resurrection is taking place. How long it takes, meaningless, how much pain, meaningless. If it takes a day or a lifetime my resurrection will be complete and whole.

When that understanding finds place, my questions begin to cease. Understanding brings about the ending of the questioning nightmare. Not the understanding of all things. For me, a better understanding of the deep issues of living, not mere existing. The issues of pain, suffering, despair, hopelessness, yes, even longing for death, all take on new purpose and meaning.

 The death swarm moves about freely, searching for prey. Guided by some evil reckoning, it senses the weak or susceptible. An such life on this cosmic orb is potential feed. Hundreds, thousands, yes, millions of unsuspecting, tender living plants are targets of the evil swarm. I will always cringe at the buzz, images may always fill or cloud my vision. I know the potential that comes with the noise. But, there are lands filled with the unsuspecting, the innocent, the naive, lives that have not heard the buzz or clacking. The buzzing and clacking that brings stubble, debris and death to a land once fertile.

 Must they wait helpless, unsuspecting, ignorant of the death swarm that moves about so freely? I survived, would they? My roots held my life. Do they have roots that go deep? My roots speak of my Creator who sustains, nourishes, resurrects. What do they have? When the swarm comes upon them, and it will, will they survive? And, what about the young and tender, just breaking through and reaching, stretching sun-ward. Enjoying sun, drinking in the gentle rains as they fall fro their Creator's carefully designed canopy. Many of them will fall to the clacking and the buzz. They will have no idea of the sound that approaches them. No idea how one turns to millions. How clacking of jaws and buzz of wings leads to death and desolation. I will tell of my survival.

I will tell of my Creator's power deep within my roots. Yes, tell of His life that kept me alive. His life force, living in the fibers and threads of my existence. I responded to His great desire to see me become. I responded to His timeless plan to resurrect me to a new sense of being whole and complete. Oh, that I would sing a song of my Creator's grace. A song I could have never given voice to before that great and terrible day. I will tell of my story. Some will listen, sadly some will have no understanding of my message. You that understand, in some way, the death swarm has come near you. The buzz, demonic clattering jaws, all wanting your death.

Darkness, a great and thick darkness, overcame you. You despaired, cried, even welcomed your own ending. But, your Creator, your God, had, has, will always have, a greater design for you. Will you join me, join my voice and spirit, proclaiming to all of creation the resurrection that our God gifted us with? The message and song of today is so different from yesterday. The song of tomorrow is designed to be different than the one of today. Come and join me as we proclaim victory over the death swarm.

I wrote this piece during one of my darkest seasons. For me the death swarm was despair and an utter overpowering sense of hopelessness. If I had to define, Death Swarm, it would mean any influence that attacks your soul, in subtle beginnings or ravenous flood. Millions of wonderful people live with the life and joy devoured from their soul. Despair, hopelessness, anxiety, fear, anger, many are the names that the death swarm uses. 

Tedd Galloway
Former SA Officer
USA Central

Monday, September 12, 2011

DEATH SWARM Part -1-

If you know of a person who suffers from depression please read this seeking a new sense of understanding.  I began the first writing of this piece about seven years ago. At the conclusion I will give some background and points of understanding.

My life was like a blade of wheat, for within me was the desire and the potential to reproduce and feed multitudes of hungry souls. I knew that was my ordained purpose, in fact, my only reason for being. The soil that surrounded me provided nourishment and stability. The falling rains enabled me to grow, at times rapidly, other times, slowly. My roots penetrated deep into the earth. I grew strong and my strength helped in the storms.

And then, a day of destruction and death came. Oh, the day started like so many, a sweet morning dew glistened and sparkled in the early morning sun. Later, not much later, came a distant sound. The sound, like a faint buzz, like the buzz of a bumble-bee. I wasn't able to tell what direction the noise was coming from. Gradually the noise increased, building momentum, sounding like a giant swarm of bees.

The sky to the south was growing dark. I sensed that some type of storm was going to descend. I had endured many storms, but some type of disturbing and anxious vision told me this was to be different. The first one landed only inches from me. It's jaws clacked, like two stones striking each other. Now, its ravenous appetite powered jaws at an insane pace. The first leaf and blade, next to me, full of life, was gone in an instant. The second and third landed, their clacking jaws soon joined a number beyond counting.

The noise filled the air; it was impossible for me to hear anything but the evil ravenous clacking and their results. The sky was black, sun blotted out, extinguished by millions of hungry murderous locusts. Their jaws, clacking, chewing, untiring in their destruction of every green thing. My world was covered. My eye's couldn't see anything except evil destroying life. My ear's couldn't hear, but, the clacking, clattering of jaws, roaring of wings and the faint cry of blade and leaf, being devoured. Horror wrapped itself around my world. All I loved, all I knew, all I held so close, was being consumed by this death swarm from hell.

Time seemed suspended, each bite, each jaw movement, from the green flying demons took forever. Each leaf, blade eaten, ever so slowly by the unstoppable clacking jaws. As if signaled, the black-death swarm lifted into the sky. Millions of wings joined together in a deafening death dance. In a single movement the death swarm moves in concert to devour another unsuspecting field, a field, like mine, full of life and potential. The death swarm will not stop, consuming the living and leaving behind stubble, desolation and death.

When the attack was over I was numb, living in a timeless state. Did this really happen? Did I really experience such horror and callousness? How long, this state of near death? My life, once green, growing, now only stubble. In the soil surrounding me I find only debris and death. Is their any life in me? Has death come and I am cursed to watch what was? My senses are gone, is their any hope at all that life might exist? Have I been like this for days, months, years, or just fleeting seconds? I just don't know.

Tedd Galloway
Former SA Officer
USA Central

Love Wins 6


Rob Bell; A Bridge to Confusion? -6- Conclusion

Rob Bell’s fourth chapter in his new book Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived asks a great question: “Does God Get What God Wants?” This is the sixth installment of a series of posts on the book. In this series, I intend to expose the main lines of argument in each chapter and critically reflect on them. Admittedly, this is not always done systematically as today’s post will reveal.

I think this is probably the best chapter of the book because the argument is tight and the question is significant.

So what do you think?

Does God get what God wants? Is this answer obvious? But perhaps a more important question is: What exactly does God want? Is it presumptuous on our part to state is so simply? Could it be there a number of different answers to the question depending on the point of view or subject?

Rob asks: “Have billions of people been created only to spend eternity in conscious punishment and torment, suffering infinitely for the finite sins they committed in the few years they spent on earth?” (102). Great Question. And this really is the central issue of the chapter.

Rob surveys biblical evidence of an inclusive salvation of every person who has ever lived. On reading the list, the conclusion seems obvious: God wants to save everyone. Yet, when one drills down, it becomes a much more complicated picture. Of these complications Rob seems completely unaware. When the Bible speaks of the pilgrimage of the nations to God in the OT, does this mean every person on the earth at the time, let alone every person who's ever lived? There is a difference in the way writers can use the word “all”. “All” can mean: (1) all without exclusion of any one [this is the way Rob takes it] or (2) all without distinction between parties. While not taking the time now to show this exegetically, it is clear from the OT contexts that the second of the two is most often meant. In other words, the prophets are not predicting that every person who ever lived will come to God, but that when God visits in the last days, all the “nations” will come to him. Revelation 5:9 captures this idea in the NT: “for you were slain, and by your blood you ransomed people for God from every tribe and language and people and nation”. Notice that text doesn’t say every person from every tribe, language, people and nation, but representatives, a remnant, of every tribe, language, etc. This is “all with out distinction”. Besides in the very concrete perspective of the OT, there’s no conception of an afterlife salvation. This picture is in purely earthly terms. When God acts in history in bringing salvation, this act will be inclusive of a remnant of people of every nation not only the remnant of Israel.

Now for the sake of argument, it may be true that God will save everyone, but that is not the point of these passages. It seems to me that if one wishes to conclude that God will save all without exception, this is a deductive conclusion because no biblical passage teaches this explicitly. One needs to theologize to this conclusion. This is not a criticism, we do this on plenty of important issues (e.g. Trinity), but it is not specifically stated in Scripture. Thus, an argument like Rob’s doesn’t hold up to scrutiny because his evidence doesn’t actually support the claim. This by the way, goes for the NT evidence as well. Did Jesus and Peter and Paul and James and John believe that every person that ever lived would be saved in the end? Does Jesus’ statement in Matt 19:28 and Peter’s in Acts 3 and Paul’s in Col 1 mean that every person who ever lived will be saved? Again this theological claim may be right, but not based on the evidence given.

God doesn’t get what he wants in salvation from a biblical perspective, only if you define what he wants wrongly. God’s aims are universal, yes cosmic. God’s intentions are inclusive; yes they will reach every nation. And yes, God attains his universal aims and his inclusive intentions.

In order to answer the apparent issue of between God’s universal salvation purposes and the traditional doctrine of hell, Rob lists five options for understanding how to reconcile this contradiction. The options range from the traditional evangelical view, to extreme universalism. Rob maintains that all five of these are comfortably within “orthodoxy”: “Serious, orthodox followers of Jesus have answered these questions in a number of different ways”? (109) This conclusion is of course questionable as I've stated elsewhere since it includes the word "orthodox", although it is true that "serious followers of Jesus" have believed these things and one's view on this question does not make or break one's Christian identity.

Any reader will be able to discern that it’s the fifth option (universalism) that Rob likes best and is most convinced by, although others seem to at least be amicable to him. You even think that the fifth option is what he opts for. But before you can feel that you have got him pegged, he pulls back from that fifth choice in the subsequent paragraphs (pgs 113-17). Rob does not appear to be a universalist because for him human freedom trumps even God’s unrelenting love. But as it turns out, this circumstance is not contrary to what God wants because God wants to love. God’s love has consequences. Love wins, but it doesn’t mean that hell will ultimately be evacuated. Rob may hope for this and surely does, but he’s apparently a realist. Rob says, “Love demands freedom. It always has, and it always will. We are free to resist, reject, and rebel against God’s ways for us. We can have all the hell we want" (113).

In the final analysis according to Rob the question of the chapter “Does God get what he wants?” while a good, interesting and important one, is fraught with speculation about the future. It is no doubt true that God gets what he wants; the precise manner of it is concealed. However, there is a question that he thinks is much easier to answer and no less important. The question: “Do we get what we want?” To that question the answer is absolutely yes. Yes we get what we want, because “God is that loving” (117). So as C.S. Lewis said, there are two kinds of people in the world, those who say ‘Thy will be done’ and those who say, ‘My will be done’.

There is a vague sense of justice in the chapter’s conception of restoration, but it is the weakest part of the chapter and Rob’s whole proposal in my view. Rob writes
This is important, because in speaking of the expansive, extraordinary, infinite love of God there is always the danger of neglecting the very real consequences of God’s love, namely God’s desire and intention to see things become everything they were always intended to be. For this to unfold, God must say about a number of acts and to those who would continue to do them, “Not here you won’t” (113).
*
Still this chapter surfaces what I think to be the most significant and thorny question with which traditional evangelicals must deal: the question of the justness of infinite punishment for finite sin. And this is not simply an issue Rob Bell has raised. The idea that the sin we commit in our finite bodies deserves an infinite amount of punishment seems absurd on any definition to a growing number of people. We can pretend that it makes “perfect sense”, as someone has recently remarked [Tim Keller: “I seems perfectly reasonable for an infinite God to punish infinitely” – round table discussion at Gospel Coalition].

But simply saying it’s “perfectly logical” does not actually deal with the question. To growing number of people it's just not. While it in fact may be reasonable, the biblical argument needs to be made today in a way that is freshly compelling and grounded in Scripture. I don’t completely know where I am on this and I haven’t thought enough about it to offer anything of a thoughtful cohesive view. I think there are fundamental parameters, however, within which one must work. In spite of arguments to the contrary, biblically the afterlife of the unrighteous is:

(1) eternal—final and unalterable,
(2) conscious—there is a person, mind and body, and
(3) retributive—there’s no reformation

The actual working out of these is where things are fuzzy for me. In addition, the extent of the actual punishment in this eternal, conscious and retributive state is also something I continue to mull over.

Recently, Scot McKnight in his book One.Life: Jesus Calls, We Followhas given us a proposal to consider. First Scot rejects the idea of infinite punishment for finite sin, although he maintains, I think, the three fundamentals above. This leads him to the second part of the proposal. I’ll let him speak for himself:
So where are we? I have thought long and hard about hell and have come to a view that modifies the second above: hell is a person’s awareness of being utterly absent, which is what “death after death” means, but yet in the presence of God, like C. S. Lewis’ wraiths yearning to be observed and present but deeply aware that they have declined both options. I am unconvinced that annihilation fully answers all that Jesus says, but I also believe that the second view doesn’t contain enough mercy and grace (165).
I can’t say I’m convinced by his view. What’s more, I have not rejected the idea, as Scot seems to have, of infinite punishment on the basis of it being unjust. Yet, Scot exhibits the kind of fresh thinking on the question that I think is beneficial. I think we need to go back to the Bible and present its view of ultimate punishment of the wicked in a convincing well-argued manner. Simply appealing to the old argument of an infinite God who, because of his infiniteness, punishes infinitely is not adequate.

JOEL WILLITTS