Saturday, July 16, 2011

Two Minutes to Eternity -Part Two


And then suddenly the baby was out. The doctor cut the cord and gently placed him on Susan's chest. He was a healthy pink, and we saw his chest rise and fall. The breath of life. Thank you, God.

Then, almost immediately, he began to turn blue. We stroked his face and whispered words of welcome, of love, of farewell. And all too soon the doctor said, "He's gone."

Within minutes, our pastor, our parents, and our children came into the room. Together we wept, held one another, and took turns holding our son. My chest ached from heaviness. Death is enormous, immense, unstoppable.

The loss was crushing, but mingled with the tears and the terrible pain was something else. I'm not sure I can describe it.

At the births of my three older daughters, I'd felt "the miracle of birth," that sacred moment when a new life enters the world of light and air. The pneuma, the breath of life, fills the lungs for the first time. Now this moment was doubly intense because the miracle of birth was followed so quickly by the mystery of death. The pneuma was here and now gone.

"It feels like eternity just intersected earth" was all I could say to our pastor. The pain of grief was diminished not at all, but it blended with the weight of overwhelming wonder at the irresistible movement from time to eternity.

"Do you have a name for the baby?" asked one of the nurses.

"Toby," Susan said. "It's short for a biblical name, Tobiah, which means 'God is good.' "

We had long thought about the name for this child. We didn't particularly feel God's goodness at that moment. The name was what we believed, not what we felt. It was what we wanted to feel again someday.

The words of C.S. Lewis, describing the lion Aslan, kept coming to mind: "He's not a tame lion. But he's good." We clung to that image of untamed and fearsome goodness, even as we continued to struggle with the question: Why would God create a child to live two minutes?

Everything has an inside

Shortly before we discovered Toby's condition, I read a book by Christopher de Vinck, The Power of the Powerless, in which he describes what he learned from his severely and profoundly retarded brother, Oliver.

I was interested because our third daughter, Mandy, was also severely retarded, unable to respond to her environment. And just three months after Toby's birth and death, Mandy also entered eternity. She was two weeks shy of her second birthday. One of the points de Vinck made about Oliver helped me with the God-directed questions I had after Toby's birth and death. One of the greatest discoveries that a child or an adult can make, writes de Vinck, is that "everything has an inside. In our house, we split apples to look at the core, we crack walnuts to see the meat inside, we press a toy stethoscope to our chests to listen to the heartbeat."

The point: you can't always guess what's on the inside by looking at the outside.

The Bible says that "Man looks on the outward appearance, but God looks on the heart." That was true then. It's true now. We're so outer focused. We're taught to judge people by the stylishness of their clothing labels. Political campaigns are crafted by scriptwriters, TV directors, and pollsters. Educational policies are based on appearances of political correctness. We're tempted to believe that image is everything, that outward appearances are most important. We ignore the inside, the heart, the spirit.

Each of my children also has an inside. With my two older girls, I get occasional glimpses of their interior life. Their words and actions give me clues about their inner worlds. With Mandy, the glass was darker. And with Toby, we never had a chance to see inside.

But Mandy and Toby both had insides. Despite the damage to the outer frame, the inside is to be treasured.

Our unearthly calling

Not long after we buried Toby and Mandy, our seven-year-old daughter, Stacey, told us she heard God's voice in the middle of the night telling her that "Mandy and Toby are very busy. They are building our house, and they are guarding his throne."

Not knowing how to respond to a child who had never offered a claim like that before, I found myself reading the Bible with renewed interest in descriptions of heavenly activities. Was this message consistent with Scripture? Our family discussions usually focused on heaven.

We saw that heaven is a place of activity, not just leisure or ease. God is preparing a city for the faithful (Heb. 11:16), where all will be made perfect and complete (Heb. 11:40). The Bible contains many descriptions of heavenly worship as active and intense.

And since Jesus said that in his Father's house are "many mansions" and he was going to prepare a place for us (John 14), we could easily envision part of our heavenly activity being to help prepare for those yet to arrive.

I must admit, however, that I was more intrigued by the image of guarding Christ's throne. Was this an honor guard? A ceremonial assemblage of children, whom Christ on earth had invited to be near him? Or perhaps seats of honor for those Christ had in mind when he said, "The last shall be first"? I can't think of many more "last" than Mandy and Toby.

But what if guarding the throne isn't ceremonial but actual? Daniel 10 describes the angel Michael in conflict with a spiritual foe. Ephesians 6:12 describes a struggle "against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms." Could it be that among the spiritual warriors in this conflict is one named Toby?

The Book of Revelation records battles involving heavenly armies (Rev. 19:19). Could it be that along with countless others of us, Toby will serve among the heavenly hosts in that final great war?

All of this, of course, is conjecture. But what is clear is that heaven will be a place of active duty.

And when the ultimate spiritual battle is over, our responsibilities continue.

The apostle John's vision of eternity suggests what's in store for all the saints: "The throne of God and of the Lamb will be in the city, and his servants will serve him. They will see his face, and his name will be on their foreheads …. And they will reign forever and ever" (Rev. 22:3-5).

I don't know exactly what our service in that city will involve, nor can I be specific about how we will assist in reigning. But those tasks sound like they may have a bit more significance than most careers we pursue in our current lifetime.

Could it be that when I finally start the most significant service of my life, I'll find that this is what I was truly created for? I may find that the reason I was created was not for anything I accomplish on earth, but the role I'm to fulfill forever.

I realized that my earlier question had been answered.

Why did God create a child to live two minutes?

He didn't.

He didn't create Toby to live two minutes or Mandy to live two years. He didn't create me to live 40 years (or whatever number he may choose to extend my days in this world).

God created Toby for eternity. He created each of us for eternity, where we may be surprised to find our true calling, which always seemed just out of reach here on earth.


Grace, strength, and joy,


Marshall Shelley

Marshall Shelley is editor in chief of Leadership Journal. This article was originally published in Christianity Today, May 16, 1994.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Two Minutes to Eternity - Why would God allow the miracle of birth to be followed so quickly by the mystery of death? Part 1

I was with my son his entire life. Two minutes.

He entered the world of light and air at 8:20 p.m. on November 22, 1991. And he departed, the doctor said, at 8:22.

It seemed a very short time. Too short. My wife, Susan, and I never got to see him take his first steps. We barely got to see him take his first breath.

I don't know if he would have enjoyed softball or software, dinosaurs or dragonflies, machines or math. We never got to wrestle, race, or read—would he have enjoyed those things like his older sisters do? What would have made him laugh? Made him scared? Made him angry?

Those questions swarmed around my soul in the days following my son's arrival and all-too-hurried departure. So many things I wondered. But one question loomed larger than all the rest, haunting me for months: Why would God create a child to live two minutes?

Many tragic deaths can be blamed on human cruelty or foolishness. A stray bullet punctures a tenement wall and kills an infant. A driver loses control of a car and careens into a group of schoolchildren on the sidewalk. Senseless. Heartbreaking. But at least I know where to direct my anger.

With my son, no direct human responsibility could be charged in his death. It was a "chromosomal abnormality" called Trisomy 13. One of the 23 sets of chromosomes developed a third appendage. Despite genetic tests and the expert opinions of doctors, we discovered no known cause for this condition.

As far as I was concerned, this was a design flaw. And the Designer was directly responsible.

I remember the first time I heard the term "Trisomy 13." It was the same hour I first saw my son—as ghostly black-white-and-gray movements on the sonogram screen. In silence, Susan and I watched the embryonic motions as Dr. Silver manipulated the ultrasound, measuring the cranium and the femur and viewing the internal organs.

"Is everything okay?" I asked.

"Let me complete the examination, and I'll give you a full report," he said. I noted his evasive answer and hoped this was merely his standard procedure.

Moments later, he announced his observations in a matter-of-fact voice: "We have some problems. The fetus has a malformed heart—the aorta is attached incorrectly. There are missing portions of the cerebellum. A club foot. A cleft palate and perhaps a cleft lip. Possibly spina bifida. This is probably a case of Trisomy 13 or Trisomy 18. In either case, it is a condition incompatible with life."

Neither Susan nor I could say anything. So Dr. Silver continued. "It's likely the fetus will spontaneously miscarry. If the child is born, it will not survive long outside the womb. You need to decide if you want to try to carry this pregnancy to term."

We both knew what he was asking. I was speechless. Susan found her voice first. Though shaken by the news, she said softly but clearly, "We believe God is the giver and taker of life. If the only opportunity I have to know this child is in my womb, I don't want to cut that time short. If the only world he is to know is the womb, I want that world to be as safe as I can make it."

We left the medical center that July afternoon stunned and saddened.

"Pregnancy is hard enough when you know you're going to leave the hospital with a baby," Susan said. "I don't know how I can go through the pain of childbirth knowing I won't have a child to hold."

Signs of the Pneuma

Summer turned to fall, and we were praying that our son would be healed. And if a long life were not God's intention for him, we prayed that he could at least experience the breath of life. We longed see that reminder of God's Spirit, the Pneuma, flow through him like a gentle wind.

Even that request seemed in jeopardy as labor began November 22. As the contractions got more severe, signs of fetal distress caused the nurses to ask, "Should we try to deliver the baby alive?"

"Yes, if at all possible, short of surgery," Susan replied.

They kept repositioning Susan and gave her oxygen, and the fetal distress eased.


Marshall Shelley
Leadership editor in chief

Marshall Shelley is editor in chief of Leadership Journal. This article was originally published in Christianity Today, May 16, 1994.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Justice at the Mercy Seat

Several years ago a close friend and I were exchanging our private thoughts on the subject of holiness. I found myself taken aback as he hurled something of a zinger at me. He said that in his opinion, one of the two words for holiness in the Hebrew Testament (qodesh) could almost literally be interpreted as “he who does justice though he knows he’s a sinner.”

Wow! If ever a statement packed a wallop, it had to be that one! Since my friend taught preaching and theology for 10 years at a well–known West Coast seminary, I figured he must know what he was talking about. To a non–scholar like me, this simple pre–Wesleyan Hebrew definition of holy living caught me off guard and quite frankly threw me for a loop.

Growing up in the Arminian–Wesleyan Christian tradition, I recall that most sermons and discussions on holiness were centered solely on talk about eradicating inbred sin and other heavy theological concepts. So it’s easy to see how this very simple idea of “doing justice” as an integral part of holy living might have sometimes gotten lost in the maze. Yet it shouldn’t have because doing justice has always been right at the heart of Wesleyan theology and Christian faith.

The holiness God requires of his people is not just academic or personal. It needs to always be expressed in a frequent and radical concern for justice—especially toward the poor and those deemed social outcasts.

I’m reminded of an incident a long time ago that brought this point home to me—though admittedly it took a few years and some maturity before it did so! It was the mid–1960s and I was a corps cadet (student of Salvation Army doctrine and history in a five–year course of study for teens) at the Lawn Corps (church) in Chicago. Our brigade had become known for our theatrical portrayal of Vachel Lindsay’s “General William Booth Enters Into Heaven.” We had performed it at two divisional events and were soon getting gigs at various corps in the area.

One night we were guests at a revival service for the Joliet, Ill., Corps. A retired, widowed officer in the corps named Brigadier Margaret Norris had made herself the unofficial “mercy seat” (altar) sergeant at Joliet. Whenever an invitation was given to come to the altar and pray, she was always there—standing guard, walking up and down passing out Kleenex to all the seekers.

Showing true mercy

This particular evening when the invitation was given, the mercy seat was lined with people, and Brigadier Norris was doing her thing. Our brigade was sitting in the back of the hall watching all the activity.

A very heavy–set woman who had entered the building for the first time went forward with tears in her eyes. She had huge rolls of fat on her legs. At that time, obesity wasn’t as prevalent or as talked about as it is today, and nobody really understood it as anything other than a moral failing.

Brigadier Margaret Norris

It was obvious the woman couldn’t bend down and was too heavy to kneel. But somehow the Brigadier sensed that she needed something more than to just stand there and pray. Without flinching, Brigadier Norris turned the woman around, sat her on the mercy seat, and prayed with her.

To a group of teenagers in the back pews, this scene was very humorous, and the smirks on our faces must have revealed our inner laughter. On our way back to Chicago there were all the obvious jokes about new meaning to “My All Is on the Altar,” etc.

But some four decades on, I now see what Brigadier Norris did as one of the pivotal moments in my development as a Christian. As a young man, I experienced many mass meetings where droves of people would stream down to the mercy seat. However, those scenes remain little more than a blur on my consciousness. Yet there is one sight indelibly etched on my brain forever, leaving the deepest of impressions. It is that of Brigadier Norris exemplifying holiness as she did justice by gently helping a rotund woman unable to kneel to sit on the mercy seat so she could meet Jesus. It’s what the Kingdom of God is all about.

by Daryl Lach


Copyright © by The Salvation Army.
Article reprinted with permission.
PRIORITY Fall 2010
TSA USA East

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Dealing with the Illness of Loved Ones and Other Challenges in Life Part 2

Some thoughts to remember.....

During these days I have come to realize that illness is not evidence of God 'punishing' us for past 'misdeeds'. Unfortunately, there are some who would have you believe this. God allows illness to visit His people for a reason. That reason may not always be clear, at first, but we can be assured, whatever it is, God knows exactly what is happening and why. He loves you and cares for you and He will work out His perfect will through you, even when illness is present.

Illness always brings with it the need for reliance upon God. During times of illness we feel most vulnerable. Some would say helpless. God wants us to exercise our faith in ways that bring honor and glory to Him. It is during times of affliction that God works His most powerful ways through us. He makes His presence felt by those who need Him the most. It is when we are at our most vulnerable that we 'cast all our care upon Him'. Depending upon Him for strength, endurance, understanding and compassion brings into our life a power that is sufficient to enable us to serve Him most effectively.

God has a grand design for our lives. We may not always understand it. It may not always be a plan that we would choose. But, as we stand in His presence, we come to realize His wisdom, perhaps in ways not understood before. For His people God works all things out for the good.

Finally, He will not leave you or forsake you! God is an ever present help in time of need. He is there for you to talk with, cry with, rejoice with and serve with. He is alongside of you and He will never be absent. That is true throughout life, but never more true than is times of great distress.

This knowledge is what helps each of us deal with our life circumstance. It is the realization that God has brought many blessings our way and He continues to do so. He is an ever loving, ever present God. It is upon Him that we rely. Whatever the future holds, we do not walk alone. It is not necessary for us to deal with these realities by ourselves. God draws up alongside, each step of the way.

Are you facing challenging circumstances in life? Are you dealing with the illness of a loved one? Please know that you need not do it alone! God stands, even now, at your side ready to guide, comfort, strengthen, and enable you to navigate difficult waters. Take some time to seek Him out and, as you do, "count your blessings"!

"The will of God will never take you
Where the grace of God cannot keep you,
Where the arms of God cannot support you,.
Where the riches of God cannot supply your needs,
Where the power of God cannot endow you."

May God Bless you!

Gary D. Laws
Former SA Officer
USA Central

Monday, July 11, 2011

Dealing with the Illness of Loved Ones and Other Challenges in Life Part 1

In 1992, my wife began showing signs of muscle weakness. At first it was mild. She had pains in her arms and legs, often her eyes would cross and her eyelids would shut involuntarily. Over about 6 months, the symptoms became worse and someone had to be home with her around the clock. I worked the day shift and my son the night shift which enabled one of us to be home at all times. Eventually she became totally unable to care for herself. Soon we had a diagnosis of Myastheina Gravis. We were not sure what the future would hold. After about a year, and many, many trips to the doctor and hospital, she went into remission and we were, indeed, a joyful family as she began to regain her abilities.

She did very well for several years, then illness struck again. She would begin to experience many behavioral difficulties which no one could adequately explain. More doctors and multiple hospitalizations. More discouraging diagnosis. Then came the heart attacks, two to be precise, and ultimately 3 full blown strokes and a severe bout with depression over a one year period. By this time my son had joined the military and our ministry had taken us far away from our other four children who, now, were grown and had families of their own. It became necessary to leave our ministry of many years and move closer to three of our children. More doctors and hospitals, most recently a two month stay at which time we almost lost her.

Recently, the overall diagnosis for these newer conditions became Vascular Dementia, resulting from the strokes. Once again, this wonderful lady found herself totally dependent upon others for even the most simple things in life such as dressing, bathing, walking, eating and more. She is not always able to speak as she would like or formulate her words. Often, she will sit on the edge of the bed and weep, thinking that life will never again be normal for her.

One day we went outdoors to sit in the sunshine and, as we looked off in the distance, there was a woman in a wheel chair making her way across the distant parking lot. She was alone, pushing herself backwards with one foot, a few inches at a time. I was a bit worried, in that moment, that Susan would see herself (in that woman) at some time in the future, so I did not say anything for fear of bringing that to mind. We were both silent and then, as the lady made her way behind a building and out of our view, Sue looked up at me and said in words as clear as ever, "We should be thankful for our blessings!"

"Thankful"?, I thought to myself! My wife, over several years, has been ill beyond anything she deserves, and we should be thankful? We have lost our ministry, our retirement, our freedom and my wife has lost the ability to care for herself and somehow this seemed, to me, like a strange way for her to react. After all, she could very well be in the same situation as this poor lady in the wheel chair, and in the not to distant future at that.

These thoughts lasted only for a few fleeting seconds. The Lord convicted me immediately.Then, I was reminded of my wife's powerful, albeit simple words. "We should be thankful for our blessings!" In that moment I started counting those blessings, as that great hymn suggests. Naming them, "one by one". We live comfortably, while finances are a challenge we have sufficient. We can communicate with each other, hug each other, share quiet moments throughout the day! We are able to enjoy our children and grandchildren. We can get out and move about many days. I have the physical and emotional strength to serve my wife in these days and most of all, we have a God who loves, enables and cares for us each step of the way. Then I realized that we had not lost our ministry at all. It has simply changed. I have a new, God given ministry to my wife and I hope she realizes that she ministers to me, also, in countless ways.

End Part 1


Gary D. Laws
Former SA Officer
USA Central

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Iran: Death Sentence Upheld

The Iranian Supreme Court has upheld the death sentence of a pastor convicted of apostasy and accused of evangelizing Muslims. Pastor Youcef Nadarkhani, 34, has been in prison since October 2009, and the appeal of his death sentence was rejected by the Iranian Supreme Court on June 28, 2011. He is to be executed by hanging. If the death sentence is carried out, it will be the first court-ordered execution of a Christian in Iran in 20 years.
Youcef and his wife, Fatemah
“At this time, there is no more action that can be done inside of Iran to overturn this sentence,” a VOM contact said. “It can be carried out at any time. The only options right now are to immediately and swiftly bring international attention to the issue.”
Nadarkhani, a pastor from Rasht, about 750 miles northwest of Tehran, was arrested in October 2009 after he protested a government policy that required children, including his 8- and 9-year-old sons, to study the Quran in school.

Nadarkhani told school officials that the Iranian constitution allows for freedom of religious practice. As a result of his protest, secret police called him before a political tribunal and arrested him for protesting. The charges were later amended to apostasy and evangelism of Muslims. Nadarkhani was tried on Sept. 21–22, 2010, by the 1st Court of the Revolutionary Tribunal and sentenced to death on Nov. 13 for apostasy.

Nadarkhani is imprisoned in Lakan prison, where authorities have used various methods, including medication, to convert him back to Islam, according to Present Truth Ministries. After Nadarkhani refused to convert to Islam, his wife was arrested, put on trial without an attorney and sentenced to life in prison. She was later released after an attorney appealed her sentence. The Nadarkhanis’ children were cared for by a relative while they were both in prison.

Please lift up Pastor Nadarkhani urgently before the Lord and ask for his release.

Saturday, July 9, 2011

Daily Telegraph Blog Editor Condemns 'Islam's Persecution of Christians'

Damian Thompson saw fit yesterday to exploit the murder in Pakistan of Shahbaz Bhatti, Pakistan’s only Christian minister, to launch a tirade against Islam and the religion’s supposed persecution of Christians and the apparent failure of Christian leaders to speak out against such persecution.
He wrote in his Telegraph blog:

“Shahbaz Bhatti was Pakistan’s Minister for Minorities and today he paid the price for belonging to the most despised Pakistani minority of all: Christians. He was shot dead in his car for the crime of campaigning to reform the country’s medieval blasphemy laws. Those laws are used to make life hell for Christians – but that doesn’t seem to bother Britain and the EU, which pour millions of pounds into Pakistan and don’t make a big deal out of anti-Christian persecution.”

“Meanwhile, as my colleague Ed West has often noted, Iraq’s indigenous Christian minority is close to extinction. To be fair, that wasn’t intention of the originator of the Tony Blair Faith Foundation when he invaded the country – but it was certainly the vision of the founder of Islam.”

“Serving C of E bishops touch on the subject occasionally, but most seem slumped in a multi-faith snooze. And Catholics? Various bishops do good work in the Holy Land, but they seem more interested in ‘bridge-building’ than protesting about the evisceration of the ancient Churches.”

Thompson’s piece is similar to the one published by Leo McKinstry in December when he also attempted to blame Islam for the persecution of Christians in places such as Iraq and argued that religious leaders had not done enough to challenge “Islam’s culture of persecution.”

Then, as now, Christian leaders did highlight the persecution of Christian minorities in these countries but refrained from blaming the door at the foot of Islam. It is difficult for someone to argue that Islam compels Muslims to persecute Christians when we witness reports of acts such as those in Egypt, where Muslims “turned up in droves” for the Coptic Christmas mass to protect Christians from violence – unless of course, they have an anti-Islamic agenda which they wish to peddle at any available opportunity.

As for Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), who one can only assume is the one referred to by Thompson when he says ‘the founder of Islam’, he instigated many treaties during his lifetime for the purpose of protecting Christian communities. See here for an example of the treaties. That would hardly be the actions of someone whose vision was to extinguish Christians.

Perhaps Thompson did not know of this and is in need for a history lesson. Any takers?

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Justice for Caylee?

What I know for sure about the Casey Anthony verdict
by Ginger Kolbaba

“This just in . . . murder is legal in Florida.”

Those words popped up on my Facebook page from a friend. She, of course, is responding to the Casey Anthony verdict of not guilty.

I’ve been following the trial off and on over the course of its six week run. So I was interested to hear the jury's decision. Would Casey Anthony be found guilty or not guilty of murdering her two-year-old daughter, Caylee?

With the verdict of not guilty, I find myself wondering now, Is Casey really innocent? Or is she just not guilty? And I really don’t know.

But this is what I do know. As I watched the live stream from my computer, I realized how grateful I am that there’s something more than this trial and this verdict.

I am grateful that God is real.

Why?

Because as a Christian, I know that one day the truth will come out and justice will happen. We have that guarantee. God will make all things right.

If Caylee's death was genuinely an accident, which was covered up by a poorly judged choice that snowballed out of control, God will make things right. If Caylee's death was an intentional murder by Casey or by someone else, God will make things right.

I believe these things with my entire being. But I think about the people who don’t believe in God who have been following this case. If they believe that Caylee was murdered, they probably now believe that Caylee’s murderer will never be brought to justice. Because to them, justice happens here on earth. There is no one, outside of the courtroom, who can avenge the wrongs of others.


If Caylee's death was an accident, I mourn for a mother who made poor choices, but who will live with those choices. I grieve for a woman who is far from a God who loves her, who desperately needs a Savior to grasp her out of a dysfunctional, lost, hopeless life.

If Caylee's death was a murder, I still mourn for a mother who made poor choices, and who will live with those choices. I still grieve for a woman who is far from a God who loves her, and who desperately needs a Savior to grasp her out of a dysfunctional, lost, hopeless life.

And ultimately, as a follower of Christ, I know that Caylee’s death will not be in vain. Though finding the truth is now a dim prospect, and soon the media’s attention and cameras will move on to other newsworthy events, there is One who will not forget. The ultimate loving Father, the Judge and Jury, the One who knows all and sees the truth and the hearts of everyone involved, will not allow Caylee’s untimely death to be forgotten or lost.

At the right time, and in his perfect way, God will honor Caylee’s short life. And this is true not only for Caylee, but for all those who have been hurt or neglected by another, for all those who have died too soon.

We want answers now. We want to see justice accomplished, to know that the perpetrator “got what was coming.”

But truth and justice know no bounds, limitations, or timelines. And although answers may not happen when we want them—they may not even happen on this side of eternity—we can know that they will come. The innocent will not be forgotten.

And for that, no matter what the verdict, I am grateful that God will make things right.

What do you think about the trial’s verdict? What do you think about the true justice that God gives?

Ginger Kolbaba







COURTESY OF:

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Same-Sex Marriage: What Can I Say? -2-


Four pastors discuss the pressures and opportunities of the current controversy. (2004)
Forum: Phil Busbee, Tony Campolo, Cheryl Sanders, and John Yates

On May 17, the day that same-sex marriage became legal in the state of Massachusetts, Leadership gathered four pastors to discuss the implications.

Phil Busbee is pastor of First Baptist Church of San Francisco, California.
Tony Campolo is a preacher at Mount Carmel Baptist Church in Philadelphia and a sociologist who has taught at Eastern College and the University of Pennsylvania.
Cheryl Sanders pastors Third Street Church of God and teaches ethics at Howard University in Washington, D.C.

John Yates is rector of Falls Church (Episcopal) in Falls Church, Virginia.

I didn't have a snappy answer for him. If we attack gay marriage and don't address the bigger threats to marriage, it does look like we're a bit homophobic.
Sanders: The Bible warns us against those who are proud of being right, even when they claim Scripture as their authority. Jesus rejects that self-justifying, judgmental attitude.
Based on history, the African-American perspective would suggest that white evangelicals are not to be readily trusted on biblical interpretation. It goes back to what they said about slavery. That's why black people didn't get too excited about debates over inerrancy and the authority of Scripture, because you look at the behavior of the people carrying on the conversation. Are they using the Bible to justify themselves?
I'm learning from Jesus that it's more important to be righteous than to be right. Our attitudes and actions speak louder than any position we articulate.
The Bible's always talking about reversal. That's Mary's Song. God has taken the high and mighty and cast them down. The lowly he elevates. That's the perspective I bring to this issue. You can't be too heavy-handed. There has to be an openness that says "whosoever will, let them come."
At the same time, we have to have some sense of righteousness and unrighteousness that we articulate in a fair way. It doesn't just condemn people based on some categorization or prejudice that comes from the fact that I have power and you don't.
If a same-sex couple comes to you and says, "Would you perform a ceremony to bless our relationship?" what would be your response?
Sanders: I would say, "I have no basis either in my faith tradition or in my understanding and application of Scripture to bless a same-sex union. So I can't do that."
Campolo: I agree. The church has been around for 2,000 years, and like Wesley, I think one has to consider church tradition. And the church has unanimously, for 2,000 years, rejected same-sex marriage. I'm surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, and I'm not arrogant enough to call them all wrong.
The church has unanimously, for 2,000 years, rejected same-sex marriage. I'm not arrogant enough to call them wrong. —Tony Campolo
Having made a High Church comment, let me also say that, as a Baptist, I think this question should be determined by each local congregation.
What if same-sex marriage becomes the law of the land? Would you be obligated to perform the ceremony?
Busbee: No, even now I sometimes tell heterosexual couples I won't marry them. Not only am I conservative in the area of divorce and remarriage, but for many other reasons I may feel that a couple should not marry, and I'll say so.

So from the standpoint of Jesus' teaching in Matthew 19 about what marriage is, I would have to say to a same-sex couple, "I don't believe that you qualify to be married."
Yates: I too have had to say no to heterosexual couples who considered it fine to be living together and now want to be married. My heart says, "I want you to be married," but my head says, "Until you can ask God to forgive what you've done up to this point, I don't think I can take the further step in blessing your marriage."
Campolo: I think we need to follow the European model, where there are two ceremonies. A couple goes to the courthouse for the civil union, and then if they're Christian they go to the church for the marriage. They are two separate things. The church blesses Christian marriages and the government establishes civil unions.
Our word marriage has become an umbrella term for both holy matrimony and the civil partnership, with its attendant rights of inheritance, insurance coverage, and so forth.
Campolo: And that's a problem. When I perform a ceremony, you know what I have to say? "By the authority committed unto me, by the state of Pennsylvania, I hereby declare you man and wife." Wait a minute! Where did my authority come from? I thought it came from the church, from God. All of a sudden I have shifted from being a representative of the Kingdom of God to being a representative of an earthly state. What does that mean for me if the state changes the definition of marriage?
How can you be pastoral amid the heated political situation?
Campolo: It's become heated because extremists at both ends have manipulated us into this intense debate. That's not just my opinion. The editors of Advocate, the gay magazine that is legitimately trying to deal with issues, wrote a book called Perfect Enemies. They described how the religious right and groups at the other extreme like Queer Nation need each other and feed off each other. Both sides use similar tactics—any time either side needs to raise money, it quotes a hostile statement from the other side. This turns up the heat, generating fear, distrust, anger.
Eric Hoffer said it well in his book The True Believer: "A movement can exist without a god. Many have—Nazism, Communism. But no movement can exist without a devil." The extreme left has made the religious right the devil, and the religious right has made the gay community the devil. That makes it tough for those of us in the middle trying to express the love of Christ in a way that makes sense.
Yates: I really resonate with that. We have men in our church who are desperately trying to deal with sexual addiction—heterosexual, homosexual, whatever. Their group is called SALT (Sexual Addicts Learning Trust). They're learning to trust Jesus. It's a highly confidential group. We don't go around condemning them. We're trying to encourage them and figure out what God is calling them to, and how to deal with these addictive attitudes.
But while in my heart I feel I have a moderate spirit, as soon as I preach any message, based on the authority of Scripture, that explains that God has called us to either celibacy or heterosexual marriage, then I am branded as a homophobe and our church is labeled, by elements of the homosexual community, as "a hostile church." It's happened over and over again. I've sort of accepted it as inevitable.
Campolo: One way to get out of that box is by championing calls for justice on behalf of gay and lesbian people. When the church stands up and says, "Landlords have the right to discriminate against you with housing," then it's pretty hard to say convincingly, "But we love you in the name of Jesus."
It's important for the church to stand up for civil rights for our gay and lesbian friends on legitimate concerns of discrimination; so that they see us as their friend. A pastor can say, "I don't have to buy into homosexual eroticism to recognize that discrimination is wrong, and I'm going to stand with you on this matter."
Would you baptize someone who was still in a homosexual relationship?
Busbee: We've really struggled with that. I just baptized a man who at this point does not know enough of Scripture to be convinced he needs to stop practicing homosexuality. But he has indicated a willingness to follow Jesus as Lord and obey his commands as they become clear. I've also baptized men in drug recovery programs who have not completely conquered their addiction.
What's necessary for baptism in such a case?
Busbee: I ask each candidate for baptism two questions: "Have you asked Christ to come into your life and forgive you of your sins?" and "Are you willing to follow Christ wherever he will lead you?" And each of them said, "Yes, absolutely."
I cannot refuse to baptize someone just because he does not yet understand everything the Scripture teaches. I believe Jesus is powerful enough that if he gets in the door he's going to make the transformation. I'm convinced that in this case God was saying to me, You're not going to stand before me and give an account of his life. You're going to give an account of your life. So let him stand before me and give an account. He said he'll follow me when I tell him what to do. He'll have to answer to me for that.
Another pastoral question. If an older couple comes to you and says, "Our son has a gay partner. Would you pray for him?" As you're sitting there with the parents, what do you pray for?
Yates: I will pray for that young man to come to know the love of God, to see his need for Jesus Christ, and that he will begin the process of turning from sin. None of us fully realizes the degree of sin in our lives. But I'd pray that his eyes are opened to the sin in his life, and that he'll be pulled toward the love of God in Jesus Christ and find new purpose in him.
don't want to focus primarily on a person's sexual behavior or even on a person's sexual temptation. What God is looking for is people who realize their need for God. When someone comes to God and says, "Help!" that's the beginning of salvation.
No matter what a person's sin is, we don't start by trying to fix the sin but with the gospel. We're all in need of a Savior, whether I'm homosexual or heterosexual. And Jesus is looking for our recognition of that.
Busbee: A couple years ago, a man began attending our church, and for three months he just worshiped. He never talked to anyone and kept to himself.
Then suddenly he showed up at a different small group every night of the week, and in each group he told his story of sexual addiction and drug addiction and homosexuality. We have about 30 groups, and he hit seven of them in a row just to see what would happen.
Later he testified that he anticipated negative reaction from every group, but instead, every group just surrounded him and prayed for him and loved him. By the end of the week he was so loved, he was blown away. That transformed him.
As a pastor, I don't want to be known for my stand on "the issue." I want to help a person meet Jesus and grow into mature faith. That guy needed tremendous healing. He still does. And it goes beyond his sexual activity, though that's part of it. There was a deep wound in his life that only God can heal, and he just needed a healthy context to be healed in. We loved him and accepted him. There's great power in that.


Copyright © 2004 by the author or Christianity Today International/Leadership Journal.
Click here for reprint information onLeadership Journal.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Same-Sex Marriage: What Can I Say?


Four pastors discuss the pressures and opportunities of the current controversy. (2004)
Forum: Phil Busbee, Tony Campolo, Cheryl Sanders, and John Yates

On May 17, the day that same-sex marriage became legal in the state of Massachusetts, Leadership gathered four pastors to discuss the implications.

Phil Busbee is pastor of First Baptist Church of San Francisco, California.
Tony Campolo is a preacher at Mount Carmel Baptist Church in Philadelphia and a sociologist who has taught at Eastern College and the University of Pennsylvania.
Cheryl Sanders pastors Third Street Church of God and teaches ethics at Howard University in Washington, D.C.

John Yates is rector of Falls Church (Episcopal) in Falls Church, Virginia.
The prospect of same-sex marriages raises both pastoral and political issues. What's the most important thing you want to say, pastorally, to a homosexual couple?
Busbee: Our church is located in San Francisco in an area known as "the gateway to the gay community." We feel that God gave us that location for a reason. We're there to be good neighbors, to interact with individuals not movements, and to live out the gospel and invite people to follow Jesus.
Campolo: I speak on about 20 college campuses each year, and no matter what topic I talk on—it could be "Einstein's theory of relativity and the Christian faith"— when I conclude with "Any questions?" one is inevitably "What about homosexual marriage?" You can't avoid it.

There's great antagonism toward the church because it's seen as an oppressive, homophobic institution. I love the church, but it's important to admit that at times the church has been homophobic, unjust, and downright mean.

After that, then we can help them understand where the church is coming from on this issue.
Sanders: It's important to articulate what marriage is and isn't today. Recently in a group discussion I said, "If you took a poll around this table about what century we're in, we would get different answers." If we're all in the twenty-first century, what is the role and purpose of marriage today?

In our congregation, the typical adult is not married. Now they're not necessarily homosexual; some are divorced, widowed, or never married. I believe, based on Scripture and the century that we're in, that marriage is between one man and one woman, but how you speak about marriage is important.

Busbee: That's crucial. Our current practice of marriage is deficient. So many of the Christian man-woman marriages don't seem exemplary. If we're going to have any kind of moral authority to speak out on the issue of marriage, it has to come out of the reality of our lives, not simply out of our doctrine.

Yates: I got concerned about this back in the Sixties, when I saw how dysfunctional so many families were. That led my wife and me into a lifetime commitment to build Christian marriages. A major emphasis of our church is building Christ-centered family life. When Christian marriage isn't doing any better than non-Christian marriage in our culture, we need to help people gain a fresh vision for God's purpose for marriage.

So the biblical model of marriage is one man, one woman, one lifetime?
Campolo: A "biblical model" is harder to establish than you think. A colleague of mine has identified, I think, 16 models of marriage in the Hebrew Bible, including polygamy, concubinage, handmaidens, levirate arrangements, purchasing of wives, and spouses that accompany political alliances. It's so pious to say "the biblical model of marriage." Which of those forms of marriage do you mean?

I do think in the New Testament it gets clearer.

Yates: I believe Genesis 2 gives us the foundation—a man and woman leaving, cleaving, and becoming one flesh—and then I jump to Mark 10 and Jesus' understanding of the permanence of that relationship.

Campolo: Speaking of Mark 10, what do you do with divorced people who remarry? Do you accept them in your church? I mean, while Jesus never speaks about gay marriage, he speaks very clearly about those who remarry after a divorce. I don't know many churches that enforce a no-remarriage rule.

Has the church said, "We have to be faithful to Scripture about marriage, except on the issue of divorce and remarriage"? Or do we extend grace? Because if we're going to show grace toward people who are divorced and remarried, an area Jesus specifically called sin, then how do you not show grace to people in a sexual relationship that Jesus never mentions?

Yes, Paul addresses it. But the fact that Jesus doesn't is important, because it's apparently not on his top ten list of sins.

Yates: I think you're conflating two very different things. Remarriage after divorce, for me, has been more of a painful pastoral issue than homosexual marriage. It has been for thirty years, because we're always confronted with it. What does the Scripture teach about it? It suggests that reasons for divorce extend from Moses and the allowance for hardness of heart, to Jesus for reason of immorality, and to Paul who mentions desertion.

Should homosexuality be treated by the church differently than heterosexuality?
Busbee: I want to say about as much about that issue as the Bible does. And about as often as it comes up in the Scripture. Communicating redemption and God's mercy, regardless of the situation, is more critical. I mean, homosexual offenses are listed in 1 Corinthians 6 alongside all kinds of other immoral behaviors that we've managed to deal with, by the grace of God—the greedy, drunkards, slanderers, swindlers …
Attitudes speak louder than any position we articulate. There has to be an openness that says, "Whosoever will, let them come." —Cheryl Sanders

Sanders: I explained to my church that "we're not going to do any kind of hunt to discover who is homosexual and who is not, because it's not fair to subject homosexuals to certain scrutiny that heterosexuals are not subjected to."
At least in the African-American community, I'm much more concerned about heterosexuals who have decided that marriage isn't important. In our city, 70 percent of children are born out of wedlock. It's now the norm!
If you minister in that setting, you're going to be surrounded by people not living the biblical ideal. I don't affirm that, but I don't have to condemn them.
Now the difference is, if a man and woman who are living together come and say, "We want to join this church," I will say to them, "In our church we believe that if you're living together in a committed relationship, you need to be married."
Well, they may need to rectify some things—like finalizing the divorce from the previous marriage. But we believe marriage is better than just living together. Their relationship can be acknowledged by the church; they can get married.
What do you do when a homosexual couple wants to join the church?
Sanders: There's nothing I can do to endorse their relationship. But in no case do I reject people or ask them to leave on the basis of their sexual orientation.
We do outreach ministry. We open our doors to the poor every day. Among them are transgendered, cross-dressing, and homosexual individuals—all kinds of people who come in, and we welcome them even if we don't affirm everything they do.
Do you welcome practicing homosexuals into membership?
Sanders: We don't emphasize "membership" in the Church of God.
Campolo: I like that, because I think church "membership" is a false definition of reality. In our society two-thirds of the people who claim church membership never go. So what does membership mean? And yet we have somehow said, "I love gay people; I just don't want any in the membership of the church." Maybe the time has come to do away with "church membership" and just say whosoever will may come into the congregation and be a part of the growing ministry and fellowship.
Yates: I've always said the only requirement for membership in our church is to acknowledge yourself as a sinner in need of God's grace in Jesus Christ. And that just cuts across everything.
Is it right for same-sex couples to marry?
Campolo: The late Lewis Smedes raised what I think is the center of this issue. My loose paraphrase of his argument is this: "God's original intent for creation has been marred by the Fall. In the context of fallenness, we look for the best alternative."
I don't want to be known for my stand on "the issue." I want to help a person meet Jesus and grow into mature faith. —Phil Busbee
Smedes holds up his own marriage as an example. "The design of marriage in Genesis is not only one man and one woman, but progeny—having children." Smedes and his wife didn't have any children. So they adopted. They were making the best of a less-than-ideal situation.
My wife (who doesn't happen to agree with me on this issue) would argue that in light of the fallenness of creation, and in light of certain people having a homosexual orientation, that gay marriage is a viable alternative. She would say that marriage is better than living together without marriage, and it's certainly better than promiscuity.
Busbee: I'm not convinced that the majority of the homosexual community wants to get married. Not long ago in San Francisco, when the civil union law was passed, only 3 percent of the gay population took advantage of it.

Campolo: Opposing gay marriages does put Christians in an uncomfortable situation. A gay man told me recently, "We can't please you evangelicals, Campolo. First, you condemned us for our promiscuous lifestyle. Now that we want to settle down and be married, you're all upset. You claim we're a threat to marriage. We're not a threat to marriage. Some of us want to get married, want committed relationships. The threat to marriage is divorce, the desertion situation, and the number of children being born outside of marriage."

Copyright © 2004 by the author or Christianity Today International/Leadership Journal.
Click here for reprint information onLeadership Journal.