The death of our spiritual brother had a profound impact on many in our fellowship. The ‘born-again’, uniformed, Salvationist was in his late 20s, and was always the 1st on his feet to witness to the change in his life.
His death and the diagnosis of life threatening illnesses raised questions of mortality, life after death, suffering, spirituality, and religion. These issues took on greater importance because of the stigmatization and judgment that accompany HIV/AIDS. I led a discussion with a focus on our 'spiritual dilemma' challenging all to explore and answer those questions that give purpose and meaning to our lives; what is my role and purpose in this world?
The reality of AIDS in our midst raised questions of sexual orientation and the stigma attached both to ‘fags’ and AIDS and why some faiths denounce homosexuality as sinful (this was in 1991-92). Stories of a ‘creepy’ uncle were told, and I shared from my own children’s experience about the ‘nasty’ Star Lake counselor who showed the boys in his cabin how to ‘stimulate and pleasure oneself’. Then there was my kid’s equestrian teacher who liked to have the young girls model their riding breeches privately in his office. And there was the swimming coach in our local Junior high school who was arrested for indecent exposure.
The group agreed that ‘we all have a nasty Lester type person in our private past’, however, most accepted that deviant persons and behavior were not normal for any person regardless of their sexual orientation. And we agreed too that homosexuality as an inherent part of the person, but believed that homosexuals, as with heterosexuals, ought not act on their orientation except in committed relationships. Our discussions were rooted in ethics, cultural and societal, this at the time, when in the latter part of the twentieth century when churches began to move their emphasis away from discussing ‘distasteful, evil, sinful’ homosexual acts to the more Christian response of love and inclusivity, no matter how naïve and cloudy “our” understanding was. For our corps and me there was no turning back.
Less than 10 years later when stationed in Moscow, Russia, I initiated a mighty row with the Burroughs Wellcome Ltd Corp, a subsidiary of Wellcome, a British drug manufacturer of AZT, the prevailing drug to thwart AIDS devastating effect during those years. I had learned that Wellcome was ‘dumping’ outdated medicines to the 218 AIDS sufferers, all toddlers, and their families I represented in Volgograd. There was clear evidence that some of Russia’s top health officials, those responsible to approve the government’s purchase, were on the ‘take’, a standard operating procedure in many companies and government ministries.
My threat to expose their greedy efforts to the BBC and London Times correspondents in Moscow, both good friends of mine, brought about a quick turn-around and apology. The tragedy of that AIDS epidemic may be shared in a later article.
Our open discussion groups examined other ‘important’ issues; The Church's teaching about the immorality of violence, prejudice, discrimination, unequal distribution of wealth and resources, etc. We also spoke of American corporate greed and global efforts to dominate capitalistic expansion. Pejorative words to label companies that act only out of self-interest were thrown about: self-indulgence, self-satisfaction, self-righteous, self-rationalization, self-delusion, self-serving, and more. Positive words lacking in their makeup include self-control, self-discipline, and self-correcting. We agreed that the words can be exchanged with ease between individuals and organizations…
But what about the Salvation Army? Could we be called self-righteous, self-rationalizing, self-delusional, self-serving etc.?
TSA in both the southern and northern hemisphere issued official press releases in haste to demonstrate our position in favor of, or our stance against political ‘takes’ on various equal rights for homosexuals and same sex partnerships only to rush out new releases where we made complete red faced turn-arounds due public and/ or political pressure. Salvationist leaders, who apparently new little of the issues being debated were caught off-guard and we found ourselves embarrassed by the organization to whom we were so loyally bound. The SA in the USA appeared to have constitutional amendments in the works, in collusion with Washington, D.C. and perhaps since they were working at such high levels is why it was a non-concern for us and remained so.
And as shared in an earlier article, I wonder if we, as a youngish member of the family of churches, have too willingly taken the role of observer, letting our older and ‘wiser’ brothers voice their authoritative interpretations first and we simply add our Amen?
BITS AND PIECES
The SA flip flops in the USA
Political Controversy
However, during the last decades of the twentieth century, the Salvation Army placed itself in the midst of controversy, taking a firmly right wing stand as part of the conservative Christian movement. It campaigned against sodomy law reform in various parts of the world, including especially Australia, and opposed the glbtq movement for equality in the United States and Great Britain.
Since the 1970s, the Army has moved away from street evangelizing to become more of a general service provider and has received millions of dollars in government grants. In 1998, the Salvation Army turned down a $3.5 million contract with the City of San Francisco because the city requires organizations it contracts with to offer domestic partner benefits to queer workers.
As a Christian church, the Army refused to offer benefits to gay or unmarried straight workers. In October of 2001, the Western Territory of the U.S. Salvation Army did sign a government contract in which they agreed to provide domestic partner benefits, but after protests from anti-gay Christians, they rescinded the decision just a month later.
The Secret Deal with the Bush Administration
Perhaps the most shocking controversy of the early twenty-first-century Salvation Army revolved around an internal Salvation Army memo, which was made public by The Washington Post in July 2001. The memo exposed a secret deal between the Army and the office of President George W. Bush.
The Salvation Army promised support for the president's so-called "faith-based initiative," a proposed policy to grant hundreds of millions of tax dollars and billions in tax breaks to religious groups providing social services. In return, the administration would support legislation allowing the Army and other Christian groups legally to discriminate against gay men, lesbians, and other sexual minorities.
Although the White House and the Salvation Army quickly backed away from the notion of a secret quid pro quo, many people were scandalized by the cynical deal-making. In a protest led by the gay support group Parents, Friends and Families of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG), many communities showed their disapproval by placing fake "three-dollar bills" in Salvation Army kettles during the Christmas season of 2001, stating that they refused to donate to a bigoted organization.
Meanwhile, efforts by the Bush administration to grant waivers from anti-discrimination laws to participants in its faith-based initiatives continues.
And our ‘stance to non-stance to stance’ brought this from New Zealand…
It is likely that many initially supported the petition and/or the submission, but later changed their mind when they saw the strength of the opposition to the Army’s stance or began to think through some of the complex arguments involved in this issue.
…
It is probable therefore that many Salvationists had difficulty discerning the Army’s position in all this from media representations. It is possible that few would have read or understood the Army’s submission. The Salvation Army’s own good reputation in society may have made it a target in this issue. The Editor of the Catholic magazine The Table, having roundly praised the generosity and compassion of The Salvation Army said “that’s why it [the Army] has to be attacked and besmirched by those who want sodomy to become an acceptable practice in our society" (Kennedy 1985:1). In such a heated cauldron of emotion it is understandable that opponents to the Army’s position would wish to denigrate the Army in an attempt to discredit its cause.
One positive aspect the involvement in this issue did was that it got Salvationists involved in discussing a particular issue that was a real part of life and not some ethereal spiritual concept.
-----------------
Thank you for inviting The Salvation Army to comment on the 20th anniversary of the passing of the Homosexual Law Reform Act. We are grateful for this opportunity, as we are conscious that because of actions taken by The Salvation Army at that time there is still a need to rebuild some bridges.
Our statement for publication on your TV2 series, Kiwifruit, follows:
SALVATION ARMY COMMENTS ON ANNIVERSARY OF THE HOMOSEXUAL LAW REFORM BILL
“The Salvation Army encompasses a diverse community with a wide range of opinions on the subject of homosexuality and other issues. We continue to seek God’s wisdom on what it means to live as Biblically-informed Christians in today’s world.
We understand our official opposition to the Reform Bill was deeply hurtful to many and are distressed that ill feeling still troubles our relationship with segments of the gay community.
We regret any hurt that may remain from that turbulent time and hope to rebuild bridges of understanding between our movement and the gay community. We may not agree on all issues, but we can respect and care for one another despite this.”
Commissioner Garth McKenzie
(Territorial Commander)
This from Der Bund, a Swiss newspaper interview with General Shaw Clifton (2007)
B: What is your standpoint on homosexuality?
SC: We take our standpoint on sexuality from the Bible. According to the Bible, the right context in which to live out our sexuality is the marriage of man and woman. But we don't ask people who apply for work with us whether or not they are homosexual.
B: What happens if you know someone is homosexual?
SC: If a person's sexuality has a negative effect on their work or their clients, that would be dealt with according the local labour laws. We expect that a person's sexuality should not hinder their work.
B: Does that mean you would appoint a homosexual?
SC: Yes. There are even homosexuals amongst our clergy. But of course we expect them to lead celibate and abstemious lives.
This from the BBC
Homosexuality
The Salvation Army believes that homosexual Christians must live celibate lives, since the Bible forbids sexual intimacy between members of the same sex.
The Army does not accept same-sex unions as equal to, or as an alternative to, heterosexual marriage.
The Salvation Army opposes any discrimination against homosexuals, and accepts as members homosexuals who will abide by the principle that sexual intimacy is only acceptable within marriage.
Homosexual practices unrenounced render a person unacceptable as a Salvation Army soldier, in the same way as heterosexual acts of immorality.
Is there a turnabout in the making?
Sven Ljungholm
On the road in Latvia
FSAOF LATVIA MISSION 2011
His death and the diagnosis of life threatening illnesses raised questions of mortality, life after death, suffering, spirituality, and religion. These issues took on greater importance because of the stigmatization and judgment that accompany HIV/AIDS. I led a discussion with a focus on our 'spiritual dilemma' challenging all to explore and answer those questions that give purpose and meaning to our lives; what is my role and purpose in this world?
The reality of AIDS in our midst raised questions of sexual orientation and the stigma attached both to ‘fags’ and AIDS and why some faiths denounce homosexuality as sinful (this was in 1991-92). Stories of a ‘creepy’ uncle were told, and I shared from my own children’s experience about the ‘nasty’ Star Lake counselor who showed the boys in his cabin how to ‘stimulate and pleasure oneself’. Then there was my kid’s equestrian teacher who liked to have the young girls model their riding breeches privately in his office. And there was the swimming coach in our local Junior high school who was arrested for indecent exposure.
The group agreed that ‘we all have a nasty Lester type person in our private past’, however, most accepted that deviant persons and behavior were not normal for any person regardless of their sexual orientation. And we agreed too that homosexuality as an inherent part of the person, but believed that homosexuals, as with heterosexuals, ought not act on their orientation except in committed relationships. Our discussions were rooted in ethics, cultural and societal, this at the time, when in the latter part of the twentieth century when churches began to move their emphasis away from discussing ‘distasteful, evil, sinful’ homosexual acts to the more Christian response of love and inclusivity, no matter how naïve and cloudy “our” understanding was. For our corps and me there was no turning back.
Less than 10 years later when stationed in Moscow, Russia, I initiated a mighty row with the Burroughs Wellcome Ltd Corp, a subsidiary of Wellcome, a British drug manufacturer of AZT, the prevailing drug to thwart AIDS devastating effect during those years. I had learned that Wellcome was ‘dumping’ outdated medicines to the 218 AIDS sufferers, all toddlers, and their families I represented in Volgograd. There was clear evidence that some of Russia’s top health officials, those responsible to approve the government’s purchase, were on the ‘take’, a standard operating procedure in many companies and government ministries.
My threat to expose their greedy efforts to the BBC and London Times correspondents in Moscow, both good friends of mine, brought about a quick turn-around and apology. The tragedy of that AIDS epidemic may be shared in a later article.
Our open discussion groups examined other ‘important’ issues; The Church's teaching about the immorality of violence, prejudice, discrimination, unequal distribution of wealth and resources, etc. We also spoke of American corporate greed and global efforts to dominate capitalistic expansion. Pejorative words to label companies that act only out of self-interest were thrown about: self-indulgence, self-satisfaction, self-righteous, self-rationalization, self-delusion, self-serving, and more. Positive words lacking in their makeup include self-control, self-discipline, and self-correcting. We agreed that the words can be exchanged with ease between individuals and organizations…
But what about the Salvation Army? Could we be called self-righteous, self-rationalizing, self-delusional, self-serving etc.?
TSA in both the southern and northern hemisphere issued official press releases in haste to demonstrate our position in favor of, or our stance against political ‘takes’ on various equal rights for homosexuals and same sex partnerships only to rush out new releases where we made complete red faced turn-arounds due public and/ or political pressure. Salvationist leaders, who apparently new little of the issues being debated were caught off-guard and we found ourselves embarrassed by the organization to whom we were so loyally bound. The SA in the USA appeared to have constitutional amendments in the works, in collusion with Washington, D.C. and perhaps since they were working at such high levels is why it was a non-concern for us and remained so.
And as shared in an earlier article, I wonder if we, as a youngish member of the family of churches, have too willingly taken the role of observer, letting our older and ‘wiser’ brothers voice their authoritative interpretations first and we simply add our Amen?
BITS AND PIECES
The SA flip flops in the USA
Political Controversy
However, during the last decades of the twentieth century, the Salvation Army placed itself in the midst of controversy, taking a firmly right wing stand as part of the conservative Christian movement. It campaigned against sodomy law reform in various parts of the world, including especially Australia, and opposed the glbtq movement for equality in the United States and Great Britain.
Since the 1970s, the Army has moved away from street evangelizing to become more of a general service provider and has received millions of dollars in government grants. In 1998, the Salvation Army turned down a $3.5 million contract with the City of San Francisco because the city requires organizations it contracts with to offer domestic partner benefits to queer workers.
As a Christian church, the Army refused to offer benefits to gay or unmarried straight workers. In October of 2001, the Western Territory of the U.S. Salvation Army did sign a government contract in which they agreed to provide domestic partner benefits, but after protests from anti-gay Christians, they rescinded the decision just a month later.
The Secret Deal with the Bush Administration
Perhaps the most shocking controversy of the early twenty-first-century Salvation Army revolved around an internal Salvation Army memo, which was made public by The Washington Post in July 2001. The memo exposed a secret deal between the Army and the office of President George W. Bush.
The Salvation Army promised support for the president's so-called "faith-based initiative," a proposed policy to grant hundreds of millions of tax dollars and billions in tax breaks to religious groups providing social services. In return, the administration would support legislation allowing the Army and other Christian groups legally to discriminate against gay men, lesbians, and other sexual minorities.
Although the White House and the Salvation Army quickly backed away from the notion of a secret quid pro quo, many people were scandalized by the cynical deal-making. In a protest led by the gay support group Parents, Friends and Families of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG), many communities showed their disapproval by placing fake "three-dollar bills" in Salvation Army kettles during the Christmas season of 2001, stating that they refused to donate to a bigoted organization.
Meanwhile, efforts by the Bush administration to grant waivers from anti-discrimination laws to participants in its faith-based initiatives continues.
And our ‘stance to non-stance to stance’ brought this from New Zealand…
It is likely that many initially supported the petition and/or the submission, but later changed their mind when they saw the strength of the opposition to the Army’s stance or began to think through some of the complex arguments involved in this issue.
…
It is probable therefore that many Salvationists had difficulty discerning the Army’s position in all this from media representations. It is possible that few would have read or understood the Army’s submission. The Salvation Army’s own good reputation in society may have made it a target in this issue. The Editor of the Catholic magazine The Table, having roundly praised the generosity and compassion of The Salvation Army said “that’s why it [the Army] has to be attacked and besmirched by those who want sodomy to become an acceptable practice in our society" (Kennedy 1985:1). In such a heated cauldron of emotion it is understandable that opponents to the Army’s position would wish to denigrate the Army in an attempt to discredit its cause.
One positive aspect the involvement in this issue did was that it got Salvationists involved in discussing a particular issue that was a real part of life and not some ethereal spiritual concept.
-----------------
Thank you for inviting The Salvation Army to comment on the 20th anniversary of the passing of the Homosexual Law Reform Act. We are grateful for this opportunity, as we are conscious that because of actions taken by The Salvation Army at that time there is still a need to rebuild some bridges.
Our statement for publication on your TV2 series, Kiwifruit, follows:
SALVATION ARMY COMMENTS ON ANNIVERSARY OF THE HOMOSEXUAL LAW REFORM BILL
“The Salvation Army encompasses a diverse community with a wide range of opinions on the subject of homosexuality and other issues. We continue to seek God’s wisdom on what it means to live as Biblically-informed Christians in today’s world.
We understand our official opposition to the Reform Bill was deeply hurtful to many and are distressed that ill feeling still troubles our relationship with segments of the gay community.
We regret any hurt that may remain from that turbulent time and hope to rebuild bridges of understanding between our movement and the gay community. We may not agree on all issues, but we can respect and care for one another despite this.”
Commissioner Garth McKenzie
(Territorial Commander)
This from Der Bund, a Swiss newspaper interview with General Shaw Clifton (2007)
B: What is your standpoint on homosexuality?
SC: We take our standpoint on sexuality from the Bible. According to the Bible, the right context in which to live out our sexuality is the marriage of man and woman. But we don't ask people who apply for work with us whether or not they are homosexual.
B: What happens if you know someone is homosexual?
SC: If a person's sexuality has a negative effect on their work or their clients, that would be dealt with according the local labour laws. We expect that a person's sexuality should not hinder their work.
B: Does that mean you would appoint a homosexual?
SC: Yes. There are even homosexuals amongst our clergy. But of course we expect them to lead celibate and abstemious lives.
This from the BBC
Homosexuality
The Salvation Army believes that homosexual Christians must live celibate lives, since the Bible forbids sexual intimacy between members of the same sex.
The Army does not accept same-sex unions as equal to, or as an alternative to, heterosexual marriage.
The Salvation Army opposes any discrimination against homosexuals, and accepts as members homosexuals who will abide by the principle that sexual intimacy is only acceptable within marriage.
Homosexual practices unrenounced render a person unacceptable as a Salvation Army soldier, in the same way as heterosexual acts of immorality.
Is there a turnabout in the making?
Sven Ljungholm
On the road in Latvia
FSAOF LATVIA MISSION 2011



















