Thursday, April 21, 2011

RECONCILATION; THE WORLD'S MOST BEAUTIFUL WORD IN ANY LANGIAGE



FROM THE WAR CRY

Moscow Central Corps Pulpit Cloth

Central to The Salvation Army's crest is the Cross of Christ. It is the symbol of God's conciliatory act, offering His grace and glory to His wayward children.

Reconciliation has been called the most beautiful word in any language. The Greek verb "katalasso" (reconciliation) does not come from the language of worship or law but rather from that of diplomacy and social relationships. In the ordinary Christian life it is often up to us to initiate and seek reconciliation. However, the Easter story is one in which the initiative was purely God’s. It's not we who reconcile ourselves with God but God who reconciles the world to Himself. Thus reconciliation is a one-sided act of peace from God to His estranged creation; God alone is the agent of reconciliation.

In our individual preparation for Easter, and as we take this time to journey through Lent, I want to take you to Moscow, in the spring of 1992. It is Easter Sunday morning and we conducted our service in a rented thousand seat auditorium; our “hall” for the last several months. It was the first Easter service conducted in a Moscow, Russia Salvation Army hall in 70 years, the last one having been celebrated by my grandfather, Adjutant Otto Ljungholm.

Near the front of the hall, in the shadow of a twelve-foot cross sat a girl of twelve or thirteen. By this time she had been coming to the corps regularly along with others from a nearby orphanage. As I brought the Easter message I was gripped by what seemed like secretive, searching glances of this young girl. Her eyes darted from the cross, to me and then to a poorly dressed woman seated some distance away.

As the invitation was given to ‘come to Christ and be reconciled with your loving Heavenly Father’ the young girl stepped forward, with scores of others into the aisle and moved slowly towards the crudely constructed cross. At the same moment, the shabbily dressed woman also stood up and with determined strides approached the many already standing and kneeling at the foot of the cross. Both the woman and child moved through the crowd and, paused for a moment, just inches apart, and somewhat awkwardly, faced each other and exchanged words.

As others continued to respond to God’s invitation these two strangers, continued their private dialogue, becoming more and more animated. Then it happened! As a thousand people watched, the woman wrapped her arms around the young girl and then lifted her up, there, right in front of the cross!! In that moment, the two were reconciled under the cross of Christ…

I later learned that the woman was a loving mother who had been unable to provide proper care for her three-year old child and had been forced to give her up to the care of others. Now, some ten years later, they stood under the cross of Christ at a Salvation Army hall in Moscow, holding each other and vowing never to separate again.

After the service, the teenage girl said to me, with tears streaming down her face: ‘A stranger hugged me, but it was my Mother.’ This is the central message of the cross. A loving parent, God, calls to us, His estranged children to come. At the cross of Christ our relationship with God is restored.

A loving stranger with nail-pierced hands, scars on His back and brow, longs to embrace us today. Pierced for our transgressions, He wants to draw you and me to His cross. A loving stranger who escaped from death’s dungeon, wants to walk with you and me into eternity.

This Easter, may we come to the cross afresh and know what it is to be truly reconciled to our Father God. May we allow God to make Calvary very real to us again and may we see victory in Christ for each one of us.

Share the reconciliation story near and far, beginning at home...


Dr. Sven Ljungholm
Govan Citadel Corps
UK

Monday, April 18, 2011

God welcomes His children home...





Rev. John R. W. Stott tells a story about an imaginary poor man from the slums of Brazil who climbs 2,310 feet up the mountain to the colossal statue of Christ that towers above Rio de Janeiro—"The Christ of Corcovado."  After the difficult climb, the poor man finally reaches Jesus and says; "I have climbed up to meet you, Christ, from the filthy, confined quarters down there … to put before you, most respectfully, these considerations: there are 900,000 of us down there in the slums of that splendid city … And you … do you remain here at Corcovado surrounded by divine glory? Go down there to the favelas … Don't stay away from us; live among us and give us new faith in you and in the Father. Amen."

Stott asks, "What would Christ say in response to such an entreaty? Would he not say '[in the suffering of the cross] I did come down to live among you, and I live among you still'"?

Then Stott adds,
We have to learn to climb the hill called Calvary, and from that vantage-ground survey all life's tragedies. The cross does not solve the problem of suffering, but it supplies the essential perspective from which to look at it … . Sometimes we picture [God] lounging, perhaps dozing, in some celestial deck-chair, while the hungry millions starve to death … . It is this terrible caricature of God which the cross smashes to smithereens.

LEADERSHIP
John Stott

Sunday, April 17, 2011

ROB BELL - Summary

I have written four blog posts during my reading of Rob Bell's book "Love Wins", and here’s my final commentary.

The criticism I have levied is not directed at Rob Bell. I do not judge Rob Bell as a person. Rob Bell is indeed a very likeable person. What could possibly make Bell less sympathetic though is when he rails against (jokes) and more or less mocks Christians, those with a more traditional view. But, as I said, I do not judge the person. On the contrary, what ‘we’ did, and what everyone is obliged to do, is to test and evaluate (judge) the message.


Rob Bell's book is about heaven and hell. But the concept of heaven and hell according to Bell is not primarily about the future, but (his) heaven and hell concerns how we experience our lives here and now.
-Heaven is defined as experiences of "joy, peace and love, in this (earthly) life" (p. 59).
-Hell is defined as the "failure to trust God's story (direction) of our lives" (p.173).

In the brief section where Bell deals with an eventual hell following death, it is a time-limited (temporary) hell with an opportunity to re-select heaven. And, writes Bell, the love of God is likely to melt the hardest heart, so that all will eventually choose Jesus.

Bell has no doubt drawn inspiration for these ideas from theologian NT Wright, who is a highly respected theologian. But N.T. Wright also makes some strange utterances. He says:
"Hell is that which is ‘ongoing’ in order that people say to God, in whose image we are created:
We do not want to worship you
We do not want our lives to be shaped by you
We do not want to be transformed by the love of Jesus, He who died and was raised again for us
We do not want any of these things
We want to remain who we are and take care of ourselves "
http://youtu.be/vggzqXzEvZ0

If hell’s reality is ‘to not worship God and to simply look after yourself’, I think a great many people would first of all like to continue to live in (this) hell for eternity. I see them driving around in fancy cars, dressing in fine clothes and living their lives in the fashion of a non-stop party. If that is hell, it's surely the most attractive place for many people to be. The hell that I read about in Jesus’ teaching in the New Testament has markedly more far-reaching consequences than that.

When one takes out the compass at an orienteering event and begins to run in a slightly different direction than the correct one, not much harm is done. However, if one continues to run in totally the opposite direction one will finally end up in completely the wrong place.

It is often said that, “the problem is not the Prophet but the Prophet's disciples”. In that Bell develops N.T. Wright's theories (pronouncements) there is the risk that the alternative course (path) takes us away from where we ought to be. And what happens when in turn Bell's disciples recounts Bell's thoughts?

I believe our decisions in life have eternal consequences. I believe that Jesus was serious when He so passionately urged us to be prepared and that some will miss the celebration because they weren’t ready. I believe that Jesus means ‘eternity’, when he says ‘forever’. Who will spend eternity where is not for me to judge. It is Jesus who will judge, and I am sure that He will judge fairly (a fair trial). I believe that Jesus will judge every man in accordance with the person’s life choices offered (and made) through life. But I do not know, and I do not have to worry about how Jesus will judge.

I could be wrong, and Bell may be right, when he says that hell is essentially (duration) time limited and with the possibility of reversing one’s decision. But I won’t take that risk. I dare not preach Bell’s doctrine - what if Bell is wrong! I do not want to hear in eternity: "Well, Peter told you it was not so bad with hell and that we could choose again."

Therefore, I continue to compel people to choose Jesus here and now. Jesus has called me to continue Jesus' teaching about the consequences of our choices in life. God does not want that any peope shall be damned. He wants all people to have eternal life.
"For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have everlasting life"





Lt. Peter Baronowsky
Regional Commander
Latvia



OTHERS' CRITIQUE BELL...

Thursday, April 14, 2011

ROB BELL - PART 4


Chapter 7- "The good news is better than all that…"

In this chapter, Rob Bell repeats the parable of the prodigal son: The prodigal son’s story is in itself about misfortune and to no longer be worthy of being called 'son'.

The father's story of the prodigal son focuses on the son being precious, longed for and loved.

The story of the son who remained home-bound is about himself; he worked as a ‘slave’ his entire life without getting the least little share from his Father for it.

The father's story about the dependent son was that he was rich and always had immediate access to the father.

The prodigal son believed in his father's story above his own and was the guest of honor at the home-coming celebration.
The son who had remained at home believed in his own story (interpretation) more than the father’s, and felt himself an outsider and did not want to be present at the party.

Life is all about which story of one’s life we want to believe. Should we believe our own version of story about ourselves or do we believe in the father’s.

So far, it's a great story retold in a fantastic way. But then, this follows: This is all about heaven and hell. Heaven and hell are here on earth and it's taking place right now. The two sons were in the same home-coming celebration yet one of them experienced heaven and the other hell.

This statement is repeated several times in the chapter. "Hell is to trust in God's story of your life" (p. 170). It is we ourselves who create hell when we fail to trust God's story of our lives (sid.173).

If hell is just something that is simply here and now I think that it presents a sad and very poor perspective. The future hope of eternity is lost, and heaven and hell is all about how we choose to live our lives here on earth. What about all the songs of eternity with the God who has built previous generations of Christians? Is there no hope beyond living as good a life as possible here on earth?

What was the intent of Jesus dying on the cross? Was it because we were to believe (give more credence to) more in the father's story than on our own? We could have had sufficient faith in the father's story as well, without Jesus having had to die on the cross?

I believe that Jesus' death on the cross had a much deeper and more significant motive than to simply offer a compelling story: "For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life" (John 3:16)

Chapter 8 - "The end is here"
In the last chapter Rob Bell tells of how he, as a young boy with his parents, prayed for salvation. Bell explains the significance the event had in his life.

Then Bell shares the many Bible passages and the seriousness in ‘choosing’; in making the right choices. He tells the story of the five virgins who were not ready when the time came and missed the festivities.

Bell writes:
"Whatever they told you about the end-
the end of your life
End
end of the world -
Thus, Jesus nudges us passionately to live as if the end is near,
Now,
today. "(p. 197)

A very nice chapter, and one that I find somewhat difficult to fit into the book as a whole - but, again, a very fine chapter.

I'll be back with my final comment in the next post ....







Lt. Peter Baronowsky
Regional Commander
Latvia

PS
This is not an attempt at a scientific analysis of Rob Bell's theology. This is a blog post. Blog entries typically express the spontaneous reaction to what we encounter in life. This is my spontaneous reaction when reading Rob Bell's book


Wednesday, April 13, 2011

ROB BELL - PART 3

Chapter 6 - There are cliffs everywhere.

In this chapter Bell expounds on the episode when the Israelites were without water in the desert. When Moses struck the rock (cliff), water poured out (of the cliff). Later, in the New Testament, Paul refers to this incident: "They drank of that spiritual Rock that followed them: and that Rock was Christ" (1 Corinthians 10:4).

Bell interprets the story of the Old Testament tribe as having encountered Jesus, without knowing that it was Jesus; without even knowing that Jesus existed. The title of the chapter alludes to Jesus’ presence being found in the same way in each cliff, and everywhere else for that matter.

Bell expounds on this “Presence” as being “an energy in the world, a spark, a current with which everything is in contact. The Greeks call it the" zoe ", the mystics call the "spirit ", and Obi-Wan calls it "the power " (p. 144).

Bell continues the chain of thought that, just as the Israelites met Jesus in the rock, anyone can, even Muslims, Hindus and Buddhists can encounter Jesus, without knowing that it is Jesus; without even knowing that Jesus exists.

I doubt very much that this theory will hold up. All the spiritual energy we encounter in life and in different religions cannot, of course, be Jesus. In fact, the Bible says that evil spirits and false gods influence us. Can one worship someone / something one does not know or recognize? Is it reasonable to worship just anyone/anything at all? And if we can encounter Jesus in many different religions, was it necessary for Jesus to die on the cross? Are there different paths to the Father?

Here I want to be absolutely clear:
-Rob Bell does not say that there are multiple paths to the Father
-Rob Bell says that Jesus is the only way
-Rob Bell does not say that it doesn’t matter which religion one adheres to ...
.... But yet, is that not exactly what he’s saying ?

Rob Bell is seemingly deliberately ambiguous.

Bell has just released a video wherein he denies that he is a universalist (that all people are ‘saved’ in the end, no matter how they live their lives). Concurrently, according to many who read Rob Bell's book, they deem Bell a universalist.

Stephen Sward, who was for many years Chairman of the Swedish Evangelical Free Church, shares that he has now perused Bell's book for the third time, and confirms that Bell is a universalist.

How is it possible that so many people around the world write, subsequent to reading "Love Wins, that Bell is a universalist, while he himself denies it? Can’t they read properly? Do they not comprehend what he writes?

The reason is that Bell's style of writing expresses both ‘this’, but also ‘that’…  There are clear statements that suggest that Bell is a universalist and abstract statements that suggest that Bell is not a universalist. Bell's narrative art allows for both ‘one and the same’ but also ‘either/ or’. Yes is not a definitive yes and no is not a definitive no. It is clear that a presentation using such style creates confusion. If Bell thinks he has something important to drive home, he should endeavor to be understood. Instead it appears as if Bell purposely strives to be misunderstood. (ambiguous)

It is the same in this chapter. In reading the chapter, one can easily get the impression that the presence of Jesus is a spiritual energy. When, for example, participating in occult séances and asking for the spirits’ presence, Jesus' spirit can appear along with the other spirits without knowing that it is Jesus, or even knowing that Jesus exists. Is this what Bell wants to convey?

Or if you worship Allah or any of the Hindu gods, it may well be that suddenly you may be praying to, or worshiping Jesus, without knowing it. Even without knowing that Jesus exists. Is this what Bell means?

In intentionally remaining ambiguous Bell can afford to express whatever views he wishes without taking responsibility for those views. Then Bell can step forward; deny and distance himself from what he’s written. It is probably this that has caused such frenzy about a book that really has no clear (distinct) message.

To be continued





Lt. Peter Baronowsky
Regional Commander
Latvia

PS
This is not an attempt at a scientific analysis of Rob Bell's theology. This is a blog post. Blog entries typically express the spontaneous reaction to what we encounter in life. This is my spontaneous reaction when reading Rob Bell's book

Peter Baronowsky

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

ROB BELL - PART 2



The first part of my commentary on Rob Bell's book, "Love Wins", is available here.

And here follows the continuation.

Chapter 4

The chapter title is: "Does God get what Got wants?"

Bell begins by quoting various churches’ creeds from their websites where it reads, among other things, that the Church believes that the unsaved will be separated forever from God in hell. And Bell wonders who would be attracted by such a confession of faith and counters it with the ironic commentary on the Church's confession: "Welcome to our church."
I believe that much of the problem with Bell's theology is evident. There is a true, genuine desire to communicate the gospel so that it becomes attractive to people in a postmodern world. But in his eagerness to make the gospel understandable and attractive the language is altered, and unfortunately also the content so that it easily becomes "another gospel"  as Galatians 1 strongly warns against.
Bell does not criticize the churches that believe in an eternal separation from God for having a false theology. He’s not saying what they believe is wrong. What he attacks is that they dare to talk about what they believe in even if it may be perceived as less attractive. Would it have been smarter to hold the faith but remain silent?

The main theme of the chapter is the question, "will God get what he wants or not?"  What God wants, of course, is that all shall be saved (1 Tim 2). And Bell asks: "How big is God? Is He big enough to fulfill (meet) His objectives?" And he continues rhetorically "Will this great, mighty, glorious God fail in the end?" The answer seems to be obvious, even if it is provided mainly in the form of questions (pg. 98).

When I read this, I want to shout: "No, God does not get what He wants!". I don’t know if anyone would have liked to say it to one of the six million Jews who, following a long period of suffering were killed during World War II. Does God really get what he wants? Or the mother who slowly sees her baby starve to death because no help is found to get food for either her or her child. Does God truly get what He wants?

Bell continues his argument that the God of the Bible is certainly not powerless or helpless and that God really is not one who gives up (pg.101).

But love, Bell points out, will never force anyone. Love has freedom at its nature. Then Bell writes that after death there a "second chance" will be given to those who did not believe in God in their life time (pg.106). How much time they will have, asks Bell, and he then answers, “as long as necessary".

And then Bell summarizes his exposition; if given sufficient time God's love will in the end melt every hard heart, and every sinner will turn to God. However, since love requires freedom, no one will be forced.

Will all be saved or will some suffer eternal separation from God because of their choices? Bell said that on these issues we have no answers.

And then Bell returned to his original question: "Will God get what he wants?" And he comments that it is an important issue that should be discussed further. But Bell himself doesn’t offer any answer to the question (if he has not already done so in his previous reasoning). But there is one even more important question: "Will we get what we want?" and to which Bell answer a concrete, yes, (pg 116) we will live in the outcome of our decisions.

This chapter has proffered many at present to reason in the blogosphere and in newspapers whether Bell is a universalist or not. (Universalism is the belief that all will eventually be saved). On this question Bell answers both yes and no. And presumably, he does so deliberately.

Chapter 5

The next chapter is called "Dying to live '(Dying To Live).

And I think it's a really good chapter (or have I misunderstood what Bell meant?).

Bell speaks about different descriptions in the Bible that describes the effect of Jesus' death.
-One accused who is freed
-A relationship that is restored
-Something lost which is redeemed
-A struggle that will be settled
-A final sacrifice offered
-So no more sacrifice is necessary
-An enemy who is loved

Bell asks which of these images are correct, and answers that, to select a single image would be too "restrictive" to describe what happens on the cross (pg 129).

But it's not simply about Jesus' death. It's about what happens after death. And Jesus comes alive again. And this is the life principle. Through death to life. When we lose our life, we find it. That's what it means ‘to die is to live’.

As already said, a real good chapter.

PETER BARONOWSKY


Sunday, April 10, 2011

Rob Bell's LOVE WINS; A critique Part 1 of 4


April 2011

I’m currently reading Rob Bell's book

So, I finally picked up Rob Bell's book, "Love Wins", at the post office in Riga. It was several weeks since I ordered it on Amazon.com.

It is with a certain bit of anticipation that I start reading the book. I have read plenty about the book already. I have read the reviews, both the Swedish and international ones. The vast majority has been very critical and describe Bell's book as a clear deviation from the classical Christian faith. I'll try to read the book without any preconceived ideas, even though I have very real problems in accepting the teachings emanating from the Emerging Church movement.

Introduction

Even in the introduction I suddenly understand why so many designate the book as deviating from traditional Christian teachings. It is simply because Rob Bell distances himself from classical Christianity. He writes in the introduction that the dominant Christian teaching on the dual outcome (end), heaven and hell, is completely misleading. Bell stages a frontal attack on the doctrine of the dual-outcome and writes that this erroneous doctrine has been announced as the central truth of Christian faith (page VIII).

The only argument for this claim that I can detect are the disconnected words (contextual error) from the Bible verse: "For God so loved the world ..." (P. VII). However, if one reads the continuation of the verse, we read that ‘love’ provides the explanation that relates to the dual outcome.
"... That He gave His only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish but have eternal life" (John 3:16).

Oops, Rob Bell, it was hardly a good start to use a Bible verse on the dual outcome to argue that that very doctrine (the dual outcome) is not valid.

Chapter 1
In chapter one, he questions all traditional salvation teaching/preaching and presents many questions that in themselves can be very important to reflect on.

This chapter includes, as I said, a lot of questions but no answers. The answers are promised in the upcoming chapters. I look forward to these.

Chapter 2

Rob Bell:
The second chapter deals with heaven, eternity and the world to come. The message is that heaven, eternity and the world to come is not a different place (eternal location) and that it is not about life after death.

Heaven is a place where we find ourselves after death.       (and) Heaven is about life here on earth when it transforms (improves) into something better. Heaven is when we feel intense joy, peace and love in this life (p. 59). When Jesus speaks of heaven, he uses it often as a name for God (sid.58). Eternity is not primarily about time without end, but more about the quality of life here on earth. The eventual-coming ‘eternity’ time is not something that comes after death, but something that is created here on earth.

My comment:
There is a lot of what Rob Bell writes in this chapter that I can agree with. I believe that eternal life begins here in the present time, when we are saved and accept Jesus. But I do not believe that eternal life relates solely to circumstances improving in ‘this time’. I also agree that we should contribute to the Kingdom of God coming here on earth and that we can get a foretaste of the coming world’s power. (Hebrews 6:5).

But is this really all Jesus has to offer? That we will have it better in the present? I find nothing in Rob Bell's exposition on heaven that speaks of eternity in relation to time parameters. None of us living on this earth will do so forever. I think it's a poor world-view. What does this say to all the martyrs of the past and present day?

Is the message to them that they will have it better on the earth tomorrow? Ther’ll be nothing left in the morning!

When Jesus said to the thief on the cross that he will be with Jesus in paradise today, did Jesus mean that he would have it better here on Earth???

And if heaven only exists here on earth why should we then pray "thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven"?

Chapter 3 - Hell
Rob Bell turns to abuses of Christian preaching and starts the chapter with some demonstrators wearing jackets; "Turn or burn". Bell uses several examples of how Christians describe hell as a place where you will burn and suffer
(be tortured) forever. It's just that I never in my life heard such preaching. I have attended worship services my entire life, since I was ten years old, and have never heard anything like that being preached. So Bell bases his reasoning from something that I believe few have experienced (heard preached).

Bell speaks a lot about hell as something we experience here on earth, and to the extent we experience hell after death, it is a temporary state and not eternal suffering.

Furthermore, he says that those who talk about people going to hell are often those who care least about the hell that is going on right now (earthly experience), while the people who care about hell on earth right now, appear to be the least interested in hell after death. It is possible that there may be some truth in that statement, but I have for the most part experienced the opposite. Those who truly believe in hell after death are those who are most eager to save people from hell, both hell after death and the hell (experienced) in this life.

I work in a context where one of the articles of faith speaks of "the eternal happiness of the righteous; and in the endless punishment of the wicked." (Salvation Army Articles of Faith). Among the circle of people around me who signed on to this article of faith, work is carried out daily to provide food, clothing, warmth and care for people living in unimaginable misery. So there can be found much compassionate care and human concern among those who believe in an eternal hell after death.

I agree with Bell that many people live their lives on earth in an indescribable hell. I see them daily, and we are engaged on a daily basis in trying to alleviate this hell. But I think that Bell overemphasizes the hell we experience on earth and ends up in a type social gospel with very little focus on the eternity that follows death. The consequences of Bell's focus is that it’s likely that we spend all our energy on helping people during the years we spend on earth, but forgetting that salvation in Jesus Christ is the only way to eternal life in fellowship with Jesus.

When I read the chapter, it reminded me of William Booth's prophecy of the future where he says among other things that proclamations will include "heaven without hell." Hell is mentioned (appears) in Rob Bell's book, but it is redefined to relate mainly to the present time (earthly period) and to the extent that there is a hell after death, it is simply a transient phenomenon.

I will return when I have had time to read more in Bell's book.


Lt. Peter Baronowsky
Regional Commander
Latvia

PS
This is not an attempt at a scientific analysis of Rob Bell's theology. This is a blog post. Blog entries typically express the spontaneous reaction to what we encounter in life. This is my spontaneous reaction when reading Rob Bell's book.

(translation from Swedish; Sven Ljungholm)