Wednesday, February 23, 2011

BODY PARTS NEEDED Conclusion A



Everything in the universe is subject to change
and everything is on schedule! (Canadian bumper sticker)

CONCLUSION PartA

ORGAN PROCUREMENT - EUTHANASIA and ASSISTED SUICIDE

Active Euthanasia: to be involved with, or to participate in bringing about the death of another person.
Passive Euthanasia: To deliberately withhold or withdraw medication, which would help a patient to live longer (thus resulting in the patient's death taking place sooner).

For consideration; both of the above actions are performed with the same intention - to end the life of a human being. Views on whether our life-spans should be in the hands of other human beings differ; we should be entitled to live all the life we've been assigned.

Voluntary Euthanasia:  Euthanasia at the request of someone.

Non-voluntary Euthanasia: Ending the life of someone no longer capable of communicating; performed believing this person would not want to continue living

For consideration; is administering medication to someone, intended to relieve their suffering but will have the side-effect of causing them to die, a form of active or passive euthanasia?


Other choices for those seeking early termination of their life are:
Oregon (USA) (since l997, physician-assisted suicide only).
Switzerland (1941, physician and non-physician assisted suicide only).
Belgium (2002, permits 'euthanasia' but does not define the method.
In many countries there is no specific law dealing with the matter of assisted dying, and often cases are tried based on other established laws.

Some common arguments in favor of legalizing euthanasia:
·      Do not want to be an emotional and financial burden to their relatives, or society.
·      Not all pain can be controlled by drugs.
Some arguments against legalising euthanasia
·      We do not know if someone will never recover from a 'terminal' illness.
·      People should be looked after, cared for, and helped through their last days, rather than be 'got rid of'.
·      Doctors are meant to do all in their power to preserve life, not end it!
·      Legalising euthanasia is giving people a license to murder.

There are countless people who have end-stage organ disease and could be saved by transplantation. Do we as a society have a responsibility to explore every possible ethical means for increasing the rate of recovery of acceptable organs?  Should we accept the view that people can sometimes be required to act for the greater good and consequently accept a ‘routine recovery’? Ought we to endorse the intended legislation being introduced on many fronts that while alive, people’s organs should be considered their personal property, but after death their “organs [should be considered] a societal resource.” Or does adopting organ procurement using this practice leads to an unnecessary loss of life?

The shortage of organs for transplantation has worsened forcing clinicians to review alternative approaches to organ procurement. Organ procurement has relied on the altruism and goodwill of donors, a 40-year-old policy. However, in that not a sufficient number of people want to donate, Henri Kreis of the Faculty of Medicine Paris-Descartes, Department of Transplantation shared; “in order to increase the availability of suitable organs and allow cadaver organ trans-plantation to continue, it is time to consider new strategies other than donation.” 

In Europe, the euthanasia lobby is becoming bolder and more extreme. They have let go of their traditional anthems of voluntary euthanasia for the competent and suffering to that of language that would lead to euthanasia as a human right. This serves as a useful reminder that the issue of euthanasia is not about terminal illness, compassion for the dying or ending suffering. Recently, there have been fewer restrictions on euthanasia and assisted suicide. Pressures also are appearing to establish a “right” to be killed.


Is hastening the death of a person to save the life of others not the greatest sign of love? No greater love…

FRANCE 
The shortage of organs for transplantation has worsened forcing clinicians to review alternative approaches to organ procurement. Organ procurement has relied on the altruism and goodwill of donors, a 40-year-old policy. However, in that not a sufficient number of people want to donate, Henri Kreis of the Faculty of Medicine Paris-Descartes, Department of Transplantation shared; “in order to increase the availability of suitable organs and allow cadaver organ trans-plantation to continue, it is time to consider new strategies other than donation.” 

The “passive" form of euthanasia is allowed, with proponents stressing that this differs from the practice now permitted in some other European countries.  Unlike the situation in the Netherlands and Belgium, where doctors are not prosecuted for actively ending the life of a patient, the French legislation deals mainly with acts of omission. (see The NL and Belgium heading)

Described as a "patient's rights" bill, it will allow doctors, acting at the request of patients and their families, to end medical treatment that is seen to be maintaining life artificially. Doctors will furthermore not be penalized for administering - at the request of patients suffering from extreme pain - higher-than-normal doses of medication, even if the drugs have a secondary and subsequent effect of hastening death. A third aspect of the law will allow a gravely or a terminally-ill patient to refuse life-sustaining medical treatment. "This legislation is one that allows dying but does not allow killing. That is how it is different from euthanasia.  

UK
Euthanasia in the UK
Although it is illegal to actively end the life of another person, in reality doctors in the UK regularly practice a form of 'passive euthanasia' when they turn off life-support machines in cases where there is 'nothing more they can do'.

Cost-effectiveness of transplantation 
In addition to saving lives, transplantation is highly cost-effective, and represents incredible savings to the NHS budget and is the treatment of choice for many patients, particularly those with end-stage renal failure. 

There are over 37,800 patients with end-stage renal failure in the UK. Nearly 21,000 are on dialysis, whilst the remainder have a transplant.
The indicative cost of a kidney transplant (including induction therapy but excluding NHSBT costs) is £17,000 per patient per transplant. 
The immuno-suppression required by a patient with a transplant costs £5,000 per patient per year. Kidney transplantation leads to a cost benefit in the second and subsequent years of £25,800 pa. 

The cost benefit of kidney transplantation compared to dialysis over a period of ten years (the median transplant survival time) is £241,000 or £24,100 per year for each year that the patient has a functioning transplanted kidney.  At the end of March 2009, the UK Transplant Registry had records of over 23,000 people in the United Kingdom with a functioning kidney transplant. On 1 April 2009 there were 6,920 patients waiting for a transplant of which the majority were on dialysis, costing around £193m per year. If all of these patients received a transplant, the approximate cost would be £41m per year, which represents a saving to the NHS of £152m per year. 

(USA) Some physicians have advocated a policy of "presumed consent," which allows physicians to retrieve organs unless the deceased opted out by specifically stating an opposition to organ donation prior to death. It was suggested that drivers’ licenses could be used for this purpose.
A countered argument is that presumed consent is fraught with legal and ethical traps. "It will only take one case in which someone’s decision not to donate is overlooked or ignored to put an end to presumed consent for good."
More popular with both physicians and ethicists is the policy of "required request," mandating that hospitals ask families about organ donation in every case of brain death. Many hospitals across the country have voluntarily adopted such a policy, and several states have enacted or have pending required-request legislation.
Many people support the right of a terminally ill patient to die - but what if the act becomes an obligation? And what of the potential for abuse by those might profit through the death of another? And for the purpose of this paper, should the death of a terminally ill patient be sacrificed to harvest life saving organs?

·      Should dying patients have the right to order their doctors not to start or continue medical treatment?
·      Should doctors be protected from prosecution if they shorten a patient's life expectancy with pain-killing drugs

The NL and Belgium
Euthanasia and assisted suicide were legalized in the Netherlands and Belgium in 2002. The Netherlands had effectively legalized euthanasia and assisted suicide by the decree of the courts in 1985, with the 2002 legalization simply codifying accepted practice into law.

The Netherlands are often hailed as a model when arguing for the legalization of euthanasia, where it is allowed if:
·      The patient is in unbearable pain, with no improvement in sight
·      The patient has voluntarily requested euthanasia on more than one occasion
·      The patient is aware of their condition and options
·      At least two doctors agree that these conditions are present
·      That euthanasia is carried out in a medically appropriate manner
·      That the patient is at least 12 years old.


The Netherlands
Cost containment is one of the main aims of the health care policy in Holland and Belgium. In an effort to contain costs and increase speedy procurement of body parts euthanasia training has been part of both medical and nursing school curricula since the early 1990s. The expense of the training is quickly recouped when those trained get their hands on patients.  Euthanasia has been administered to people with diabetes, rheumatism, multiple sclerosis, AIDS, bronchitis, and accident victims.

Holland is widely regarded as one of the world's most civilized countries. Active euthanasia is legal there, but for the past decade the government has not prosecuted doctors who report having assisted their patients to commit suicide. A Dutch government investigation of euthanasia revealed some disturbing findings . In one year in the early 1990s, 1,030 Dutch patients were killed without their consent. And of 22,500 deaths due to withdrawal of life support, 63% (14,175 patients) were denied medical treatment without their consent. Twelve per-cent (1,701 patients) were mentally competent but were not consulted

The Dutch experience seems to demonstrate that the "right to die" can soon turn into an obligation. We need to contemplate the potential reality for abuse if mercy killing becomes legal. What if someone stands to gain by the expedient death of another? 
Right-to-die advocates often point to Holland as the model for how well physician-assisted, voluntary euthanasia for terminally-ill, competent patients can work without abuse.

The main argument in favor of euthanasia in Holland has always been the need for more patient autonomy -- that patients have the right to make their own end-of-life decisions. Yet, over the past 20 years, Dutch euthanasia practice has ultimately given doctors, not patients, more and more power.  The question of whether a patient should live or die is often decided exclusively by a doctor or a team of physicians.

In the 1990s in  Holland:
·      52% were killed by doctors (active, voluntary euthanasia). 
·      12% died as a result of doctors providing them with the means to kill themselves (physician-assisted suicide). 
·      48% died from involuntary euthanasia, meaning that doctors actively killed these patients without the patients' knowledge or consent.
·      14% of these patients were fully competent.
·      72% had never given any indication that they would want their lives terminated.
·      In 8% of the cases, doctors performed involuntary euthanasia despite the fact that they believed alternative options were still possible.

8,100 patients died as a result of doctors deliberately giving them overdoses of pain medication, not for the primary purpose of controlling pain, but to hasten the patient's death. In 61% of these cases (4,941 patients), the intentional overdose was given without the patient's consent. According to the Remmelink Report, Dutch physicians deliberately and intentionally ended the lives of 11,840 people by lethal overdoses or injections--a figure which accounts for 9.1% of the annual overall death rate of 130,000 per year.

The majority of all euthanasia deaths in Holland are involuntary deaths. The most frequently cited reasons given for ending the lives of patients without their knowledge or consent were: "low quality of life," "no prospect for improvement," and "the family couldn't take it anymore." 

In 45% of cases involving hospitalized patients who were involuntarily euthanized, the patients' families had no knowledge that their loved ones' lives were deliberately terminated by doctors.

Critics have claimed that the Dutch initiative for euthanasia will trigger a wave of "euthanasia tourism", and this potential boom has begun through the establishing of death clinics in Cambodia and Mexico. 

In 2003, a group of “ethicists” at the Groningen University Hospital began looking at the question of infant euthanasia in the Netherlands. The 2002 law allowed the euthanasia of consenting persons over the age of 12. The problem that the committee at Groningen University was attempting to solve was: what should be done with newborns that are born with anomalies? The Groningen Protocol allows euthanasia of infants when the parents give consent and when the child is considered to lack an “acceptable” quality of life.

In the Netherlands, the goal is the legalization of the “last-will pill.” This is a prescription that would be given to healthy individuals (usually the elderly or people with disabilities) who were tired of living.
Switzerland
Switzerland has tolerated assisted suicide for many years. Suicide groups have been assisting suicide within Switzerland based on a legal interpretation of their 1918 suicide law. In other words, Switzerland never legalized assisted suicide, but tolerates the practice based on a legal interpretation. The Dignitas Suicide clinic is probably the best known of these groups.
The Dignitas clinic has now changed its suicide technique from the use of a prescription to that of the plastic bag with helium (an exit bag). Using the plastic bag with helium method to eliminate the need for a physician to agree to assisting the death, because even many physicians who support assisted suicide would often refuse to write lethal prescriptions for people who weren’t dying or suffering. The clinic is known for its encouragement of suicide tourists from countries around the world where euthanasia is not permitted or tolerated, who go to Switzerland to die. It is estimated that two out of three people who die at their suicide clinic are suicide tourists.
The Dignitas assisted suicide groups in Switzerland, has some 2,000 members and welcomes foreigners. Dignitas must be fully informed in advance of a person’s wishes, circumstances, and agree to help. It is not (yet) a ‘walk-in’ clinic.  The most serious question facing Dignitas concerns welcoming and assisting the the mentally ill or depressed as much as those suffering a physical illness and pain. Dignitas members argue that mentally ill people have the same right to take their own lives as others: "You can't say and you shouldn't say that mentally ill people should not have human rights." "A lot of people feel lonely, lonesome at that stage and they say, 'Well, I have nothing more. I have no relatives, I have no friends, no life ... Why am I still living anymore,'" says Eichenburger. "That's when I say that the dying has begun." 


Although the Dignitas market is largely German, by late 2008, approximately 100 British citizens had travelled to Switzerland from the UK to die at one of Dignitas' rented apartments in Zurich. Just a month later the number of British members of Dignitas had risen to 725. Assisted suicide is not a criminal act under Swiss law if it is motivated by altruistic considerations.

Dignitas launched an effort to gain legal permission for healthy foreigners, including married couples committed to suicide pacts, to end their lives in Switzerland.  Dignitas has found
  
If voluntary euthanasia is made legal for "persons of sound mind" there will inevitably be tremendous pressure to provide it for those who "would request it if they were able to" - the mentally ill or handicapped, the senile, the unattached or non-productive elderly, etc. One can easily argue too to link euthanasia and health care costs in the same breath; financial pressures will multiply in the coming years as our population ages. 


Sven Ljungholm
Soldier
Govan Corps

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

BODY PARTS NEEDED Part Four



The first UK-wide multimedia organ donation campaign was rolled out only 18 months ago. Research reveals that 96% of UK residents would accept an organ if needed, however, only 27% have the joined the NHS Organ Donor Register (ODR) to date. If we would accept an organ, shouldn’t we be prepared to give one?
More transplants were carried out last year than ever before, but the need for organs never stops as more than 10,000 people in the UK currently need a transplant. Of these, over 1,000 – on average 3 a day – die every year before they receive an organ.
Nonetheless, only 3,500 transplants were carried out in the UK last year. Alongside these figures, however, are transplants performed privately, many of them overseas patients paying to get onto the waiting list for organs donated by British people. It emerged that more than 700 transplants, mostly liver transplants, had been carried out on non-UK patients over the past decade with most coming from countries such as Greece and Italy. Not known is the number of UK residents who traveled abroad for transplants; ‘transplant tourists’.

Leaders of the UK's main religions have joined in the appeal urging their followers to register as organ donors.  They are trying to counter uncertainty about what their religions teach about organ donation. The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, the head of the Muslim Council of Britain and the Chief Rabbi are among those involved. BBC News Religious Affairs Correspondent Robert Pigott says senior clergy report that some people are unsure what their religion teaches about the subject.

The Church of England says organ donation is a Christian duty. The transplantation of human organs through a systematic organ donation process may well be a watershed in the relationship between science and Christian ethics.

Many however, do not share the Christian or altruistic viewpoint, especially overseas where many ask, "Why should we sign up as organ donors if our organs can and are being sold to the highest bidder?”  

In the UK someone tried to hawk their kidney on eBay, only to have it pulled by the site -- but not before the price reached epic heights. In 1999, before eBay delisted a kidney put up for auction, bidders drove the price up to $5.75 million. 

Cash-strapped Brits are charging up to £60,000 for this vital organ. Why the astronomical figure? Currently at least a million people worldwide need a kidney, and quickly; the key characteristics of marketing: PRODUCT, PRICE, PLACEMENT, PROMOTION.

Kidneys are particularly big on the black market. The World Health Organization provides this quick price comparison: 
KIDNEY
INDIA                                     $20.000.00 
CHINA                           40,000.00 
ISRAEL                         160,000.00 
(as in all sales and marketing enterprises the producer (organ donor) doesn’t collect all the money—there are several levels of fees that accompany illegal donation) 

“The person giving up the organ only gets a fraction of the fee,” says Sally Satel, a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. After the organ broker—the guy who sets up your kidney-for-cash transaction—takes his cut, he needs to pay for travel, the surgeon, medical supplies and a few “look-the-other-way” payoffs. Most people get $1,000 to $10,000 for their kidney. 

It's illegal in the U.S., and most other nations, to offer or receive compensation for an organ donation. But a black market for human organs does exist. Citizens of impoverished nations or regions are often tempted to sell one of their kidneys on the black market. In some cases, these entrepreneurial donors are recruited (or learn through word-of-mouth and volunteer) and flown to another nation, where the organ is removed in a makeshift operating room.

In 2003, a slum resident’s organ was bought for $6,000.00, flown to South Africa where middlemen were then able to sell it for $100,000.00]. Villagers in a destitute part of India who sold their kidneys in a similar scheme received about $800 for their organs. At one time, Israeli organ brokers were obtaining kidneys from people in former Soviet-bloc nations and transplanting them into patients who traveled to Turkey for the operation. For the broker, there was money to be made -- one Israeli middleman in the organ trade made $4 million before being caught.

Last summer, a man offering one of his for $100,000 (plus medical expenses) on Craigslist received several offers until the Web site removed his post.

Italy, with its close proximity to the once war-torn Bosnia and Albania, used to be a gold mine for black market organs. Before a police sting in 1997, a private clinic in Trieste was making millions selling the organs of murdered Bosnian prisoners of war. 

Latin America has long been a hotbed for the organ theft trade. In El Salvador it is rumored that a whole child can be bought for $16,000 and harvested for organs. Corneas can be bought for just $6,000 in the alleys of Honduras. In Guatemala City stripping tissues from the deceased is one of the perks of being an undertaker. And in Colombia, where every body may be harvested for organs unless the family files special objections, organ theft is not even illegal. 

Closer to home the scene is a quiet hotel room in midtown Manhattan when two Chinese nationals are concluding a business deal to sell the kidneys, corneas, livers and lungs of executed Chinese prisoners for tens of thousands of dollars. 

No one, not even human-rights advocates, believes organs should never be harvested for humane medical purposes. Rather, the controversy arises, as it always does with transplants, over how those donations are solicited and under what circumstances they can be used. 

Wealthy foreigners willing to pay anywhere from $10,000 to $40,000 for a kidney operation.. "We estimate there are about 6,000 prisoners executed in China each year," says William Schulz, executive director of Amnesty International, U.S.A., "and about 90% of transplanted kidneys come from executed prisoners." 

Chinese doctors remove organs from executed prisoners before the "donor's" heart has stopped beating, according to congressional testimony by a Chinese physician who now lives in the United States. The organs are harvested to profit from demand for the part by foreign organ-transplant patients. It's estimated that China conducts around 3,000 executions per year, so you're talking a multimillion-dollar business when you consider a selling price of as much as $30,000 for a heart or kidney. 

Like any business, it comes down to simple supply and demand.  And euthanasia seems a likely step in the supply chain for those who can afford it. The illegal sale of human body parts is big business, and an expansion in the euthanasia business will undoubtedly add to this already widespread global racket.

According to reports by U.S. insurance companies and hospitals, the going rate for a lung is $116,400, a kidney $91,400 and a heart $57,000 – making a human body one of the most lucrative thefts around. In fact when googling for ‘body parts’, human spare part sites now outnumber those selling auto parts.

Although illegal body part sales are often linked to third world countries and those where human life holds little intrinsic value organ transplant criminal cases are slowly spreading across the United States.  A doctor in a north California Regional Medical Center was charged by Los Angeles police with giving drugs to a comatose 26-year-old man to hasten his death for a transplant team. The man didn’t die after being taken off a life support machine and police charged the doctor with hurrying his death.

To thwart body snatchers at the University of California, a major destination for organs and cadavers donated to science, they are considering inserting super-market style bar codes or radio frequency chips into corpses to make sure they are not nabbed by body snatchers.

Indian police said stolen kidneys are being sold for between $6,000 to $10,000. Many Indian doctors make less than $10,000 in a whole year so the temptation to steal organs is high.

Near New Deli, three leading Indian transplant surgeons, the owner of the Noida Medicare Centre, a hospital famed for transplants, and six others were arrested after Shaukat Ali, a mechanic, complained he'd been drugged and robbed of a kidney during a routine medical examination. Two similar accusations had already been filed against the centre including the theft of a kidney belonging to a mentally retarded child. Police say that hundreds of poor Indians disappear every day in New Deli alone. Human rights activists wonder how many were murdered for their organs.

In a German controversy involving autopsy, human body parts are smuggled out of hospital basements by shady hospital workers and sold to local drug companies for the extraction of growth hormones.  The list of items on drug companies's plan does not stop there.  In an investigative report by Der Spiegel, a liberal German newsmagazine, drug companies also buy meninges --the membranes that surround the brain and spinal cord -- by tens of thousands. 

In Russia bodies of the dead are automatically owned by the government and must be turned over immediately to authorities. Horribly gruesome pictures have surfaced showing tables full of stacked nude bodies of men, women and children with long incisions showing they had been harvested for body parts.

Russian academician warn that euthanasia in Russia will become a legal way to seize human organs; the risk of criminal seizure of human organs sharply increases, Russian Academy of Medical Sciences academician Sergey Kolesnikov (United Russia) told a REGNUM correspondent commenting on Senator Valentina Petrenko’s initiative to draft such a law… it will become one of legal ways to seize property of an individual, depending on how the procedure is stated by the law,” Kolesnikov believes. “It is no secret that there is a practice of signing contracts with elderly people on using their organs after their death. In this case it would be legal,” he said.

Italy, with its close proximity to the once war-torn Bosnia and Albania, used to be a gold mine for black market organs. Before a police sting in 1997, a private clinic in Trieste was making millions selling the organs of murdered Bosnian prisoners of war.

Latin America has long been a hotbed for the organ theft trade. In El Salvador it is rumored that a whole child can be bought for $16,000 and harvested for organs. Corneas can be bought for just $6,000 in the alleys of Honduras. In Guatemala City stripping tissues from the deceased is one of the perks of being an undertaker. And in Colombia, where every body may be harvested for organs unless the family files special objections, organ theft is not even illegal.

Although transplant surgery is saving lives, at the same time, it has created a trade in human body parts.  The inevitable result is a booming international black market of body parts that caters to rich recipients and destitute (and sometimes helpless) donors

Ethicists say that turning donations into transactions diminishes the human element. "Some, in their religious or cultural views, regard as sacred or holy things that we say `aren't for sale.' For example, our own moral integrity, it's not for sale."

Questions about the underground world of organ trafficking were thrust into the open after the Star discovered that a man accused of being the mastermind behind an alleged, massive black-market trade in kidneys was living in Toronto.

In ethics literature some have argued that the creation of a market in which people are free to sell their organs – as long as they're not coerced to do so – could go far in reducing the tortuous reality of years-long waiting lists for transplants. However, some of those selling their organs are some of the poorest people on the planet. Can they really be making an autonomous choice that by not selling the kidney they can't buy food to eat? It's really not a free choice, a necessary component in making a moral choice, along with having alternate choices and knowing consequences.

In the West, a wealthy person needing a kidney can order a trip from a "medical tourism" company to a place where rules are lax, such as the Philippines, to get a transplant for about $80,000. One website allows customers to add the transplant to the online "shopping cart," as you would add a book on Amazon.com before paying with your credit card.


BODY PARTS NEEDED Part Four


The first UK-wide multimedia organ donation campaign was rolled out only 18 months ago. Research reveals that 96% of UK residents would accept an organ if needed, however, only 27% have the joined the NHS Organ Donor Register (ODR) to date. If we would accept an organ, shouldn’t we be prepared to give one?
More transplants were carried out last year than ever before, but the need for organs never stops as more than 10,000 people in the UK currently need a transplant. Of these, over 1,000 – on average 3 a day – die every year before they receive an organ.
Nonetheless, only 3,500 transplants were carried out in the UK last year. Alongside these figures, however, are transplants performed privately, many of them overseas patients paying to get onto the waiting list for organs donated by British people. It emerged that more than 700 transplants, mostly liver transplants, had been carried out on non-UK patients over the past decade with most coming from countries such as Greece and Italy. Not known is the number of UK residents who traveled abroad for transplants; ‘transplant tourists’.

Leaders of the UK's main religions have joined in the appeal urging their followers to register as organ donors.  They are trying to counter uncertainty about what their religions teach about organ donation. The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, the head of the Muslim Council of Britain and the Chief Rabbi are among those involved. BBC News Religious Affairs Correspondent Robert Pigott says senior clergy report that some people are unsure what their religion teaches about the subject.

The Church of England says organ donation is a Christian duty. The transplantation of human organs through a systematic organ donation process may well be a watershed in the relationship between science and Christian ethics.

Many however, do not share the Christian or altruistic viewpoint, especially overseas where many ask, "Why should we sign up as organ donors if our organs can and are being sold to the highest bidder?”  

In the UK someone tried to hawk their kidney on eBay, only to have it pulled by the site -- but not before the price reached epic heights. In 1999, before eBay delisted a kidney put up for auction, bidders drove the price up to $5.75 million. 

Cash-strapped Brits are charging up to £60,000 for this vital organ. Why the astronomical figure? Currently at least a million people worldwide need a kidney, and quickly; the key characteristics of marketing: PRODUCT, PRICE, PLACEMENT, PROMOTION.

Kidneys are particularly big on the black market. The World Health Organization provides this quick price comparison: 
KIDNEY
INDIA                                     $20.000.00 
CHINA                           40,000.00 
ISRAEL                         160,000.00 
(as in all sales and marketing enterprises the producer (organ donor) doesn’t collect all the money—there are several levels of fees that accompany illegal donation) 

“The person giving up the organ only gets a fraction of the fee,” says Sally Satel, a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. After the organ broker—the guy who sets up your kidney-for-cash transaction—takes his cut, he needs to pay for travel, the surgeon, medical supplies and a few “look-the-other-way” payoffs. Most people get $1,000 to $10,000 for their kidney. 

It's illegal in the U.S., and most other nations, to offer or receive compensation for an organ donation. But a black market for human organs does exist. Citizens of impoverished nations or regions are often tempted to sell one of their kidneys on the black market. In some cases, these entrepreneurial donors are recruited (or learn through word-of-mouth and volunteer) and flown to another nation, where the organ is removed in a makeshift operating room.

In 2003, a slum resident’s organ was bought for $6,000.00, flown to South Africa where middlemen were then able to sell it for $100,000.00]. Villagers in a destitute part of India who sold their kidneys in a similar scheme received about $800 for their organs. At one time, Israeli organ brokers were obtaining kidneys from people in former Soviet-bloc nations and transplanting them into patients who traveled to Turkey for the operation. For the broker, there was money to be made -- one Israeli middleman in the organ trade made $4 million before being caught.

Last summer, a man offering one of his for $100,000 (plus medical expenses) on Craigslist received several offers until the Web site removed his post.

Italy, with its close proximity to the once war-torn Bosnia and Albania, used to be a gold mine for black market organs. Before a police sting in 1997, a private clinic in Trieste was making millions selling the organs of murdered Bosnian prisoners of war. 

Latin America has long been a hotbed for the organ theft trade. In El Salvador it is rumored that a whole child can be bought for $16,000 and harvested for organs. Corneas can be bought for just $6,000 in the alleys of Honduras. In Guatemala City stripping tissues from the deceased is one of the perks of being an undertaker. And in Colombia, where every body may be harvested for organs unless the family files special objections, organ theft is not even illegal. 

Closer to home the scene is a quiet hotel room in midtown Manhattan when two Chinese nationals are concluding a business deal to sell the kidneys, corneas, livers and lungs of executed Chinese prisoners for tens of thousands of dollars. 

No one, not even human-rights advocates, believes organs should never be harvested for humane medical purposes. Rather, the controversy arises, as it always does with transplants, over how those donations are solicited and under what circumstances they can be used. 

Wealthy foreigners willing to pay anywhere from $10,000 to $40,000 for a kidney operation.. "We estimate there are about 6,000 prisoners executed in China each year," says William Schulz, executive director of Amnesty International, U.S.A., "and about 90% of transplanted kidneys come from executed prisoners." 

Chinese doctors remove organs from executed prisoners before the "donor's" heart has stopped beating, according to congressional testimony by a Chinese physician who now lives in the United States. The organs are harvested to profit from demand for the part by foreign organ-transplant patients. It's estimated that China conducts around 3,000 executions per year, so you're talking a multimillion-dollar business when you consider a selling price of as much as $30,000 for a heart or kidney. 

Like any business, it comes down to simple supply and demand.  And euthanasia seems a likely step in the supply chain for those who can afford it. The illegal sale of human body parts is big business, and an expansion in the euthanasia business will undoubtedly add to this already widespread global racket.

According to reports by U.S. insurance companies and hospitals, the going rate for a lung is $116,400, a kidney $91,400 and a heart $57,000 – making a human body one of the most lucrative thefts around. In fact when googling for ‘body parts’, human spare part sites now outnumber those selling auto parts.

Although illegal body part sales are often linked to third world countries and those where human life holds little intrinsic value organ transplant criminal cases are slowly spreading across the United States.  A doctor in a north California Regional Medical Center was charged by Los Angeles police with giving drugs to a comatose 26-year-old man to hasten his death for a transplant team. The man didn’t die after being taken off a life support machine and police charged the doctor with hurrying his death.

To thwart body snatchers at the University of California, a major destination for organs and cadavers donated to science, they are considering inserting super-market style bar codes or radio frequency chips into corpses to make sure they are not nabbed by body snatchers.

Indian police said stolen kidneys are being sold for between $6,000 to $10,000. Many Indian doctors make less than $10,000 in a whole year so the temptation to steal organs is high.

Near New Deli, three leading Indian transplant surgeons, the owner of the Noida Medicare Centre, a hospital famed for transplants, and six others were arrested after Shaukat Ali, a mechanic, complained he'd been drugged and robbed of a kidney during a routine medical examination. Two similar accusations had already been filed against the centre including the theft of a kidney belonging to a mentally retarded child. Police say that hundreds of poor Indians disappear every day in New Deli alone. Human rights activists wonder how many were murdered for their organs.

In a German controversy involving autopsy, human body parts are smuggled out of hospital basements by shady hospital workers and sold to local drug companies for the extraction of growth hormones.  The list of items on drug companies's plan does not stop there.  In an investigative report by Der Spiegel, a liberal German newsmagazine, drug companies also buy meninges --the membranes that surround the brain and spinal cord -- by tens of thousands. 

In Russia bodies of the dead are automatically owned by the government and must be turned over immediately to authorities. Horribly gruesome pictures have surfaced showing tables full of stacked nude bodies of men, women and children with long incisions showing they had been harvested for body parts.

Russian academician warn that euthanasia in Russia will become a legal way to seize human organs; the risk of criminal seizure of human organs sharply increases, Russian Academy of Medical Sciences academician Sergey Kolesnikov (United Russia) told a REGNUM correspondent commenting on Senator Valentina Petrenko’s initiative to draft such a law… it will become one of legal ways to seize property of an individual, depending on how the procedure is stated by the law,” Kolesnikov believes. “It is no secret that there is a practice of signing contracts with elderly people on using their organs after their death. In this case it would be legal,” he said.

Italy, with its close proximity to the once war-torn Bosnia and Albania, used to be a gold mine for black market organs. Before a police sting in 1997, a private clinic in Trieste was making millions selling the organs of murdered Bosnian prisoners of war.

Latin America has long been a hotbed for the organ theft trade. In El Salvador it is rumored that a whole child can be bought for $16,000 and harvested for organs. Corneas can be bought for just $6,000 in the alleys of Honduras. In Guatemala City stripping tissues from the deceased is one of the perks of being an undertaker. And in Colombia, where every body may be harvested for organs unless the family files special objections, organ theft is not even illegal.

Although transplant surgery is saving lives, at the same time, it has created a trade in human body parts.  The inevitable result is a booming international black market of body parts that caters to rich recipients and destitute (and sometimes helpless) donors

Ethicists say that turning donations into transactions diminishes the human element. "Some, in their religious or cultural views, regard as sacred or holy things that we say `aren't for sale.' For example, our own moral integrity, it's not for sale."

Questions about the underground world of organ trafficking were thrust into the open after the Star discovered that a man accused of being the mastermind behind an alleged, massive black-market trade in kidneys was living in Toronto.

In ethics literature some have argued that the creation of a market in which people are free to sell their organs – as long as they're not coerced to do so – could go far in reducing the tortuous reality of years-long waiting lists for transplants. However, some of those selling their organs are some of the poorest people on the planet. Can they really be making an autonomous choice that by not selling the kidney they can't buy food to eat? It's really not a free choice, a necessary component in making a moral choice, along with having alternate choices and knowing consequences.

In the West, a wealthy person needing a kidney can order a trip from a "medical tourism" company to a place where rules are lax, such as the Philippines, to get a transplant for about $80,000. One website allows customers to add the transplant to the online "shopping cart," as you would add a book on Amazon.com before paying with your credit card.


Friday, February 18, 2011

BODY PARTS NEEDED Part three of Four

Organ transplants can save lives and help improve the quality of life for someone who is seriously ill. The earliest transplant to be carried out was of a cornea, and which took place in 1905 in what is now the Czech Republic. In 1954 the USA carried out the first kidney transplant, and 6 years later, in Scotland, the first living donor kidney transplant took place. Transplants are still major operations but they have become routine over the last four decades. 

The first ever liver transplant in the UK was carried out in 1963 and since that time more than fifteen thousand liver transplants have been performed in Britain. Heart and liver transplant programs are among the major organ transplants performed in the UK. In the first five years of the 21 century, Britain carried out over 4000 liver transplants and in the twelve-month period running from April 2007 to the end of March 2008, UK surgeons transplanted a total of 3235 organs from 1665 donors. (donors gave more than one organ for a successful transplant) 

Currently, there are no accurate figures for the number of transplants performed worldwide. Only general trends and information is available from estimates. These show, for example, that the USA performs twice the number of kidney transplants than are carried out in the whole of Europe each year.

SHORTAGE
The shortage of organ donors is a universal problem and strict rules are in place, though not always respected or enforced,  encouraged by the World Health Organization, to prevent poor and underprivileged people being forced into becoming living donors. This practice is becoming more common but needs to be tightly controlled. In most countries there is a shortage of suitable organs for transplantation. Countries often have formal systems in place to manage the process of determining who is an organ donor and in what order organ recipients receive available organs. 

In the United States, about 108,000 people are on the waiting list. Wait times and success rates for organs differ significantly between organs due to demand and procedure difficulty. Three-quarters of patients in need of an organ transplant are waiting for a kidney, and therefore have much longer waiting times. At the Oregon Health and Science University, for example, the median patient who ultimately received an organ waited only three weeks for a heart and three months for a pancreas or liver — but 15 months for a kidney, because demand for kidneys substantially outstrips supply.

Approaches to addressing this shortfall include: donor registries and "primary consent" laws, to remove the burden of the donation decision from the legal next-of-kin monetary incentives for signing up to be a donor an opt-out system ("dissent solution"), in which a potential donor or his/her relatives must take specific action to be excluded from organ donation, rather than specific action to be included social incentive programs, wherein members sign a legal agreement to direct their organs first to other members who are on the transplant waiting list In hospitals, organ network representatives routinely screen patient records to identify potential donors.

ETHICAL ISSUES
Issues include the definition of death, when and how consent should be given for an organ to be transplanted and payment for organs for transplantation. Other ethical issues include transplantation tourism and more broadly the socio-economic context in which organ harvesting or transplantation may occur. A particular problem is organ trafficking.

Transplantation Tourism
Because of the ongoing organ donor shortage, transplant tourism is occurring at an increasing rate both in the USA and abroad. Transplant tourism is an increasing reality facing the USA transplant centers. Most professional societies do not condone it yet cannot abrogate a physician's right to care for such patients. Ethical principles mandate transplant physicians provide adequate care for returning transplant tourists. Transplant tourism exists because of the disparity between the need for organ donors and their availability and will increase. 

Opt-in vs. opt-out 
There are two main systems for voluntary systems "opt in" (anyone who has not given consent is not a donor) and "opt out" (anyone who has not refused is a donor); legislative approaches started in the 1990s.

United States 
It remains a pure consent system rather than an extended consent system or even a dissent opt-out system. 

Europe 
The EU does not regulate organ donation uniformly; the decision is left to member states. According to a 2010 New York Times article, a total of 24 European countries have some form of presumed consent (opt-out) system. In 2008, the EU parliament overwhelmingly voted for an initiative to introduce an EU organ donor card in order to foster organ donation in Europe. In the United Kingdom organ donation is voluntary and no consent is presumed. The UK has recently discussed whether to switch to an opt-out system in light of the success in other countries and a severe British organ donor shortfall.

The Spanish System
The Spanish transplant system is one of the most successful in the world, but it still can't meet the demand, as 10% of those needing a transplant die while still on the transplant list. Under Spanish law, every corpse can provide organs unless the deceased person expressly rejected it. And because family members can still forbid the donation, carefully trained doctors ask the family for permission, making it very similar in practice to the United States. A network for communication and transport allows fast extraction and transplant across the country.

Deontological issues 
Most of the world's religions support donation as a charitable act of great benefit to the community. Nonetheless, issues surrounding patient autonomy, living wills, and guardianship make it nearly impossible for involuntary organ donation to occur. 

From a philosophical standpoint, the primary issues surrounding the morality of organ donation are semantical; the definitions of life, death, human, and body is ongoing. For example, whether or not a brain-dead patient ought to be kept artificially animate in order to preserve organs for procurement is an ongoing problem in clinical bioethics. 

Teleological issues 
On teleological or utilitarian grounds, the moral status of "black market organ donation" relies upon the ends, rather than the means. In so far as those who donate organs are often impoverished and those who can afford black market organs are typically well-off, it would appear that there is an imbalance in the trade. In many cases, those in need of organs are put on waiting lists for legal organs for indeterminate lengths of time — many die while still on a waiting list. 

Organ donation is fast becoming an important bioethical issue as well from a social perspective: the fact remains that demand far outstrips supply. Consequently, there has arisen a black market trend often referred to as transplant tourism. The issues are weighty and controversial. On the one hand are those who contend that those who can afford to buy organs are exploiting those who are desperate enough to sell their organs. Many of those in favor of the trade hold that exploitation is morally preferable to death, and in so far as the choice lies between abstract notions of justice on the one hand and a dying person whose life could be saved on the other hand, the organ trade should be legalized. Legalization of the organ trade carries with it its own sense of justice as well. Continuing black-market trade creates further disparity on the demand side: only the rich can afford such organs. Legalization of the international organ trade could lead to increased supply, lowering prices so that persons outside the wealthiest segments could afford such organs as well. 

Prison inmates 
In the United States, prisoners are not discriminated against as organ recipients and are equally eligible for organ transplants along with the general population.

Because donor organs are in short supply, there are more people waiting for a transplant than available organs. When a prisoner receives an organ, there is a high probability that someone else will die waiting for the next available organ. A response to this ethical dilemma states that felons who have a history of violent crime, who have violated others’ basic rights, have lost the right to receive an organ transplant.

Many argue that a quid pro quo arrangement be introduced: donate an organ in exchange for a reduced sentence.

Religious Viewpoints 
All major religions accept organ donation in at least some form on either utilitarian grounds (i.e., because of its life-saving capabilities) or deontological grounds (e.g., the right of an individual believer to make his or her own decision). Most religions, among them the Roman Catholic Church, support organ donation on the grounds that it constitutes an act of charity and provides a means of saving a life, although certain bodies, such as the popes', are not to be used.

Some religions impose certain restrictions on the types of organs that may be donated and/or on the means by which organs may be harvested and/or transplanted. For example, Jehovah's Witnesses require that organs be drained of any blood due to their interpretation of the Hebrew Bible/Christian Old Testament as prohibiting blood transfusion, and Muslims require that the donor have provided written consent in advance. Orthodox Judaism considers organ donation obligatory if it will save a life, as long as the donor is considered dead as defined by Jewish law.

There appears to be three basic issues in the euthanasia debate as it pertain to religious arguments: 
Value – What value has a human life? 
Fear – What are the main fears which euthanasia is intended to relieve? 
Autonomy – What right do we have over our own life? 

Value 
It is the belief of many contemporary non-Christians that there is no inherent absolute or intrinsic value to human life. 

On the other hand there are non-Christian scholars who still recognize and support an intrinsic importance and value to human life; a view of human ‘value’ based upon ‘best interests’, drawing a distinction between: 
Experiential interests – what causes pleasure or pain. 
Critical interests – what gives life meaning. In many respects this kind of viewpoint is an attempt to create a secular understanding of human value.

Alternatively, the Christian worldview understands and proffers the fact that we have intrinsic value because God has created us in his own image. Human beings are godlike beings, possessing a range of faculties (rational, moral and social) that distinguishes us all other creatures.

Succinctly, from a Christian point of view liberalizing the law would be hugely problematic for at least three reasons: 
First, human life bears God’s image and it is not for us to terminate. 
Second, according to the Christian worldview we are part of community joined to each other. We are not autonomous. The decisions we make impact other people. 

Finally, if the law was changed there would be a great risk that people would feel pressured into accessing assisted suicide or euthanasia. At present if you are a burden on your family and the state and have a sensitive conscience you don’t need to feel guilty about being a burden in the sense that there is nothing you can do about it. If assisted suicide or euthanasia became available, though, then there would be a mechanism sanctified with legal approval that one could suppor.


Sven Ljungholm
Former Officer, USA, Sweden,Russia, Ukraine